cock beading drawers
Catharine Kennedy
>I'm looking for instructions on how to do this with hand tools!
Thanks!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
cock beading drawers
Catharine Kennedy
>I'm looking for instructions on how to do this with hand tools!
Thanks!
Re: cock beading drawers
Bob Hackett
>a scratch stock comes in handy for this as does a well tuned side bead plane.
MB
Re: cock beading drawers
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Catharine,
Do you want the bead on the drawer itself, or integral to the case? I can share a bit on beading the drawer itself, but before getting started with a long story, thought I'd ask.....
Wiley
Re: cock beading drawers
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I am not sure whether you need information about making the beading or the drawer parts, but here are some notes.
One method has the beading material (say 1/8 X 1/2) sitting in rabbets in the drawer front. Dovetail and glue the drawer, then cut a 7/16 rabbet in the side edges. Chamfer the end of the endgrain run so that it does not break out. Don't chamfer the whole corner, just as far back as the rabbet goes. Use a moving fillister with spur. The chamfers disappear when you later make rabbets on the top and bottom of the drawer. I like to mold my cockbeading on the edge of a 1/2 thick board, then rip the strip off and plane the strip to thickness. Clamp the strip to the bench and plane away from the clamp.
Another method avoids the side rabbets: Cut the drawer front narrower than normal by twice the thickness of the beading. Make the dovetail sockets shallower than the drawer sides so the dovetails will protrude the thickness of the beading when put together. Make rabbets top and bottom. Then after you glue pare off the dovetail protrusions. The beading pieces for the side are wider than for the top and bottom and cover the entire dovetails. The side pieces are mitered at the front where they meet the top and bottom beads, and then flat with the top and bottom of the drawer.
Re: cock beading drawers
Catharine Kennedy
>excellant! Just what I was looking for! Thanks!
making the bead *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Here is a video where Steve Latta is showing how to make the bead with a scratch stock that he filed from a card scraper and inserts into a scrap block of wood.
One thing I was told over at SAPFM and found to be true, is that the size of the bead makes a big difference. For example, 1/8" is one-third larger than 3/32", and looks it. On a small project I made, table with two shallow drawers, 3/32" looked better to my eye.
I also found that it worked best to cut slightly fat--like 1/32" over--then plane to final fit in the drawer opening. You can use the final planing to achieve the drawer fit you're looking for.
Mitering the corners....I suggest using a method where you can sneak up on a fit. If it comes up short, you need another piece of cockbead. I chiseled mine by eye, but a more careful worker I suppose would use a miter block and slide the chisel down it. I would suggest installing the top and bottom beads, then use the side pieces to make the final miter fit with top and bottom in place. The side pieces are shorter and easier to handle, and if you mess one up it's a smaller loss to make up.
In addition, to expose dovetails......
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I love cock beads but my scratched ones are not attractive, so I apply them like Warren described. However, if you apply the full width bead to the drawer edges it covers your lovely (more more or less in my case) dovetails. So, make the cock bead strip more narrow for the drawer end. This approach involves a worrisome notched miter where this narrow bead meets the full width bead but mine turn out acceptable.
In the PIC you can see the end grain of the full width beading strip on the bottom of the drawer edge and of course the more narrow strip on the drawer edge.
PS..... making the strip
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>It is trivial to scratch the half round profile for the beading strip. I use a chain saw file to make the scratch stock profile.
For ease in application the beading strips for the top and bottom of the drawer are the full width of the drawer stock thickness. Drawer looks better with full thickness beading strip on top.
Full width strip *LINK*
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>I trust Warren's knowledge on what is Period-correct. Were the partial-width beads generally used back in the day?
LIke Bill (and Steve Latta's example in the video), I used full width bead strips top and bottom. It looked neater. But also because the drawer fronts were a thick veneer (3/16"): Full-width beads taken from the same board as the drawer front veneer puts the same wood tone on all visible parts of the drawer. See link.
If one is going for Period correctness though, this is going to be an important detail. Warren, can you tell us whether the seamed beads were always used, or generally used, or sometimes used?
Thank you, Wiley
Full width cock beads top and bottom
Re: Full width strip
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Why wouldn't you do full width strips all around before cutting the dovetails?
Pam
Re: Full width strip
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>Wiley, cockbeads were used over a long period, notably in William and Mary and Federal furniture. They are especially valuable for veneered drawer fronts because without them the veneer on the corners would be quite vulnerable. They also add visual refinement to drawers with wild veneers. There are lots of variations; I was just giving some examples.
