We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>"SO, the question is, what other hand tools do you need? I am not giving up power, just seeing what the hands on power free stuff can do better."
Hello Bob,
First off, that's a fine plane you bought. It will bring much pleasure.
In answer to your question above, you might think about what you want to do with hand tools, rather than the tools themselves. For example, how do you do dovetails at present? Jig + router? If you're happy with that, then scratch dovetails off the list. But if you want to do them by hand, then there are some tools you will need.
However, even before you get to that point, there is some gateway equipment you will need, if you don't already have it. For example, sharpening. Are you set up for that? Secondly, a bench to plane on--will you be needing one, or are you set?
Back to the tool question.... getting good with scrapers, like card scrapers, is a very useful skill. Especially for finishing. Do you have files? They are great to have, including half round, for preparing small details for finishing, where you don't want to round them off with sandpaper. You need a file for your scrapers too. Files are good for doing the final fitting of pin ends on drawer dovetails for example. Or any other visible end grain.
Getting things to fit is a big category where hand tool skills can help you. You mentioned chisels--they're good for fitting stuff. Like tenon cheeks. Or slightly undercutting tenon shoulders to make them airtight.
>Build something and you will soon discover what you need for the style of building you choose and what you choose to build with this style. If you never make a corner round by hand you will not need a spoke shave, for example. If you install a hinge you will find a chisel essential. I would think that a set of chisels would be a must for any style of building or even house maintenance.
I would not recommend to pre-buy, hoping I might need something. The plane is an example. Way more than than the tool holder(plane body), the too(plane blade) is what is important in a plane. What you found desirable about the LN plane was likely the fact that its blade was sharp. An old Stanley with a properly sharpened blade would most likely have met your needs for some time.
BTW, I did something similar to what you did. When I was new to hand tools I bought a LN #4 and now I never use it. An ancient Stanley #5 is my "go to" plane for most of the planing I do.
Which reminds me, your success with hand tools will to a great degree be determined by your success in sharpening them. If at all possible find someone to teach you how to sharpen. If there is a club near by join it and find a mentor.
>My work is pretty obscure and specialized so feel free to "never mind" but . . . I've caught myself collecting saws. Not for the sake of collecting but they all do specific tricks or gags. Antique, off the shelf or "shop-modified". I don't have them for the sake of " the hand tool does it better than power " but, well, ah, they do it better than power.
My recommendation, if you're really itching to spend money, buy the first book by David Charlesworth. It contains an incredibly detailed and thorough article on rehabbing and tuning up old planes.
Next thing to look into is tools to sharpen your plane. (stones, typically)
L-N blades come acceptably sharp from the factory, and they work acceptably well. But they can be made to be much sharper.
At this point, most of my go-to planes are old stanleys, with Hock replacement blades. I do own Lie-Nielsen, too... but I tend to buy tools from them that I couldn't find elsewhere... like high angle smoothers, a (relatively) affordable low-angle jack plane, rabbet block, (now replaced by my old stanley 10 1/2) and the like.
The slippery part of your slope is this: the urge is definitely there to be a tool collector. There are a lot of very shiny, very high end tools out there. And if you want a comprehensive list, I suggest you root through Christopher Schwartz' blog archives. I like his blog, but tool porn runs rampant over there.
The advice to work first, and buy as you need, is very good advice. I'm not saying that tool collecting is inherently a bad thing, just that it should be secondary to your woodworking. I think a pristinely planed piece of wood is still vastly inferior to a fully completed piece of furniture that was surfaced with a random orbit sander. (Even if it was surfaced with a Festool random orbit sander.)
Aside from the info you've already received here's a short list (by no means all inclusive) of things you'll need to start off well in the hand tool world.
90 and 45 degree squares
Bevel gauge
Marking Knife
6 and 12" ruler
LA Block Plane
Bench Chisels
Sharpening Apparatus: (freehand is better, but a jig will get you started faster)
Western Back Saws (rip and CC) or Japanese saws
Mallet
card scraper(s)
There are an endless selection of other tools that you may or may not need, but these should get you well started on the journey to financial ruin :).
>1. Sharpening stuff (whatever method you prefer, just pick one and learn how to do it well)
2. Learn to sharpen well.
3. Did I mention sharpening?
The above is somewhat tongue in cheek, but learning to sharpen well and what truly sharp really means can do more for success with hand tools than any other skill or tool. A piece of junk tool that is sharp can outperform a nice tool that is dull most any time.
Otherwise, I would look for a set of chisels which can always be used, then buy tools as you need them for various projects. Let your work drive the tool selection. (unless of course, you have an unlimited tool budget, then I could be open to be adopted and we could buy stuff together ;-))
>There seem to be power and non power solutions out there. I sharpened an old plane blade up with wet/dry sandpaper glued to a thick (1/2") granite tile and then touched it up with a 1000 grit water stone. It has a nice edge, but I think I still need better, it barely shaved my arm.
So, 2 questions:
1) Power (Tormek, etc) or Hand (Scary sharp, etc) or (shudder) send them away? (I do this with my 10" power saw blades and Router bits)
2) Books, techiques, links, training, whatever for the technique you are a proponent of.
Thanks again, I love this forum. I have been gone for years, but I am back.
>Sorry, the budget is capped below the adoption level. I asked the wife about a nice set of Japanese Chisels at $1500 today and was told firmly that it was NOT in the budget, but a few individual ones at $30-40 each we doable if I had projects to use them on.
