Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

Posts

Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#1

Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>In an earlier thread, the question arose whether rebate (and shoulder) plane blades should be set flush or slightly proud of the sides of the body.

I was taught to use the plane with the side of the blade slightly proud of the body. We are talking a miniscule amount here. I am not sure it one can realistically qualitify it. About .001 - .002"?

However in practice this did not work as expected and I began to set the blade flush with the side of the body. This worked for me.

So which way should it be?

So .. a scrap of pine and a Record #778. The only problem was that I realised later that I planed across the grain and not with the grain. So we will call this Part I.

Record #778 ...


.. and freshly sharpened blade ..


Set square and flush against plane body ..


Shavings look like this ..


And the frebate is square with a perpendicular side ..



OK. What about a blade set fractionally proud? Here it is (and I have added an insert as well). The blade was tapped with my trusty genno, gently ..


The nicker is no longer helpful now, so it is retracted and the board is knifed..


This is the result. The side is ragged and not perpendicular ..


Comments?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#2

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1 *LINK*

Marc Waldbillig

>Hi Derek,

A very good feature of the Veritas rabbet plane is the possibility to adjust the nicker the way it is in line with a slightly proud blade. I only have superb results...

On an older plane as yours is, I'd shim the nicker, did that on a conventional wooden rabbet plane (as was an actual Ulmia). It worked fine too.

What differs in our "rabbeting" methods is I use a long and large fence and plane the board vertically clamped.

Cheers,

Marc


Blog Entry on the Veritas Rabbet Plane

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#3

Fillister vs. rebate

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Derek,

Beautiful work! And a great demonstration, as always!

Just one comment. And this is based on my anecdotal experience--I'm no expert....In the case of a fillister, which you show, it is the nicker that is defining the cut line and keeping the wall vertical. In this situation, you want the blade to cut to the nicker line and not beyond it, else the wall will be ragged as you show.

However, in the case of the rebate plane (where there is no nicker), one is relying on the main blade to prevent a little fillet from forming at the base of the vertical wall, which will push the rebate plane away. For me at least, a few thousandths proud works, when using a rebate plane (such as a shoulder plane), especially the cut is going down a ways. Every so often, and certainly on the final pass, the rebate plane is turned on its side, and the vertical wall is planed directly.

But when setting up a fillister, I do as you do, and let the blade cut to the limit of the nicker, but not beyond.

Wiley

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#4

Re: Fillister vs. rebate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>it is the nicker that is defining the cut line and keeping the wall vertical. In this situation, you want the blade to cut to the nicker line and not beyond it, else the wall will be ragged as you show.

Hi Wiley

In the cross-grain example here I agree that a nicker is likely to aid in avoiding spelching (breakout). This is why I will do "part 2" and repeat the above but planing with the grain.

The thing is, how do you keep a moving fillester fixed-position nicker in line with side of the blade when planing across the grain? I suppose one answer is that you don't use a #78/778 but use a plane with a skewed blade to make a slicing cut (which is what I usually do).

Or you define the area with a deep knife score (using a heavy-duty knife, such as the one I made that was recently on show here) and do not worry about the nicker at all (as I did here, but unsuccessfully).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#5

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>A very good feature of the Veritas rabbet plane is the possibility to adjust the nicker the way it is in line with a slightly proud blade. I only have superb results...

Hi Marc

I have long admired the work you do. And you have impeccable taste in tools < grin >

I do have the Veritas rabbet twins. (In fact I was honoured to be able to fondle and play with the CNC-ed plastic originals before they went to production). The Veritas planes are superb. I have been promising a review of them for several months - having accumulated massive amounts of images with the Veritas', Stanley #289, Stanley #46, ECE, and Record #778. But I have been slack and needing to find the time and energy to put together such a complex article.

What differs in our "rabbeting" methods is I use a long and large fence and plane the board vertically clamped.

A deep fence is a good idea. It does come down to the direction of the grain (you would not want to do this directly into end grain, as used here!). I started this planing having a small "senior moment" - otherwise I would not have been planing end grain. Prior to grabbing the board and the #778 I had been planing large panels (for a cabinet), and was in some mindset :(


It's a good point you touch on. Holding the board in the vise allows the plane's fence (even the standard one) to be held against the side. Further, it is easier to orientate for vertical/squareness.

It would be great to hear from Warren or Stephen or Joel, or any others experienced in traditional woodworking, for pointers on using rebate/fillister planes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#6

Re: Fillister vs. rebate

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Derek,

Humble admission: I've never had a 78 or 778 in my hands, so I don't know the answer to the question about lining up the nicker and the main blade.

I have two moving fillisters, both woodies. A modern C&W, and an older Tysack. Both have skewed blades, and nickers that are fixed. In each case, I adjust the main blade laterally to run in the shadow of the nicker. I also leave the nicker down for long grain cuts--don't know if everyone does that.

On the original issue of setting a rebate plane blade (meaning a pure rebate, not a fillister), I'm not feeling dogmatic about it. It's really just a practical matter. The blade has got to be constantly swiping the sidewall of the rebate, or else a pesky little fillet will develop and soon the plane will be running against the fillet--this is what your very nice graphic was showing.

Now it may well be that your working methods are precise enough that you can take a pure rebate plane (shoulder plane or 778 w/nicker raised, for example) and keep the plane running against the vertical wall with a flush blade. And get perfect results, even making a deep cut.

I can't. And that's all i'm saying. To keep the sidewall perfectly clean, I need a little tiny bit of positive clearance. Your experience may well differ from mine. I would just encourage anyone to visually inspect their rebates as they're cutting them, to ensure that they're cutting all the way to the wall. Otherwise, you end up pretty soon with a non-trivial problem to fix, as the wall starts creeping toward you.

Bottom line: If your methods work, I agree with them!

Wiley

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#7

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

Joel

>The blade should be proud only a couple of thou - that I can see how proud it is from the photo suggests a lot more offset. That blade might be to wide for the plane and the sides not flush or slightly beveled back.

Re: Setting a rebate plane blade - revisited #1

#8

Rabbet planes on end grain... *LINK*

Marc Waldbillig

>Hi Derek,

I'll be glad to read your review of the rabbet planes' pair. I wonder what advantage you'll find in having both...

You wrote:

...It does come down to the direction of the grain (you would not want to do this directly into end grain, as used here!)...

Actually it is exactly what I did, when I planed a tongue on the four panels of a tray (It was part of the folding campaign table from PW). The rabbet plane worked great on end grain. See the link.

The way you made a rabbet cross grain with a proud iron without nicker is like going against the fur. Only the side wall of the rabbet plane would stabilize the planing movement, as it did in the first rabbet - the iron flush to the plane's body. In my method, the iron can be proud, because the fence stabilizes the cut. Okay that's only thoughts, guess work ;-)

I have to return you the compliment on tool selection. I often read your reviews and like to "walk" through your shop.

Cheers,

Marc


End Grain Rabbeting