Re: Different definition of "starved joint"?
wilbur
>"Starvation is just a lack of glue, however that happens."
This is true. But to be fair, Adam, when I looked back on where this discussion came from, this is what you had said:
"It's true that high clamp pressure will starve HG joints."
So if we are talking about whether high clamp pressure can lead to glue starvation, I'm not sure how your example of a tight fitting M/T joint really applies to this discussion as you originally defined it. As has been mentioned, it seems more likely that the glue escaped the joint because of the scraping from the tight fit of the tenon into the mortise.
As to whether Warren's careful planing of his workpieces led to a decrease in pressure which saved the joint from starvation, that just doesn't seem reasonable to me. Firstly, the amount of pressure in his setup far exceeds what any reasonable woodworker would do, given that he had completely covered the joint with clamp pad surfaces with his REcord sash clamps. I also have no reason to believe that those clamps don't generate at least the same amount of clamp pressure as any other commonly used clamp today. From your descriptions of clamp pressure leading to glue starvation, it doesn't seem like you are talking about people who put a clamp along every inch of the joint, as Warren did in his test, and I certainly don't think that such an approach describes your clamping style.
Secondly, if I had made that joint, I certainly would not have done as good a job as Warren did, which would lead to smaller areas of contact due to a not precisely matched joint. This does lead to greater pressure at those areas, but it also leads to areas of less pressure in between where the sides of the joint don't touch. It is hard to see how glue starvation would occur in those spots where the joint doesn't match well, since the high clamp pressure that supposedly causes the glue starvation won't be happening in those areas.
Warren's test is only a piece of anecdotal evidence. But so are the other examples that you have given so far.