Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

Posts

Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#1

Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

James Watriss

>Hi all...

Brief post, but for those of you who have this particular vise, I was having some minor issues which I worked out today. So you may find this information helpful...

http://jameswatriss.blogspot.com/2009/11/veritas-twin-screw-vise-my.html

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#2

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Those are both interesting mods, James. The threaded insert is kinda fun, but disassembling that shaft in order to drill it would not be (for me, anyway).

Did you try doing any super-duper honking down on the grub screws before you decided the-heck-with-it-I'm-gonna-drill?

Wiley

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#3

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise

James Watriss

>I'd honked on em at least 3 times previous to doing this. That's why i decided to just let it roll for a while, and make do with doing it the old fashioned way.

But today I needed to close the vise with one hand while holding the part with the other, and I decided that enough was enough.

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#4

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise

David Brown

>I've been having the same issue with my veritas twin screw vise and it drives me nuts. My cover is permanently removed so I can "fix" it about once a month. Thanks for posting about this. I think the design of the 2 grub screws is very problematic. They just don't hold no matter how much you torque them in my experience.

Cheers.

--Dave

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#5

Detail question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>James,

Check me on this, please. It appears to me that to get at the shaft for drilling, you need to do the following (AFTER punching the shaft thru the grub screw holes):

1. Remove the T (the thing the handle goes thru), by punching out the hollow pin;

2. Release the chain, by taking off the removable link;

3. Remove the follower sprocket--the thing that holds the two grub screws--by loosening the grub screws and sliding it off.

At that point, it looks like you have access to the shaft for drilling. Is this right, or what do I have wrong?

Thanks a lot,

Wiley

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#6

If you`re still concerned about it

Bob Hackett

>Loctite makes a product that may help.I believe it`s called Stud and Bearing Loc and was made to keep bearings etc from spinning or moving on the shaft they were attached to.

If I remember correctly it even wicked into the assembly so you didn`t have to disassemble as long as the parts were clean and dry.

MB

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#7

Re: Detail question

James Watriss

>That's the basic order, yes. :)

But it's important to remember to have the vise clamped shut when you do the marking, AND before you start taking it all apart.

I also found it was helpful to remove the plate that mounts to the vise jaw, just to make a little more room to work with.

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#8

Re: If you`re still concerned about it

James Watriss

>That sounds liek an interesting solution, but I'd still be concerned. Loc-titing a bearing to a shaft may help, but the bond doesn't have to be super-strong, just stronger than the stiction that's keeping the moving parts of the bearing from spinning. But, since the other part of the bearings are meant to spin anyway, I'm not sure what that implies about the strength of the bond. So I don't know how well it would keep a grub screw hooked to the surface of a cylinder.

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#9

Had the same issue. TIghtening grubs daily.

Raney

>I also had the same issue with my twin screw. Drove me up a wall as well, and for the last year I had it I used it without the chain. When I built my new bench, it didn't make the transition with me... though if I'd figured out this mod I might have thought about it.

I think it's a great design addition James has made here - the only issue with it is that if one overtorques, you've really got no 'saftey' to release as with the pin and grub screws. SO something would probably shear, and it might not be an easy piece to repair/replace. I imagine that is why LV didn't make a more 'positive' link of hub to shaft - they might have ended up replacing a lot more parts.

If I still had mine, though, I know what my evening would consist of. Great mod James.

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#10

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise

Chris Friesen

>I haven't had any problems, but maybe my technique is different. I use the vise one-handed to snug things down so the item being clamped won't drop, but then I use both hands together to tighten the vise up to working pressure.

Why bother stressing the weak points when it's not required?

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#11

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise

James Watriss

>That's what I was doing before. But after a while, one side always moved a little more, or needed more tightening. Maybe the piece wasn't perfectly centered in the vise, or something else... And once it started slipping, it kept on slipping.

I suppose I could simply have pulled the pin every time I needed to snug things down. But that seems a bit fussy for (what should be) such a simple piece of equipment.

