Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

construction question for Warren and others

Posts

construction question for Warren and others

#1

construction question for Warren and others

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Daughter has requested a chest of drawers so the following question has become timely.

Historically, in case construction it was common to dovetail a full secondary wood top into a chest/cabinet and then overlay this top with a primary wood top, usually over hanging, with molding etc.

Alternatively, one could dovetail in a partial secondary wood "top" consisting of a 3", or thereabouts, wide piece front and back instead of a full width top. This alternative involves less wood and less dovetails to be cut, both of which would be important considerations to the cabinet maker in days of old.

I have great faith that the 18th/19th century cabinet makers discovered and used the best construction techniques while at the same time they worked efficiently, ie they didn't do anything that didn't add value or indeed wasn't essential.

What would be the benefit of a full top secondary wood top, vs the case where the top of the cabinet was held together by a "partial top" consisting of a dovetailed 3-4" wide piece front and back?

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#2

Re: construction question for Warren and others

Ted

>"What would be the benefit of a full top secondary wood top, vs the case where the top of the cabinet was held together by a "partial top" consisting of a dovetailed 3-4" wide piece front and back?"

I just completed a chest of drawers with this construction, but a primary wood top dovetailed to the sides. This makes a *very* rigid construction that you would not get with only a partial top. I would think that this is the primary reason for using the "full top" dovetailed to the sides; it will be very resistant to any deformation later.

Ted

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#3

Re: construction question for Warren and others

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>A full width top is slightly stiffer and stronger, somewhat better at resisting racking and warping. The dovetailed carcass is the strength of the piece.

There are some other considerations. If you just have front and back rails, the top piece is attached only at the front and back and could warp. Also the drawers can tip downward when partly open. Because of these problems, we often add kickers, front to back rails above the drawer sides which can be used to attach the top. Making these kickers adds to the work.

Another problem is that a full drawer can have something get stuck on the front rail, preventing you from opening it. When this happens in a lower drawer you usually remove the drawer above to fix the problem. When it happens in the top drawer you are looking for a long screwdriver or something. I know this from experience.

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#4

Re: construction question for Warren and others

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>A couple of problems with a solid secondary top, first it is a waste of wood, not that that mattered in the nineteenth century, but it added extra weight to the piece where you don't want it at the top.

It would also be more difficult to get the primary top flat on the secondary if either has any problems, then there is the problem of air and wood movement with two solid pieces placed tightly together.

The secondary frame top is easier to dovetail to the carcase and can be made out of secondary woods. When the top is screwed down there is not much racking and a properly dovetailed frame will hold the carcase square anyway.

If the frames between the drawers have dust panels, then racking is minimized. If you have problems with too much stuff in the drawers, hindering them from opening, build another chest of drawers, because you have too much crap in the drawers.

Stephen

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#5

Re: construction question for Warren and others

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco------WebKitFormBo

>"If you have problems with too much stuff in the drawers, hindering them from opening, build another chest of drawers, because you have too much crap in the drawers."

Would you please talk some sense into my wife? ;-)

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#6

Ellis Walentine

Could be trouble, Glenn

Ellis Walentine

>If you proceed with that argument, you might be committing to make her another dresser. Just checking in...

Ellis

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#7

Re: construction question for Warren and others

Jerome Bias

>How is the primary wood top attached? Screws? and if so where do you place them?

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#8

Re: construction question for Warren and others

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

I think Warren answers the question. However, here is a little info in a lot of words....

Jeffrey Greene's book, American Furniture of the 18th Century, has great exploded drawings of period furniture in it. So I took a peek....

In the Queen Anne period, he shows both a Newport chest of drawers (four drawer tiers) and a flat-top high boy. Both stylish--don't look like country furniture. In each case, he shows a dovetailed top, which is the only top. However, there is a cornice molding applied in each case which covers the dovetails and makes the top look beefy and great. The key to making this work visually from the front is a top rail let into the sides--impossible to describe without looking at pp. 229-233 in the book, but basically, this top front rail covers the structural top and is itself partially covered by the cornice moulding. Needless to say, these pieces of furniture look fantastic, but there is only a single top, encircled by cornice moulding.

Another solution he shows is in the Chippendale period. He shows two chests of drawers--again, high style, one is serpentine and the other is bombe. In both cases, there is a single top. The case sides are dovetailed into the bottom plate, but up top the case sides have a half-dovetail (male) running the full depth of the side. The single top is dadoed to receive (and conceal) this half dovetail--the front overhang of the top conceals the joint. I'm sure the way it was made was not a stopped cut, but a through cut for most of the width of the top--then the overhang piece could have been glued on to make it a 'stopped' cut. The top would then slide on from the front. The top join would be covered in the rear by the case back. These Chippendale pieces are on pp. 255-260 in Greene's book.

So the tradeoff for you would be to pay for an appearance top, versus making a fancy cornice in the Queen Anne style, or executing that 20" long (or whatever) half dovetail join in the Chippendale style.

Wiley

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#9

Greene's book is a favorite, see page 139

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>On page 139 he shows the "partial top" AKA, the sides joined by a dovetailed rail front and back. I have always made chests with this construction, however, I have seen many pieces with the full secondary wood top which prompted the question. Warren makes some good points. I use a pocket screw in the middle of each side as well as the screws through the rails as shown in the picture. The kickers can be simply nailed on.

Headley's partner, Steve, showed us a slick way to do pocket screws and get them just right in length, and attractive. It uses just a drill, marking gauge and gouge. I can do one in a minute. I will see if I can figure out how to illustrate it and post. (One of many tips we gained in the week).

Re: construction question for Warren and others

#10

Re: Greene's book is a favorite, see page 139

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bill,

I would like to see that method of making screw gains. The Seymours in Boston in late 18th-early 19th century, used that method. They were careful in their layout of the pocket.

I was planning on using that method, but lost my nerve at the last minute because of the fear of driving a screw on the slant up into the top. I could calculate the distance and add a safety factor (so as not to drive the screw all the way to daylight), but I never could get the conviction that I really knew how far I could drive the screw. And if you use too big a safety factor, the screw won't have enough bite.

Please show if you are able.

Wiley