Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

Posts

Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#1

Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Rob,

Among the saws pictured on the September 2009 LV drool book is, top left, a handsaw with what appears to be a teardrop-shaped hole into which your art director has cleverly placed a padsaw just the right size.

Assuming that's not a piece of black paper on the handsaw, what was the purpose of that hole? Surely it wasn't to set a padsaw in it for compact toolbox storage. Did the maker envision some reduction in friction or something?

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#2

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

Jim Shaver - L6H 6Y0, Canada

>I think the one with the tear drop opening is a pruning saw.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#3

How does the opening help with pruning?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#4

Would you believe....

Rob Lee

>.... a hang hole for even the largest screw head you can imagine???? :) :)

Actually - don't have clue on that one, but I'd suspect it was to reduce friction. What it would really do though, it cause the edges of the opening to score/burnish the edge of the kerf - unles the blade ran perfectly true... any amount of flex, and the edge could catch...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#5

reasonable guess

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It was probably a marketing idea from a tool company of the day to differentiate their product from others. Didn't matter that it was a flawed idea because the customers that are susceptible to these sorts of marketing ideas would not saw much with it anyway.

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#6

Re: Would you believe.... *LINK*

Joshua Clark

>That would be Richardson's patent Timber Saw. It's an incredibly rare handsaw. The teardrop shaped hole was intended to prevent the saw from binding, heating, and buckling during heavy work. This feature was awarded patent #315,663. Here's an ad from 1886 that shows this saw and describes its uses.

Awesome saw!

Josh


Richardson Saw Advertisment

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#7

Re: Would you believe....

Rob Lee

>Thanks Josh!

You just saved me a trip to the collection, and a some time searching out the patent! I just don't have the memory for associating patents and names that others do...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#8

As always, light on the darkness

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I thought maybe it was to provide an easy place to lash on the blade protector - but I note there's a nib, so such a use would have been redundant.

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#9

Re: Would you believe....

Alex Grigoriev

>I guess it's the same job that cutouts in circular blades do.

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#10

except

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>circular saws move at a slightly greater clip than most handsawyers I've watched; and, as Rob Lee points out, the shape seems designed to get caught on the wood - I can feel the jolt to my arm when that hole hits the arris or a big splinter.

I am reminded of what I understood to be a Yogi Berra line: �In theory there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice there is.�

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#11

Re: except

Alex Grigoriev

>My next guess is that the cutout makes the plate less rigid, so it can move easier in a crooked kerf.

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#12

Richardson's claims *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Christopher Richardson's patent of 1885 (referenced above by Josh Clark) makes a number of claims. See link below to his filing. He claims the cutout makes the saw run more freely in the kerf, and therefore averts having the saw bind in the cut, and also that it is like a large gullet in helping clear the waste. He then asserts this allows the saw to run with less set.

He makes two interesting claims with respect to manufacturing. Specifically, that the saw plate is easier to forge (and emerges straighter), and that it requires lighter hammer blows to smith it to straightness.

He didn't say anything about how the cutout would tend to catch the side of the kerf.....

Wiley


Christopher Richardson's 1885 patent filing

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#13

Re: Would you believe....

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>You wouldn't want to use your thumb as a guide for starting a cut with this saw*. While it is improbable you can cut off a finger or thumb with a hand saw, that hole looks like it could lop off a thumb easily.

Stephen

*that is what the nib is for.

Re: Catalog cover question for Rob Lee

#14

What catalog??

Dean Lapinel

>All this talk has me checking the mailbox daily...no catalog yet!