Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Cost vs. utility *LINK*

Posts

Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

Cost vs. utility *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>I posted this on the main board, but it is certainly appropriate here, too...

In a recent thread on the main board about Bridge City Tools, Brent Smith brought up an issue that lurks in every tool purchase: cost versus utility. My sense is that our primary criterion when buying a tool is utility. We need a tool that accomplishes a particular task. From there, it seems the criteria are all over the map. Some people buy adequate tools and take pride in making them work. Others buy fancy or highly engineered tools because they appreciate the feel or the engineering or some other characteristic of the tool, or simply because they can afford it, so why not buy the "best" or most expensive one available?

What I'd like to know is how do *you* buy tools? How good is good enough? How important is the price? How much extra are you willing to pay for marginal increases in utility or feel or bragging rights or investment value? What other factors enter your decision?

Just curious...

Ellis


Betty Scarpino guest chat, Nov . 18

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Cost vs. utility

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I'm cheap.I shop at flea markets and yard sales on a regular basis. However,when it comes to tools, I learned years ago that top quality makes a large difference.I shop around alot before making most purchases(my earlier post is a rare exception).When I was a mechanic I found that when you use something every day and depend on it it makes sense to get the best.

Having said that I have to add that I also learned that the top brand name is also not the best choice.Snap-On makes undoubtedly the best mechanics tools,however,Mac or Matco tools are comparable in quality but less expensive.So while I own some Snap-On tools ,most of my tools are Mac or Matco.

The same goes for Woodworking tools.While I don't doubt the quality of Bridge city for example,I don't think they're worth the extra cost.I won't buy cheap tools but cost definitely comes into it when making a purchase.---Jack

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#3

Re: Cost vs. utility

Ace Karner

>I absolutely subscribe to the old saw "Buy the best you can afford, then you only cry once".

In my younger days I can't tell how many times I ruined a project using a cheap tool, then found I hand to spend more money on supplies and buy the better tool also.

I can't afford Bridge City or Holtey but I would buy them if I could, as it is I do own a Bronze LN 4 1/2 and use it all the time.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#4

Re: Cost vs. utility

Bob Hackett

>If I need to part with a moderate to large amount of cash then I will shop around for the best tool for the job.For me that means utility/performance.I pay more for things like Carhart clothes and Redwing boots because they are a known commodity.I can take them off the shelf and know they will fit the best and last the longest.I still look for sales though.

Durable tools come under the same scrutiny.Sometimes the best tool for the job means buying high dollar raw materials and making it myself or buying an older proven used tool and a new iron.

I still look forward to the Veritas and LN catalogs.I own afew Veritas tools that impressed me with their innovation and aspire to own more bronze than my LN low angle block plane(as soon as I can bear to part with my Bedrocks).

One thing I do NOT do is buy CHEAP tools,I don`t care if they have a lifetime warranty.That only means I`ll be regretting that purchase for the rest of my life.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#5

yes ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>Both or either, depending on the tool. I also generally subscribe to the 80/20 rule as mentioned by someone else on the main board. For me, somewhere in the middle is usually the best for me, not the cheapest, and not the most expensive. A lot of the time, I will check here to see who has experience. I have ended up skipping a purchase based on info here, and have also ended up with something that I never thought of.

Thet said, there are a few times that I do buy for other than just price or utility. I own a few Clark and Williams planes. I am sure that I could get something that would work for less, but if you have ever seen one of them, they are works of art that work superbly. I guess in some cases, I will spend a bit more for hand craftsmanship and to help do my tiny bit to support those that are willing to take the time to construct tool jewelry for the rest of us. Someday, my dream would be to get a half set of H&R from Clark and Williams. I am sure I could put together a set for less, but not with the same beauty and feel.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#6

Re: Cost vs. utility

Tony Z

>My wife and kids have a standing list of tools I desire and these are the presents I receive for Christmas, birthdays and Father's Day. These types of tools are generally the ones I will not buy for myself, not because of price, but because they may be something not used all the time.

When I buy for myself, I generally buy a quality tool, but not necessarily the "bling" tool.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#7

Re: Cost vs. utility

wilbur

>The fact that I took on woodworking as a hobby means that I crossed the "justify the cost" line a long time ago. :@)

Seriously, although the cost vs. utility issue is phrased as if it's an objective, quantifiable decision, it really is a subjective question. One person may see no added utility in a Lie-Nielsen bench plane above a rehabbed Stanley. Others may appreciate cherry handles and totes and brass accents and the appearance of a new plane. Does that mean that there is no utility in those design elements? Not if you think that the pleasure you get from a tool is worth what you paid for it.

