We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
As the title suggests, this is a finishing question. However, it does apply to hand tools and neanderthal wood working because it involves my latest project. I wanted to give it a nice coat of blond shellac before the unveiling.
I've been meaning to try my hand at mixing my own since I can make as much (or as little ) as I need. I also wanted to try to make a wipe on version of this since I seem to have better luck with these kinds of finishes.
Now I went and bought the denatured alcohol and have all the other stuff needed to mix it up. HOWEVER, as I stated in the beginning of the thread, I wanted to make a wipe on version. I have the article from FWW that tells of the proportions (cuts) to use. But I'm still a bit vague on the right cut to use. This is for a shop tool. I also want to use it to refinish some totes and knobs for hand planes.
What cut/mix do you use for shellac (in regards to hand tools).
I really only want to make about 1 quart or maybe even a pint.
And does anyone know what additive to use to make shellac a wipe on finish? I was talking to one guy at the WWing store who said adding 10% of mineral spirits would work. Does that sound right?
>I have seen demonstrated several times shellac being padded (wiped) on and done it my self. The professionals that have demonstrated this application use from 1/2 to 1 pound cut. They used a "rubber" , basically a ball of something absorbent wrapped with a durable cloth. Wool tightly wrapped with linen works nicely. None of these persons used anything but ethanol for the solvent. Because each coat is thin it takes a while to build up the finish but there is almost no waiting between coats. I spray a 2 pound cut. It gets the job done quicker than padding. For something like a tote you could just dip the whole thing.
The nice thing about shellac is that you can slather it on about any way and then sand it smooth. It is a dream to level by sanding.
There's no additive. Use your denatured alcohol from the Borg. Screw the cap back on tight, because you don't want vapor getting in there and condensing during temperature changes. A tiny amount of water will ruin the alcohol for shellac purposes (shellac won't dissolve).
What will help with the wipe on is, as Bill says, use multiple thin coats. The reason is that as you get thicker, say up in the 2lb and 3lb cuts, it is easier to get 'fat edges' along arises, where the shellac pulls itself up into a bead by surface tension. With thin coats you don't get that.
Another thing about thin coats and wiping: The shellac wants to dry right now, and the thicker it is, the more it wants to do that. So it is easy to overwipe and leave wiping tracks in thicker cuts. In fact, you don't ever be wanting to drag a half dry wiper through shellac you've already laid down. Get the rag wet again, and then do it. The thinner cuts don't get tack quite as fast and more readily redissolve when you come in again with a wet rag--the alcohol on the wet rag dissolves what is already down there--it's like hide glue in that regard--and blends the two coats together without a seam. That's also why you don't really need to denib until the last coat. Bottom line: Never mind additive, it's the thin coat that makes it easy.
I like really old discarded 100% cotton t-shirts or boxer shorts, but I don't know what is really best. The main thing is--no lint. If there's lint, it'll get embedded in the shellac, sure as little green apples.
What I like to mix in--and these are found everywhere--are 1 qt. round rubbermaid containers, with the blue rubber top. I think they actually hold a bit more than a quart, but it is a convenient size. So, the quart is 1/4 gallon. If you have a lb container of flakes, use one-fourth of that. Put the 1/4th of a pack of flakes into your quart container and fill it to within 1/2" of the top, and that's roughly a l lb cut. By the way, there's no rocket science about mixing proportions. Get it in the ballpark. Cause over time you can thin your solution by adding more alcohol as the level falls, or else let it thicken if you think it is too thin. But 1 lb is a useful cut. For insides of drawers, I like about 1/2 lb cut. It has a great smell which lasts.
Flakes will dissolve faster in a warmer place than in a colder one. Also, the more you stir, the more you break down the gradients and hasten the dissolving. If your flakes stick together (this will happen in time, at least with some vendor's flakes, bust them up into small stuff with a hammer--small pieces dissolve faster than lumps.
You're gonna love shellac. Get a new appreciation for bugs.
