Grinding Nirvana - Tormek and more
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Question 1: Approximately how long does it take to establish the hollow in, say, a badly rounded 5/8" plough iron or 3/4" chisel? Secondly, can you grind continuously, or do you have to stop and cool the work, as you do with a higher speed dry grinder?
Question 2: The Tormek system has numerous attachments and gadgets. Which ones do you really need for sharpening chisels, gouges, plane blades?
The simple answer is that it is possible to grind indefinitely on a Tormek since the wet grinding system continuously cools the blade. I�d go so far as to say that it is impossible to burn an edge on the Tormek. That is what the Tormek is all about, and the best introductory statement to this machine.
Still, there is a place for other types of grinders, and there are pros and cons to everything.
I have the 10� Tormek and an 8� half-speed Carba-tec dry grinder. In Australia the latter runs at 1400 rpm. This is slower than the typical USA half-speed model, which runs at 1750 rpm. The benefit of a slower grinder is that it generates less heat than a full speed machine. For note, an 8� machine runs at approximately twice the speed of a 6� machine, as measured at the circumference. For reference, the Tormek runs at 90 rpm.
There are a few tricks to reducing heat on a dry grinder. The simplest is to dress the wheel frequently since they load up with iron filings as they grind, and these filings create friction, which create heat. The other common approach is to use a friable wheel. Even better, use a friable and coarse grit wheel, the coarser the better.
In my opinion, the �coolest� running wheel is the blue Norton 3X, and second to this is the white Norton. I use 46 grit wheels. Many dry grinders machines come standard with 60 and 120 grit wheels. These are too fine for bench chisels and likely designed for HSS lathe chisels.
Keep in mind that a grinder is the first stage of sharpening. A grinder does not produce a working edge. A blade that is well-prepared on a grinder is significantly easier to hone.
Why I use a Tormek
One of the common criticisms levelled at the Tormek is that it grinds slowly. It does. However this observation needs to be placed in context.
Firstly, it is my grinder of choice for thin blades, where the blade does not create a �heat sink� for itself. Such as Japanese chisels, with their laminated steels, and my Berg paring chisels.
Secondly, the Tormek works pretty quickly on high carbon steel. It is satisfactory on A2, but noticeably slower, and it is too slow on HSS.
I often read �tests� of grinding speed where the blade is deliberately chipped (chopped) with another blade. This is meaningless in the real world since how often does one have to re-grind a blade? In most cases, what one does is return an established bevel to a full hollow. This does not take long � perhaps a minute or two at the most with A2 and half that time with HCS. Yes, I can grind at twice this speed with a dry grinder, but the difference is insignificant in this context.
Compared with the various clones on the market, the Tormek is more heavily built. The motor is very difficult to stall - you can create very high down force on the wheel with the blade. This will increase grinding speed.
There is a third reason to use a Tormek. The 10� wheel creates a very shallow hollow. One of the arguments against using a hollow grind on a Japanese blade is that it removes needed support. As may be seen below, this is unlikely to be so.
Here is a Miyanaga ground on the 10� Tormek. It has had a little use.

So why do I also have a dry grinder?
My plan has been to develop the dry grinder for my lathe chisels. I had been looking into buying the solid Wolverine Grinding Tool Rest to replace the LV tool rest (good but lightweight). I liked the idea that it interchanged a tool rest for bench chisels and plane blades with a rest for lathe chisels. I have been freehanding all my lathe chisels to date, but I realise that, while this is fine for spindle work, I will need to improve the accuracy of complex grinds as I begin to do bowls.
The Wolverine is not available in Australia, and so I had begun to look at alternatives. The one that caught my eye was a recent product from Tormek. No, not another wet grinder ... but a tool rest for a dry grinder, the Bench Grinder Mounting Set BGM-100.
This is not really a new product, but a packaging of the universal support and adjustable mount. It comes with a manual for setting up and use.
So this is this one I bought, and have just set up, and used. There it is ...

Note that I actually have just the single universal support (the tool rest) for the grinder. The second one here is borrowed from the Tormek. I do have two mounts so that a support can be swapped from one side to the other.
There are also two types of tool jigs: the chisel/plane blade holder and a flat rest. I do not, as yet, have any for lathe chisels.
The chisel/plane blade holder is terrific for grinding a perfect hollow, while the flat rest allows for freehanding a hollow or grinding a skew (or any other custom need).
What is great is that one can move between the machines (Tormek and grinder). This is facilitated by the ability to set the grinding angle exactly when using the AngleMaster:

Here is a chisel I re-ground from scratch. It took about 1 minute or less to set up the angle to 25 degrees and a couple of minutes to grind fully (note that I keep a finger on the edge of the steel to feel if it is heating up) ..

The 3X stones is cool enough to grind to the edge of the steel (the blade is an old Stanley). A few swipes on my waterstones ..

I also ground the camber for a D2 jack plane blade. To do this I used the flat rest ..

After honing ..

What I like about this set up is that it is so easy to obtain a repeatable angle, as easy as to grind a clean camber, and the promise of great flexibility and range in grinding all types of blades.
Some will say that the Tormek jig on the dry grinder is akin to training wheels on a toddler�s first bike. I will say that I have nothing to prove as I am comfortably proficient in freehanding blades on a flat rest, and the Tormek jig ROCKS! Quick to set up and a reliable grind on straight edges. I use the flat rest for curves and skews.
My Sharpening Centre
I had the opportunity to re-build the workshop at the end of 2008 as the garage/workshop was gutted in preparation for an office addition above. One of gthe first things I added was running water.
So .. here is my sharpening centre (still has doors to go on the sink cabinet) ..

To now answer the question about containing the mess that the Tormek creates, I have enclosed it in a plastic tray. The inner dimension of this one is 13� square.
... and Shapton waterstones used (1000/5000/12000) ...

Regards from Perth
Derek






