Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The Making of a Steinway

Posts

The Making of a Steinway

#1

The Making of a Steinway

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hope a few of you remember the great series in the NY Times about making a Steinway. Well, tonight, PBS is showing "Note by Note (The Making of Steinway L1037)." Should be a great woodworking show.

Pam

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#2

I saw it; it fell short of my hopeful expectations

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Talk about a bent lamination!

As is usually the case with these things the person producing it was clueless as to what they were filming and a hundred of my questions remained unanswered. They always make the assumption that the audience will mostly be interested in the people story and not the technical story. I wish they had indeed spent the hour telling how the instrument was made and not spent 45 min on people playing it. Typical touchy-feely NPR.

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#3

Re: I saw it; it fell short of my hopeful expectat

Hank Knight

>I saw this film a year or so ago. It was shown as a fund raiser for a local arts group. The best part was that the piano that is the subject of the film toured with the film and was played by the pianist from the local philharmonic orchestra after the film was over. It was a nice touch. Bill is correct; it is a little "touchy feely," but it's aimed at a "touchy feely" crowd. I didn't go thinking it was going to be a "how to build a Steinway" film, so I wasn't disappointed at all. On the contrary, I enjoyed it a lot.

Hank

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#4

Re: I saw it; it fell short of my hopeful expectat

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If most of this program had been true to its title, "The Making of Steinway L1037", I would not have been disappointed. In fact most of the program had nothing to do with making the piano.

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#5

Re: I saw it; it fell short of my hopeful expectat

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, short of mine, too, sort of, was hoping for more woodworking; but I'd read the series of 12 articles in the paper, so knew not to expect heavy expert content. I enjoyed seeing parts of the process and hearing from so many who were involved. I also learned some stuff from the pianists who were looking for specific attributes, like the one with the incredible sustain. So I rate it a half full. :)

Pam

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#6

PS

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I also hope that a more detailed series of films could follow, an expansion of several parts.

Pam

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#7

"key stock"

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There used to be a lumber grade of basswood called "key stock". (light goes on above head) This grade must have been for piano keys. It had to be all sapwood.

The action pieces were clearly maple. There was another grade called "piano action stock. The lever pieces between the keys and bonker things were clearly maple, so I presume this stock was for these pieces. It had to be very straight grained.

I bet they pay plenty for the lumber that was used for the laminated sides.

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#8

Re: "key stock" *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Interesting, Bill, adds a lot.

BTW, I forgot to provide a link to the NYTimes series, turns out to have been nine, not twelve, articles; so here it is. IIRC, they discuss the sourcing for Steinway's lumber in one of the articles.

Pam


NY Times series

Re: The Making of a Steinway

#9

thanks, I enjoyed the articles' more detail

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>