Re: lets us be fair and banlanced (as the saying g
ThomD
>"Unless you are willing to believe that professionals are stupid the issue raised by FWW has been settled for something like 150 years, namely apprentice work is more efficiently done by machines. Only when life style choices become important, or the size of the task tiny, do the machines loose."
I would suggest splitting wood vs. sawing it, in the cabinetmaking context. There are a lot of things that are faster by hand though obviously many power processes are faster.
One thing is that many professionals are hacks which is why, paradoxically, the quality of work has fallen into a rat hole as the efficiency of the means of production has exploded to unimagined heights. And in fact a fair number of professionals are stupid in the sense that the purpose of a lot of mechanization is lower the quality of person required to do the work. Of course there are many advantages also, but speed = shortcuts. Professionals know you can make more money and happiness making Nikes, than Bespoke shoes. The only thing you can make faster is quality shoes.
But industry is one thing and the home shop is another. I have something like 40 machines in my shop, I can't even remember them all. I am far from convinced that they are really all that fast. A small shop is not an industry. While there are a few obvious winers one way or another, the machines consume a great deal of time and money for what they do. My experience with machines is that one thing leads to another, and that opening the door leads to more and more required machines. They are all heavier, bigger, noisier, and more expensive to maintain than any hand tool. They are also a huge practical anchor. They have reduced my freedom. Right now I could move to France or BC if the spirit moved me, except for packing the machines.