Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

LV Pocket Marking Gauge

Posts

LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#1

LV Pocket Marking Gauge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>

I have been asked by some whether this marking gauge is useful or a toy ..

I have a half dozen marking gauges, all of which get used. The ability to keep on hand gauges with different settings is very helpful. For example, with dovetails, mortice-and-tenon joints, etc. ... and especially if you are working with boards of different thicknesses (which is usually the case when they are hand thicknessed).

Not all gauges are equal. I prefer cutting gauges for cross-grain work and have a few, ranging from the wheel cutters of LV and Titemark to the more traditional knifed ones of Colen Clenton, Japanese and shopmade.

Depending on the size of the fence, some suit larger work and some suit smaller work. While they can be used for any size work, the original LV and TM wheel cutters are best suited (in my opinion) to medium sized work, that is, boards about 1/2" thick. Now I often work with thinner boards, some 1/4" thick, where one is working closer to the edge. This is also a feature of hinge mortices, where the depth may be between 1/16" to 1/8". These markings are quite delicate and would benefit from a gauge that offers a delicate touch. The size of the fence is important here (in my experience) - you actually want less of it as it just obscures the view and, thus, accuracy. Because you are marking a shallow depth, a small fence will offer sufficient registration.

Do you agree/disagree?

Today I was building a box that was made of boards 4" wide and 1/4" thick.



A tip: the knobs are identical. I scored a cross on one (with a Dremel) to aid in differentiating the ends.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#2

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>And you can get this and the little shoulder plane for a special price here


special

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#3

More of a question than an opinion

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Derek,

You make a good argument for the little guy.

I have a question. It's a question because I have never had a wheel cutter in my hand. And I know they go quite a ways back--there are Starrett ones that are close to turn of the century as I recall. So the design has survived a long time, which is always a sign of usefulness.

I use three kinds of gauges, more or less interchangeably. They're all cutting gauges. The Japanese gauge (Kinshiro); Colen Clenton (best true cutting gauge I know of); and the English ebony cutting gauges.

In every case, what I like about them--and particularly the Kinshiro and Clenton--is that the fence sits perfectly in my hand with the beam in the web of my hand between thumb and first finger, my palm behind the fence. The control is perfect and effortless with one hand. That's what I like about my gauges--it's such a natural and effortless motion with lots of control.

So how do you hold the wheeled gauges? As I understand it, the wheel does not turn--is this correct? If so, the wheeled gauge is a shallow cutting gauge, with a broad tip. If I'm wrong, please straighten me out. But in any event, how do you hold them? I see on this little one, you have to use a pinch grip. Is it the same on the full size TiteMark type ones?

And for whichever grip you use, how do you compare the ergonomics against the longer-fenced cutting gauges--like Kinshiro and Clenton?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#4

Now hang on just a sec....

Edward in Vancouver

>I check the LV website fairly frequently--at least once a week, and niether the mini shoulder plane NOR the marking guage come up on "What's new" in woodworking tools OR Gifts.

YET

Yet this link is just such an entry from the LV site

What's up?

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#5

I was wondering something similar...

Christopher Fitch@Memphis

>myself. I had not seen either of these items on the website nor the special in any LV catalog and I just received one a few weeks ago.

Just a bit unusual.

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#6

Re: More of a question than an opinion *LINK*

charlie belden

>The "wheel" is a single bevel, VERY sharp carbide, with the bevel towards the "fence". Once the scribe line is begun, that bevel pulls the fence tight against the edge or end of the stock being marked. The attached link has a picture of one gripping position when using this thing. You press down and towards the cutter in use.

The cutting wheel doesn't rotate, but you can change grips to get to a sharper part of the wheel if an area dulls, unlike a japanese "blade" type marking gauge, or a filed to get a double beveled edge on a "pin" type marking gauge. buy a spare wheel and you've got a sharp cutting edge for years. AND, you can lap the wheel back to sharp on a diamond plate.

Unlike the full sized version of this tool, the fence locking "nut" extends out beyond the radius of the "fence" - so the tool WON'T roll off your bench - and on to the floor - where it will invariably land on the cutting edge - something carbide doesn't seem to like.

The beauty of these wheel marking gauges is that you can quickly, easily and accurately reset them to an existing scribe line - something that's a bit trickier to do with either a japanese blade or a euro pin or blade marking gauge.

You can also use these things for measuring depth - of say a mortise, or to set a rip fence after setting the gauge to the thickness of an existing piece of stock, or a router bit height - again, something the more traditional marking gauges can't do.

I've not used the LV version of this type of marking gauge - but I've used the earlier to the market, and more versatile, Glenn Drake micro adjustable wheeled marking gauge and have found it to work very very well.

The one potential problem I see with this little gauge with wheels on both ends is the possibility of getting cut by the end you're not focusing on in use. As noted earlier, the cutters are VERY sharp.

