Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

W. Butcher gouge questions

Posts

W. Butcher gouge questions

#1

W. Butcher gouge questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I saw a W. Butcher in-cannel socket gouge at an estate sale today. The metal of the gouge was very grainy looking, except about an inch on the "back" - non-bevel - side of the gouge, which was very smooth. I might go back tomorrow and look at it again.

Was this likely a laminated gouge?

Is this something valuable, or just interesting?

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#2

Most are cast, AFAIK

Alan DuBoff

>Bill,

I know that most all of the chisels are cast, and I have to believe that the gouges are cast as well. I don't think I have any Butcher gouges, the only vintage one I can find of decent size is a Charles Buck, and it is marked "cast steel". I have a Butcher chisel and it is cast.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#3

So, this one I saw

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>which I did not get, by the way - the promised Sunday opening of this estate sale didn't happen - must have been seriously rusty at one time, and cleaned up with a honking wire wheel. Think I'll pass, if the sale ever opens up again.

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#4

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions--more questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill,

It's almost collectible just because of the improbability of finding a W. Butcher (strike 1), incannel (strike 2), socket (strike 3) gouge, in (strike 4) California. Wait a minute, there's only 3 strikes. It would help if you could remember the mark--was it the feathered arrow mark, or one of the more exotic marks? The original W. Butcher died in 1870, after an abortive steel casting venture in American, I believe, but the mark may have lived on for quite a while.

If the chisel was marked 'cast steel', that means the raw steel was cast. The gouge is forged.

The lamination question is interesting, to me anyway. Can Stephen Shepherd or someone else knowledgeable describe how socket chisels/gouges were made over time? I mean, were there originally iron sockets and shanks laminated to steel bits? I suppose so, because socket chisels go way back--Moxon shows one in his House Carpentry section, Plate 8. Smith's Key has a few. But then at some point socket chisels began to be forged from solid, but when did that happen?

Wiley

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#5

So, did they...

Alan DuBoff

>Let you in to see the estate before they opened? The ones I've been to have not allowed that, but I've only been to a few. I have heard of that happening...

BTW, not sure if your interested in coming down for the BAG-A-THON (Bay Area Galoots) this year, it's going to be held next Sunday (Sept. 13th) up in the Los Gatos hills, around the summit. If your interested I can forward the info to you in email.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#6

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions--more questions

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley, et al,

The tangs on chisels/gouges were drawn out of the wrought iron billet of the appropriate size then shaped in a two piece swage that forms the bolster. I am not sure if it was done before or after the thin veneer of cast steel was forge welded to the billet.

Sockets on chisels/gouges were also drawn out to the appropriate diameter and a piece of thinner wrought iron was forge welded onto the billet and onto itself. This was done over the horn of the anvil or a mandrel of the proper size.

Sometime in the late nineteenth century they started to drop forge the stuff in complicated dies, so as to eliminate the hand work but still had the thin veneer of steel that holds the edge.

Then the price of steel came down and they started making them out of solid steel and the quality of tools went down.

Stephen

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#7

Thnks for the invite

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>No, it was while it was open, but the woman running it couldn't deal, and I was trying to come down on price.

Thanks for the invitation; we've got a commitment this weekend.s Perhaps next year.

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#8

imprint

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>All I could see on it was "W. Butcher" up toward the socket end, very heavily stamped in.

The consensus seems to be that Butcher chisels are not laminated, so the likelihood is that this particular gouge was cleaned up very badly, and is thus less attractive. I struggle with my desire to buy interesting tools, trying to buy useful ones only and failing often enough...

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#9

How do you figure that?

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley said:

"If the chisel was marked 'cast steel', that means the raw steel was cast. The gouge is forged."

How do you figure the gouge is forged if it was cast?

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#10

Re: How do you figure that?

Joel

>ALan,

"Cast Steel" is the trade name for crucible and another type of tool steel. It has nothing to do with how the tool was made. Actually by the end of the 19th century I would get that almost all edge tools were made of cast steel.

That being said - there is no such alloy defined by "cast steel" and while dozens of alloys were sold as such slight differences in ore, coal, furnace technique resulted in steel suitable for many different tooling operation - not all edge tools. You could say that almost all edge tools were made of cast steel but not all cast steel was good for edge tools. Catalogs of the time describe various versions of cast steel - and what that type is good for - but they don't have the alloy definitions that we have today.

All carbon steel edge tools of any quality are forged. You can hand forge them, drop forge them, or use rolled bar steel which has some attributes of forging.

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#11

I don't know Bill...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>All my W. Butcher mortise chisels are laminated. There are stamped with W. Butcher and an Iron Cross.

