We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I recently finished resawing about 9 feet of 5" wide walnut. It was a fairly unpleasant experience. I'll be doing more of it in the future since a bandsaw is not an option due to location, noise and stubborness.
I was using a frame saw I made using a piece of 1/2" 3tpi bandsaw blade. It cut pretty quickly but the frustrating part was keeping the cut straight. Should I try a wider or narrower blade, or a standard rip saw?
I've been thinking about making a tool similar to a router plane to cut a narrow (roughly 1/16") groove about 1/2" deep the length of the board. The groove would act as a guide for the saw blade for better tracking. Any thoughts on all this?
>Most people would use a wider blade, like 1 to 3 inches, which tends to keep you straight once you are on track. I am sure you can do better with your present blade, however. Some people saw down only one side at a time so they don't have to watch the line on the far side. This is helpful for a beginner, but an experienced person can get a nicer cut by going straight across, both sides evenly.
I think the hardest thing to learn is to make adjustments to the cut very gradually. If you are 1/16 off, think about correcting it over the next 4 inches, not the next 1/4 inch. This is hard to explain, but if you lean the saw too far to one side, the blade tends to wander in the opposite direction inside the board. It is like a complex wave with two nodes. If you put a straightedge across the board and it is hollow or humped, you are probably leaning too hard. Of course if it always wanders to the same side the saw might be the problem. I think most people would have trouble believing how little pressure to one side will gradually correct the course of the saw.
As pointed out a wider blade would help. Another possibility is that the blade is not taut enough. But most of the problems of a saw cutting to one side is the fact that the blade is not properly whet on the sides. Try running a whet stone or file from the heel to the tow of the saw, equally on both sides of the blade.
Use a standard rip saw. Make sure it is sharp and the teeth are set evenly on both sides of the blade.
If the saw wanders either way, the saw is either dull or it's the operator. If the saw wanders to the same side all the time, you might be able to correct it by jointing the teeth on the side that the saw wanders.
A sharp saw will wander off the line if the teeth are not set evenly or if the teeth are not filed evenly.
The saw you made will cut just fine if it is sharp and properly set and if you have it tensioned about the same as it would be on a bandsaw. But keep in mind, on a bandsaw, you have blade guides just above and below the wood. With the frame saw you made, you don't have guides.
You didn't say how thick the board is. Is it 5" wide or 5" thick?
In the old days, when a thick beam was ripped, they marked on both sides of the beam. They sawed a short distance on one side then flipped the beam over and sawed a little on that side, and so on and so on.
>Location is a pretty good reason not to use a bandsaw.
Noise isn't. Bandsaws are one of the quietest power tools out there.
Stubbornness is a lousy reason, too. Stubborn-ness is the side of the argument that insists you're doing it right, despite the evidence in front of you. Stubbornness will keep you working against yourself despite reason and logic. It will also keep you doing the work, but there's a fine line between good stubborn and bad stubborn. Check that stuff at the door. At the end of the day, it's the finished piece that matters, and your own personal quirkiness is not something you want getting in your way. Decisions made out of stubbornness are the only thing you'll regret later. I've ended up losing SO much waste in the wake of a stubborn decision that in the end, the stubborn voice is one I have to listen for all the time... as much as I have to listen for that little voice that tells me when enough is enough. There is no such thing as cheating in woodworking, so there's no need to be stubborn.
I don't know if you mean a 9 foot board, or several pieces, totaling 9 feet.
I can say that the kerf down each side is a good idea. But the saw can still wander through the wood due to tooth issues, (set, grind, etc), operator issues, if you're using a frame saw, maybe the weight of the frame to one side is causing it. Or, differences in the density of the grain could be giving you hassles.
Back in school, a friend of mine built a custom frame saw to resaw an enormous 3" thick plank of mahogany, that was almost 3' wide. He used some very wide scrap bandsaw blade to tackle it. He did run tablesaw kerfs around the edges to help with guidance, and to lessen the amount of wood needing to be cut. But even still, the blade curved through the material. Picture the vertical blade turning slightly right, and arcing around the center of the board, coming gradually back to rejoin the frame on the other side of the plank. Added more friction (more work) and doubtless made the cutting slower, too. But we weren't able to tell what was going on, becuase it was in the middle of that enormous board. Maybe that was a tooth issue, maybe it was a wood issue, we never figured it out. But he sawed from each end, the kerfs met on the edges of the wood, but because of the way the saw was working, and how the kerf was curved, there was still a 15" wide section in the middle that was still joined.
