construction question for Warren and others
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>Daughter has requested a chest of drawers so the following question has become timely.
Historically, in case construction it was common to dovetail a full secondary wood top into a chest/cabinet and then overlay this top with a primary wood top, usually over hanging, with molding etc.
Alternatively, one could dovetail in a partial secondary wood "top" consisting of a 3", or thereabouts, wide piece front and back instead of a full width top. This alternative involves less wood and less dovetails to be cut, both of which would be important considerations to the cabinet maker in days of old.
I have great faith that the 18th/19th century cabinet makers discovered and used the best construction techniques while at the same time they worked efficiently, ie they didn't do anything that didn't add value or indeed wasn't essential.
What would be the benefit of a full top secondary wood top, vs the case where the top of the cabinet was held together by a "partial top" consisting of a dovetailed 3-4" wide piece front and back?



