Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

How to buy planes at auction (long)

Posts

How to buy planes at auction (long)

#1

How to buy planes at auction (long)

Mark in Texas

>I founded and chair the hand tool splinter group of our local woodworkers club. Lately, I've noticed that some of our newer members have made poor choices in acquiring common planes, including when shopping on our favorite online auction. So I thought I would develop a list of helpful hints. I thought it might be nice to post it here, for additional viewpoints on the subject. Mark (main text follows)

"We have quite a few members who are just beginning the hand tool journey, and are in need of the basic tools. Like it or not, Ebay is arguably the most practical way to acquire quality tools at a reasonable price -- higher quality than a brand new Stanley, more reasonably priced than a new Lie-Nielsen. That said, it can also be a minefield for the uninitiated. With that in mind, I thought I would try to list some pointers. I�ve probably made every rookie mistake in the book, so this is the voice of experience. On balance, though, I�m pleased with my win/loss record, so I�m still a proponent of this venue for tool acquisition. For the other members of the group, feel free to reply with additional tips; I�ll add them and reissue the list.

Much of what follows is oriented toward planes but is still applicable to other tools.

Much of what follows is my own bias. If you like old tools, you most likely have firm convictions about subtle details. This is part of the fun. Just don�t miss the forest for the trees.

1. Caveat emptor.

Some sellers will return your purchase price, but you may be out 2 x shipping and handling charges. For a common plane, this may be so much money that it�s not worth it, so it�s best to make sure you want the plane. Of course, you should also read and understand the other Ebay rules and regulations and understand the Ebay system.

2. Patience, patience, patience

This is the real key for successful Ebay shopping. You have to know what it�s worth (at least to you) and be prepared to fold if the price goes too high. I guarantee that a similar or identical plane of equivalent quality will eventually show up at a reasonable price. Notice that I said reasonable price. Disabuse yourself of the notion that you�ll score a complete Stanley 42 for $25. There are too many guys like me surfing Ebay on a daily basis for this to happen. Likewise, note that I said �eventually�; you just can�t be in a hurry.

2a. Don�t get auction fever.

It�s fun and exciting, especially at first. But it�s easy to get caught up in the heat of the moment and overspend.

3. Search strategies

Everyone should develop their own search strategies; these are a strong function of how much time you want to spend at this. I don�t pretend to know the optimum strategy. I do believe that most of the decent planes are in the �collectibles� section.

Timing. Once in a while, I get a good deal by paying attention to items listed in �off peak� periods (defined as not on Sunday or not in the evening during the week). This is very hit or miss, though.

4. Completed listings

In the advanced search section, you can view the sales price of completed auctions. For common planes, this is a quick and easy way to roughly determine market value, because you can compare plane condition and age in one list to make sure that you are comparing apples to apples. For example, you should compare a type 12 Stanley 4 to another type 12 Stanley 4, not a type 12 and a type 19.

For planes with fewer sales, it�s a more dicey proposition since there may only be one plane from a certain vintage listed.

5. Type Studies � aka Homework

It looks easy to buy a tool on Ebay. And frankly, it is. It�s probably too easy, because you will be tempted to pull the trigger prematurely. You have to do your homework before you can buy with confidence. You need to become intimately familiar with type studies for any tool that you buy. For Stanley bench planes, three good references are:

http://primeshop.com/access/woodwork/stanleyplane/pftsynch.htm

http://www.hyperkitten.com/tools/stanley_bench_plane/dating/

http://home.comcast.net/~rexmill/planes101/typing/typing.htm

My personal bias is that a Stanley bench plane from 1910 to 1940 should be fine.

Every tool of every brand will have it�s own type study, and some will be difficult to find on the internet.

6. Beware the Frankenplane

One reason to be intimately familiar with type studies is that you have a better chance to spot a plane where someone has mixed and matched various parts to make a complete plane. This doesn�t mean the plane is unusable. It does have a strong effect on the value of the plane; you should pay much, much less for a Frankenplane.

My personal bias is that you should avoid Frankenplanes. Decades from now, your heirs will be selling these things, so you don�t want to cheat them out of their just due.

