Re: More of a question than an opinion *pic* *LINK*
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>So how do you hold the wheeled gauges? As I understand it, the wheel does not turn--is this correct? If so, the wheeled gauge is a shallow cutting gauge, with a broad tip. If I'm wrong, please straighten me out. But in any event, how do you hold them? I see on this little one, you have to use a pinch grip. Is it the same on the full size TiteMark type ones?
And for whichever grip you use, how do you compare the ergonomics against the longer-fenced cutting gauges--like Kinshiro and Clenton?
Hi Wiley
Interesting questions - I tend to analyse some of these things to death :) but hopefully this helps others understand what the choices are.
The Kinshiro mortice cutting gauge (which may also be used as a single cutting gauge) is my absolute favourite!! This was a gift from a very nice person (and for those who do not know, Wiley was the one who spoiled me!). It is very easy to set up once you know how - I use the method you showed me Wiley - detailed in my recent article on mortice and tenons (link below).
The Colen Clenton is another very nice cutting gauge. Both have in common a comfortable grip, and one that allows for as much down force as you desire. Here are the Kinshiro and CC together ..

And here a picture of the CC in use ..

I like the width of the fence/faces for longer and especially wider markings. This is taken to the extreme when you use a panel gauge - the fence needs to be wider still to control the extra leverage at the cutting end ..


By contrast the wheel gauges have small faces/fences (not sure what to call this). The Tite-Mark and the LV are very similar in size (and, in fact, the rods are the same, making all attachments interchangeable). I have not compared their size against the LV Pocket Gauge, but I suspect that the rod is the same diameter.

As you noted, the wheel gauges are help in a pincher grip. The advantage of these gauges is that they are very controllable, very accurate, adjust more easily, and may cut fine and light lines. They work better in small areas (such as a narrower board, or the side of a tail board). I am not mad about leaving the lines on drawers and boxes, and deep (sometimes even light) lines are very diffucult to plane out. The wheel gauge is easy to form light lines (and then just deepen the working areas).

This strength is also a weakness. I find that the wheel gauge are more difficult to bear down on, and thus they are unsuited to deep lines, such as tenon shoulders, tenon cheeks and mortices.
I do not wish to make it appear that everyone must have a dozen different gauges to suit different size boards. For years I made an old Stanley #65 work very well for everything. It is still my favourite pin gauge (although the pin has been converted to a knife).

Better to have a dozen marking gauges and assign a different one to different areas you wish to mark.
I do want to draw attention that there is an "ideal size". This is where we came in. The little Pocket Gauge is a really useful size for small (tiny) boards. I had no idea that it was on the LV drawing board and it was a wonderful surprise to discover it. My intent was to pass on my thoughts, and I had hoped that the original post would lead to some discussion of these points.
Regards from Perth
Derek
A Primer for Mortice-and-Tenon Joints