Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

To store or not to store, that is the question.

Posts

To store or not to store, that is the question.

#1

To store or not to store, that is the question.

Roy Anderson

>Should your work bench have storage cabinets under it or not? Why? This is not an academic question. I'm finally going to replace my thrown together work bench with something more functional.

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#2

Space

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Christopher Schwarz makes the point that cabinets can interfere with clamping, if I recall his book correctly; and certainly the tool you need will inevitably be in the cabinet when you've got a huge panel clamped in your face vise, covering the front of the bench.

On the other hand, if your shop is small, like mine, every cubic inch of space not devoted to walking around room must be used.

I've got storage cubbies under mine, and happily live with the issues in the first paragraph because I'd have nowhere to put the tools that are there if I didn't.

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#3

No

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>At least not for me. I like to sit at the bench on a stool for some kinds of work and put my feet under the bench top (for example chopping out dovetail waste and other tedious tasks). I do have a shelf down there to put feet, and corded power tools, on.

If you only stand at the bench then cabinetry would make sense for storage. A compromise could be to put cabinetry under part of the bench and leave room for feet in the remainder.

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#4

I like storage...

John in NM

>And I definitely like the extra mass all those tools give a bench (Gettin' old, I don't want to have to manhandle a super heavy top either!).

But I think Bill makes a good point about how one is comfortable using the bench. If you're used to resting your feet on the stretchers while sitting, you'd probably not care for drawers instead. The clamping thing is less important to me, I don't use my current open bench in anyway that would be upset by cabinets underneath. I'm having a bit of trouble imagining such a clamping situation too - an inch or so of top overhang is about all I need.

So its storage for me - if I ever get around to finishing the darn thing (its currently a makeshift router table - because I don't want to build a permanent one!)

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#5

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The cabinets could get in the way of holdfasts in a big way. I suppose you could recess the cabinet, but then you run into issues of drawer accessibility.

And then there is the issue of tools knocking about if there's any bench movement at all, to say nothing of sawdust invading everything possible.

Pam

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#6

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question

Dick Coers

>I put doors and a single shelf under mine, but now wish I did drawers instead. Getting down to floor level to dig out the lower deep stuff wasn't a big deal when I built it 25 years ago. Now at 57 I want to remove the doors and slide in a drawer unit. I kept the whole storeage unit down about 4" under the top, and set back 4" front the front of the top, so I can add any assortment of clamping devices over and under. There is a hole in the top of the storeage where the hold fast slides in. Haven't run into anything in the storeage yet.

The handiest bench I ever added to the shop, was a little unit about 14"x30" with a front vise, single row of bench dogs that line up with the front vise, and a single Record hold down. That's the bench I sit down at. It's heavy for it's size, and works great for using the dovetail fixture, or even setting the mini lathe on it. I slide it over by the table saw when cutting plywood. It's not flush with the table saw, but it lets me get the plywood horizontal. I'm off the bench surface when the cut begins. The plans ran in Woodworker's Journal when I worked there. Let me know if you would like more info.

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#7

Chris Scholz

No, it's bad chi!

Chris Scholz

>

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#8

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question

steve mackay

>When I built my bench I built in drawers and some closed space. Didn't like it. Filled up with saw dust pretty quickly. Took it all out and put in racks for smaller stock and such. Just wiggle and the dust falls to the floor.

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#9

Stretchers can support removable units

Steve Elliott

>When I built my bench 30 years ago I just followed a drawing that came with the Ulmia vise hardware. The benchtop is supported by a frame held together by two wide stretchers that work well for tool storage in a number of ways. My router table is low enough that it will slide in and rest on the stretchers and my toolbox is low enough to sit on the floor underneath the bench. Over the years I've changed the storage to suit my needs in a number of different shops.

I'm glad my bench is a finished piece without any built-ins in the base, and also glad that I can easily use the space below for storage as needed.

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: Works for me

Dale Lenz

>The only valid response above that drawers would cause that I read would be a bench holdfast, don't use them, have learn to use other clamping methods. I have 3/4" plywood between my stretchers and built a box with 8 drawers inside the box that is fastened to the plywood panel. Sawdust is not a major problem unless I leave a drawer open, happens sometime, I don't cry over it, blow it out if need been, shoot(!) it's a woodshop, dust happens. My box-of-drawers sets back a few inches and often put my feet on the paneled covered stretcher. Have a few inches of over-hang on my bench top, clamping not a problem. Once in over twenty-five years have I had a large panel in my face vise and forget to get something out of my drawers prior to vising it up, maybe I'm lucky, don't know, but drawers under my bench is winner for me!

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#11

Yes... storage is wonderful *LINK*

Paul M.

>I built my bench several years ago, with pictures at the link below. I fixed the holdfast issue mentioned above by creating a space between the top and the storage so that the holdfast can drop below the surface. This is a heavy bench that never crawls across the floor, and I wouldn't change anything at all after years of use.


My bench with storage

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#12

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question

Ted

>I have two drawers mounted between the legs of my bench above the stretcher. I originally built it without the drawers and used it that way for a couple of years before I added the drawers about 5 years ago. There are some minor inconveniences to having the drawers there, but they are far outweighed by the advantages.

The bench is about 100 pounds heavier with the drawers and contents. It is also stiffer since the drawer box is screwed between the legs like a huge stretcher. I use holdfasts, but only in holes outside the legs, which don't find to be a problem. Occasionally I will leave a plane that I need in a drawer and have to remove a clamped panel to get at it, but usually I remember to remove all the planes I will need for that job before clamping. Dust is not a problem since the drawers are enclosed by a box and close completely.

It is very nice to have all my commonly used planes immediately at hand without having to move away from the bench and have my bench situated in the center of the room. I would not change it back.

Ted

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#13

I also put my feet on the stretchers...

Alan DuBoff

>Bill,

I do the same, and I wouldn't want cabinets under my bench as I don't want anything rattling as I work on the bench, either.

I'm with you! ;-)

Re: To store or not to store, that is the question.

#14

YES! NO! wait... CRAP! um... ABSOLUTELY, MAYBE!!

James Watriss

>It's all a matter of personal choice, and a matter of options... some people don't have much space, and they need to make do.

My suggestion is to make a beefy bench with hefty stretchers. Then use your new bench to make a nice unit with drawers and/or a cabinet, that is sized to sit on the stretchers. Make sure there are a few inches between the top of that, and the underside of the bench top to clear your holdfasts, if you use them.

It'll add mass, it'll hold your tools, it'll clear your holdfasts, and if you ultimately decide you'd rather rest your feet on the stretchers, you can make a stand or a space for it somewhere. Either way, you'll still have a bench, and a place to keep your tools.

I'd focus first on making sure the bench is absolutely functional. You can always find a way to integrate drawers or storage later, if you choose to.