7. Consumer versions.

Don�t buy anything that says �Handyman�. My personal bias again.

7a. Plastic or stamped steel parts.

Also to be avoided like the plague. Here�s two good references:

http://www-2.cs.cmu.edu/~alf/en/antique-tool-faq.txt

http://www.brasscityrecords.com/toolworks/graphics/plane%20id.html

8. Brands

It doesn�t have to be a Stanley; it just happens that way because they sold millions and millions of planes. The other advantage is that the literature for Stanley is vast (see #5 above).

Ok (in decreasing order of preference): Millers Falls, Sargent, Union, Ohio Tool, Record

Not ok: Fulton, Craftsman, Shelton, �Made in the USA�

9. Broken castings/Repaired castings

Just say no. Many can still be used, but why bother when you can find perfectly good ones with no cracks? Usually, you can rely on a seller�s claim that there are no cracks, breaks, etc. If there is no such claim explicitly stated, ask the seller directly before you buy.

10. Incomplete planes

I�ve traveled this road a lot. The temptation is to buy the plane and shop for the missing part separately. On balance, I�d have to say that it just isn�t worth it. You will either end up waiting a long time (think years) before you spot that missing depth stop in a subsequent auction, or you will spend just as much money as if you had simply waited for a complete one to come along.

11. The Blade - MIA

It�s very common to find a better deal on a plane because it�s missing the blade. It�s ok to buy these as long as your eyes are wide open. Just be aware that a new replacement (eg from Hock) will cost $20 - $50 plus S&H. Perhaps less obvious, a replacement from Ebay will still cost $20 -$30 ($15 plus S&H). The discrepancy will be even bigger for rare or exotic planes. A good example is a Stanley 46 combination plane. The plane can be had for $25-$50, but the blade set costs $100 - $200. If you passed on a plane plus cutters for $100 in favor of a plane without cutters that cost $25, you made a mistake.

11a. The Blade � Previously owned by a grinding fiend

I�m referring to a blade that has 1/8� remaining between the edge and the slot. With proper care, a blade should last a lifetime. But there are some out there who feel the need to regrind the blade between every sharpening. Of course, no one in the hand tool splinter group falls into this category. Ideally, the seller will post a photo of the blade by itself. If not, you should look closely at the picture to see how far the blade extends over the tote. If it�s above the tote, it�s probably ok. If it stops short of the tote, be suspicious.

12. Multiple items in the auction

Be extra suspicious if more than one plane is included in the auction. One or more may be broken, or incomplete, or simply not worth buying.

13. Incorrect or incomplete auction descriptions

These are a potential source of good deals. The item will still be spotted by the tool junkies, but at least the pool of bidders will be smaller. Also, see #5 above.

Good Hunting!"

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#2

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

Bob Hackett

>Might want to add something about the difference between rust and pitting.

I`m also surprised to hear you warn folks away from Craftsman.Thier early planes are quite a bargain and were made by Stanley and Sargent among others.Easiest way to tell is by looking at the lateral adjust lever.

Mainely,Bob

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#3

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I concur, in theory, on the Craftsman planes. The trouble for a newcomer to the hand tool universe is distinguishing good Craftsman from bad.

Another good, but unrecognized name is "Wards Master." These seem to be very good tools; not sure who made them for Wards.

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#4

What kinds of mistakes did they make?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Mark,

Thanks, your thoughts will spur other peoples' thinking, and especially those new to buying tools on ebay.

Are there some particular mistakes that stand out in your mind? Like people buying rabbet planes when what they need is a bench plane. Or not seeing in the photos that the plane they are buying has a brazed side? Or a cracked and reglued tote? Or a lever cap from another maker? Or the plane is just too shiny and restored?

I agree with your characterization that the post-sweetheart 1930's planes are good. I have a Type 16 No. 6 that is an excellent tool. If I were to add anything to your extensive list, it would be these:

1. Don't buy bad wood. It's a bad sign in terms of what else may be wrong that you can't know until you see the plane (tote screw stripped and epoxied into place; wrong tote screw cross threaded into place; wrong or stripped frog screws; depth adjust shot; etc etc). In other words, if the wood is sound and original looking (not shiny), then that serves as a proxy for the mechanical condition of the plane. The wood doesn't lie.

