Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

Posts

Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#1

Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundary9yANUT8mn8C+Zo

>i am not advocating using wood gouges for turning wood, it's just that several times when I have been looking at used lathes, there is a wood gouge in the box of turning tools. When I bought one of the lathes, I ended up with a Greenlee socket gouge that had been modified to have a fingernail grind. So was it common for turners to grab a wood gouge and grind it to suit? A lot of the other tools gotten with the lathe were old files with the teeth ground off. Apparently one of those turners who didn't want to spend a lot on tools.

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#2

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

Phil Joines Krum,Tx

>It was common 20+ years ago to make tools from files and tools not made for turning. Until fairly recently most turning tools were carbon steel and hard to find.

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#3

When I did a little turning years ago

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I was using a Stanley chisel. I can easily imagine a gouge getting drafted into the whirly world.

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#4

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I don't think you are looking at a serious turner when you see firmer gouges in with turning tools. I was able to buy nice Sorby tools unhandled for about $10 apiece in 1981. The 1985 Garrett Wade catalog listed more than 90 different turning gouges and chisels, both HSS and HC. Try and find a high quality high carbon gouge today.

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#5

Going the other way

Bob Hackett

>Now that HSS is being used for most turning tools(as well as particle steels and other exotics)it`s hard to find HCS tools anymore where once that was all that was available.

I`m finding new uses for the heavy duty HCS turning tools by brazing a bolster on and using them for roughing/heavy mallet work or giving them to folks I know who do wood sculpting.Obviously a bolster is not needed with a socket chisel.

I and my brothers still use alot of the old turning tools for detail work at the lathe.Excellent quality high carbon steel should be used and not wasted.

Use what ya got!Something the previous owner of your turning kit understood well,from the looks of it.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#6

Re: Going the other way

wilbur

>This probably belongs in the turning forum, but what do you think is the main reason that HCS turning tools were replaced by HSS tools in this era of turning?

I can think of three factors:

1. To accomodate burning/bluing mishaps on a grinder when sharpening.

2. Turners using higher speeds when turning (larger blanks or more RPMs). leading to increased heating of the tool in use.

3. Increased use of exotic (read hard) species in turning.

Warren was kind enough once to show me how to use a HCS tool on a manually powered lathe. It's quite a different experience than on the Conover lathe that I have at home.

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#7

Temper of HCS turning tools

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bob and Warren,

Were/are the HCS turning tools smithed and tempered different from chisels? Or from plane irons? Harder? Softer? More hot work?

WIley

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#8

That's a good question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have a set of Buck turning chisels, dating probably to the 1930's, whatever that makes them. They get sharp, but that edge doesn't seem to last. OTOH, when I've needed to turn something, it is always with dried wood, never green. I have no experience with HSS turning gear (for the power industry folks) to compare the CS Buck Bros cast steel gouges.

Bruce

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#9

Turning tools vs bench chisels

Bob Hackett

>The main reason for HSS in turning is wear resistance.The fact that you can turn the tool blue at the grinder and not draw the temper is a plus too but not the main reason for using it.Particle steel is even more abrasion resistant than HSS and doesn`t require special wheels as does carbide.

As far as I can tell the HC steel on most turning tools is similar if not the same as bench chisels from the same maker.Turning tools have a heavier cross section and more robust design than bench chisels to resist flex and reduce vibration and chatter on the work.This makes them better suited to the heavy/rough work I`ve been using them for.

Some folks will want to argue this I`m sure but I feel the HCS takes a better edge more easily than HSS and that is one reason why I still use some HCS for detail work.Another reason is there used to be a better selection(especially in gouges) of HCS than we now enjoy with HSS and some tools (especially smaller ones)are just not available in HSS.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#10

Re: That's a good question

Bob Hackett

>You really can`t beat a HSS/particle steel gouge for edge holding ability when turning kiln dried wood or abrasive woods like teak.I`ve had sparks fly from some silica deposits in teak and of course stump wood.I try to use carbide for initial turning of stumps.Go to the AAW site for your state or look on the turning forum here for a turner near you and take one of the HSS gouges for a spin on a scrap of your most abrasive wood,you`ll be surprised.

HCS turning tool`s will hold an edge longer if you retemper them harder(not too hard or they fracture) but I understand this may be beyond most folks comfort level.