In any event, it's working a lot better now.

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#12

Something I've been considering...

Alan DuBoff

>I've only been using my twin-screw for a couple years, and haven't had that problem, but the majority of my work has been non-flat work which I do in an Emmert clone I have mounted in the tail position.

I modified my Emmert clone to adapt a wheel on it, and like it quite a bit. Not to diverge, I have been doing some flat work recently and there is no better vise than the twin-screw for dovetailing. Don't forget about the wheel just yet though...*wink*

I see why the vise was deigned as it is, which I suspect is to allow the handles to be lined up once they get out of sync. The odd thing about it is that there are spring clips that hold the T-section on the end of the screw, yet the grub screws are used to allow for "tuning the screws", for lack of a better term. ;-) But the grub screws become the weak point as you point out. Seems it would have been wiser to have the 2 grubs 180 degrees on the diameter of the screw, rather than 90 degrees how mine are set. That might give it the extra strength it could have used.

Back to the wheels, I think they could be the solution for me, although will still have the grubs as the weak link as well. However, it will not matter with a wheel, as unlike a handle they are round. It seems the handles are always out just a tad anyway, they are never perfect and they fluctuate depending on the direction and/or where the slack of the chain is taken up. The one downside is that currently the t-handle is offset about 2 1/2" from the center of the spring clip. My 6" wheel on the Emmert clone has a 4" offset from the same location. Because of that I might consider the wheels that have folding handle on them, so I can fold them down when I'm not using it, or adapt a shallower ball type handle so it doesn't protrude as much. That's my main gripe about the twin-screw, those damn thumb-screws to lock the handle in place ALWAYS seem to catch the hammer loop or one of the pockets on my Carhartts...I was thinking about drill those just a tad so that they could be screwed down farther and possibly not catch me all the time...the wheels will change that if I go that route.

The twin-screw is not perfect, as I remember Chris Schwarz mentioned to me when I was building my bench, but the wooden screws create a juggler out of one's self...I 'spose there is no perfect world, and I like the speed of the twin-screw, personally can't imagine settling for using it without the chain to sync them...For at that point I would probably just replace it with wooden screws. The reason I keep and put up with the idiosyncrasies of the twin-screw is to in fact have the chain.

Anyway, wheels might be a great solution for me. Kinda like Studley meets LV in the designing room...however, like most tools, they probably won't be perfect...(but neither are the handles for me:-) I think I can fit 8" wheels and still have the top below the bench top. I could only fit a 6" wheel on the Emmert clone because of that. With a metal screw, hand wheels are way cool...;-)

BTW, I have my jaw lined with leather, not sure if that extra cushion makes a difference, but as I recall you might have your jaw lined also...

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#13

Anyone have the Lie-Nielsen version?

Jim in N.VA

>I've been considering adding a twin screw vise and am wondering how they approached the design.

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#14

Re: Something I've been considering...

James Watriss

>Hi Alan,

I thought for a second about grub screws at 180 to each other. Then I realized that the 2 at 90 will push the shaft away from both, into the far side of the socket in the handle yoke... so really, there are 3 points of contact. 2 at 180 would simply be working against each other, and would be the two primary contact points. It does make intuitive sense at first, I had the same thought, but it's 2 grub screws in conjunction with the collar that they're threaded through.

I hear what you're saying about the wheel idea, and the image of the Studley bench that you're conjuring up is really cool. I think it's neat for the Emmert, too, since it sounds like a better way to position the vise, or at least, provides another handle to use to manipulate the thing.

But the grub screws aren't really there to keep the handles aligned with each other so much as they're there to keep both sides of the vise aligned with each other. I was having issues with the vise because I'd tighten down on the handle with the sliding pin, and it would turn the gear on the other shaft, without actually turning the other shaft. So the right side of the vise would move in a bit, while the left side stayed put, and the vise gets racked... which is one of the reasons to get a chain vise in the first place.... no racking.

