Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Posts

Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#1

Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>There's a workbench on the cover of the Landis paperback Workbench book that shows a bench in Hancock Shaker Village. It consists of a timber in front and a plank in back for the top and the back legs are splayed. If someone has seen this up close and personal can they tell me how the back legs were connected to the top and if the plank was screwed to the timber or how was it connected? I know it sits in a rabbet but that's all I can tell. Your help would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#2

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Catharine Kennedy

>If you mean the blue work bench, that is amply covered in the book as to how it's constructed... I worked at HSV for 16 years, most of that time in the same room as that bench. If it's another bench, please post a photo & I can go from there for you!

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#4

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Catharine Kennedy

>oh, okay- THAT bench is not the one at Hancock, so can't help you with that! Thanks for posting the photo!

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#5

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>In Landis' photo credits he lists Hancock as the source of the photo. Perhaps it was there and isn't now or perhaps Landis has miscredited.

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#6

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Catharine Kennedy

>I checked my 1995 edition of Landis' book and don't even see that particular bench shown at all. Certainly does NOT look like any of the Shaker benches I've ever seen, so, sorry- can't help you at all with this one!

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#7

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Didn't look like a Shaker bench to me either, more like a Dominy bench. However, if you take the storage from underneath Shaker benches they do start to resemble this one. It's also very similar to Mike Dunbar's bench which he wrote about in the first FWW Shops and Tools issue at the end of the year (or whatever they call it).

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#8

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

David Cockey

>The book in the link looks like a later printing with a different cover than the original. The credit probably wasn't updated.

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#9

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

John Aniano in NJ...

>Patrick,

Somewhere, I thought I learned that that bench was owned by Garrett Hack. I think I have a photo of it in my shop - from a Lee Valley, or maybe a Lie-Nielsen calendar. Then again, maybe I'm wrong...

John (who copied the deadman profile from the bench in question for his own bench)...

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#10

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

Alan Pound

>This is from the Hand Tools Archive:

Subject: Garrett Hack's bench....

Posted By: Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs fmutchler@adelphia.net

Date: Friday, 1 October 2004, at 11:43 a.m.

Just a note to relay some information regarding the bench on the soft-cover edition of Scott Landis', "The Workbench Book" and also on pg. 73 (74 some editions) of Garrett Hack's, "The Handplane Book".

Adam & I were discussing the bench offline and decided to "ask around" to determine whose bench it actually is. I contacted Rosewood Studio where Garrett Hack is listed as an instructor. They were kind enough to forward my inquiry to Mr. Hack and he very kindly responded. The following is the reply I received:

Dear Mr. Mutchler.

The following is the answer I received from Garrett Hack:

About the bench. The bench photographed on page 73 is not mine, but Ted Ingraham's. We photographed at a number of different shops, his being one, and thus there are a variety of benches shown in both of my books.

I still use an Ulmia type bench I made in 1978, the one photographed in virtually every article I write for Fine Woodworking, and shown in many photos in both books. That said, I like Ted's bench a great deal. It's different than mine - more traditional you might say, with lots of good

features.

Further confusing this issue is the new book on WORKBENCHES. In there I am shown at Ted's bench, and also his sharpening station, with the misleading captions that this is my shop. Certainly not. The author used my photographs, but never checked out the details, thus the misinformation.

Garrett

Now, how do we get ahold of Mr. Ingraham to discuss the finer point of his bench? ;>)

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

#11

Re: Has anyone been to Hancock Shaker Village?

victor Parisian

>Here is a start I just Googled his name.

�Making 18th-century Wooden Planes.� Ted

Ingraham, joiner, planemaker, and tool researcher,

North Ferrisburgh, Vermont

good luck,

victor