Re: Full width strip
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Just as a guess, I would say that it's an aesthetic issue, because you would have the face grain tails interlaced with face grain pin ends, but cross grain to each other, and with a different set of seams showing than folks are used to seeing. In short, it wouldn't 'look right', but that's just my guessing.
I have a book on Japanese furniture (not bringing this up because of your Japanese interests, but because of the dovetail topic), and it shows dovetailed and cockbeaded drawer fronts where the side bead strips cover the full dovetail section, apparently to shield the pin end grain against moisture changes in the air. But there, the strips are applied after the joint is cut and glued. Warren above makes reference to a method where the side pieces cover the entire dovetail section--I wonder if it is for the same reason, i.e., to cover the end grain of the pins.
Wiley
Re: Full width strip
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Yeah, but it's simply another aesthetic to reveal the dovetails and another to cover them completely. Guess I'll have to try it some day.
I've been told that the Japanese consider it gauche to reveal joinery.
Pam
Re: Full width strip
James Watriss
>Because the strip runs all the way around, in order to cover the DTs, you need to run a rabbet all the way around. This includes going across the front end of the drawer sides... the applied strip should be lush with the sides, so it needs to be let in.
So it's easier to join the drawer box, then run the rabbet, because it gets the sides of the front, and the front of the sides, in one pass.
Re: Full width strip
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I see your point, nothing to disagree with; but seems it would be fairly simple to cut off the drawer ends 1/8", or whatever, thus obviating the rebate. Of course, there's a bit more room for error.
Pam
Re: Full width strip
James Watriss
>No doubt, you're absolutely right.
You'd still have to cut the DTs and notch out the sides for the side strips. I think, for my purposes, it'd be easier to handle that work with the drawer together, and I'd be less worried about damaging the edges of the veneer while cutting the joints if it was going to be cut back later.
Re: Full width strip
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi James,
Great points you're making. Here was Pam's original question:
"Why wouldn't you do full width strips all around before cutting the dovetails?"
I understood her to be getting at a way to do the cockbeading without rabbets at all, by pre-cockbeading the drawer front to full nominal size with full-width strips "all around". Then cutting the half-lap dovetails right through the side strips.
Maybe i have it wrong, but I understood her to be exploring a simplification of the entire method.
Wiley
Yes, that's exactly what I intended to say.
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
Seems like it`d be more visually appealing.
Bob Hackett
>And alittle stronger due to not reducing the mass of the dovetails.
MB
There you go.
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>
the reason why this idea has mechanical problems
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>Lets us start with an extreme case, an English drawer that may only be 1/4 to 5/16" in thickness and a 1/8" cock bead. In this case only 1/8" to 3/16" of the tails would be in strong grained wood( the part of the drawer front that was not the long grained cock bead strip). Less extreme cases have lesser strength limitations but in all cases the drawer is mechanically less sound if pre-cockbeaded. Executed as I showed in the picture, the technique I was taught in Headley's shop, has stood the test of time in terms of efficiency and utility.
The bottom line here is that there is no practical reason to not cock bead after drawer assembly. The process goes rapidly and reliably. The stepped miter seems like it might be difficult but my crude home made miter guide enabled it to be sawed with acceptable precision. So long as one errs on the long side when wrapping something with molding(cockbeading in this case) it is not difficult to get tight fits.
not so
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>1. If I am understanding correctly the premise is incorrect. The dovetails are not compromised at all with a "full" cock bead, full being defined as full on top and bottom but not the sides. See the picture I posted. The dovetails do not involve the cock bead at all.
2. At least 200 years of judgment says a full width on the end grain drawer edge is not more appealing or that is the way it would have been done over these years.
Weak grain?
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Wouldn't you wind up with a bunch of short sections of weak grain on the cockbeading between the tails?
Re: not so
Bob Hackett
>Are you talking about an applied front on the drawer Bill?
That`s the only way I can see to replicate your pic and still not cut into the dovetails at all.
Am I missing something?
MB
PS
Bob Hackett
>Do you by any chance have a pic of the unassembled joint showing the cuts involved?
It also looks as though the grain runs vertically in the drawer front pic.Am I missing something here too?Horizontal grain is what I`m used to in drawer fronts.
MB