Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

Posts

Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#1

Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

charlie belden

>Earlier, there was a thread in the usenet newsgroup rec.woodworking on Michael Fortune�s �design for production� approach to making things out of wood.

An example of his approach - the design of a hand mirror and the jigs to permit relatively unskilled people, using readily available and relatively inexpensive hand held power tools, to produce multiples of them.

Morris Dovey noted that a CNC machine could make them without all the jigs Fortune came up with. My response was that what would distinguish the hand and jigs pieces from the CNC pieces was soul, one would have some and the other would not.

That raised an interesting question.

If it�s OK to use power joiners, planers, table saws, bandsaws

and the like to do the �grunt work�,

where does the grunt work stop

and the craftsmansip, with the �soul� that goes with it, begin?

Morris asked if the grunt work stopped - say at 0.0012� from the final finished piece. He implied that once the concept was developed to the point that a CNC machine could be used to make the piece - the rest was grunt work -the �soul� in a piece coming from the mind of the designer, not his or her hands, or anyone else�s hands for that matter.

I noted that there are some things that don�t lend themselves to CNC machine work - undercuts, flowing curves and the like. Morris noted that a 3 1/2 axis CNC machine, with the right tooling, could do that kind of thing as well.

I thought about that. With enough technology - and money - almost anything a craftsman could do could probably also be done by automated machines. So what was it that was missing with the automated approach?

I found the answer in the March-April 2006 issue of Woodworker West (www.woodwest.com). There�s an articel by W. Patrick Edwards titled �Form Follows Process - A Historic Look at Workmanship�, first published in The Journal of American Period Furniture in January of 2001. Mr. Edwards, according to the article, has 30 years of experience restoring antique furniture masterpieces and constructing new pieces utilizing traditional 18th Century techniques - and he therefore may be biased towards hand work and hand tools.

In the article, Edwards presents David Pye�s distinction between �hand work� and �machine work� and Pye�s definition of �craftsmanship� as the �workmanship of risk� as distinct from the �workmanship of certainty�. In both cases, he�s talking about production work, be it with hand tools, with machines or a combination of the two. Remember that pre-power tools furniture makers, like their power tools successors, made their living producing furniture, with the emphasis on production. Pre-Industrial furniture makers who used efficient methods and procedures to produce their furniture while maintaining their quality standards prospered just as their successors have.

Pye boils �craftsmanship� down to answering the question �Is the result predetermined and unalterable once production begins?�

If �risk� is involved, and the opportunity to modify either the method of work (what tool to use in a specific situation and method of using it) or the original design is modified to adapt to specific conditions at hand, then it�s �craftsmanship�. If not, it isn�t �craftsmanship�. Both �workmanship of risk� and �workmanship of certainty� can result in wonderful pieces of furniture - or crap. But I think that �workmanship of risk� allows for more opportunities to create a great pieces than does �workmanship of certaintly�.

And that gets us back to today�s automated production methods and, specifically, the use of CNC. CNC tooling and the capabilities of CNC machines make it possible to manufacture just about anything a furniture designer can come up with. With good quality control of both the the raw materials (wood) and the machine processing, high quality furniture can be produced at a price point significantly below that of anything a small �workmanship of risk� shop can produce.

So why go the �workmanship of risk� route rather than the �workmanship of certainty� route? Isn�t it the idea for a piece, developed to a sufficient level of detail to have a CNC machine �do the grunt work�, where the �soul� of a piece is instilled in the piece?

I think that the answer is no - and here�s why.

�Risk� implies not only the opportunity for mistakes and perhaps failure, but also the opportunity for success, to �produce� a piece better than the original �plan�.

�Producing� nice/good furniture involves far more than coming up with an idea, drawing it in sufficient detail to describe what the componets dimensions are, what goes where and how the parts are joined together. Beyond The Measured Drawing(s), there are a series of critical decisions that must be made on the way to the finished �production� piece, some of which MAY result in minor, or even major modifications of the original �plan�.