Perhaps not as aesthetically pleasing to the eye, or as comfortable and familiar as your present marking gauges, if you tried one I'm betting you'd GET one.


grip for mini-marking gauge

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#7

I received the LV News email update...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>All you need to do is sigh up for them on their web site!

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#8

Re: More of a question than an opinion *pic* *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>So how do you hold the wheeled gauges? As I understand it, the wheel does not turn--is this correct? If so, the wheeled gauge is a shallow cutting gauge, with a broad tip. If I'm wrong, please straighten me out. But in any event, how do you hold them? I see on this little one, you have to use a pinch grip. Is it the same on the full size TiteMark type ones?

And for whichever grip you use, how do you compare the ergonomics against the longer-fenced cutting gauges--like Kinshiro and Clenton?

Hi Wiley

Interesting questions - I tend to analyse some of these things to death :) but hopefully this helps others understand what the choices are.

The Kinshiro mortice cutting gauge (which may also be used as a single cutting gauge) is my absolute favourite!! This was a gift from a very nice person (and for those who do not know, Wiley was the one who spoiled me!). It is very easy to set up once you know how - I use the method you showed me Wiley - detailed in my recent article on mortice and tenons (link below).

The Colen Clenton is another very nice cutting gauge. Both have in common a comfortable grip, and one that allows for as much down force as you desire. Here are the Kinshiro and CC together ..


And here a picture of the CC in use ..


I like the width of the fence/faces for longer and especially wider markings. This is taken to the extreme when you use a panel gauge - the fence needs to be wider still to control the extra leverage at the cutting end ..



By contrast the wheel gauges have small faces/fences (not sure what to call this). The Tite-Mark and the LV are very similar in size (and, in fact, the rods are the same, making all attachments interchangeable). I have not compared their size against the LV Pocket Gauge, but I suspect that the rod is the same diameter.


As you noted, the wheel gauges are help in a pincher grip. The advantage of these gauges is that they are very controllable, very accurate, adjust more easily, and may cut fine and light lines. They work better in small areas (such as a narrower board, or the side of a tail board). I am not mad about leaving the lines on drawers and boxes, and deep (sometimes even light) lines are very diffucult to plane out. The wheel gauge is easy to form light lines (and then just deepen the working areas).


This strength is also a weakness. I find that the wheel gauge are more difficult to bear down on, and thus they are unsuited to deep lines, such as tenon shoulders, tenon cheeks and mortices.

I do not wish to make it appear that everyone must have a dozen different gauges to suit different size boards. For years I made an old Stanley #65 work very well for everything. It is still my favourite pin gauge (although the pin has been converted to a knife).


Better to have a dozen marking gauges and assign a different one to different areas you wish to mark.

I do want to draw attention that there is an "ideal size". This is where we came in. The little Pocket Gauge is a really useful size for small (tiny) boards. I had no idea that it was on the LV drawing board and it was a wonderful surprise to discover it. My intent was to pass on my thoughts, and I had hoped that the original post would lead to some discussion of these points.

Regards from Perth

Derek


A Primer for Mortice-and-Tenon Joints

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#9

Re: More of a question than an opinion

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>The beauty of these wheel marking gauges is that you can quickly, easily and accurately reset them to an existing scribe line - something that's a bit trickier to do with either a japanese blade or a euro pin or blade marking gauge.

Hi Charlie

As I mentioned above, Wiley taught me what to do, and I have described this process in a recent article. To save time looking it up, here are the salient points:

... mark across the width with the mortice chisel, as shown below.


This is going to aid in setting up the mortice gauge. Simply place the ends of the knives (or points) in the ends of the cut. This sets up the cutting width.


Now slide the head of the gauge against the work piece to set its depth. This completes setting up the mortice gauge.


Mark the mortice lines.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#10

Three wheel marking gauges

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Someone asked about the size of the Pocket versus the full sized version.

I have not measured the diameter of the rod of the Pocket Gauge, but the LV and TM are both 5/16".


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#11

Re: Now hang on just a sec....

Rob Lee

>Hi Edward -

The pair is an email special - but is also available at the store. Since we don't have a catalogue in the mail for another week, it's not in print anywhere.

Both items are shown in the Main Christmas catalogue though, but the pair price will have expired by then. We couldn't print such a short time period offer for the Christmas catalogue, as we have no control over when it gets delivered, and don't want to risk having customers recieve an expired offer.

We will be having more email only offers, as the cost of printing and mailing continues to increase (substantially!). We will definitely continue with printed catalogues, but there will be additonal email based offers, and online flyers to augment our regular mailings.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#12

Not carbide

Alex Yeilding

>Charlie: Just a clarification here. On the LV website, the cutters are described as hardened steel, not carbide.

