Re: Setting shoulder (and rebate) plane blades
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Hi Derek,
"The red here represents the slope that results.
Just my observations. Opinions of others?"
________
I like your extension to the general case of rebates, because it's easier to discuss than trying to figure out what a shoulder plane is for (<:).
Also, I agree with your analysis.
But let me say a couple of things about what it's like on Planet Wiley. On my planet, the side of the rebate plane is dead straight--well, let me amend that, it's straight within some little tolerance. Also, the vertical wall of the rebate is dead straight along its length--well, OK, not exactly dead straight, if you want to get really technical, it's straight within some small error which I don't want to try to figure out. Then when I tap the blade of the rebate plane flush to the sole with my trusty hammer (whichever is the closest one to reach), it is absolutely flush--well, not exactly absolute, but it's within an opinion of being flush.
My data point: What I find will keep the rebate plane planing a vertical wall in a slightly imperfect world, is to leave the blade just an opinion's worth on the proud side. Not enough that it drags or hangs or rags the wall--not even enough to notice at a glance-- but just enough proud, that I know for sure it is not shy. Because if it is even a little shy, the plane will walk away from the wall after a few passes, as shown in red on your excellent drawing. Of course, if we're talking about making just a pass or two, and then a final pass on the vertical wall, then close is fine.
Wiley