2. Don't buy rust. There's no point, since there are so many planes in good shape.

3. Restored planes or tools. If a seller makes a business out of restoring tools, and states in detail how they go about the restoration, and points out fixes they have made--then I take that as a good sign. Oftentimes, sellers like that have a faithful following and for good reason.

On the other hand, if the tool has obviously been redone, but is presented without discussion, I take that to be a bad sign--the seller knows more than they're saying, and you don't know what's cosmetically hidden. It's a better risk to find a plane that's just been ignored and sitting on a shelf for the last 70 years.

4. No firm rule on this, but steer away from sellers that don't post multiple good pictures and provide something in the way of description. The best protection you have is a seller who is knowledgeable and who provides good photos and descriptions. Because they're competent and are not going to buy junk themselves, and because their descriptions reduce the buyer's risk. A seller who doesn't show much and doesn't want to say much leaves all the risk to the buyer. Plus, I have sometimes discovered that the cause for silence is that there is something the matter with the tool that the seller would rather be silent about.

Thanks for your post,

Wiley

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#5

Re: What kinds of mistakes did they make?

wilbur

>My version of Wiley's Rule #4:

"I don't know much about this plane" should be translated as, "I know something about this plane, and this is my way of getting out of having to tell it to you."

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#6

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

Joshua Clark

>Bill! Shh! You don't want to let that get out.. we'll start getting competition for those crummy old Craftsman planes! The early Craftsman stuff are excellent tools, many made my Millers Falls and Sargent. The Sargent-made Craftsman tools often have the Sargent part numbers cast into them. Some tools marked Dunlap are also Sargent-made.

In their hey day Sargent and Millers Falls were making tools that were right on par with what Stanley was producing. As with all of the other makers, the later stuff is just junk. You can get a rough idea of the quality by looking at the tote. If it's big and chunky, its junk.

Josh

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#7

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

Hank Knight

>Mark,

That's a good set of guidelines. I would suggest you add Keen Kutter "K" series planes to your "good" list. They're Bedrocks for all practical purposes, and often sell for much less than the Stanley Bedrocks.

Hank

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#8

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

Mark in Texas

>Good suggestion about rust and pitting, I'll add that to the list.

I'm not very knowledgable about Craftsman planes. All that I have seen in person are lower quality recent vintage, so I probably overgeneralized. The list of ok vs. not ok brands will always be subjective to some extent. With experience, my new members will naturally make their own list. I'm just trying to get them started with a simple list.

Once again, thanks, Mark

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#9

V&B too

Bob Hackett

>Vaughn and Bushnel are also essentially Bedrocks.While more rare than some other planes they are easy to recognize due to the flat sides that are cut at an angle to the sole.

Mainely,Bob

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#10

Re: What kinds of mistakes did they make?

Mark in Texas

>Wiley,

Excellent comments, thank you!

On item 4, this was a big omission on my point. It's in the category of being so second nature that I don't even think about it any more.

On item 3, I'm aware that some sellers are selling nice refurbished planes. However, I haven't developed a list of trusted sources, so I was reluctant to give advice in this respect. If anyone out there does have a list, I'd be delighted to pass it on to my new members.

Cracked or damaged wood wasn't a big concern for me. Once every year or so, our group has a meeting where we make new totes from scratch. My feeling is that the new guys shouldn't be scared of wood damage. We are, after all, woodworkers.

Over the years, I've seen new guys bring in welded planes. Recently, one of my members passed up several obtainable Stanley 4's from the good years in favor of a pair of #4 planes; one was a recent vintage Stanley and the other was something that had a plastic depth adjuster.

Thanks,

Mark

Re: How to buy planes at auction (long)

#11

Re: What kinds of mistakes did they make?

Mark in Texas

>Right on.

Thanks,

Mark