Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Best way to get light rust off steel

Posts

Best way to get light rust off steel

#1

Best way to get light rust off steel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

What's your favorite way to get light rust off of steel, like the blade of a steel square. Gray pad doesn't quite get it all, but I don't want to make bright scratches either.

Wiley

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#2

400 grit ?

steve mackay

>

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#3

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel *LINK*

Tom MacGregor

>This is a link to a post w/photo I placed on "Messages" a while back showing how I use electroylsis on long objects. You'd have to dunk each arm of the square, but it wouldn't come out scuffed or too bright. I usually dip or wipe the piece down with WD40 to remove all moisture from the nooks & crannies after I'm done cleaning it.


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives.pl?read=381285&v1=e2vrt43&v2=Cabinetmaking&v4=joinery&v5=fkl8yt6

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#4

I like the grit eraser thingies *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Some years back, I bought one of those grit erasers that Klingspor sells - abrasives in a rubber block, kind of like a serious version of those big pink erasers we got in elementary school. They call them "abraser blocks" (the official name is "sandflex," but for some reason this won't get action on Klingspor's search engine). It's now worn down enough to the point that it will fall out of the little cardboard sleeve it came in; I think I've got about another 20 years of use left.

I use this for final polishing, after light sandpaper to remove as much rust as possible. I keep thinking I should use wet-and-dry lubricated with mineral spirits, as I've seen suggested here, and keep not remembering to do that when I'm actually cleaning up a tool.


Like these

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#5

I also got an offline recommendation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>on these from a friend. He thought 'medium'. What kind of a surface does it leave?

Wiley

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#6

Vinegar

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#7

Re: I also got an offline recommendation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I got medium too, and it leaves a smooth, VERY shiny surface. Takes a little time, which is why I do as much cleanup as possible with sandpaper.

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#8

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Great setup of the anode, Tom. Surrounds the plane body and also keeps the copper lead out of the solution.

Is that a battery charger on the other end of the leads? What amperage setting did you use?

For the benefit of others, in that same thread Bill Tindall and Spencer Hochstetler have an Article on electrolysis that is an excellent primer on the subject (for folks like me that don't know much about it). See link for Bill and Spencer's Article.

Wiley


Tindall, Hochstetler on Electrolysis

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#9

Re: Vinegar

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Stephen,

Do you have any problems with re-rusting after the acid treatment? Does an ordinary wipe down with oil prevent re-rusting?

Wiley

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#10

Re: Vinegar

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

I wash it with soap and water to stop the action of the vinegar. If we had humidity out West, I would rub on a coat of oil.

Stephen

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#11

Re: I also got an offline recommendation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Bill. That is helpful. This is the second really dumb rust accident I've had in a month. The first one, I left a cloth with metal etching solution on it in proximity to a 6" Starrett double square. This time, I left a couple of largish precision squares where they shouldn't have been--was working on the porch--and a sprinkler misfired overnight and got water all over them. DIdn't know til the next morning. Gray pad took most of the powdery rust off, but there is still a little.

Wiley

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#12

Or Lemon Juice

Steve Elliott

>On older tools with a nice patina I hate to take the steel back to a bright finish. If there are rust spots I dampen a paper towel with lemon juice and rub the surface until the red rust color disappears. I'm not sure about the chemistry but I think the red rust changes to something gray. I always rinse thoroughly and oil the surface afterwards to prevent further chemical action.

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#13

why it works

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Citric acid is an excellent solvent for rust. So are most acids but citric and oxalic are especially good. The product is largely colorless, so they work nicely for iron stain removal. The problem is that you then must get every trace of this stuff off the metal or it will promote re-rusting, and, the surface left is especially susceptible to rerusting.

So, the recommendation to wash thoroughly and re-oil is essential to success.

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#14

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

Tom MacGregor

>That's an inexpensive 12 volt battery charger that can be set for either 2 or 10 amps. Ten amps is a little faster but it works on either setting. Keeping the clamps and connections clean improves performance, too.

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#15

Re: I also got an offline recommendation

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

Here's an easy and fast method to remove new light rust. I would start with 000 steelwool and WD40. The WD40 is thick enough to work well with the steelwool so you won't get scratches and the 000 is fine enough to also not leave scratches. Work it slowly and lightly, just enough to get the rust off. The WD40 will leave a light oiley coat that will, in a short time go away. And it smells good too. If you want a protect the surface from rusting, give it a couple of good rub downs with a good paste wax, same as you do your handsaws.

Marv

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#16

Worked

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Marv,

Lots of good advice, but I took yours under the 'first do no harm' principle. I used Liberon 00 wool and my all purpose camellia oil*. Lifted everything up in about 2 minutes. And as you say, no scratches. This Liberon wool is nice.

I didn't see any saws of your'n on the bay--what's up.

Thanks much,

Wiley

*Before there is any chortling and ill-considered remarking about camellia oil, let me say that this camellia oil is special, being collected just after dawn on but one day each year, right after the shadow of the torii gate falls across the single 10-acre field where it is grown. It bears no resemblance to that buck-fifty a gallon vegetable oil at the corner grocery. Thank you for listening.