The decisions begin with the wood. Go with one for all the visible parts or go with multiple woods? If multiple, which woods would compliment each other the best - fo this piece? This one�s a push since both approaches, risk and certainty share this / these decisions.

When you get to stock selection and parts layout the two approaches diverge significantly. While both can account for grain orientation, even the better sheet goods/ply �cuts layout� software has this capability, the type of grain and the location of the figure in a particular part can�t be selected by a machine. Even if a machine could �see� the grain pattern/figure, could it select the best area of the raw stock which would be both most pleasing to the eye AND be harmonious with adjacent parts? After all - we�re talking about furntirue made of wood. THAT is the first major difference - for wood, unlike metal or �wood products� is not uniform nor homogeneous, either structurally or in appearance.

So parts layout is a significant difference. With the �risk� approach, �optimization� of the use of the wood is a consideration, but not the over riding consideration. One may chose to �waste� some wood to get a nicer looking part that goes better with adjacent parts. In normal handcrafted

furniture I�ve heard allowing for 10 to 15% for waste. In higher end shops it could be 25% or more (though �scraps� and �cut offs� seldom go to waste).

For me, parts layout/selection is a fun process of getting out a bunch of �candidates�, moving pieces around, flipping one or more over, rotating 180 degrees, slipping and sliding to get close to some combination that may �work�. Then I make a �viewing frame� for the part�s size, appropriately using framing squares, and slide my �window� around �til I see something in it that �fits� and �works� for the piece I have in mind. I start with the major focal point(s) of the piece - door panel(s), drawer face(s), table top, then the �support� parts - literally or figuratively.

Sometimes this process may change the original design, maybe merely modifying the size of the piece or the proportions -or - become the beginnings of an idea for a completely different piece. This is just one of the things �workmanship of risk� has over �workmanship of certainty�- It�s adaptive - throughout the process of �producing� a piece - Pye�s differentiating question - �Is the result predetermined and unalterable once production begins?� answered.

And that adaptation throughout the process of �production� in the �workmanship of risk� approach may, or may not, fine tune and improve the original design and plans. If you�re preparing the stock for a piece at �human speed�, be it with handtools or with handheld power tools, one may see - or feel - something in the wood that suggests either an eminent problem or a possible improvement - and make a choice. As edge treatments, sometimes very important in a piece, are worked on - the wood of one piece may indicate that something other than a 45 chamfer might bring out a pleasing grain, or remove some less than pleasing grain - or maybe a sap pocket or the like. The closer the method of working the wood comes to human speed with tools that allow the human to sense changes both visually and tactily, the greater the potential for incremental improvements - or screw ups.

Rather than continue, let me repeat - at some point, the method of processing the parts of a piece in the �production� process begins losing �soul� as the human �maker� is working farther and farther from the wood.

If it�s OK to use power joiners, planers, table saws,

bandsaws and the like to do the �grunt work�,

where does the grunt work stop and the craftsmansip,

with the �soul� that goes with it, begin?

What say you? Is there anything to this �craftsmanship of risk� vs �craftsmanship of certainty�?

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#2

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certaint

Tom MacGregor

>I think that the risk vs. certainty concept has some valid points, but the line between the two will remain gray. Machines cannot comprehend aesthetics, but artistic value cannot be comprehensively defined either as it varies according to the sensibilities of the individuals involved in both production and consumption.

A neighbor, who is aware of my particular fondness for planes, invited me over to see his new dining room table. It was produced in a local shop with a "hand planed top". He proudly had me run my hand over the surface to feel the undulations left by the smoother. Had a 19th century journeyman presented that top to the master he'd have found himself out back stacking firewood for the next week. I spoke to the shop owner. He informed me that the sad reality of the marketplace is that handtools are associated with imperfection, and that too good a surface will not sell. Not artsy enough.

I have begun to rely on machinery for much of the "grunt" work. I prefer the quiet connection hand tools give me with the wood, but arthritis has compromised how much heavy work I can do with my hands. I'm not about to quit working wood worrying about a possible lack of sufficient artistic merits in the non-purist approach I require to continue.

