Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

Posts

This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#1

This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

wilbur

>Apparently the folks at Fine Woodworking are going to do a live video stream this Thursday to see whether a bench plane or a power sander is faster at getting a finish ready surface.

Whichever one turns out to be faster, I already know which method will leave my lungs in better shape.


FWW bench plane vs. power sander challenge

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#2

Jumping the Shark!!

Brent Smith in Montreal

>They must be hard up for ideas over there. No doubt in my mind on which is faster if the plane is in the hands of someone who knows how to sharpen, set up and use it.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#3

FWW RAW!!!!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I can see it now...a steel cage death match between a drill press and a brace and bit. EXTREME!!!!

Tom

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#4

throwing raw meat to the wolves

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It would seem that the main objective of this "contest" will be to stir up the passions of their clients. It will result in an outpouring of letters and hence interest in the FWW product. In my youth I once naively asked an older woman why women dressed so foolishly. "To be noticed" was the reply. May work for FWW. Maybe they are feeling the heat from PW.

If the race is as illustrated in the picture there is little doubt of the outcome and little doubt to the relevance of this outcome. Will this result demonstrate that hundreds of cabinet shops have made flawed decisions? I think not. It certainly won't convince me to sell my air driven ROS, or my hand plane, even if they did deliver equivalent surfaces for finishing, which they don't.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#5

Pentathlon

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Modest proposal for Hand Tool olympic event:

1. Bench plane vs. ROS

2. Sharpening--jigged vs. freehand

3. Western vs. Japanese saws.

4. Pins first vs. Tails first

5. Bevel up vs. bevel down

That should set the cat among the pigeons (isn't that an expression?)

Wiley

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#6

Re: Pentathlon

wilbur

>Actually, given the way the Tauntons are pitching this thing, my guess at the FWW pentathlon would be:

1. Bench plane vs. ROS

2. Sharpening--honing guide vs. grinder

3. Tenons: handsaws vs. tablesaw and tenon jig

4. Dovetails: by hand vs. router jig

5. Bevel up or bevel down plane vs. thickness planer

Regardless, I think that there's a shark tank in Newtown, CT, just waiting for a woodworking editor to leap across it.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#7

Was wondering . . .

steve mackay

>how soon the router was going to get mentioned. Shouldn't it be competeing in EVERY event ? I'm told it can do-it-all.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#8

I`m just surprised ...

Bob Hackett

>That it isn`t plane vs wide belt sander.

Switch it on,one pass thru and you`re done.

What could be easier?

Mainely,Bob-Who gave up on FWW a long time ago.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#9

Re: I`m just surprised ...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, but at what price? Say the inferior surface? Does quality matter?

Pam

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#10

Re: Pentathlon

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Maybe setting loose a fox in a hen house? After all, pigeons are big as cats, could probably clean their clocks if they choose.

Pam

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#11

Re: Pentathlon

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>My guess is one on one the cat wins. My adopted stray is 12 lbs. Bet a pigeon is less than 2 lbs. Plus the bird has a beak against the cats claws. I should post a picture of my livingroom arm chair...

JR

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#12

lets us be fair and banlanced (as the saying goes)

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Shaper vs molding plane(s)

thickness planer vs scrub

chop saw vs miter box

Binks vs brush

Saw Stop vs rip saw (Japanese or Western, users choice)

Bonus event in case of tie- Forest WW II vs shooting board

Unless you are willing to believe that professionals are stupid the issue raised by FWW has been settled for something like 150 years, namely apprentice work is more efficiently done by machines. Only when life style choices become important, or the size of the task tiny, do the machines loose.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#13

Stephen Shepherd

Seems silly to me...

Stephen Shepherd

>There is no competition as there are two separate 'races'; there's one for a sanded finish (sometimes desired) and one for a glass smooth hand planed surface (something completely different and sometimes desired).

If you want to have a realistic challenge use criteria like:

Ear splitting noise verses none.

Irritating fine saw dust verses none.

Tedious setup verses none.

Reliance on electricity verses none.

Even that is silly. If you want to use power tools, use them, if you want to use hand tools, use them and don't argue. If you want to have a fight, take it outside.

