Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

LOVE those Japanese super stones!

Posts

LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#1

LOVE those Japanese super stones!

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi everyone

Over the weekend I was playing with my new Naniwa Japanese "Super Stones" that I got from TFWW. In addition to the super stones, I also got a Steel Flattening Plate (Kanaban) and some 45 Micron Diamond Paste.

Since I was in between coating a project with shellac, I decided to take my new toys for a test drive. I chose an old 3/4" Whitherby Chisel whose back I could not seem to get flat using the old "sandpaper-on-glass-method".

After I cleaned the Kanaban plate with some mineral spirits to remove any grease or oil, I fastened it to a chunk of plywood. I then added a drop of that diamond paste to it and proceeded to lap the back of that chisel in under a minute! OK, now I'm a covert to Diamond Paste.

So then I took out my new 5000 and 8000 Nainwa super stones. I got the set that includes the 1000 stone, but that is on back order. So I resorted to honing the bevel with 200 grit sandpaper and then moved to the 5000 and 8000 stone.

Again, it was an almost religious experience. All it took was a couple stokes on each stone and that chisel had an edge I could see my reflection in! And NO SOAKING of the stones was necessary! only a couple spritzes of water.

Japanese super stones

Japanese super stones

As you can see, the end results are worth it.

Chisel parring end grain pine

old Whitherby chisel after sharpening on Japanese super stones

I can't wait to try this stuff out on some plane irons that need sharpening!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#2

Very cool. I may try them myself.

Victor Parisian

>

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#3

Question

Al Goldstein

>Dominic,

For flattening backs how does the 45 micron diamond paste compare to the Woodcraft horizontal grinder with a 400 grit stone and then the 1000 grit stone? Easier? Quicker?

Al

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#4

Re: Question

Dominic Greco in Buck County Pa

>Al,

I'm sort of surprised that someone else was asking this question. I turned to the diamond paste after my disappointment with the Woodcraft Horz grinder.

Even after I got the 400 grit wheel, it's just not fast enough and has a tendency to give you an "out of flat" surface. The diamond paste just works so WELL it's amazing!

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#5

So Dom, I have few questions...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>If'in you don't mind...

Have you used any other water stones? If so why are these better?

How did the diamond paste set into the steel plate for flattening?

Can you use other grits in the plate now or has the diamonds you applied contaminated the plate?

Scott, who spent WAY too much time flatting a "new" & "improved" blade for the past 2 day...

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#7

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Hey Scott!

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Hi Scott,

I would definately check out Bill's article on diamond abrasives. It contains a heck of a lot more info than I can impart here.

You wrote:

"Have you used any other water stones? If so why are these better?"

Yeah, I used to use King Waterstones (from 220 all the way up to 4000) and just got fed up with the soaking and the mess. These stones do not need all that much water. You just give them a spritz and then go to work.

During WIA I had a long talk with Tim and Joel from TFWW about the downsides of conventional waterstones. My big beef was the fact that conventional waterstones could not be stored in my unheated shop. If they had water in them and then froze, you'd end up with cracks and some ruined waterstones.

The real appeal (at least for me) of these super stones was that they need very little water, the water doesn't soak in, and the dry out quickly. Plus they give you an edge like a razor!! :>)

"How did the diamond paste set into the steel plate for flattening?"

In short, due to the particle shape it embeds itself in the surface. How? Not sure about that. I just know that it does.

"Can you use other grits in the plate now or has the diamonds you applied contaminated the plate?"

I would have to say that each grit would need it's own flattening plate. To be honest, I think using the diamond paste for every day sharpening would get pretty damn expensive! That's why I went for the Japanese Super Stones.

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#8

Comments on you comments, and a disagreement

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The pressure of the tool on the diamond particle will embed them into cast iron, the material used for this purpose for centuries. Diamonds are both hard and extremely tough. The question of the day was whether diamonds would embed in these steel plates. Form the description it appears that they do.

.Your worte: To be honest, I think using the diamond paste for every day sharpening would get pretty damn expensive!

Not so. If you came to this conclusion then you are using way too much paste and/or you paid too much for it. The last time I bought diamond powder it was about 1$ per caret. I use a few milligrams at most to charge a 3 x 12" plate. At this rate the 25 carets I bought will last a life time. For the paste, a 1/4" worm of paste will charge a plate and a charge will do several sharpenings.

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#9

Thanks Dom! (and Bill too)

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Sounds like I should look at upgrading my King stones as well.

Re: LOVE those Japanese super stones!

#10

Re: Thanks Dom! (and Bill too)

ThomD

>I know I would think about it if they were locally available, still I have pretty much resigned myself to the idea that a new miracle Japanese stone will come out ever 2 years, and I won't buy it.