Maybe the trick is to keep enough art in your work to stay happy and enough craft to stay fed.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#3

The Nature and Art of Workmanship

Steve Elliott

>�The Nature and Art of Workmanship� by David Pye is one of my favorite books but not for the distinction it makes between workmanship of risk vs. workmanship of certainty. Instead I like his emphasis on the range of qualities that are possible with hand tools. To quote Pye:

�The deterioration comes not because of bad workmanship in mass-production but because the range of qualities which mass-production is capable of just now is so dismally restricted; because each is so uniform and because nearly all lack depth, subtlety, overtones, variegation, diversity, or whatever you choose to call that which distinguishes the workmanship of a Stradivarius violin, or something much rougher like a modern ring-net boat. The workmanship of a motor-car is something to marvel at, but a street full of parked cars is jejune and depressing; as if the same short tune of clear unmodulated notes were being endlessly repeated. A harbour full of fishing-boats is another matter.�

I�ve spent a couple of years running a CNC router in a custom furniture shop and consider it an interesting and useful production tool. The shop owner thought of it as a �universal jig� because of its ability to recreate any shape it had been programmed to produce. But even the most skilled operator couldn�t get the CNC to match the surface left by a well-tuned hand plane.

I�ve seen demonstrations of woodcarving done on a CNC and the result looked dead. There was nothing that showed the fluid stroke of a chisel or the crisp intersection of two cleanly cut surfaces. Such carvings could make a piece of furniture more intricate but they wouldn�t make it better.

To my mind good workmanship is a reflection of judgment and skill. It can be done using power tools or hand tools, with or without jigs, and in many differing styles. It invites and rewards close inspection.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#4

these issues don't concern me

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I am content with just worrying about whether something I make will be functional, look good, and last.

I'll make one comment on this thought and that is even though many shops have CNC machines I don't see any of them turning out Goddard or Townsend reproductions of knee hole desks, to name one example.

When I stick a piece of lumber into our big thickness planer I know with great certainty what size it will be when it comes out the other end. I don't trouble myself with thoughts as to whether that makes me a lesser woodworker or not. I am sure my daughter won't give a flip whether the lumber for her chest of drawers is machine planed or hand planed. She will be concerned with how quick I get it made. I have enough problems making stuff without burdening my brain with the philosophical implications of what I am doing, or why I am doing it, or whether it will be "better" if I eschew a machine here or there.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#5

Re: The Nature and Art of Workmanship

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I remember reading an interview with Sam Maloof in which he discussed the design of the lines in a chair. In particular it was the hard line that joined the back to the arm, and his comment was (and I paraphrase) that "it's one thing to draw the line and quite another to make it mean something." Maybe that's why he never bothered with CNC machines.

bh

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#6

Re: The Nature and Art of Workmanship

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>A good illustration of the deadness of machine work is a swan's neck pediment. A pediment made by a shaper will look stiff, while one made by a good carver looks flowing and natural. This not because one is slightly irregular and the other is not, but because a good carver can make subtle changes to the molding profile to enhance the shape. A little deeper or rounder here and a little flatter there. One pediment elicits an emotional response and the other does not. This is not a matter of risk and certainty, but a matter of control. Once a pattern is set in stone, there is no more control.

With machine work one makes up a pattern and then all the parts contain any small weakness in the design. When one does repetitive work by hand, he is constantly evaluating the curves and making small changes to make it look better. This constant evaluation makes for a better eye and a better product.

Years ago a fellow told me that technicians were getting so good at synthesizing music that musicians would no longer be necessary. I asked him if he thought people would be able to make Bacos so good that he would not prefer real bacon. He said no.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#7

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certaint

Marv

>What is in the mind of the person carving by hand versus what is in the mind of a CNC operator?

The CNC operator is focusing more on making the machine do what it is designed to do. The reward is finishing a hundred parts and have them all look the same as a result of having made all the right settings.

