Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

sharpening profile scrapers

Posts

sharpening profile scrapers

#1

sharpening profile scrapers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>What brought this question up is the need to smooth some tiny ogee bracket feet. Which led to making a custom profiled scraper from some 3/4" package strapping. So, once I have the profile filed what is the best/preferred way to refine the edge, and then resharpen the edge when it gets dulled?

The options seem more limited than for the case of a flat card scraper. For one thing it is not possible to file parallel to the profiled edge, at least if it is concave. Do you file straight across, at an angle, try to form a burr with a burnisher??

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#2

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>Bill ...

I use .125 tool steel to make these useful little tools. I bought a piece that was 12 x 18" about twenty-five years ago. I've probably made 60-70 scrapers over the years (used to do a lot more period pieces than I do now) and I probably have at least half of the original stock left.

Once I have the edge filed to the profile I want I harden the scraper with a torch; then flatten the leading face and refine the profile with a slip stone. Every time you touch up the cutting edge you will change the profile slightly, but this isn't usually a big problem.

I have a notebook filled with all kinds of data that my tired old brain won't retain anymore and I make a tracing of each new profile along with some notes about the job it was made for.

Most of the catalogs have slip stones in various profiles. I bought mine at a knife show about 20 years ago - they aren't terribly expensive.

Good luck .... RJ

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#3

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Very helpful, RJ! But do you sharpen the edge to a bevel, or try to maintain it square (even though there is no simple way to joint it).

Wiley

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#4

more questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Yours are way more substantial scrapers than I am making out of the thin stock I have. How do you hold them? How hard did you make them(could they be filed after heat treating)?

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#5

Re: more questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Bill,

I have made several profile scrapers, and just cut them from an old worn out saw. I ground close to the final profile, refined with a file, tried to flatten the edge with a slip stone or draw-file if possible and then burnished with my card scraper burnisher. No special hardening was necessary, but then these were for limited run moldings, maybe 10-15 feet at a time.

Bruce

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#6

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

Bob Hackett

>The scrapers I`ve made have been from old carbon steel knives (stainless will work too) I pick up from the dump.I file them straight across,no burr.

If I don`t have a slipstone(look at places that sell used machinist tools)the right size or shape then I use a dowel,the file,etc,wrapped in fine abrasives to hone.

If you have Garret Hack`s handplane book there`s instructions there too,to include holding devices.

Mainely,Bob

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#7

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Bill,

I have made concave scrapers by grinding to rough shape then finishing with round files. You can draw-file with a round file. I then turn a burr on both square edges.

Luthiers sharpen their scrapers to 45 degrees and turn one (more agressive) burr.

Stephen

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#8

Clarification

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>1. I shape the profile to a slight bevel - maybe 10 degrees

2. I make a simple holder out of whatever scrap of hardwood is available and fix the cutter to the holder with a set-screw passing through a threaded insert.

3. I'm not sure what the Rockwell hardness is - I heat to cherry red and quench in oil. Can't really file the profile after hardening.

I admit that I am probably way in to "overkill" when it comes to material. I make up for it by not being too fussy about refining the edge.

With few exceptions I have used the scrapers once and never touched them again, but my grandfather taught me that spending a little extra time when building a tool is usually a good investment.

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#9

Is that burr on the bevel side?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: sharpening profile scrapers

#10

Burr on the flat side

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>