To look at it from another perspective, being woodworkers, I'm sure we all appreciate a bookcase made from solid cherry. From a "utility" standpoint, that bookcase won't hold books any better than the cinder-block-and-2x-material bookcases we all had in college, and the price differential between a solid cherry bookcase and a pile of cinder blocks and 2x material is a lot higher than that between a LN plane and a used Stanley, or a Festool router vs. a Porter-Cable.

Now, this is not to say that everyone should dump their used Stanleys for Lie-Nielsens, or that everyone should sell their high-end gently used tools, take the proceeds and buy cheap used ones and pocket the difference. We all have our own perspectives on what "utility" is, which is what make the world go round. Where these conversations gets into trouble is when they transition from "This is what I would pay extra for," to "and therefore everyone else should make the same purchasing decision."

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#8

Re: Cost vs. utility

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bob said, "One thing I do NOT do is buy CHEAP tools,I don`t care if they have a lifetime warranty.That only means I`ll be regretting that purchase for the rest of my life."

Now that is funny. Words to live by.

Wiley

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#9

Re: Cost vs. utility

Chris Friesen

>I see it as sort of an asymptotic curve. Initially an increase in price can get you a lot more utility (but doesnt' guarantee it), but as price goes up you get less and less improvement for the price difference.

For myself, I have a reasonable income, an infant son, not a lot of spare time, very little in the way of used tools available locally, I live in Canada (which cuts out much of what's on ebay), and there is a Lee Valley within 10 minutes drive. It's awfully tempting to just go out and buy tools new.

Veritas (and to a lesser extent Lie-Nielsen) seem to be at a pretty good value/utility/aesthetics point for me for much of their offerings. It also depends on the specific tool. My planes are mostly Veritas, my good chisels are L-N.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#10

Marginal Utility

Jay Samuels

>Every time I am tempted to buy a L-N block plane, I ponder whether the performance will be so superior to my Sargent made Craftsman as to justify the price. Then I keep using the Craftsman. Then in about a month the aesthetic of owning the L-N surfaces again, and I go through the thought process all over. If all tool users were economically rational, we would not have high-end toolmakers. Since it is desirable to have high-end toolmakers, every once and a while I will give in to the aesthetic (2 L-N planes and 2 L-V planes), but for general purpose tools where you can find a Stanley or a MF, the marginal increase in utility probably does not often justify the difference in price. The genius of marketing is to convince us that we are buying something in terms of design or status or quality or some psychic intangible in addition to a marginal increase in utility. Just like a Mercedes or a Coach purse.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#11

Re: Marginal Utility

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I started using a 60-1/2 block plane roughly in 1963, and I've had the same plane ever since. I did upgrade it with a Hock blade after I wore out the original one. I did an awful lot of trim carpentry with it, and there were times when it was the only plane I had, so it also had to serve as a smoother or jointer as needed. I like that plane a lot and never thought I'd look at another.

Then for my birthday this year, my family gave me a new Veritas premium block plane (it was one of those milestone b-days). I rarely use my old stanley anymore. The Veritas is that much better. And frankly, that surprises me. An awful lot of thought went into the Veritas which is evident as soon as you use it.

I've been a user kind of guy my whole life, trying to do the best with what I have rather than upgrading just to upgrade. But when I have upgraded, I've never been disappointed. Makes me wonder what the process would have been like for me if I'd started somewhere further up the line.

I'm equally sure there is a point beyond which I'm not willing to go. I have a decent set of Berg chisels, which seem very good to me, but I lust in my heart after a set of Dave Jeske's Blue Spruce bench chisels. I wonder where that will lead. At the other end of that continuum is a set of Genju Funahiro Bench Chisel. I just know I'll never even hold one of them.

And so it goes.

Bruce

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#12

Re: Cost vs. utility

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I go for utility, I want the tool that best does the job, regardless of look.

One exception is the Veritas premium block plane, in that case I will buy the NX over the DX because it looks so good, even if the DX works as well...

DC

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#13

Re: Cost vs. utility

ThomD

>If you feel any better, isn't the more expensive one rust proof? I have lost planes to rust when I moved shop once, really bugs me still.

I will pay extra for tools, including fairly large amounts of extra money as long as there is a performance increase. I have said in the past that no extra increment spent on Japanese tools has failed to rewarded me. I tend to buy pro grade tools. I would prefer to buy a 3 K set of chisels if it was simple pro, rather than 3k tourist style ones, so there are traps in the Japanese market also.

With western tools it is often less clear for three reasons:

1) many of the best western tools are still antiques, particularly in stationary power tools, but also in some areas like chisels, or planes that are no longer made.

2) Money tends to go into the sizzle not the steak. Which in my case I would define as stuff other than blades.