A router plane can make that groove for you. So can a well-aimed circular saw. I do have a real respect for the craftsmen who are able to do the things they do using only hand tools. But at the end of the day, a real craftsman makes the best use of all the tools available to him at the time.
>I was using a frame saw I made using a piece of 1/2" 3tpi bandsaw blade. It cut pretty quickly but the frustrating part was keeping the cut straight. Should I try a wider or narrower blade, or a standard rip saw?
Unless that blade is very taught, amd I mean very taught, it would be impossible to cut in a straight line. Very similar to metal hacksaw frame. Most are impossible to acheived a high enough tension on the blade and they wander all over.
I do not know how you tension your bandsaw blade on your shopmade frame, but i suspect the tension is nowhere near enough
>Thanks for the responses everyone. I'll try your suggestions. After the sawing I'm having to plane all the wood flat with innapropriate/subpar planes, so every little bit at the sawing stage helps. Of course, as budget allows I'm upgrading the planes and will try a good rip saw.
>I've seen some very run-down looking planes do a fine job.
On the other hand, there are some out there that really are just lousy.
If you're working with something with a reputation that is only tarnished by a lack of bronze and fancy hardware, I think you'll find you're probably working with something that will do just fine.
There are a lot of really trashed out tools out there. It's important to remember that someone, somewhere, was able to use them right up to the point where they were in the condition that they're found today. I've seen, and own, wooden planes that were simply astonishing, for no other reason than that it was clear that they were well worn, well used, and yet were clearly in regular service for a while.
Last thing I think is worth passing on... It's really important sometimes to remember that it's not really important to have every shaving, every pass of the plane be smooth and free of defect. The most important one, really, is the last one. Even if every swipe you take is so clear that you can see yourself reflected in the freshly exposed surface, it's all rough shaping until the final surface is exposed. And how you do that shaping isn't really critical, as long as you don't do irreparable harm.
I've got a Home Depot Stanley #4 and an old Stanley #5 1/4. The blade on the #5 1/4 is so badly pitted it's hard to sharpen it properly. A replacement blade is on the "to do list". I have them both tuned up to the best of my ability and they both do a reasonably good job.
I won't blame poor workmanship on poor tools (if anything it's operator error in my case), but I also know the difference the right tool can make. With what I've got I'm able to get a decent final product, but can't help thinking it would go a bit quicker and easier with more suitable planes.
I've got a Home Depot Stanley #4 and an old Stanley #5 1/4. The blade on the #5 1/4 is so badly pitted it's hard to sharpen it properly. A replacement blade is on the "to do list". I have them both tuned up to the best of my ability and they both do a reasonably good job.
I won't blame poor workmanship on poor tools (if anything it's operator error in my case), but I also know the difference the right tool can make. With what I've got I'm able to get a decent final product, but can't help thinking it would go a bit quicker and easier with more suitable planes.
>The 5-1/4 is a nice size of tool. You can get replacement irons from a number of sources; I like my Lee Valley irons, one of which would run you $36-38 plus shipping (unless you wait for one of Lee Valley's periodic free shipping times).
>your saw's brace may be too short to properly tension the blade. I find that if the distance between the arms slightly longer at the stretcher than at the blade a frame saw works much better. This compensates for crushing of the wood fibers while the saw is under tension. The arms pivot on the ends of the stretcher as tension is applied. Maximum useful tension is reached when the arms are perpendicular to the stretcher. If even more pressure is applied the blade can be forced into a arc and will wander more. This might be due to the back of the blade being under compression while the teeth are under tension.
>A good blade is the heart of a hand plane. I'd start there. The rest of the plane serves only to do one thing: hold the blade. If you're already getting pretty decent results with what you have, an upgrade in the working end of the tool will go a long way, believe me.
AND, a good aftermarket blade will run you a lot less than a high end plane. That'll save you enough dough to help you buy more nice tools...