Stephen

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#14

I Beg to Differ

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Bill,

I understand what you are saying and in some shops you are probably correct. It's no secret that I burn plenty of electrons in my shop. But if I thought that power tools were the most expedient way to get from point "A" to point "B" I wouldn't have all the hand tools that I own. I would love the luxury of working more with hand tools. But yes, the power tools are my work horses. That said, I have learned over time that there are many tasks that cannot be done as well or faster than with hand tools. You take away my dozuki saw, my planes and my chisels and I would be in a world of hurt! :-)

Tom

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#15

Safety and compromise

Bob Hackett

>I don`t think anyone will dispute that machines excel at doing preliminary work quickly.Try cutting down a tree with a 2 man crosscut saw instead of a chainsaw if you doubt this.The compromise is one of personal safety and control in favor of speed.No protective chaps, earmuffs or faceshield needed when using the "misery whip".No inhaling exhaust fumes either.

The same could be said for power tools in the shop.How many people have had their hands etc mangled or experienced kickback from a handsaw?How many have lost 1 or more fingers to a hand plane?With power tools the work progresses quickly and things can go very wrong in a hurry too.

Mainely,Bob

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#16

True but....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Some here probably know that I had a life threatening kickback accident several years ago. So I certainly don't dispute the dangers of power tools. But aside from that I have had no other significant injuries with power tools (knock on wood). I have however had a couple of nasty lacerations....caused by....you guessed it, hand tools. Sharp tools are safer tools but even they can slip! Ouch!

Tom

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#17

Ouch is right!

Bob Hackett

>Sharp tools are safer,as you say,but they also cut deeper.

I am still sometimes lulled into thinking that hand tools are innately user friendly and that usually leads me to blood loss.:^(

Too soon I forget the mantra"Flesh BEHIND the sharp edge and away from the direction of travel".

Maybe I need another tattoo.

MB

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#18

OK, you cat wins. Was fooled by the feathers. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#19

Re: Pentathlon

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Cat among the pigeons is, I believe, a British phrase. Maybe British cats are more ferocious or British pigeons weaker.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#20

"Maybe I need another tattoo."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>But you'd have to have it somewhere you could read it. On your forearm?

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#21

Let's not go there ;-)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I shudder to think a "show and tell" might ensue here. Decorum must keep us from a "here is my scar....top that"! (memories of "Jaws") ;-)

Tommy

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#22

Too late,I`m going!

Bob Hackett

>No room on the arms.

Maybe if the printing`s small there might still be room on part of the RT hand.

I did say I was a biker in a past life didn`t I?

MB

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#23

I couldn't agree more

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Machines and hand tools each have their place in a shop whose objective is to make stuff. Some silly, and hopelessly flawed, contest by FWW doesn't help anyone making stuff to reach a decision on what is best in their situation.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#24

Re: lets us be fair and banlanced (as the saying g

ThomD

>"Unless you are willing to believe that professionals are stupid the issue raised by FWW has been settled for something like 150 years, namely apprentice work is more efficiently done by machines. Only when life style choices become important, or the size of the task tiny, do the machines loose."

I would suggest splitting wood vs. sawing it, in the cabinetmaking context. There are a lot of things that are faster by hand though obviously many power processes are faster.

One thing is that many professionals are hacks which is why, paradoxically, the quality of work has fallen into a rat hole as the efficiency of the means of production has exploded to unimagined heights. And in fact a fair number of professionals are stupid in the sense that the purpose of a lot of mechanization is lower the quality of person required to do the work. Of course there are many advantages also, but speed = shortcuts. Professionals know you can make more money and happiness making Nikes, than Bespoke shoes. The only thing you can make faster is quality shoes.

But industry is one thing and the home shop is another. I have something like 40 machines in my shop, I can't even remember them all. I am far from convinced that they are really all that fast. A small shop is not an industry. While there are a few obvious winers one way or another, the machines consume a great deal of time and money for what they do. My experience with machines is that one thing leads to another, and that opening the door leads to more and more required machines. They are all heavier, bigger, noisier, and more expensive to maintain than any hand tool. They are also a huge practical anchor. They have reduced my freedom. Right now I could move to France or BC if the spirit moved me, except for packing the machines.

Re: This ought to be interesting: bench plane vs. ROS *LINK*

#25

And a winner was declared *LINKS*

wilbur

>Apparently, the smoothing plane won.

If you missed it, there's a replay of the video you can look at as well. (I still haven't seen it yet.)