Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Why do we do it?

Posts

Why do we do it?

#1

Why do we do it?

Bob Hackett

>I can understand the need to do woodwork in one form or another.What I`m wondering is why we each choose the particular path we do.

Antique hand tools allow me a connection to both the past and the wood that I don`t get from power tools.They allow me to slow down and consider things or creep up on just the fit that I want.They allow me to break away from the confines of power tool limitations.

What I also wonder about is that what pulls me may not be what others are after.I look at tools and wonder what they`re capable of.Where can they take me?

If I wonder at all about how the original owners used(or abused)them it`s just to establish a baseline to use as a starting point.I try to keep an open mind and always look for new techniques to try and/or apply in order to make the process more enjoyable.Being faithful to the way a particular tool was used during the 1700`s is secondary to me,although sometimes the old ways really were the best by way of simplicity alone(the trend toward simple workbenches comes to mind).

So,is this heresy? Am I the only one who likes to think outside the box regarding old tools?

Mainely,Bob

Re: Why do we do it?

#2

Re: Why do we do it?

steve mackay

>Old tools (not just planes) are cool because they make me look better and smarter. They also do the job better than any other tool. No other tool on the planet will do what a #78 or #289 will do better. While I'm useing them I start getting that warm fuzzy. Its not the object of the excercise but a welcome side effect.

Re: Why do we do it?

#3

Re: Why do we do it?

Raney

>Personally, while I do sort of appreciate the connection to the past, and the mroe leisurely feeling about working with handtools, mostly I use them because I find that they're capable of a much higher quality of work than strictly machine woodworking.

I do not like Arts and Crafts furniture, and I'm just lukewarm on shaker furniture. I found that if I wanted to make furniture outside those styles, which I did, then I needed to either learn to use handtools, or spend a LOT more time making jigs than furniture.

That, and I hate the noise and dust that tailed routers kick up.

Re: Why do we do it?

#4

Re: Why do we do it?

Bob Demers

>Like a lot of my peers around here, I started with mostly electron burning WW, then I discovered old hand tools, got intringed, researched them, learned to tuned them, used them and there has been no turning back since. Besides the link to the past I feel while using them, what really got me hooked is the therapeutic aspect. I find it so liberating, to not have to cough dust and don ear defenders.

Another aspect I truly appreciated is that I can enjoy my 'addiction' anywhere (well almost anywhere, they wont let you bring a plane on board an aircraft now a days. Take me to Cuba or I plane down the pilot :-)

At work, I keep a piece of wood and a plane, and use it stricly for making shavings. Pure meaningless, unadultered relaxation.

People quickly learned that when im planing a lot of shavings, it mean, stay away from Bob, he is working out his frustrations. Work everytime, dont even have to say a words, they notice, and 'whatever' get resolved quickly. Ah, the true power of the plane, who would have thunk :-)

Bob, who also makes shaving just for the sheer enjoyment, empty the mind and help me refocus.

And just for the record, �yes, I actually work inside a 'plane' hangar :-)

Re: Why do we do it?

#5

If you want to work out frustrations

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>in my opinion, NOTHING beats a drawknife. You can make great heaps of chips in no time.

Re: Why do we do it?

#6

Re: If you want to work out frustrations

Bob Demers

>LOL, true, but it would be a tad intimidating at work, besides someone could get hurt :-)

Seriously, my making shavings trick, work great, and if they would rather have me making shavings than addressing the problem, then so be it. But it always does the trick, and it draws in people and engage them in. As a bonus, you get to know the real woodworkers at work, and get them to 'chip in' he he

All jokes asides, it works everytime, and it add to my relaxation, bonus :-) And since im not making anything at all, besides piles of shavings, no one can accuse me of 'not working' at my job, it is my job to get things done...peacefully. OK failing that there always the M61 and the PGMs and, and...but they tend to leave the wood surface splintery I found..

Bob, shaving problems one plane swoop at a time

Re: Why do we do it?

#7

Re: If you want to work out frustrations

Marv

>Bob,

You must be a salaried employee? :)

Marv

Re: Why do we do it?

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Why do we do it?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Power tools are a means to an end.I enjoy finishing the project but the doing is a chore.With hand tools,it's different.I enjoy the doing.Also,I love the look and feel of old tools.---Jack

Re: Why do we do it?

#9

Ever used an adz?

Bob Hackett

>

Re: Why do we do it?

#10

Re: Why do we do it?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I got interested back in the back-to-basics 60s. Since then, I've come to a slowly more refined understanding of the capabilities of hand tools. I'm not ready to give up the electron-eaters, but I find more pleasure in working, when I can, with the quiet side; and definitely appreciate what hand tools can do that power tools either flat can't or can't do as efficiently.

I was pleased, this last week while talking with my contractor son, to find that, even though his truck is filled with power tools, he's made a lot of use of the Craftsman (Sargent-made, Stanley 78 style) rabbet plane that I gave him when he started doing carpentry.

Re: Why do we do it?