Re: the thumb screws that are driving you crazy, that's one more reason to use the brass inserts like I did on my handles... the screws can go all the way in, and they don't scratch up the handle that way.

I still like your wheel idea, and it's really got me thinking... Just what I need. More ideas.

: )

Where do you get your wheels?

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#15

On the Emmert clone I used Jergens 6" Aluminum *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>James,

The reason I don't like the 90 degree grubs, is that they seem to be pushing into the screw shaft at an angle, it seems that if you had 2 opposing each other, and especially if you were to drill indentations like you did, they would be solid.

With the indentations it sounds like it's not a problem, and not too much choice unless one wants to drill the gear collar also. That could certainly be done though, with not much difficulty. Seems easier to leave it as-is.

I'm not sure what type of brass inserts you used on your t-handles, but will go back and read your blog and see if a pic is there.

The hand wheels are great, IMO, especially on a metal screw. There are 2 schools of thought on the hand wheels, aluminum is light and creates less wear on the screw itself, but I'm not sure that is a problem, it's the nut that will wear out most likely as it seems as it was cast. On the Emmert clone I didn't want the extra weight, and went with the Jergens 6" Aluminum wheel with handle. The handle snaps into a pre-drilled hole, but the wheel itself is not drilled in the center, you need to do that yourself. I used a Silver & Deming bit, which can be gotten at most hardware stores, 1/2" shank with a 3/4" drill. The LV screws might only be 1/2", in that case any metal bit would work. I like to spray alu with either WD-40 or Tap Magic as I'm cutting.

The other school is to use the cast iron wheels, they are much heavier and have more mass, so they can spin longer on momentum. I don't think the screw will be an issue, but not sure, I've gone through a LV quick release nut on a quick release vise which I have, but Rob Lee replaced it for me. Could be a bit smoother due to mass, although the alu is not an issue, spins well...it's so fast to adjust, way faster than the handle...I think it would scream on the twin-screw.

It seems that I can fit 8" wheels, but I would do more measuring before I buy them to make certain they won't stick up above the bench top.

Yeah, I understand how it wears a groove, and agree, one of the main reasons to have the twin-screw is so that it DOESN'T rack.

Despite the quirks, I do like and use it. I'd like to try some wooden screws sometime, possibly, but it's another expensive vise option, feels more like a vice...:-/

My Emmert clone has really turned out to be one of the most useful tools I have, and it's odd how I have it mounted as the tail vise, but it works out excellent. Maloof always worked his Emmert off that corner of the bench, although he didn't use it as a tail vise, he could have. He seemed to use a lot of clamps on the top, so had other ways of securing pieces. But for the non-flat stuff, you can't beat the vise on the dominant side, so that one can work around that corner and move the work in most any direction. At the same time it can be used as a tail vise, I really like the setup to compliment the twin-screw on the front.

Let's see if I can put an image in, I linked to the Enco page so you could see the wheels.

Here's a handle I was using a spoke shave on for a toolbox:


Here's it being used as a tail vise.




img

Enco's Master Catalog

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#16

Re: On the Emmert clone I used Jergens 6" Aluminum

James Watriss

>I don't remember who made the brass inserts, but I do know I got em at Rockler. They're sold as shelf pin sockets, but they're drilled for 1/4" pins, so they handle the 1/4-20 thumb screws just fine.

I fully agree that, despite the quirks, the Veritas is a great vise. The original point of the post wasn't to bash the product, just to offer up my solutions for dealing with the quirks.

I really like the wheel idea on the vise like that. Once I have the time and cash to spare, I think I'll work similar magic in my own shop.

Cool idea. :)

(beautiful bench, too.)

Re: Minor modifications to Veritas twin screw vise...

#17

Re: On the Emmert clone I used Jergens 6" Aluminum

Marv

>Hi James,

Could you make your wheels out of wood? If you did, you wouldn't be limited as to size.

I have a milling machine vise with a handle with three spokes with a knob at the ends. Kinda works like a wheel, but it is easily spun. Just a thought.

Marv