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#13

Wheel v. pin or knife

Alex Yeilding

>Wiley,

You may find that you have developed marking technique you are not conscious of.

My go-to marking gauge is an inexpensive English pin gauge (Clay) with the pin sharpened blade-like, set to draw the fence to the wood very slightly. I bought a wheel gauge a while back to see what all the fuss was about, and became aware of some of my gauging technique that was previously subconscious.

My gauge has a square beam. When marking, I lay the forward edge of the beam on the work, then flex my wrist slightly forward to lower the pin to a trailing position, cutting as lightly or as deeply as I want based on subtle flexing of my wrist. No matter how shallow or deep the scribe line, I have solid contact all along the beam and the fence. I REALLY missed this when I tried a wheel gauge. With the wheel gauge, I felt like I had the choices of

  • cutting to the depth equal to the radius of the wheel minus the radius of the rod,


  • trying to hold the rod a fixed distance above the workpiece, or


  • having the points of contact being the wheel, the rod at the fence end, and the bottom of the fence. (I know, these angles are tiny, but that was the feeling I had.)

Far better woodworkers than I swear by wheel gauges, so you would almost be irresponsible not to try one, particularly with a deal like this. I just thought this perspective may help.

I plan to buy this for small projects, hinge mortises, and as an occasional two-pass mortgage gauge.

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#14

This one's much better...  *LINK*

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>


Now for a real gauge!

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#15

Re: Not carbide *LINK*

charlie belden

>Was thinking of the Tite-Mark's cutter. Should have read the LV description better. But both can be quickly and easily sharpened with a pass or two over a diamond plate in the case of the carbide, or a stone in the case of hardened steel.

But the advantage of a wheeled marking gauge over a knife marking gauge is that you've got a lot more sharp edge you can use before having to sharpen.

Don't know if the LV wheeled marking gauge lets you use a pair of cutters you can set the gap between to your mortising chisel width, but the TiteMark has them as accessories.

The big plus using this pair of cutter wheels is that setting the width is independent of setting the distance from the fence.

It appears from the photographs of setting up the two separate knives marking gauge, that the fence AND the two knives all appear to be locked down by the single thumb screw. So if you have to move the fence - without a way to lock down the knives spacing - there's a chance something will move that shouldn't.


TiteMark with pair of mortise cutters option

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#16

Re: This one's much better...

charlie belden

>You did notice that the thing weighs 11 pounds.

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#17

Re: This one's much better...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Yup, doubles up as a barbell :-)

DC

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#18

Re: Now hang on just a sec....

Edward in Vancouver

>Thanks Rob,

Today was my day off and I went for my "bike ride", a brisk, rain sprinkled slog of about 12 k, at the end of which, my reward is not alcoholic in nature, nor caffein related, but rather a relaxing time in a certain Woodworker's store, and then back 12k to my garage to experiment with new toys...

And there they were, on the sales counter. Sure are cute, but I only snapped up the marking guage (and a few other items....)

I'm not on the special mailing list, but I will be.

I did find both items on the regular website catalouge, but you have enter the specific name to bring it up.

Looking forward to the Christmas Catalouge

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#20

Fast ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>I ordered them last night and got notification this morning that they were shipped ;-)

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#21

My Wheel v. Pin preference- wheel wins

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You focus on a factor that I have not found significant, or even noticed. Either style registers equivalently in my hands. For me, the wheel wins because I can adjust it quickly and precisely to a target setting (I have the kind that has a threaded adjuster). I also prefer threaded depth adjusters on hand planes for the same reason. The non-threaded adjuster kind is inconvenient to adjust, even more so than the pin style, and I abandoned mine long ago.

I much prefer the ergonomics of the pin style, as Wiley describes, but until I am shown, or figure out, how to adjust it as conveniently as my wheel gauge the wheel will remain my go to tool. Having the rod contact the work is irrelevant and the marking depth is easily controlled by pressure. However, it doesn't fit the hand nearly as well as the typical pin gauge.

As far as this tiny wheel gauge, it is counter to my multitasking expectations for tools (except fire extinguishers). I don't see that it will do anything so much more convenient that my full sized marker that I would be motivated to buy one. However, it is a slick looking device that will find a market among those more tolerant of specialized tools.

Re: LV Pocket Marking Gauge

#22

Re: My Wheel v. Pin preference- wheel wins

Joel

>"I much prefer the ergonomics of the pin style, as Wiley describes, but until I am shown, or figure out, how to adjust it as conveniently as my wheel gauge the wheel will remain my go to tool"

Easy peasy. hold the gauge by the beam with your fingers just behind the fence. With the screw slightly loose squeeze the beam, forcing your fingers flatter and wider, moving the fence a tiny amount. vary the finger pressure varies the amount the fence moves.

With the fence loose and the beam held vertically it's even easier. with a tiny amount of practice it's second nature.