One of the reason`s I like HCS is because you can quickly hone the edge back to sharp while standing at the lathe.My Conover`s tailstock is beginning to show the effects though.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#11

Re: Turning tools vs bench chisels------WebKitForm

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundary9yANUT8mn8C+Zo

>HSS will take a mediocre edge and hold it forever. I heard that from knife makers.

Roy Girolami

------WebKitFormBoundaryS2Xo+uP8OnzVT4da

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#12

why HSS replaced carbon steel- edge retention

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In a typical turning situation the turner makes a mile of shaving in less than 5 minutes of turning. Edge retention is the primary concern for turners. It is an accepted fact that many, if not all, of the tool steels have more to vastly more abrasion resistance than carbon steel- they hold an edge longer, to much longer. There are other benefits but abrasion resistance is the primary factor.

Some believe that particular properties of tool steels have benefits for hand tools, for example superior toughness and or abrasion resistance. The down side is try abrading M2 tool steel, or M4, on an aluminum oxide stone. I once tried sharpening my M2 jointer knives by hand- a fools errand.

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#13

carbon steel vs HSS and sharp

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Alan Batty was in for a class some months ago. Alan worked in the English trades since his early teens starting with sharpening the shop's lathe tolls and eventually becoming the apprentice trainer and then owner of his own shop. Alan is a "put the product out the door kind of person". He turns to make money, not support a lifestyle. I would be inclined to trust his pragmatic opinions.

He too thought carbon steel tools took a better edge. However, he used high speed steel tools in his demonstrations.

I think his statement needs qualification-took a better edge "under the conditions under which it was created". Alan had a piece of leather that hung from his belt and every now and then the tool was stropped upon this leather. There is little doubt that the effect of this operation will be vastly different on carbon steel vs something highly abrasion resistant like M2.

Steve Elliot's seminal work on sharpening left no doubt in my mind that the tool steels that he investigated could be sharpened to the same degree of refinement as carbon steel, provided the sharpening technique could deal with the abrasion resistance of these steels.

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#14

Wondered where you were at Bill

Bob Hackett

>That`s why I worded my above responses as I did.

Your help and direction has helped me to see that just about any steel can be brought to near the same level of "sharp" given the right abrasives,approach and time.

What my approach(and experience/opinion) means is nothing more than not breaking out of that stance and mental zone by being able to restore an edge almost without thinking using the "Leather on belt" technique applied to HCS tools.The key here for me is "quickly and easily".I suppose if I practiced it enough I could do the same thing with HSS and a pocket diamond hone.

I do all my roughing and intermediate turning with HSS(and hone them too).I save the HCS for detail work and maybe "last pass" using tools that are better shaped for the task than any finely honed HSS I own(usually gouges).

I agree that HSS can be brought to the same edge quality as HCS just not as quickly for an old dog like myself.You also have to wonder why knife makers and hand tool makers still overwhelmingly offer O1 or it`s equivalent as opposed to HSS.Maybe it`s similar to offering transitional planes and iron soled planes at the same time from the same maker or why wood bodied planes still sell when we all know metal bodied planes are far superior.;^)

Thanks again for for your help and input,and I mean this sincerely.You were an exception where an old dog(me)could indeed be taught new tricks.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Use of Wood Gouges for Turning

#15

where I was...... and more on turning

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The screen said "Windows\system32\config\system\ file is missing or corrupt". I'm well now.

I hone between grindings with a diamond pocket hone. Well, actually since I am cheap I have a small piece of cast iron charged with 30 micron diamond that I hone with. I wished I had been able to discuss this topic more with Alan Batty, but he made the statement that for oak the tool is not honed. I think he said that the tool cut oak better if not honed. His experience would have been with English white oak, I presume. He honed when he was turning yellow pine. (BTW, the finish on the pine right off the tool looked like a finely hand planed surface. It was ready for finish.) It was a sobering experience to see what an experienced "parts turner" could do- how quick he could turn something, the perfection of the proportions and the quality of the finish. After all, he is planing with out the benefit of a tool holder other than his hands.

I gave him a bun foot I was struggling with. He took a 1/32 or here and 1/64 off there and the improvement in the shape was astonishing.

"You also have to wonder why knife makers and hand tool makers still overwhelmingly offer O1 or it`s equivalent as opposed to HSS." tradition and it is relatively easy to sharpen. I am told by a knife maker (Jerry Hossom) that the knife performance contests are being won primarily by M4 knives. M4 is awesome- tough at Rc64 and abrasion resistant, and a challenge to sharpen.