Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Krenov's passing

Posts

Krenov's passing

#1

Ellis Walentine

Krenov's passing

Ellis Walentine

>This from my friend David Welter....

James Krenov is at last at rest, having left this life with a piece of wood in his hand, at 7 pm on September 9.

Funeral services will be private. His ashes will be spread at the ocean, likely along the route of his daily walk.

The family asks that those wishing to make contributions in Jim's memory do so The James Krenov Scholarship Fund care of the College of the Redwoods.

Ellis

Re: Krenov's passing

#2

A sad passing.

Hank Knight

>But he lived a great life.

Re: Krenov's passing

#3

the messenger

David Brown

>Ellis,

Thank you for keeping us updated and being the bearer of such poignant news. JK meant many things to many woodworkers. He will be missed but each of us has fond memories of what he meant to us. Keeping his zen-like methods of work alive and sharing them with others is the best way I can think of to honor him.

regards,

David

Re: Krenov's passing

#4

Re: Krenov's passing

wilbur

>That's very sad, but the fact remains that this is a better world due to his work, and that is something that should be celebrated.

Re: Krenov's passing

#5

I will remember him always

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>

Re: Krenov's passing

#6

Re: Krenov's passing

Thomd

>Sad news. His books led me into cabinetmaking. I was building a canoe around '79, and having some trouble and was at a local bookstore, and found one of his books. Wasn't really specifically relevant to my project at the time, but was inspirational.

Re: Krenov's passing

#7

R.I.P. Mr Krenov

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Your contribution to woodworking was amazing. Your work, in my eyes, took the complicated and made it simple.

Re: Krenov's passing

#8

I had the opposit experience

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your work, in my eyes, took the complicated and made it simple.

Shaker is simple, and simple to build. Krenov pieces can appear simple but I didn't find them simple to build.

When I began building a wall cabinet similar to one of his I saw in a book I soon discovered that this "simple" cabinet became one of the most difficult pieces I ever attempted. In building it I came to realize and appreciate what an accomplished engineer Krenov was. His solutions to assembly problems resulting from his designs are elegant. And his designs do lead to assembly problems not found in traditional furniture.

I have been pestering David Finck to write another book that would describe in detail the construction techniques Krenov developed/used. So far, no luck.

Re: Krenov's passing

#9

Re: I had the opposit experience

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Hi Bill,

Perhaps I over simplified my posting. I started woodworking in the early 70's. At the time there wasn't much that I could find in print here in Montreal on the subject. My main reference material was the occasional article in Popular Mechanics and a pocket book format book that I have since lost. A few years later I came across one of Mr. Krenov's books at a small book store. It was the first book, or for that matter magazine, I had ever read on real woodworking. So many things became evident to me that I had not even realized prior to that. I think the main thing that I took from that book was the fact that wood is not a stable or static medium. It is a live and fluid thing that will do as it sees fit and all you can do to try and tame it is to try to form or use it in a way that it will accept.

So to me, his book was a revelation. He made the complicated simple. After reading that, I had a better idea of what I needed to accomplish in order to make a piece that would be more than a couple of boards thrown together. In no way do I think his work was simple. If I ever was lucky enough to put anything together in a way that I thought was even close to what he did, I'd stop right there, knowing that I'd never be able to match it, never mind beat it.

Re: Krenov's passing

#10

In memoriam ...  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Ellis

Once again thank you for taking on the job of messenger of sad tidings. Even though your earlier message prepared the way, there is no doubt in my mind that we are all the sadder for the news that Jim has passed, and the end of another era has come.

My heart is with the Krenov family.

I thought that it would be appropriate if (those in a position to do so) might post a picture or two of something inspired by James (Jim) Krenov. That would be a fitting statement.

I have not made any of the classic Krenov cabinets ... yet. They are there on The List. However I have made a couple of sofa tables, the one below is described in more detail in the review I wrote of the smoother that Jim sent to me (link below).



Regards from Perth

Derek


Krenov Smoother Review

Re: Krenov's passing

#11

What a wonderful life he had...

Alan DuBoff

>I see a lot of folks saying how sad it is to see Krenov pass, but honestly, the man lived a wonderful life, and appeared to have a wonderful wife that was with him and by his side most of life, not just in the end.

To have such an impact on people far and wide, and not for a single generation, but many more to come! Honestly a man can't ask for much more than that!

It was obviously getting hard for him to get along in the later years, heck, he was 89 years young, but that's a few years for many folks.

I think his life was a fantastic journey from the old country to the new, marking his place on earth for all to not only see, but to observe and imitate. Imitation is the most flattering compliment anyone can pay tribute to a craftsman, and there are many, many folks who copy his work tit-for-tat...

I will be first to admit that I don't like all of his work, maybe I'll have tomatoes thrown at me for saying that...but what I do admire about him was that he wasn't afraid to follow his heart, and we don't see that too much anymore. To understand and feel one's work is something that just can't be put into people. Even Krenov couldn't make artists out of people that didn't have it within themselves, yet even a follower can imitate and produce artistic work. It is the leaders that create that work to begin with, and it is the leaders who are the true artists.

Congrats to you James, you lived a wonderful live, and you were a leader in every sense of the word.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Krenov's passing

#13

I agree Adam...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>No need for tears here. Just a good celebration for a grand woodworker.