BCT from the beginning was more into the look than the performance. I bought one of their marking gages a long time back, and it isn't as good as a white oak standard Japanese marking gage. Which is one case where the Japanese version is pretty shabby looking. Their new saw thingy is truly an innovation though.

I am a big believer in owning tools that are the equal of the work I do, or want to do. Good work can be done with junk, but why live like that? Is good work worth it or not. Why have high standards in what you admire and aspire to produce but low standards in the stuff you use to make it. Even a pretty good Japanese chisel costs what some people spend on cigarettes (well at least up here) in a week.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#14

Re: Marginal Utility

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>There is 'utility' in beauty. Just look at what you are willing to create from wood, time and sweat. And look at who appreciates it.

Not everyone, but enough. And we 'resonate' with those types of people who appreciate similar things.

That you find sufficient utility in the older tool is great. That I find utility as well in the product from Maine is also. It's a big world out there.

I don't shop fleas or garage sales. It's just me. There are more interesting things to do in my limited time.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#15

Re: Cost vs. utility

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Same here, which also allows me to make a mistake in buying a tool since I'll be able to sell it without any problem.

Pam

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#16

Re: Cost vs. utility

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>To look at it from another perspective, being woodworkers, I'm sure we all appreciate a bookcase made from solid cherry. From a "utility" standpoint, that bookcase won't hold books any better than the cinder-block-and-2x-material bookcases we all had in college...

I think this particular example is not quite true. Look at all the space taken by cinder block girth, thus allowing the solid cherry version to hold more books in the same space. Also, there's no cinder block grit afflicting the floor/carpet.

Pam

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#17

Re: Cost vs. utility

Edward in Vancouver

>I belive that there are two thresholds in most equipment quality structures. The first threshold is from crap to quality, and the second is from quality to art.

I TEND to stop after the first threshold, hate crap tools but am too cheap to buy art.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#18

What is your hobby

Neal in San Jose

>I teach hand plane classes at a couple of venues, and one question I always ask is "What is your hobby"? If it is metal working and rehabbing old planes, then fine, go to ebay or a flea market and pick up an old, experienced tool and put it back to work. Nothing wrong with that. If your hobby is woodworking, however, a LN or LV, or more recently, Wood River, gets you to woodworking right out of the box. The cost? Well, what is your time worth? If that old plane takes me 5 hours of work to get working well, even if I only figure my time at $20, then a new high quality plane makes a lot of sense. I can tell you that my shop time is a LOT more valuable to me than $20 per hour! I may not be able to justify a Holtey, but I can sure as heck justify a LN, LV or Wood River.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#19

Basic economics...

James Watriss

>What do you have a surplus of? Time, or money? Spend whichever you can most afford to part with.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#20

The thing that thinking discounts...

Bob Hackett

>Is the fact that if you rehab an old tool then you acquire a true working knowledge of how and why that tool works.That knowledge allows you to troubleshoot problems and evaluate performance and feedback more effectively IMO.

MB

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#21

Jack Guzman from Maine

voice of experience?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>HI Pam,

Sounds as if you may have had a cinderblock bookcase sometime in your past. :-}---Jack

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Not quite......

Jesper, Denmark

>Lost time can never be regained. You are alotted a certain amount, and then.........

Lost money can be recovered or re-earned.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#23

Re: Not quite......

James Watriss

>I agree, but think of the array of people that are coming into the hobby. I wouldn't tell a 20 year old who's barely making rent to blow $300 on a L-N #4. $40 on a vintage stanley and a few hours worth of tuning it up will be a lot more affordable for him or her... and I don't think that learning such a skill is really wasted time... it's well spent, and results in a tool that can (IMHO, and experience) work better than an out-of the box premium plane, which hasn't been sharpened, or cambered.

I also think that the experience that's bought with that expenditure of time will give the user a much better idea of how the plane works, and a little more willingness to experiment, than someone who's looking at shiny bronze, and thinking "MY EXCALIBUR! THIS WILL CUT EVERYTHING PERFECTLY!!!"

All things considered, I think the middle road is my preferred way to go... buy vintage, tune it up, and add aftermarket steel. Finish up with a little bit of shellac and wax on the handles, and an old Stanley can feel amazingly new. It's remarkable what the tactile sensations can contribute to how we think of our tools. There's a reason L-N's handles feel as good as they do, and the truth is that the old rosewood handles feel remarkably sexy with a little bit of attention.

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#24

Sure, & it was a couple years after college. :)

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Cost vs. utility *LINK*

#25

Well, yeah, but

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the voids in the cinderblocks are a perfect location for the candleholders (or, for settings with smokers, ashtrays) made from lunched motorcycle pistons.