#11

Re: Why do we do it?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't really care if a tool is old or new; but since I'm entrenched in wood, most of my western tools are old (except that one long, heavy, marvelous C&W jointer and a few metal things). And then there are all the new Japanese wooden things I love. I think I like to feel things, warm things like wood, regardless of where it's found. The one time I tried to feel a table saw blade, it mangled my finger. :)

Pam

Re: Why do we do it?

#12

Re: Why do we do it?

Paul M.

>Good question! We all need to stop and take stock in what we enjoy once in a while.

1) I found I'm allergic to just about every variety of sawdust. It doesn't matter if it's pine or rosewood. The dust from a sander will give me a fever for a day or 2. I'll do anything I can to not produce dust. Planes and card scrapers are the only way I can do woodworking.

2) It's so satisfying to have a big pile o shavings around my ankles. I know I've done a good days work when the shavings start to pile up.

3) When noisy machines turn on, my brain shuts off. I do occasionally use a powered router, but only when I really need to. I don't have a tablesaw or powered jointer, because flipping the switch makes me flip out. I can work with the radio on low, and still hear what's going on with hand tools.

4) I find that my accuracy is not at all compromised using hand tools compared to power tools. My speed is undoubtedly slower, but the accuracy is still fine.

5) My wife and the shop cats will join me in the shop to keep me company while I'm working. That wouldn't happen with dust and noise from power tools.

Re: Why do we do it?

#13

You mean like this type of work?

Alan DuBoff

>Unfortunately this not mine, but isn't it gorgeous? I just had to post since you mentioned...:-)

I gotta get me an adz...*sigh*



Re: Why do we do it?

#14

I can't imagine the delight

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>it would be to experience those wonderful beams every day. Wow! that texture is fabulous.

You gotta get an adze!

Bruce

Re: Why do we do it?

#15

Re: Why do we do it?

Victor Parisian

>With power tools it's "watch your fingers,watch your fingers,watch your fingers..." With hand tools it's "watch those shavings" :>)

victor in Houston

Re: Why do we do it?

#16

Re: Why do we do it?

wilbur

>I've decided that I don't really have to justify anything I do in woodworking. The very fact that I decided to take up woodworking as a hobby meant that I crossed over the justification line a long time ago. :@)

Seriously, my impression is that in woodworking there are people who are interested in the product, and people who are interested in the process. I am as interested in the process as much as I am in the product. I like figuring out how things are done, and how things are put together. This is probably more an issue of how my brain is wired, as opposed to following some sort of woodworking philosophy.

Re: Why do we do it?

#17

Plane hangar...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Isn't that your shop? :-)

Any snow up there yet?

DC

Re: Why do we do it?

#18

That would be it!

Bob Hackett

>Now imagine all those large chips flying thru the air!

I once took an after hours job attacking lumber yard beams to make them look hand done for a local custom home.The owner and builder said it was fun just to watch me have fun,and paid me well for it.

They don`t call an adz a "Shin hoe" up here for nothing.I`ve been told that they used to use small bottomless nail kegs as shin guards for the apprentices till they got the hang of it.

One recommendation,if you feel you need to buy one,look for a shipwright`s adz or lipped adz(the sides curl up).They work better cross grain and are easier to control(for me at least).The "hang" on an adz is even more crucial than an axe and can be adjusted by fore and aft wedges cut to fit.Finding or making(the best way)a proper handle is the hard part.

For those really into old tools and technique there`s a clip on Youtube of a fellow hewing a small log that shows him making good progress on what looks to be hard timber.He then hands the adz to the spectators so they can see the STONE blade.Came across it while looking at jade carving clips.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Why do we do it?

#19

Re: Why do we do it?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I can't help myself.

Stephen

Re: Why do we do it?

#20

You're sending me to youtube?!?

James Watriss

>There goes a couple of hours...

Re: Why do we do it?

#21

I know how you feel!

Bob Hackett

>How do you think I went from power hammers to jade carving to woodworking=afternoon shot!

All I can say is RESIST THE URGE,hard as that may be.

MB-Who especially enjoyed Catherine`s 3 videos.

Re: Why do we do it?

#22

Isn`t that what we`re for?

Bob Hackett

>This IS the WC branch of the Support Group from Hell isn`t it?

MB

Re: Why do we do it?

#23

But are support groups supposed to enable so much?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Why do we do it?

#24

Yes. Support that need to do more...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>

Re: Why do we do it?

#25

Re: What I'm thinking is enlightening me------WebK

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco------WebKitFormBo

>What I WANT to be doing is completing the modern Shaker inspired Deacons' bench I have on the bench in the shop. 90% hand tool and lathe work, and maybe 60% finished at this point.

What I HAVE to be doing is the 17' of kitchen base cabinets that need replacing urgently because of a neglected water leak, now fixed, under the sink. Not a leisurely project, and using a lot of cabinet plywood, it's ear protectors and cabinet saw work, pocket screws and nail gun stuff. And consultation with the wife, on what she wants where, and how.

The first is therapy, and art. The second is pressure. But only when it won't disturb the neighbors, or can fit around the raindrops.

------WebKitFormBoundarytCNy8Rz3sfp+9Z4o