I tip my hat to him.

Re: Krenov's passing

#14

Re: Krenov's passing

charlie belden

>Did this back in 2002 but it may be what he's doing now - with a stash of wood that's out of this world.

I'd like to think that his passion for wood can't be stopped by mere death.

Sure would liked to have listened in on what he was thinking as he searched through his wood stash.


img

Re: Krenov's passing

#15

Wonderful!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Charlie,

That photo makes a sensitive contribution to Mr. Krenov's memoria.

Thank you for posting it.

Wiley

Re: Krenov's passing

#16

Here is my inspriation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don' t know of any modern cabinet maker that initiated so many cabinetry ideas that inspired others to copy. I don't have a picture of his "catches" but that is yet another of his elegant inventions that I use for holding doors shut.


img

Re: Krenov's passing

#17

And another.... Wall Cabient

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It was while I was building this cabinet that I discovered what an exceptional cabinetry engineer Krenov was. He needed to be to be able to construct the innovative designs he came up with.

I do hope that one of his students will publish a book describing in detail the innovative construction techniques he developed to make his cabinetry.


img

Re: Krenov's passing

#18

The "Krenov catch"

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Found a PIC of one. Wonderful invention for holding doors shut. I even used it on a Federal wall cabinet.


img

Re: Krenov's passing

#19

Re: Wonderful!

charlie belden

>Wiley:

It's not a photograph but rather a digital image I "painted" in PhotoShop - as if looking over his shoulder and trying to imagine what was going on in Krenov's head as he looked at the timbers he'd picked out which might work for the next piece he'd work on.

It's that interplay between maker and wood, well before a tool touches the wood, before most of the specifics are thought out and all that's left is the doing, that he let us in on - a little bit.

Michalangalo's The David shows that moment when David KNEW he WOULD slay Goliath. What I was trying to convey was that moment, looking at the possibilities, that the maker and the wood know the ultimate outcome.

To do THAT requires not only the knowledge of the woods, but also the skills and abilities learned over decades of playing with both tools and wood, along of course with something extra which all recognize but find difficult to describe - even adequately.

Re: Krenov's passing

#20

Re: In memoriam ... first try *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>This cabinet taught me about Mr. Krenov's designs. My first effort.

Here's what I learned.....It looks easy. But there is a catch. It has to be perfect, or it will not look right. In other words, though the pieces look simple, Mr. Krenov was working within extremely small tolerances. Small tolerances not only in joinery and minimalist ornament, but also wood choices and cuts of wood. For example, my case is too loud for the Krenov style. It looks good in subdued lighting, where it now sits, but just is not right.

One that is right, will be indistinguishable from an original. That's how tight the tolerances are. Look at Bill Tindall's--it meets that test.

I had so much respect for Mr. Krenov before I started this work; I had boundless respect after I finished.

Wiley


Krenov wall cabinet--birch

Re: Krenov's passing

#21

Re: In memoriam ...

Ace Karner

>I didn't do it consciously but I'm sure I was channeling JK when I designed and built this small jewelry chest.


img

Re: Krenov's passing

#22

Cabinet

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I like the chunkiness of that cabinet. It's kind of a like a healthy toddler - sturdy, but with a little baby fat. It looks like something that would make the owner smile every time s/he went to get a piece of jewelry - eager to serve.

Re: Krenov's passing

#23

Re: I had the opposit experience - real answer

ThomD

>I think it depends on perspective. He did simplify some stuff, like making dovetails. Back then a studio piece had to have startling exposed dovetails and Krenov reduced the process to a pretty simple formula. He openly admitted that people, himself included, would often goof the difficult bits and explained how to manufacture with training wheels. He believed in not making things any easier that the piece required, and not any more difficult either. Except he did embrace the odd nuttiness like planes that twisted out of shape like violins...

On the other hand, whether making one of his pieces is easier than Shaker 101... It obviously isn't. Krenov's aspiration is essentially unlimited, whereas the Shakers where more utilitarian. I think the Shakers might say "you know, that thing will (literally) hold a candle". Can someone following the path Krenov took ever be sure he framed the bookmatch the best possible way?

What I like about Krenov is that he was, in his earlier books, the last great amateur. Today amateurs normally don't see themselves at the pinnacle of craft. Pros have taken over with the idea that making a living off something and limiting the time and money you can put into it, and doing the same thing over and over, distinguishes your work beyond what an amateur can achieve.

Re: Krenov's passing

#24

Re: And another.... Wall Cabient

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bill,

I'm glad you told us that's the one you made, because it looks like an original. Just perfect. Is that quartered ash?

Wiley

Re: Krenov's passing

#25

quartered or rift ash

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I had a few logs more or less quartered. It hardly matters on ash as a rift cut looks the same as quartered. The way the logs were sawed yielded mostly rift cuts. The logs were split down the middle, laid on the flat side and sawed through in that orientation. Only the center cut would be "true" quartered, but anything with rings less than 30 degrees is considered quartered now days.

I never saw a Krenov piece made of ash. He seemed stuck on foreign woods, maybe because he was in CA and not near a source. But I think a fine textured ash goes well in his pieces.