In my experience with shellac finishes for French polishing (primarily on the bows I make) I've learned an important point: the best solvent for mixing shellac is Everclear grain alcohol. The Bekhol solvent sold in some catalogs would also be good. The denatured alcohol solvent sold in hardware stores has all kinds of unknown additives to make it non-drinkable and these can and do affect the shellac in a wiping or French polishing application. Not that you cannot use regular denatured alcohol, it is just that the results will be unpredictable - I get streaks and splotchy patches with denatured alcohol. I get acceptable results using Everclear.
>I have taken two classes on applying shellac and in neither case was special ethanol recommended.
Methanol is one of the most common denaturing agents. When I took a class on applying shellac from Alf Sharp he told us that methanol has some desirable properties for french polishing. I am more inclined to suspect that water is the source of the problems you have observed. Run of the mill "alcohol" is 5% water and exposure to the atmosphere can add additional water. At some water concentration not much above this 5% one will begin to have appearance problems in the shellac finish.
Some of the "premium" ethanol products are anhydrous so adding a bit of water to something that starts out with none won't lead to trouble from too high a water content. Persons working in moist environments could well see benefit from using an anhydrous ethanol.
The bottom line is that the premium ethanol products can be "better" but generic denatured ethanol provides equivalent results for many people. Personally I don't see any benefit to the higher priced and less convenient to buy ethanol products.
>Dissolving something that takes up solvent and becomes a rubbery glob before dissolving is a common problem when making solutions of plastics and other stuff, for example shellac. The fluid dynamics problem to be defeated is that solutions of highly different viscosity won't mix at low shear.
There are two efficient approaches- the tortoise and the hare approaches.
Tortoise approach- Use this method when labor is expensive and time is not important. Add shellac to solvent and let it sit a day or so. Solvent will diffuse into the flakes, make a glob, the glob will continue to take up solvent and eventually become un-viscous enough to rapidly dissolve upon stirring or shaking.
Hare approach- Use this method if you are in the business of selling shellac solutions. Add flakes to solvent and stir the begeepers out of it. Some kind of mechanical stirrer will be essential for this approach.It is essential that sufficient stirring be applied that the sticky flakes don't coalesce.
Watched pot never boils approach- Add flakes to solvent and attempt dissolution with mild or lackadaisical stirring. This approach eats up labor and is hardly faster than the tortoise approach.
I dissolve and store shellac in recycled jars from jam, pickles ,etc.- the kind with the elastomer sealant ring in the lid. These seal well and they are a convenient size for what I do.
>Before I get going... my shop-mate found out the hard way that Mineral spirits will do a great job of making sure the shellac stays sticky and nasty. Don't use it. Ever.
-
Back at school, we didn't really concern ourselves with how heavy a cut we were using. We were more concerned with the consistency, and after a while, the shellac will teach you whether or not you're working with a well proportioned mix. If it gets too tacky too fast, you need more alcohol. If it's not building up, you need to add more shellac stock to your mix. Our instructions were more or less the following:
-Get at least 2 Bell Jars. This is important.
-Fill the first jar close to the top with flakes. Then fill it with Denatured Alcohol until the flakes are just covered. Put the lid on, shake it from time to time.
-The second jar is your "working jar." This is the jar you'll be working from, and where you'll do your diluting. The first jar is the stock jar. Don't put anything into the stock jar. The idea is to keep your source clean.
-Pour the second jar about ha third to a half full of stock, and the rest with more denatured alcohol. That's a pretty decent working consistency.
-If you start running low, it's a good idea to have a third jar for extra stock, since you really can't refill the stock jar until it's empty, and if you need more shellac NOW, it's not so fun to run out. Luckily, any place can be a good place to stop, since new shellac will dissolve into and fuse with old shellac, but even still. Some jobs need to be finished.
Wiping finish means that the finish is thin enough that you won't get brush or smear marks. It's a term that's applicable to varnishes, because they're so thick that the marks will stay. Then you need to sand the varnish down evenly and apply a new coat. Properly mixed Shellac is thin enough that it's not an issue. AND, shellac will dissolve into and fuse with the previous layer, so the whole sanding thing isn't a relevant issue.
