Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>

Yes, folks, it's time for yet another taking of the collective pulse of the WoodCentral community. This time, for the second time this year, it's a bittersweet question, bitter because another giant has fallen, sweet because of the undying legacy he has left.

I'm talking, of course, about James Krenov, and this time around I'd like to solicit your thoughts on the man and how he may have influenced your woodworking -- your sensibilities, your style, your philosophy, your choice of tools and equipment, your techniques, your motivations, your outlook. I can think of many ways JK's life and work affected me and mine. Let's hear what you have to say by way of remembrances of this man.

As usual, we will harvest your posts, edit them to their essence and send them off to Woodworker West magazine for inclusion in their next issue, due out in November. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host




Woodworker West

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#2

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER ***

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>I was fortunate to attend "A Weekend With Jim" at College of the Redwoods several years ago. This was a few years before I took early retirement and my plan was to apply for admission to the woodworking program upon retirement. By the time I was finally able to leave my job Jim had announced his own retirement, so I abandoned my plan because I didn't want to use up a space in the program that would better serve a younger woodworker - had Jim continued on I would have, selfishly, applied for acceptance.

After that weekend I corresponded with Jim (via email) infrequently (maybe once or twice a year) until about a year ago. I have saved and printed the emails he sent me and keep them with his books.

Having been trained in cabinet and furniture making from a very early age by my grandfather, Jim's sometimes stern approach to instruction resonated strongly with my early experiences working with my granddad. Some of my stongest memories of my grandfather's teaching are absolute respect for the tools and materials. I once hit a screwdriver with a hammer in granddad's presence and he walked up behind me an rapped me on top of my head with his knuckles and asked me "... how do you like being hit on the head?". I have a strong hunch that Jim would have reacted in a similar fashion.

I am very saddened by Jim's passing - he was one of a very select few who had profound influence on the craft for a great many years.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#3

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER ***

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I was initially attracted by his beautiful slightly curved chests, especially the ones on legs. Then I read one or two of his books, which were OK. The main thing that still sticks out was his attitude toward money and professionalism, affecting me so strongly that I was forced to face my own problems with money. Of course, I thought he was quite hypocritical on this issue; after all, he was making a living woodworking or, if not, had enough money from family to not have to work at all. However, I was also a hypocrite on money issues: Basically, I don't care about money except for the status money confers; and I really care about it every time I have to buy a house or car. So, hypocrisy resolved, I care a little about money. :)

And I love his planes and all they represent about making one's own tools and making do.

Pam

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#4

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER ***

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>James Krenov was the first author I came across who showed why you had to be comfortable with hand tools in order to make something distinctive. Up to that point, I thought what you had to do to make things out of wood was to buy the full laundry list of power tools and Leigh jig and tenoning jig--and that's all you needed. Not that Mr. Krenov was any kind of purist, because he was extremely fond of his power tools; however, he made the case that they were not enough, and he showed why. This was the beginning of a long journey.

I was wrong about Mr. Krenov for a long time. I thought he made whimsical things in a whimsical way. Part of this was because his philosophising seemed to be 'winging it'. Later, I came to find out that he made very, very carefully thought out designs, after much experimentation no doubt--and he made them to an extreme degree of precision. Somehow it never occurred to me (until trying it) that if absolutely every join and seam is exposed, and every molded detail is integral (not applied)--then the work has to be at the 100th percentile, or whatever is just before that. If you make an error on one of his pieces, your eye never leaves it.

The third realization was how many gems of practical wisdom are tossed off with little to-do in his books. Things like using a paring block for dovetails, or using highly thinned shellac for the interior of cases and drawers, or how to fix a small flaw, or how to constantly touch up chisels at the bench so you never have a handful of dull chisels to sharpen. One of the few old-school guys who will tell you the little things that make a big difference [Ian Kirby is another].

It is striking how many of our generation derived a spark from James Krenov. I think he may be seen historically as having invigorated a certain craft movement, in similar manner to the early English arts and crafts workers.

Wiley

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#5

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER ***

David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast

>I learned to see grain, figure, texture and color of wood; actually, individual boards, as design elements, and thoughtful selection of these elements to scale, purpose and placement, and for that matter, thoughtfulness in every woodworking decision. I became more confident in my own design aesthetic and approach to craft, and more pragmatic in my selection and use of tools. I learned to more artfully weave process with product, and I learned to love pear and apricot and how some woods age so gracefully and to favor finishes that look like no finish at all. And Krenov awoke me to the joys of freely enhancing my work with subtle details through simple means.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#6

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER ***

GregB

>JK was a gem of many facets.

As with many, my first exposure was seeing photos of his work, as well as that of his students. From these, one could appreciate composition, style and proportions. And maybe a little of the details which suggested the twinkle in his eye.

I read his books and, as with many, became inspired. But it was actually seeing and touching his work which was the revelation. This allowed a more full glimpse of his craftsmanship. It was a glimpse into another, previously unknown, dimension.

Next came a chance meeting at a Ft. Bragg coffee shop. We spoke a little. I thanked him and he walked away. Then he turned and said, "Enthusiasm is contagious!" I was in such agreement, that I could barely reply. He then invited me up to the school's shops and the rest of the afternoon was among my most memorable. His students were terrific, both in talent and humanity. Reflections of the man.

JK was a national treasure. His greatest gift is his legacy, in his insight, his body of work and his philosophy towards the craft. "With Wakened Hands": understand why he wanted it published.

God speed, JK. Add my voice to the thanks of so many.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF SEPTEMBER *** *LINK*

#7

Beauty

roninkokomo

>Once you read his work, you never looked at a piece of furniture the same way again. He was very much about composing a picture with the wood used in a project.

I remember taking a class at Marc Adams school and the instructor said that a lot of amateur woodworkers and some professionals are making furniture that will last 500 years that is really ugly. He was referring mainly to the ways that wood grain was used.

Krenov made us look at the wood very carefully and sometimes make some hard decisions about what do do with it.