The carver is focused on the beauty of the wood, the skill using the tools, and the intimate connection between fingers and mind and the fact that it will be one of a kind. The carver owns it, even though someone else might possess it. The carver's reward can be on a spiritual level, a oneness with his/her artistic abilities.

The machine owns nothing that it produces. The operator owns his/her skills to operate the machine, but it ends there. Ok, I'm done with this part, what's next? Where is my check? Is it Friday yet?

Marv

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#8

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certaint

David Cockey

>Unless the carver is focused on getting the parts made so he/she will get paid and can move onto the next job.

Or perhaps the CNC operator is really a digital artist who is more interested in the results than the time it takes.

Consider visual art. There is a lot of great art being made using digital tools. And a lot of very mediocre art being made with traditional methods and materials. I believe it comes down to the motivations of the artist/artisan/craftsman than the tools which are used, though some tools make it easier to do mediocre work.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#9

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certaint

Chris Friesen

>I think there is basically no difference between using "jigs to permit relatively unskilled people...to produce multiples of them" and using a CNC machine to produce multiples.

In either case, the artistry is in the original design, and in the wood selection. Using CNC vs jigs doesn't change that.

You talk about things like stock selection, grain orientation, harmonious layout, etc. Hypothetically, we might be able to create a computerized neural net that could be trained to embody the same sorts of rules that people use to do this sort of thing. In this case, the artistry is arguably still there, but it comes from the original designer that trained the machine's "aesthetic vision".

Towards the end you start talking about adaptation. As soon as you start modifying the design as you go you're no longer dealing with multiples, you're now talking custom work. That's a totally different question than the jigs-vs-CNC issue.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#10

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certaint

charlie belden

>Chris noted:

Towards the end you start talking about adaptation. As soon as you start modifying the design as you go you're no longer dealing with multiples, you're now talking custom work. That's a totally different question than the jigs-vs-CNC issue.

=================

Yes - and no.

Let's take putting a profile on the edge of a piece of wood - which can be done with a hand plane or a router bit. And lets assume that the profile is cut in multiple passes.

With a hand tool - one can see and often feel - when the grain direction changes - and cut from the other direction "with the grain" - then make a series of light cuts at the grain direction transition point. With a router bit turning at 28,000 rpms, you could conceivably do part of the cut in one direction - to about where the grain reverses direction, then do a climb cut to finish the profile. In the latter case, that would require noting the grain direction change location and marking it on the part where you can see it while using the router - since the surface being cut won't be visible if a fence is being used - the part face affected being against the fence and hidden from view.

Of course the machine based process might use only wood selected for uniform grain direction to avoid the need for climb cuts - or splintering/tear out. But that could eliminate some other quality of the part you want - but would involve the grain direction change problem. So the machine approach dictates some materials selection that the machine process requires, but not necessarily what would look best in the whole piece being made.

Now to the adapting to the situation at hand part. In most instances, furniture parts come in at least pairs - in the case of a four legged table, it's for parts to a set.

So let's go with four table legs for one table. And let's say that the drawing calls for the three "show corners" of the front legs to have a uniform width chamfer on those corners.

Now the hand tool convention would be to scribe the chamfer ends here line on each face of the corners to be chamfered - in order to know when to stop planing.

But if, while making the first few passes with the plane, the furniture maker sees that a tapered chamfer, wider at the top than at the bottom adds an interesting line the leg - and calls over the supervisor - or the designer to have a look. At that point the "plan" may be adjusted to incorporate the enhancing option - or not. But there is the opportunity - with the actual result in 3D full scale - with the specific wood - on an actual leg - to see what might not have been seen on a 2D scaled drawing, or maybe even on a 2D rendering of the 3D plan.

What I'm getting at are subtle things that can present themselves at hand tool/human speed which probably would never even be considered when fabricating parts with an all power tool operation - in part because the hand tool process permits feedback - before the part is done - which the power tool process does not have.