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#17

Re: Worked

Peter Evans

>With acid, I use citric because it is benign, there are 2 critical steps:

1) Check frequently and remove from acid as soon as rust is gone from surface. This avoids pitting, which is guaranteed if left in too long. The pitting may be microscopic after a couple of hours, obvious after a day

2) After rinsing, DRY the tool with a heat gun or hair dryer and drive all moisture out of the metal. The tool should end up quite warm. In a temperate climate without excessive humidity, eg Sydney, oiling is usually not necessary, but a good idea for some tools, eg saws. I have files and rasps that were sharpened in acid a couple of years ago, never oiled - and no rust; stored in rolled up newspaper.

Sydney, Australia

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#18

Re: Worked

Marv

>Hi Wiley,

I gave two saws away last week on eBay. One was a beautiful Keen Kutter brassback tenon saw. The handle was in new condition. Sold for a whopping $47 bucks. The other was a Disston No.12....5PPI Ripper. Did some horn replacements and refinished the handle a dark color...sold for a whoping $81.. Sure glad I don't have to rely on the profits, for food.

Marv


img

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#19

But not nearly as good as... *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>the oil of Amorphophallus titanum, which must be gathered while wearing a filter mask, and during the flowering period only..

No, not really - I have no idea if this flower or its plant produces oil, though, from the description of the plant's odor, I sure wouldn't want any in my shop.


Wikipedia's description

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#20

Re: Worked

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Gawd, that is a fantastic job you did with that No. 12!! I don't think $81 is so bad, but I can imagine it looks pretty paltry considering the skill and work you put into the saw. Somebody got a really nice deal.

Only thing I would say about the prices, and I would say this to anyone, take a look at how Todd H. presents his items. Particularly on his choice stuff, he always includes things like period advertising or other background info. to explain that this was a top drawer, first cabin, primo item when it was made. No. 12 was the top of the line and pre-1929 saw, wasn't it? You have to get two people really wanting a No. 12 in top, ready to use condition--at the same time. Is there some way to demonstrate how good the sharpening job is--that's a big potential selling point IMO.

Who made Keen Kutter saws? Here's a half-baked theory--which along with $5 will get you coffee at Starbucks: Vintage items don't sell themselves unless there is already a collector or very strong user community there for you to sell into (think Berg chisels). If it's not a known collectible, and in near-mint condition, then the seller is going to have to convince the buyer of three things: (1) it was a top drawer item when made; (2) it's rare and there won't be another one for a long time; and (3) this is such a classic blue-chip item, that you can't miss even if you pay top buck. The buyer's frame of mind has to be that this item is primo, it is rare, I'm safe paying a top retail price, and I don't want it to get away. If any of those aren't there, there's no sense of urgency and it keeps the bidding down. [end of half-baked theory].

Thanks a lot for the help on the rust removal!

Wiley

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#21

Re: Worked

Marv

>Wiley,

I've been selling saws on eBay for more than a few years now. I don't write skimpy descriptions. I do include some history without writing a book. I post lots of good pictures. I emphasize the sharpening and my skills, trying not to brag too much. Most of the saws I sell are meant as users, not collectibles. Anytime I have to do repairs to a saw, that alone will devalue the saw for a lot of bidders. The saw also had a hole drilled at the toe end by a previous owner. $81.00 does seem like a fair amount to pay for a saw like that, but from this seller's standpoint, after I deduct eBay fees and PayPal fees and my cost of files and other materials used, along with what I paid for the saw, that $81.00 drops considerably when it comes to pennies in my pocket. If I wasn't retired and needed something to dirty my finger nails and the fact I enjoy restoring old saws, I wouldn't do it. When I find something else that is as much fun, I'll probably do that instead.

As for the Keen Kutter saw, as far as I know they made them, however Simmonds name is on the etch as well, not to be confused with Simonds. Keen Kutter was a major tool maker. Compare the amount the saw sold for to new saws on the market by present day saw makers. Yes, someone got a great buy at only $47.

Thank you for the kind words....

Marv


img

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#22

Re: Worked

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Marv, I've seen your writeups. They're very strong, and I didn't mean to imply otherwise. It's just impressive to me the prices that Todd gets.

I believe Keen Kutter was one of E. C. Simmons' brands, E. C. Simmons being a big wholesale hardware outfit (in St. Louis, I think).

Anyway, for $47, you're right. Somebody got a real deal. Beautiful brass-backed saw.

Wiley

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#23

Re: Worked

Marv

>Wiley,

Todd does a good job, has been selling for a long time and has a pretty good following and knows his tools. He gets good prices for some things, but not for all items. It's just that he has a good mix of things in many catagories. I mainly do saw related stuff and don't sell on a regular basis. For me it's kind of a hobby that I do when I'm in the mood.

I bought that KK saw with it missing it's back. I bought the back from a saw maker friend of mine who was kind enough to sell me one. The back not being original no doubt effected the end price. I actually lost money on that deal. You are right, the best auctions are when two people really want the item.

Marv

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#24

Wiley, you should watch some of Marvs saw...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>On D'Bay. He's not a bad seller (no offense here), and is a very reputable one as well. His saws can and do bring a premium.

Re: Best way to get light rust off steel

#25

Maybe it's just me...

Marv

>Bill,

Maybe it's just me but I find it much easier to buy some steelwool and mineral spirits at WalMart. :)

Marv