Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Replacement iron for a #6?

Posts

Replacement iron for a #6?

#1

Replacement iron for a #6?

Edward in Vancouver

>Picked up a type 11 #6 last week. Pretty sure it's a type 11, the patent dates match. It's in very nice shape--other than the p.o. stamping his name 4 (four) times on the tote and then for good measure, engraving it again with a dremel or such in the jappaning next to the patent dates.

I have a L.V. replacement iron, which is obviously thicker, and I tinkered and farted about with moving the frog to accept it, but never got very far. Any tricks to making it fit?

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#2

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

David Miller from Iowa

>The thicker iron may work if you can still get the lever cap on & the blade advance lever still properly engages the chip breaker holes. The only things you can do are move the frog back or get a thinner blade.

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#3

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

Neal in San Jose

>It sounds like this one will never interest a collector, so I wouldn't hesitate for a minute using a fine file to open the mouth enough to get the thicker blade to fit. Use a square to scribe an accurate line across the bottom of the plane, then file carefully, making sure you keep the front of the mouth parallel to your scribed line. You will improve the performance of this fine old user, and you can't hurt the value much since it doesn't have any collector value now.

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#4

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

Edward in Vancouver

>Thanks for the responses

Uhh, yeah, last resort would be to take a file to the mouth. The plane in question is in very nice shape otherwise, original iron has lots of life in it too.

The only one vocal about #6 seems to be Mr Leach who feels that they should be banned from the face of the earth. Others, including Schwartz and Kirby seem to have respect for it.

I'll fool around some more with the LV repalcement, and when that doesn't work, then I'll use the original blade, but won't file the mouth for a while.

Funny thing is, I could have taken a corrugated #5 of similiar vintage ( can't remember if it was a type 11 or not) for the same price. It was the same owner too--4 (four) name stamps in the tote, and the full name ingraved in the jappaning.

My "stable" currently consists of a #78, a Stanley low angle block, a LV bu smoother, and a LV bu jack. I thought a #6 might compliment the others.

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#5

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I love the No. 6. I often use it as a jack plane, and always find myself saying, "Hulk like this plane."

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#6

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Edward,

Did you say you had already moved the frog back?

I really think Patrick's tongue was wedged solidly in his cheek, in his remarks on the #6 plane. He's a funny guy, as is made clear by the running commentary in his monthly tool list offering--I'm reminded because the September list came out yesterday (dang, why did I buy that Stratton level?).

For whatever it's worth, I think an 18" plane, like a No. 6, is extremely useful. As a short jointer/try plane, or as a fore plane with either cambered blade or toothing blade, or as an all-round bench plane as Bill was saying. My experience is that with case goods, for example, whether it's a lady's sewing table or some huge chest, there is a huge number of sticks that are a coupla feet long give or take, all of which need to be straight in at least one dimension (edge or face).

If moving the frog doesn't work, and you don't want to file the mouth, an alternative is to use an upgrade cap iron with the original blade. The upgrade cap iron will make a positive difference, in my experience.

Wiley

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#7

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

Neal in San Jose

>It's a tool. I know a lot of people feel "funny" about modifying tools, but on the other end of that spectrum are people like me that will modify essentially any tool I own to fit my need. I drilled and tapped holes in my SawStop for a stop for my crosscut slide. I beveled the bottom of a no-name dado plane to turn it into a dovetail plane. I'm sure if I looked around in my shop, I'd find many more examples of tools I've modified to suit my needs. My next-of-kin can worry about it's value; I really don't spend much time worrying about it.

A number 6 isn't like a #1 or #2 that has collector's value just in it's scarcity and yours isn't a pristing example - you mantioned that a previous owner had marked it up pretty badly. Filing the mouth carefully isn't likely to reduce it's value very much, and you will probably turn it into a better performing tool. The nice thing about that particular modification is that is it "reversable" in that if you decide to go back to a thinner blade, the frog will probably move forward enough to close the mouth back up (altho #6 planes typically don't need a very tight mouth, anyway).

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#8

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

Edward in Vancouver

>You're right, I did forget about the "reversible" side of things, and I am certinly not a collector (well....I am a packrat, so I do "collect" in that sense....)

I'll still fiddle and fart with the frog, but if it doesn't work--and I've fidled a good couple of hours already, maybe filing is a logical option. I'd just like to make certain I've exhausted all other options before I file.

Any handplane gurus in the Vancouver area I can consult? I can exchange the fruits of my regular job--artisan chocolates and pastries- for some filing advice/demo.

Regards,

Edward

Re: Replacement iron for a #6?

#9

Re: Mr Leach, and his famous comment------WebKitFo

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco------WebKitFormBou

>I've heard Mr Leach's famous comment. I also use a really nice #6 that I bought from him.

It is alleged that Patrick is sometimes thought to speak with tongue planted firmly in cheek. ;)

------WebKitFormBoundaryobs2q+baeJxGpmCB