Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Joinery question

Posts

Joinery question

#1

Joinery question

Dan Donaldson

>I am building a box that is symmetrical and one side looks like the drawing I have attached. The two opposite sides I have labeled "A" will ba about 2.5 inches thick in the view shown and the other two sides will be about 3/4 or whatever I can get out of the wood I have. The overall depth of the box will be about 3 inches. This is for a hammered dulcimer, so there will be quite a bit of twisting stress on the "A" sides due to the strings. I have looked at several plans and most of them have a fairly simple lap type joint with screws in it. I would prefer something a bit more interesting. Any ideas? The thinner sides will be curly maple and the thicker ones will be hard maple to take the tuning pins. I will probably laminate some curly on the outside edge of the pin blocks to give some visual continuity. The bottom will be 1/2 baltic plywood and I still am looking for some quartersawn cedar, spruce, or mahogany for the soundboard. (That needs to be about 18 X 40 X 1/4 approximately, can bookmatch a couple of times to get the width)

Re: Joinery question

#3

OOPS 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Joinery question

#4

Re: Joinery question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Dan,

I dunno. However, I went searching on line to find out what a hammered dulcimer looks like. Linked below is a Swiss-made one, where there is some commentary on the geometry concerning strength, and also you can see a bit of the joinery showing.

Here's the insanely long link:

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://wiki.arch.ethz.ch/twiki/pub/Front/CaadArticleResearch2006X07X06X17X22X38/dulcimer.jpg&imgrefurl=http://wiki.arch.ethz.ch/twiki/bin/view/Front/CaadArticleResearch2006X07X06X17X22X38.html&usg=__ufhT4xuM8Hkqg8rwu8ErKET1Puk=&h=300&w=600&sz=60&hl=en&start=16&sig2=o739AroqKJ7hcb6EdBKQuQ&tbnid=KrhsOk2UV2pdfM:&tbnh=68&tbnw=135&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dhammered%2Bdulcimer%26gbv%3D2%26hl%3Den&ei=sXXeSsqXNIiHlAev95SoAw

Wiley

Re: Joinery question

#5

Re: Joinery question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Don't know if this matters, but A can't possibly be 2.5" if top to bottom is 3".

Pam

Re: Joinery question

#6

Re: Joinery question

Dan Donaldson

>That is 2.5 width in the view as shown. (it is not to scale, just showing the angles).The side pieces would be about 2.5 x 3 x 20" or so and the other two sides would be about 3/4 X 3 X 16 to 40 inches. The angles on the ends are 30-60 if you make them into triangles.

Re: Joinery question

#7

Re: Joinery question

Dan Donaldson

>That one is a bit like most that I have seen. The round plug is where the screw is located. I would like to do it without screws if possible, but am looking for a joint that would resist twisting and look nice.

Re: Joinery question

#8

Re: Joinery question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>But width of what? If top to bottom is 3", A is a hypotenuse and necessarily longer/thicker than 2.5"; but I haven't a clue as to how that drawing fits with Wiley's dulcimer, so I'll let you go now. :)

Pam

Re: Joinery question

#9

Re: Joinery question

Dan Donaldson

>Think of the "A" piece as a 2X4 a bit over a foot long standing on edge with the other two pieces as 1X3 's. I can make up a sketch if this doesn't make it clear. The dimensions are only approximate. The 2x4 would be too thick, but in the proper orientation.

Re: Joinery question

#10

quick sketch 

Dan Donaldson

>


img

Re: Joinery question

#11

Re: Joinery question

James Watriss

>Pam makes a valid point. Understood that dimensions are approximate, but if top to bottom is 3", then top to bottom at a 60 degree angle is closer to 3.5

I think if you're looking to reinforce it against tension, you're probably looking at a combination of sides that come down at a gentle slope to the inside, or an elliptical slope, just to lend support that way, or possibly ribs connecting the two sides. Dovetailing the sides to the front and back seems like a no-brainer.

But in the end, I'm really not a luthier. I can speculate until the cows come home, but I think you'd be better served by doing the research on older versions of hammered dulcimers. I'm sure it's a challenge, but probably not too hard. I'd start asking around at instrument stores to see who specializes in old instruments.

That, or try to find anyone who was a kindergarten teacher in the 70s, and ask them to teach you how to sing Puff the Magic Dragon. It's almost guaranteed that if they don't pull out a guitar, they'll pull a dulcimer out. All of my grade school music teachers played them, dirty hippies that they were.

Re: Joinery question

#12

Re: Joinery question

KenI

>Hey Dan,

Your first sketch is a plan view and your second is an elevation, right? So the instrument is sort of a trapezoid, where the non-parallel sides are very thick? The 3" dimension is the depth of the trapezoid and the strings run between the non-parallel sides. That would match up with my understanding of a dulcimer.

I'm just trying to understand the conversation. :-)

Ken

Re: Joinery question

#13

exactly

Dan Donaldson

>The top edge of the thicker sides is sloped at about a thirty degree angle to hold the tuning pins and the hitch pins. The overall box is a trapezoid with the angles being 60 and 120 degrees. Look at the picture that Wiley linked to in his post.

Re: Joinery question

#14

Hi Dan...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Don't know if I can be of help here, but here's my .02...

Is a spline miter out of the question? How about DT keys perpendicular to the joint.

Re: Joinery question

#15

Thanks

Dan Donaldson

>Nothing is out of the question. Just trying to find a strong joint that does not use screws and looks cool. A spline of some kind of DT may be the way to go. Think I will make up some test blocks and try some different stuff. I have most of the hardware and the fancy stuff for the sides. Still need to get a couple of pieces of hard maple for the pin blocks and som quartersawn stock for the soundboard.

Re: Joinery question

#16

Re: Joinery question

Paul M.

>One of the students in my stringed instrument class made a hammered dulcimer similar in proportion to what you are doing, and I believe he used dovetails to attach the cross beams to the large diagonal members on the sides. I'm working from memory here, and my memory is not the most reliable source. :-)

I'll have to search my photos this weekend to see if I have a picture of this to post up to show what he did.