Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Two Cherries Chisels

Posts

Two Cherries Chisels

#1

Two Cherries Chisels

Jerry Draper

>Recently purchased a set of Two Cherries chisels. Great for paring but when I try to chop waste out of dovetails the edges chip and distort. Is this normal? Are they only for paring? What should I get for chopping dovetails?

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#2

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have a set of Hirsch that is pretty much the same as the Two Cherries and mine work fine for chopping dovetails. Did a set last week.

Before you give up on them, check the bevel angle. Mine are set at pretty close to 30 degrees, 25 might be a bit acute for whacking.

OTOH, if you're just looking for a reason to get a different set of chisels, then the sky is the limit.

Bruce

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#3

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

Jerry Draper

>Thanks Bruce. My chisels are beveled at 25 degrees. I'll try 30.

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#4

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

James Watriss

>Hi Jerry,

Several things:

-I picked up a set of Swiss Made/Pfeil chisels a few years ago. They come from about the same part of the world, I think, and I've heard similar reviews regarding the two brands. In my experience with the Swiss, the chisels were very well polished when I received them. And the advice I was given then is what I'm about to give to you now... The buffing process sometimes heats the steel up a little bit. It's not uncommon with many steel edge tools to find the best steel a little ways into the tool. Re-grind, re-sharpen, and you should find the steel gets a little better as you go.

-The steel is pretty good, but you do need to have an eye to bevel angles. I don't know what you were chopping into, but for most typical hardwoods, I think you're going to find that something closer to 30 will work better. With Oak, you'll probably want something steeper than that.

-For myself, I use an angle somewhere around 25-28 degrees for paring. It makes for a pretty decent cutting action when you're working with or close to the direction of the grain of the wood. But chopping is a much different action. There's usually impact involved, and you're not shearing fibers on a bias, you're coming in at roughly 90 degrees, and the cutting action is a lot tougher. I usually use a steeper bevel for that. I also typically use mid-size chisels.

I found as I was learning early on that I used 1/8"-1/4" chisels for paring joinery... getting between dovetails, etc. 3/8 or 1/2" for chopping. 3/4 or 1" was for paring and general contour shaping. Once I'd figured that out, my life got a lot easier, because I was able to grind each size range at an appropriate angle to the task I was bound to use it for. Stropping on soft material was reserved mainly for chopping tools, becuase it will blunt the angle slightly, which actually makes for a stronger tip, as I learned when I was working on a DT'd project using quarter-sawn white oak. Paring chisels I strop on something harder like planed maple, or MDF.

For some folks, chisels are chisels, and you work with whichever is the sharpest in the drawer. But I think you'll learn a lot if you start experimenting with higher angles.

My .02... hope it helps.

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#5

I have some

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The steel in these is better than most as far as toughness goes. But as others have said 25 degrees is too small a bevel to hold up to whacking with this steel. Just keep increasing the angle until the edge survives what ever wood you are chopping.

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#6

wandering a bit off topic...bevel angles

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"I found as I was learning early on that I used 1/8"-1/4" chisels for paring joinery... getting between dovetails, etc. 3/8 or 1/2" for chopping. 3/4 or 1" was for paring and general contour shaping."

I've read another reference to this distinction by size; it's good to see you confirming its usefulness.

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#7

Re: Thanks to all. I learned a lot.

Jerry Draper

>

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#8

Welcome to the club!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I think we've been through this at one time or another. Mine was with Marples blue chip chisels, hence the term "blue chip". You have the right advise they will come around to good working chisels. You can get your hands around them eh?

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#9

Thanks James. I learned something new this AM.

Victor P

>

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#10

Ellis Walentine

Another possibility for you....

Ellis Walentine

>I have had similar problems with new Japanese chisels in the past. I asked Toshio Odate about it once and he told me he pounds the chisel into face-grain oak. The steel at the edge is so thin that it gets heated and softened slightly by the energy of the hammer strike and the friction it generates at the wood, thereby lowering the temper a bit and making it less brittle, regardless of the bevel angle. It worked for me.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#11

Ellis Walentine

And more from Toshio

Ellis Walentine

>As usual, Toshio has corrected me on the above advice. Based on our phone conversation today, his technique begins with "feathering" the bevel, which is akin to saying round the bevel slightly with a light uptick on the final few passes on your finishing stone. Then, do the pounding trick. Repeated use and sharpenings will also soften the steel somewhat, so over time your chisels should settle into the hardness range you want.

All of this can be found in his classic book, Japanese Woodworking Tools: Their Tradition, Spirit and Use.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#12

Instresting...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>The last time I was at Hida tool in bezerkly. The daughter of the owner, sorry his name escapes now. Told me that all Japanese chisels are better about a 1/3 to 1/2 down the chisel. So use and sharpen them...

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#13

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

Jim Shaver - L6H 6Y0, Canada

>Hi James,

I had the same issue with the buffing on my Two Cherries, I was also never able to get the backs flat, it was so much effort , I sold them.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Two Cherries Chisels

#14

tools for working wood

Dan Donaldson

>Joel has or at least had, two cherries chisels without the back buffed. They were flatter and also a bit cheaper.