Sharpening gear has a larger budget as I see it as saftey spending.
>There are lots of solutions; this is a slippery slope all its own.
Search on "sharpening" here, and you'll find a lot of threads; go to your local library and get out hand tools books, and you'll find a lot of contradictory opinions. Then you have to make your best guess about what will work for you.
In the end, I suspect the system chosen is less critical than frequent practice and acquired skills, both in the act of sharpening and in the critical judgment needed to know what sharp feels like.
>I urge you to consider Bill Tindall's thoughtful and pragmatic method. While my sharpening technique is similar (we both like 7" grinders, for example), mine evolved from gem faceting and polishing. Bill's informed approach is all about tool steels for woodworking: no-nonsense, straightforward and fast. These two posts are a good place to start.
>Oddly enough, I get to reference Schwartz twice under one post.
The basics are all very simple. And there was a blog post by Schwartz recently about teaching his young daughter to sharpen. Apparently she picked it up very easily. Moral of the story is that there are more than enough old-timers to fill your ears with hard-earned, time tested, worked good enough for me, and don't listen to that feller over there type nonsense. At the heart of it, sharpening does take skill. But it's not rocket science, or witch doctor voodoo. An 8 year old can do it. But time and practice will make anyone better.
There are a lot of varying opinions on media, technique, etc. I've tried natural and manmade oil stones. Three types of manmade water stones, and some natural water stones. And a manmade stone made of bonded natural grit. And diamond paste. And so on. The basics all remain the same. Start rough, find a way to accurately hone at a repeatable angle, and work your way to an acceptably fine grit.
1000 grit is a pretty coarse stone. There are rougher ones out there. But that's a first-step stone. 6000 or 8000 is a finishing stone, and you'll probably want something in between, though there are some who think that you can go right from 1000 to 8000 on the Norton stones. On the L-N, they may be right, and there is a 1K/8K combination stone available.
Tormek is a very viable method as a standalone, or as a way to safely hollow-grind your tools without cooking them. It's pricey, and there's a slight learning curve. But it is a very good way to get the job done.
Another method that's more cost-effective is scary sharp with a Veritas MK II honing jig.
If you want to spend money, you can go hog wild with the options available to you. And if you want to get supremely anal, again, sharpening is your ticket to a serious detour away from productivity for a while. I recommend that you don't. At most, I'd go with two different options, just so you have the eye opening experience of going back to your first method one day and realizing that really, it's the time and the practice, not the method or media that makes the difference. Sharpen to the best of your ability. Don't go crazy. Then use the tool till it dulls, and sharpen it again. As your sharpening gets better, so will your tools hold up longer. Some steels hold up better than others, but a good sharpening job with an appropriate bevel angle will last long enough to do a good job in almost any decent blade steel.
>I recommend you start with plain old Marples Blue chip chisels.
Stick with me, there's a method here...
Marples (Irwin, now) are made with good enough steel. I know guys who made it all the way through North Bennet Street School using nothing else, and did fantastic work. And, honestly, the shape and balance of these tools is really not too bad.
They are softer. This means they get dull faster, which means you'll spend more time sharpening. This is a very important thing, because it's such a critical skill. It also means you'll learn more about the results of your sharpening early on. With a long-wearing chisel made of Japanese steel, or some other premium steel, it'll be a while before you have to sharpen again. With a softer Marples, you may have to sharpen 3 times in a day, while chopping dovetails. That's a lot of experience in a very short time... and that's exactly what you need early on: Experience.
For the money, they're unbeatable. In no way are they on par with a $1500 set of Japanese chisels. BUT, and this is a really important but...
IF you don't know how to sharpen, those $1500 Japanese chisels will do you no good. And if you only know how to sharpen poorly, they're actually more likely to get damaged along the way, as they start to chip.
Once you're good with the sharpening bit, you can more easily justify a few of those really nice Japanese chisels: They hold an edge for much longer. So you'll get to spend more time working, and less time sharpening. When you get there, come back in here for advice. The last thing you really want is a normal set. Different sizes are really good for different things, and with Japanese chisels, you also get the option of different shapes. One thing at a time though.
Lastly... as you get better at woodworking, 2 things will happen. One, people will ask you to do day to day stuff for them, like mortising out a hinge in a painted fence. And two, they'll ask, on occasion, to borrow tools, knowing that you have them. If you're lucky, they'll ask before taking the tool. (Unlike my neighbor, who stripped all the teeth off of my el cheapo Japanese saw, trying to cut a box spring in half.) I have no qualms about lending out a Marples chisel, because even if they really destroy it, they're not hard to sharpen or replace.
>Folks get kind of oral/anal retentive when it comes to sharpening - and folks have come up with all kinds of devices for sharpening - many making money off those ideas. And Leonard Lee devoted a considerable amount of time writing a very extensive book on the subject of sharpening - ANYTHING that needs to be sharp.
Tage Frid was a very well known and very talented woodworker, teacher and author. In addition to cutting the most amazing joinery with a HUGE bow saw, he sharpened his bench chisels on an upside down belt sander - with 80 grit paper on it. Motor screaming, sparks flying - and he'd create an edge he used to cut perfect dovetails, blind or through, m & t, etc.. I'm usre this wasn't his sharpening method for plane irons - at least not for smoothers - but . . .
Once you get passed Close Enough To Do The Job, the rest is probably just for entertainment purposes.