Be aware that the first coat can soak into the wood unevenly. Some people refer to it as blotchiness, but the root cause is that some parts of the surface are exposing more open ends of the wood fibers. Burl is like this, as is curly. Curly appearance is made by the alternation of face grain and something more closely approaching end grain. Shellac will soak into end grain more easily than face grain.
For instance, I had a friend at school who had a cherry table top with a spot of burl in it. The table finished well the first few coats, but the burl spot really soaked up the shellac, and looked unfinished. The thing to remember is that, as the shellac cures, the volume comprised of the alcohol will shrink... and in Nick's case, the shellac on the burled area shrunk into the wood grain. So he had to keep refinishing that spot until it was filled and cured enough that it couldn't soak up any more. It's frustrating at first, but it can also be predictable. And because shellac will dissolve into and fuse with previous layers, it's not as time consuming a process as it would be with another finish, because there's no sanding. Lay a new coat on. It will become one with the coats that came before it.
BUT, if you're dealing with figured wood, one factor to keep in mind is time. It takes time for the alcohol to work its way out as the shellac cures. And with the added thickness of more coats, it takes more time. So, lay on your coats of shellac, and walk away. Give the finish time to do its thing, so you can see what you're dealing with. Otherwise you may notice in a few more weeks' time that the nice, even gloss looks a little more textured... because the alcohol has flashed off completely, and the shellac has retreated into the open pores of the grain. (This, by the way, is an excellent reason not to use shellac on really open, porous woods like oak or ash)
Print this out and refer to it later... some of this really has to be seen to be understood.
>Everclear and I even use it when French Polishing. I enjoy the fragrance of the alcohol and it isn't dangerous, unless you drink too much or it catches on fire. I also use it in my alcohol lamps when do hot shellac repairs.
As for cut, I really have no idea but I suspect I use a 1/8 lb cut or less, I like my shellac real thin. As for mixing up I avoid the clumping problems of flake shellac, I use seed lac.
Seed lac is the most unrefined form of shellac, can't buy stick-lac, so I use seed-lac. I place some in the center of a several layers of cheesecloth and tie up a small bundle with a string and suspend it in a jar of Everclear. The next day it is ready to go and I can pour it out without the branches and bug parts.
I never filter the stuff and make sure I mix it up before using, the wax and heavy bodied constituents settle out. The wax is not like beeswax or paraffin wax and doesn't interfere with traditional finishes.
My rubber or fad or pad is linen with a light coat of linseed oil/turpentine and a little rottenstone and I use cotton balls wrapped inside to hold the charge of shellac. I dip the balls into the shellac and not the linen cloth, so I don't get too much and can control the amount that is applied by squeezing the rubber. The cloth can last for several applications, the cotton balls need replacement, raw wool lasts longer than cotton balls. I replace the cloth when it becomes too smooth, linen is a sharp fiber and helps smooth the surface as it applies the bug poop.
>What I call raw wool is wool straight from the sheep. It can be 50% lanolin and other stuff. Sheep wear their clothes for a whole year so their coat can be soiled. Personal hygiene is not a sheep's strong suit.
I wash the raw wool several times with detergent, rinse well, and let it dry. Then I use it to make the pad. I don't see any reason why white wool yarn wouldn't work if you don't have a sheep farm nearby. Or I'll send you a box free if you pay the shipping.
I pad all sorts of finishing products. I think it is the best way to apply stain because it offers a lot of control of color development.
>I have used a variety of solvents. The stuff I liked best was regular alcohol from the liquor store. Got some when I was in the US, couldn't afford it in Canada. It has some small fraction of water in it which is supposed to be a bad thing, but I didn't have a problem. It also remained useable for a long time which is supposed to be a problem. It is a lot hicer to work with, kinda yummy, and I say that as mostly tea total. It just layed down really nicely, and seemed less like taking a bath in poison. Polishing out a guitar takes a long time so doing it with edible components is more of a pleasure that the other stuff.