Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

ryoba question

Posts

ryoba question

#1

ryoba question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away, I was given a ryoba. How do I tell the quality of this saw and whether it is resharpenable. I received it from a relative who I'm quite sure can't tell me.

Any hints?

Thanks

Bruce, in cold, drizzly MN

Re: ryoba question

#2

Re: ryoba question

wilbur

>Overall, if it has a replaceable blade, it's most likely not resharpenable.

Also, if you see some bluish discoloration around the teeth, that usually means that the teeth were impulse hardened, and in that case they are too hard to resharpen.

Can you post some pictures, especially close ups of the teeth?

Re: ryoba question

#3

Re: ryoba question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Wilbur, I'll post pics tonight. The teeth do not appear to be bluish. I also have a dozuki, around 20 tpi or so, and those aren't bluish, either. I'd like to get them sharpened, but if they're not of sufficient quality, then I'd simply replace them.

bh

Re: ryoba question

#4

Re: ryoba question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>is this sharp enough?


img

Re: ryoba question

#5

Looks handmade to me...

Alan DuBoff

>Bruce,

To me it looks handmade, because it looks like it's been scraped with a sen, you can see the scoring which is typically left by a sen.

The rip teeth look like the type that are sharpen-able to me, and to me it looks like a pretty decent saw.

The best way would be to test it with a file. A file won't be able to file impulse hardened teeth as Wilbur pointed out, and will skate right off them.

That doesn't look like too bad a saw, can you show a pic with the handle? It doesn't look like your typical throw-away replaceable blade ryoba, but I could be wrong.

Re: ryoba question

#6

Re: Looks handmade to me...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Alan,

I'll post the handle tomorrow morning. For the meantime, here's a tighter shot of the blade.

Bruce


img

Re: ryoba question

#7

Re: ryoba question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>You may want to post this question at Neanderthal Haven, along with photos of the cover with the writing. There's a Japanese/English speaker who just showed up recently.

Pam

Re: ryoba question

#8

One suggestion...

Alan DuBoff

>Bruce,

You might want to clean the teeth, it looks like there some slight corrosion, probably from sitting. Some spirits would probably take care of that.

Re: ryoba question

#9

Re: ryoba question *LINK*

Hank Knight

>Bruce,

I agree with Alan, your saw looks hand made. I find Japanese saws impossible to sharpen - but I admit to being a total klutz when it comes to saw sharpening. I recommend you contact Mark Grable who is a bonafide metate (Japanese saw master). He can put your saw in tip top shape. Here's a link:


Mark Grable - Metate

Re: ryoba question

#10

Re: Looks handmade to me...

wilbur

>Your ryoba definitely looks sharpenable. If you have those diamond-shaped files that are used for sharpening Japanese saws, I would go for it.

Re: ryoba question

#11

Re: Looks handmade to me...

raney

>I agree - my monitor isn't the best here, but it also looks like you can see the hammer strikes from setting the teeth. Looks to be at the very least a fairly good saw - possibly a very good one.

Re: ryoba question

#12

Re: ryoba question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bruce,

Here's how you can tell if the ryoba has any hand work in it, beyond sharpening. It should be said, the distinctions we are talking about do not equate with quality vs. non-quality. There are working professionals doing the highest quality work, who use Gyokucho or other machine made saws, rather than taking their handmade saws to a job site. Let's look at just one variable--the thickness and taper of the saw body....

Do you have a micrometer? Go to the far end of the saw and mic the saw body just above the toothline on both the rip and cross edges, and then mic it in the middle--this is all along the far edge of the saw body. If the saw has been hand-scraped, it will be thinner in the middle, which allows for some clearance when cutting. For example, I have a 240mm Gyokucho here, as well as a 240mm Chuyemon, from Hida Tool. The Gyokucho mics (in thousandths of an inch) at 18.5, 18.5, 18.5 from toothline to center to toothline. In other words, it is a flat plate. The Chuyemon mics at 18.5, 15.0, 18.5 from toothline to center to toothline. So the Chuyemon has been scraped down in the center to provide some partial clearance.

Now let's go up to the end near you, where the saw body connects to the shank. The Gyokucho mics again at 18.5 thousandths. It is simply a flat plate from one end to the other, and from top to bottom--it mics at 18.5 everywhere. It also has very little beam strength where the body enters the shank--there is a flyswatter like effect if you shake the saw. The teeth are electro-hardened, as Wilbur said.

If I check the Chuyemon at the heel end, it mics 24.0 at either toothline (above the teeth), and if I mic up the shank, it thickens to 72 thousandths at the weld. So this saw is double-tapered--tapered from heel to toe, and partially tapered from each toothline to the centerline. The double tapering could have been hand-scraped or machined or likely a combination of both--but it gives the saw a much different action when you shake it, compared to the Gyokucho. It has more beam strength, which in general means it will hold its shape in the cut better.

