Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Need help with a plane *LINK*

Posts

Need help with a plane *LINK*

#1

Need help with a plane *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I am building a strick block or miter plane of wood for the fine blade I got from Chris Sholtz at GalootTools. I spent a couple of hours bedding the iron and now need to drill a hole for the iron bar that goes above the blade that captures the wedge.

Strike Block

Question is where along the blade do I position the bar? I am thinking dead center would be proper to provide even pressure along the blade.

Would it be better to be located closer to the mouth?

Stephen


Galoot Tools

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#2

Re: Need help with a plane

Ace Karner

>I would put it as close to mouth as I could and still think it would not cause a problem with shaving clearance.

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#3

Re: Need help with a plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Stephen

In my opinion the placement of the cross pin is going to need to be higher than usual unless you chisel out an escape ramp for shavings. There will otherwise just be too little clearance for shavings.

Here is an example of the typical Krenov-style construction ...



And here is the inside of a real Krenov-made smoother ..



The escape ramp should be about 65-70 degrees from the bed. So, assuming your bed is 40 degrees, then the escape ramp should be 105-110 degrees. Yours looks to be about 90 degrees.

The advantage of a wedge seated in cheeks is that you do not need as much angle on the escape ramp as there is no cross pin to get in the way, and the wedge can be shaped to support the blade at the sides.



I think the solution is to chop away more waste and create an appropriate escape ramp. Then you can place the cross pin lower, which should translate to more stability in blade holding.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#4

Re: Need help with a plane

ThomD

>Krenov cross bars fo have to be high because they are bulky and can get in the way of clearing chips. A metal one needs to be high because it still needs to apply pressure evenly to the iron, so you want a midpoint.

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#5

Re: Need help with a plane

Craig D

>Stephen asks:

>Question is where along the blade do I position the bar? I am thinking dead center would be proper to provide even pressure along the blade.

Here is a photo of the 6", 15� miter plane I built; I put the pin 3/4" up from the bottom of the sole, 1 1/16" back from the mouth. In use, the wedge winds up pretty much where it is in the photo (1/4" of wedge below the 1/2" pin). I've had no problems with clogging. One issue I've seen (on my planes) with a rod for the wedge is it can dent the wedge. On this plane (and K planes), the pin can rotate and has a flat spot that contacts the wedge to get around that potential problem.

In my opinion, the only place you really care about pressure is at the mouth, the further away it is clamped, the more the iron can act as a diving board (which is what I think happens with Stanley's). I actually think it is a good idea for the iron to be "humped" (or sprung) so the wedge forces it flat (ie preload the iron against chatter).

Craig


img

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#6

Re: Need help with a plane

amelon

>To add to Derek's point:

Krenov's "The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking" and Finck's "Making & Mastering Wood Planes" recommend 1-1/4" height as the position for the cross-pin (before gluing on the sole - the sole adds another 1/8" or so) for Krenov-style planes. It seems this is a formula which works based on Krenov's experience. If you're using Hock blades, it puts it the cross-pin a bit below the midpoint of the blade length. But then the blade will wear eventually from sharpening, so it's not a good idea to decide placement of the cross-pin using the blade as a reference.

In addition to shavings getting clogged, a cross-pin placed too low can also result in "the wedge may not clamp the blade properly, perhaps shifting in use" according to Finck. That was my experience when I tried to adjust a friend's Krenov-style plane. I set the blade to expose the cutting edge, but when I tapped the wedge to secure the setting, the blade backed up. It was very frustrating. The fix would be to plug the hole and drill a new one, then use a metal cross-pin instead.

You also don't want the cross-pin too high. It can result in clamping issue and difficulty for blade adjustment (when blade wears down due to sharpening). Lastly it "interfere with the final shape of your plane, which usually dips along the middle area," according to Krenov.

- Bob

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#7

According to Finck.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1 1/4" above the sole.

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#8

Chris Scholz

Why?

Chris Scholz

>Man, don't leave us techies hanging luke that!

...is there any heuristic or maybe even numeric explanation where this recommendation comes from? First hand experience would be fine. Some justification, please! Just quoting a number without justification drives us nuts (if it was in SI units, maybe we could get over it).

Thanks

Chris

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#9

A citation was provided, but to elaborate...

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>David Finck, author of the book Making and Mastering Wooden Planes, teacher of numerous plane making classes, former student of Krenov who developed this style of plane, says put the hole 1 1/4" above the sole.

One can only presume that his recommendation comes from the experience enumerated above.

Re: Need help with a plane *LINK*

#10

Re: Why?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Chris,

The 1-1/4" recommendation of course presumes a certain plane height, bedding length, and bedding angle. This is clear in the context provided by James Krenov in 'The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking', p. 87, as referenced by Bob Le above.

The Krenov-type plane shown in the reference uses a double-iron. What the pin is really doing is spreading the pressure on the cap iron to the blade. The cap iron is bearing on the blade at the top of the bedding, and down near the edge. In turn, the pin/wedge bear on the cap iron just below its midpoint, closer to the edge than the top of bedding, at about the 60/40 point on the cap iron.

Although the Japanese plane has its iron bedded quite differently, the pin on a Japanese plane (except for single blade planes) also distributes the pressure of the chipbreaker (subblade). The subblade on these planes does not actually secure the main blade, but rather pretensions the blade edge against heavy cuts. The subblade bears on the main blade at the top of the bedding, and very near the blade edge. I'm looking at a Mosaku/Inomoto plane where the pin is almost exactly at the midpoint of the subblade.

In each of these cases, the pin is distributing pressure onto the main blade, but also is positioned so that the blade will back out properly under hammer taps and stay in place otherwise--surely there is more experience than science to this latter point.

Wiley