"Multiples" and "production" don't necessarily mean that all parts of every produced piece have to be identical, but merely to appear similar enough to not have one stand out as significantly different from the others. And the first table of a production run and the last table of the production run can have subtle, perhaps significant changes - but obviously look similar enough - one perhaps perceived as somehow nicer than the other. The differences may be the result of changes the hand tool person saw might enahnce the piece and followed through on the option - which a CNC operator probably wouldn't even know was there.

The use of handtools offers the ability for nuances that a CNC process won't and perhaps can't have. And it's often subtle things that add nuances to a piece that make it somehow stand out from its cousins. The eye or the hand might be what detects the differences - even though the mind can't identify what specifically is different and makes one piece more attractive than the other.

James Krenov was a master of these small subtle details which are consciously only apparent if you take the time to study his pieces fairly closely.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#11

perhaps a different view

roninkokomo

>We have lost Krenov and Maloof this year. If they were part of this discussion, I think they both would say. You use hand tools when that cam make a visible difference in the piece. I believe that would include a final pass or two with a jointer plane before a glue up, delicate small dovetails where appropriate, carved pulls and handles, etc. The problem is that these distinctions demand a perceptive audience, which is in very short supply.

Bill is right, even the most discriminating end user does not care if the wood is rough sized by hand or machine, because it is invisible. the finish details are not.

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#12

It's a simple matter with me......

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Once I took on woodworking as a business I realized that my priorities needed to change in order for me to be productive and make money. I don't have a CNC but I do use power tools. I also use hand tools. My choices for tools or methods these days are often based on the efficiency of getting a process done while maintaining my standards for craftsmanship.

I have had several gallery shows now with opening receptions. The gallery patrons love to talk to me about my furniture. Oddly enough, none of them ever ask me what tools/methods I used to make it (with rare exceptions). I know that they purchase my work based upon aesthetics, function and the craftsmanship they see when they examin the pieces. How I got from raw wood to that end product is of little concern to them it seems.

While I can enjoy the Zen moments of using hand tools I cannot afford to spend the time exclusively using them. If I did I would go broke. My clients simply would not pay the extra cost for a completely electron-free piece.

This is not to say that I sacrifice the enjoyment of woodworking. Like I said, I still use hand tools in every project. Let's face it, they are often the best choices for both craftsmanship and efficiency. But in the end, my real satisfaction is applying that first coat of oil and seeing one of my designs come to life. Simple as that.

Tom

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certainty

#13

Re: Workmanship of Risk vs Workmanship of Certaint

ThomD

>I have read two of Pye's books, and they are worth the read. The distinction between risk and certainty is a little desperate, really. First of all serious people aren't risking much of anything when they do fine woodwork. Any more than a concern pianist is at risk of falling off his chair when he plays a sonata, ok maybe a bad example.

In reality hand work stands on it's own two feet (sorry). We don't hear long discussions about whether a computerized voice is a better vehicle for a talking book, than a famous actor's. The infinite capacity for making many small adjustments is not in questions. All of the best woodwork has that touch to it. You can see the fingerprints, I think is Krenov's phrase.

That said there is a lot of bunk about hand tools vs. power tools or CNC. The real problem with CNC is it's enormous costs, and space hoggage. I love designing on my computer, and the minimal degree of cnc output I have, restricted to making small patterns, is awesome. I wish I could do more, but the cost to results ratio just isn't there. CAD/CNC really is the extension of the human mind through it's tools to a degree that is very powerful. Gotta love it.

Also, if one does an honesty check about the kind of tools that an amateur really likes from among the hand tool kit, it is stuff like hand planes that are about as free working as a table, saw, the basic components and adjustments are very similar. It isn't the risk people like about these tools, it is the realization that they are automatic and that the various clever hand tools we have can be leveraged just like a router table, jointer, planer and table saw.

There may be no clear distinction between the hand and the machine, or risk and certainty. The absence of easy categories is a problem for theoreticians, but not for woodworkers.