So you can use a mic to find out something about your saw. I might mention that traditional ryobas are flared outward in plan view, so that the saw is wider at the far end than at the near end. Also, the rip side teeth are traditionally graduated, as they are on both my Gyokucho and Chuyemon.

All of the above is not to encourage saw-snobbism. Working professionals are using machine made saws at the job site. They work, and they are practical.

Try your saw and see how it works! That's the best test.

Wiley

Re: ryoba question

#13

Re: One suggestion...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I've neglected this saw, but I have to say that I've renewed my interest in it mostly because of the many discourses that have happened on this board. I work with what I have, I lust for lots, but work with what I have. And the sad truth is I've not explored this particular one to any kind of potential. What I've learned is that it really has potential. Thanks

Bruce

Re: ryoba question

#14

Re: ryoba question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I did just that, Pam, and got a translation. It tells me that what I have is at least craftsman level, and it predates the machine-made saws. That alone is worth the info. Thanks.

Bruce

Re: ryoba question

#15

Re: ryoba question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Hank,

This saw will be taking a trip to Mark in the very near future. It's not something I'd trust to my own feeble saw sharpening skills. I wouldn't trust me to use a saw set on one, either.

Bruce

Re: ryoba question

#16

Re: ryoba question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>In the morning, I'm going to sit in front of this here computer, micrometer in hand and measure this sucker. I'll bet it shows what you've outlined. In particular, I am pretty well convinced this is a much better saw than I ever thought it was.

I'll let you know what I measure.

Bruce

Re: ryoba question

#17

Re: ryoba question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>If it is a silky, that's probably real good, lots of Japanese tool users talk fondly of them.

Pam

Re: ryoba question

#18

If you have time...

Alan DuBoff

>Bruce,

I would still like to see the handle and specifically the section on the blade at the neck, where the maker's mark is.

Looks to me like you have a fine tool, I would clean it up a tad and use it. Those are the type of rip teeth that typically work well on hardwoods, so that would make it a very useful Ryoba from my view. Some of the impulse hardened saws are not as good for hardwood, as an example the dozukis will often have crosscut teeth, and seem intended to cut softwoods with. Using that type of saw on hardware is futile. This larger, and courser pitch as on the rip side is good for hardwood. The Ryoba is a very useful saw in regard to having both rip and crosscut teeth. Those crosscut teeth also look sharpen able to me, and why I say it does have the markings of a decent saw.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: ryoba question

#19

Re: ryoba question

wilbur

>Mark will do a great job on your saw. One thing to do is to let him know what kinds of wood you plan on using with this saw -- softwoods, hardwoods, exotics. That way Mark can tweak the teeth for the species of wood you plan to cut.

Even so, you might want to try sharpening it a little yourself, assuming that you have a Japanese saw file. I've found that it's not that hard to touch up a Japanese saw, it will be good practice, Mark will still be able to sharpen it after you give it a try, and as I've heard Joel say, a badly sharpened saw will still cut better than a dull one.

Re: ryoba question

#20

Some translation for you...

Alan DuBoff

>Bruce,

I asked my wife about the kanji, several are old style that they do not use anymore, and she is not 100 percent certain on the maker name, which are the 2 in the center of the center column. If you flip the image 90 degrees clockwise it will be the proper way.

The kanji along the left side (reading top down) means "using special hagane", and the hagane is referring to the steel.

The kanji on the right side translates roughly to "the best made".

The 2 kanji on top of the center column means "Register".

The 2 kanji in the middle of the center column are Tama, and she believes Kitsune, but the kanji is not clear and it is definitely old style and could be pronounced differently.

The 2 kanji on the bottom of the center colum mean "special choice" roughly, in old style kanji which are not used anymore.

Of course it is 240mm, you can probably figure that out, and on the very bottom (left to right) mean roughly "display style", she wasn't exactly sure what that refers to with it.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: ryoba question

#21

Clarification on maker name

Alan DuBoff

>Bruce,

Just to clarify, on the maker kanji. Tama and Kitsune are what the kanji appear to be, but names are a funny thing in Japan, you will often have the same kanji which is pronounced differently.

My wife has 2 students in her cooking classes with the same kanji which are pronounced completely differently.

Often a single kanji will have many different ways to pronounce it, believe it or not, there are often 8 or more pronunciations. When the Japanese type on the computer, they will select from those various pronunciations when they input hirigana, katakana or romagi.

Tama and Kitsune would be the most common pronunciation.