Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Shoulder Plane Question

Posts

Shoulder Plane Question

#1

Shoulder Plane Question

Sawman

>I have 2 Record shoulder planes and was wonder about something. Should the blades be the 'exact" same width as the body? Or should they bit a tad wider?

Mine are wider and I always have to adjust the blade so as not to 'dig' in with the little bit that sticks out.

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#2

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Should be wider or not, I prefer them that way. It makes it easier to adjust against a flat surface if you have a bit of blade out to start with.

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#3

Agree *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Sawman,

The blades are shipped a little wide on shoulder planes. I agree with Brent that it's useful to have a little overage, for ease of adjustment. Also, there are times when I want it to be just a hair proud (literally), to positively get down into the corner of the rabbet and not leave anything there.

Attached is a link to a modern version of your Record shoulder plane (which is itself a 'modern' version of the original Preston plane IIRC), as made by Lie Nielsen. Note that Lie Nielsen deliver their irons about 5 thousandths wide. In the maintenance notes they say to just tap the iron flush on the side you're using. They also say if you prefer you can grind off 5 thou and make it dead flush with the sides. I don't recommend doing that, for the reason Brent said.

Wiley


Lie Nielsen shoulder plane

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#4

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Can't add much to what Brent and Wiley have said, except that, in general in rabbeting planes, it's better to have the iron wider than narrower - adjusting an iron that was too narrow could be like cutting a board longer.

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#5

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

Frank D. in Montreal

>I agree with the others that the blade should not be narrower, but I aim for as close to the same width as possible without going past the critical point. I just grind a little bit off each side with a 1000 stone, inserting the blade back into the body and feeling with my fingers how flush the blade is to both sides ofthe plane. When it feels pretty flush, maybe just the slightest bit wider than the body, I stop grinding. This allows me to use the plane any way necessary (on any side) without adjusting. Otherwise I find the plane close to useless.

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#6

Setting shoulder (and rebate) plane blades

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>All the shoulder planes I have used to date, with the exception of the HNT Gordon, have the blades slightly proud of the sides. The Gordon is flush. However, all should be used flush.

The aim when using a shoulder plane is to create a tenon face square to the shoulder. Therefore, in my understanding and experience, it is required that the corner of the shoulder plane (including the edge of the blade) is flush.

If the blade is not flush - whether retracted or proud - the side of the shouldder plane cannot register squarely against tenon face, and the shoulder will be cut out-of-square. In other words, prior to use, flush the blade with the side of the plane body.

The same situation occurs when using a rebate (rabbet) plane. Using a rebate plane shows the shoulder plane dynamics more easily. In my experience, unless the blade is flush, the side of the rebate will be plane out-of-square. With the rebate plane the registration is from the fence, and it is still possible to use a plane with a very slightly proud blade. However a blade that is fractionally too proud of the body will push the body away from the side of the rebate. This will be the result ...


The red here represents the slope that results.

Just my observations. Opinions of others?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#7

Re: Setting shoulder (and rebate) plane blades

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Derek,

"The red here represents the slope that results.

Just my observations. Opinions of others?"

________

I like your extension to the general case of rebates, because it's easier to discuss than trying to figure out what a shoulder plane is for (<:).

Also, I agree with your analysis.

But let me say a couple of things about what it's like on Planet Wiley. On my planet, the side of the rebate plane is dead straight--well, let me amend that, it's straight within some little tolerance. Also, the vertical wall of the rebate is dead straight along its length--well, OK, not exactly dead straight, if you want to get really technical, it's straight within some small error which I don't want to try to figure out. Then when I tap the blade of the rebate plane flush to the sole with my trusty hammer (whichever is the closest one to reach), it is absolutely flush--well, not exactly absolute, but it's within an opinion of being flush.

My data point: What I find will keep the rebate plane planing a vertical wall in a slightly imperfect world, is to leave the blade just an opinion's worth on the proud side. Not enough that it drags or hangs or rags the wall--not even enough to notice at a glance-- but just enough proud, that I know for sure it is not shy. Because if it is even a little shy, the plane will walk away from the wall after a few passes, as shown in red on your excellent drawing. Of course, if we're talking about making just a pass or two, and then a final pass on the vertical wall, then close is fine.

Wiley

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#8

And the nice thing about the LV shoulder plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>(I have the medium one) is that you can turn the adjusting screws and not have to tap anything into place. The blade stays put.

Bruce

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#9

Re: Setting shoulder (and rebate) plane blades

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>You certainly can't aim for flush and then hope that all goes well. You have to have clearance on the side and not just hope that you are too far out rather than too far in. The side of the iron needs to be able to clean up any irregularities on the wall of the rabbet as you go. A slight clearance will make up for all the things about your plane that are not perfect like flat side of plane, flat side of iron, square iron, square plane, and the fact that your technique is not perfect either. Further, the corner of the iron gets the most abuse and is the most vulnerable to dulling. A "perfectly flush" iron will act more and more like one that is set too far in as the iron dulls.

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#10

Re: And the nice thing about the LV shoulder plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Bruce,

That's an interesting feature of the plane. I have often wondered if Veritas plane owners are using these grub screws or backing them out to make more room. Sounds like you like them!

Wiley

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#11

Keen insights! Thank you.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#14

Then...

Frank D. in Montreal

>You grind the blade just about flush (ever-so-slightly protruding as I dscribed in my post) and never have to touch the screws again. I find them really handy.

Re: Shoulder Plane Question

#15

Re: And the nice thing about the LV shoulder plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I mostly use it as a shoulder plane and much less so for rabbets. The blade is registered in one position and I keep it there. The grub screws give me better control for keeping the blade square as well as set properly against the side.

bruce