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#12

Sheffield, 1879

Don McConnell

>As Joel has already mentioned, the term "Cast Steel" refers to the use of crucible steel in the manufacture of an edge tool. The term "cast" being derived from the fact that the steel was poured, or cast, from the crucible to form ingots. These ingots were then rolled or "tilted" (power hammered) into bars and rods in preparation for further manufacturing processes.

Since confusion on this issue seems to be somewhat common, I thought it might be useful to type in text, below, from an 1879 Sheffield publication which describes the forging process of edge tools in some detail. (Incidentally, the book is available through Google Books if anyone is interested in reading more of it.)

Hope this helps clarify this issue.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

_The Illustrated Guide to Sheffield and the Surrounding District_, edited by John Taylor, � 1879, pages 267 to 269.

"EDGE TOOLS."

"The manufacture of light and heavy edge tools, and other joiners' tools, is also a considerable industry in Sheffield. The variety of these tools is very great, including chisels, gouges, augers, gimlets, plane irons, braces and bits, squares, levels, spokeshaves, hammers, axes, adzes, hedging and other bills, hatchets &c., &c.

Some of the tools, moreover, are made of many sizes and shapes. In gouges, for instance, there are no less than seven different "sweeps" or bends, and each bend is made of twenty different sizes, making 140 varieties of one simple tool. The amount of detail in the trade is consequently enormous, and the sub-division of labour is proportionately great. The forgers work in pairs, as in the table knife and heavier branches of the file trade - a forger and striker in each shop - and the two are kept as far as practicable to one class of work - often to a few sizes of one tool - in which they acquire great skill.

In the shaping of tools, "prints" and "bosses" are much more largely used than for table cutlery or files, and in much greater variety of size and shape. These articles are, in fact, moulds, into the recesses of which the pliant metal is crushed by the hammer while red hot, instead of being poured while in a liquid state, as in the making of castings; and the process is called "mooding" (moulding). As previously mentioned, one side of the dies or moulds, known as "prints" or " bosses," consist of a small square block of metal, and fits into the anvil; but the other side, which is held in the hand during use, is hammer-shaped, and has a very primitive handle, formed by twisting a twig of hazel round it, and fastening the two ends together with a ring.

Special dies being required for every variety in the size or shape of the tool to be made, prints and bosses form an important part of the furniture of an edge tool forger's workshop. The walls of workshops in which the smaller tools are made are often almost concealed by rows of these implements, carefully arranged according to size and pattern, the set for a single shop costing �40 to �50. To this explanation of the simple means by which apparently difficult ends are attained, we must add that though the forging of edge tools does not differ in principle from the forging of cutlery and files, the greater number and complication of the processes occasion a much larger amount of labour.

Take, for instance, a common joiner's chisel, which is one of the most simple of edge tools. The forger heats the end of a rod of steel selected to size; roughly shapes the blade; cuts it off with sufficient for the bolster and tang; re-heats; shapes the bolster with prints, and draws out the tapering tang with the hammer. The blade is then re-heated, and carefully "plated" (hammered out) to the size and shape required, water being thrown on at intervals during the brief process to remove scale. Gouges are forged in the same way, the blades being afterwards rounded in "hollowing bosses."

The forgings then pass into other hands to be hardened, tempered, ground, glazed, and "finished," ready for packing. The more complicated socket chisel passes through the forger's hands no less than six times; is then hardened, tempered, set, ground, glazed, japanned, and finished, passing three times through the hands of the grinder in the course of these operations. �"

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#13

Re: Sheffield, 1879

Joel

>Don,

Barry Iles once gave me a set of 11 partially finished tools that show each stage of manufacture. I remarked that is was great to see "all 11 phases of manufacture" and Barry said - "well there are actually 40 phases or so - but it's too hard to explain to anyone what each one is."

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

#14

Re: W. Butcher gouge questions

Todd Hughes

>W. Butcher chisels are very common, actually probably the most common named chisel I see. Made in England but must have been sold in every corner hardware store in the USA from all the ones I see. most are nothing special generic chisels. Maybe quality is OK I don't know, I wouldn't rank most as a being high quality chisel like a Swan or witherby. On the resale market most W.Butcher rank very low to the point I normaly take the handles off to use on better saleable chisels and toss the chisel itself

Gouges are less common and a socket one is I think is very , very uncommon to the point I don't think I remember ever seeing one. Could be an example of a later American made company making chisels and using the old W. Butcher mark since in my experance is uncommon to see British made socket chisels.

This chisel sounds like a curisosity and is a bit different I think....still probably ain't worth anything though

Cast steel is of course the type of steel it is made out of and doesn't mean it is cast like say a Stanley plane. In my experance most butcher chisels are of a rather small size and are probably solid steel though larger ones might be laminated. Of course to a user it makes no difference unless it is laminated and the chisel has been sharpened past the steel bit .....Todd