We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Hi everyone, haven't been around in a while (life events and all...)
I've been asked to make bookshelves for my two oldest sons. Knowing how they take care of their possessions (been working on that, to no avail so far...), I decided to use "scraps" in the construction. One of the bookshelves uses ash uprights, of pretty low grade (one actually has the pith in it). Ran them through the jointer and planer, they came out flat but fairly rough.
So I got the handplanes out. Started with the Veritas LAJ with a 38 degree blade (not really "fresh"). Massive tearout. Funny, I've managed to smooth everything else with that setup in the past without trouble...
Time to sharpen the iron. Back to the board, still blowout. Allrightie then, time to switch to the 50 degree blade (freshly sharpened). Not as bad, but still blowout. I was flabbergasted...
First reaction was to try my little Munjingfang (4" long) plane. It is bedded at about 62 degrees (not different from my Veritas setup), yet it cleaned up the tearout areas without trouble.
On the next board I decided to use my homemade wooden smoother (Krenov type, 65 degree angle, Munjingfang blade), and it dealt with the board without trouble.
Now I'm wondering if the Bevel-up Smoother would get a better result. I would have thought not, but I'd like to hear from those who actually tried it and the LAJ side-to-side. My guess is that there should be no difference in performance between the two planes, but I'd like to hear from your experience...
Keep in mind that this is "the board from hell", and is not a put-down on Veritas planes...
Well, you did slay the monster, so things worked out.
I have a question whether the LAJ, with either blade, was pulling itself into the cut, or did you have to apply downward pressure to keep it in the cut? Did the plane feel right in the cut?
Where I'm going with this is that I wonder if the blade back has lost some clearance. If it has, you could restore original function by grinding it back to a heavy burr--however, this is all speculative on my part.
With a 38 degree blade bedded at 12 degrees, the effective cut angle of the Jack is 50 degrees... not enough for that sort of grain challenge. If you had a blade sharpened to 50 degrees, you'd have an effective cut angle at 62 degrees - and would see a difference.
If you want - I'll have our guys set a 50 degree blade for you - and leave it at the store - you can take it home and try it...
Cheers -
Rob
(who also knows that if Denis comes into the store to get the blade, he's sure to leave with something else too .... :) )
>Is there a possibility that it's not so much a cutting angle issue, and more of a clearance angle issue? Unless the grain in your board was really squirrely, I'm having a hard time believing that someone with your experience, Denis, could not plane ash with a plane set with a 62� cutting angle.
I believe that the Mujifang is a bevel down plane. If so, by switching to your Mujifang, you didn't appreciably change the cutting angle of the blade compared to your LV LAJ with a 50� blade, and I don't believe that there is anything magical about the Mujifang plane blade compared to the LV blade. But the clearance angle would have changed a lot by switching from a bevel up to a bevel down plane, going from 12� to about 30� or more, depending on how your Mujifang plane blade is sharpened.
I don't pretend to be a clearance angle expert, but Leonard Lee's sharpening book says that you can get away with lower clearance angles on dense, fine grained hardwoods, and I'm not sure that your low grade ash board fits into that category.
P.S.: I hope that Rob isn't mad at me for torpedoing a potential sale opportunity. If it makes you feel any better, Rob, I just placed an order for some pen kits. :@)
Assuming that the blades are all sharpened equally ....
I have the same planes as you (well I think I have the same Muji), so perhaps I may comment.
My little Mujingfang is a delightful plane. It is an amazing performer, and often one I use when smoothing small sections of difficult grain. Is this yours?
The obvious difference between the Mujingfang and the Veritas LA Jack is the size of the plane. The LAJ is nearly 4 times as long and the blade is 2 1/4" wide versus the 1 1/2" (from memory) of the Muji. The mouth of the Muji is very tight (although this is a lesser issue at 60-62 degrees cutting angle).
My expectation is that a shorter smoother can out perform a longer plane (there is a reason why vintage coffin smoothers were typically 7 1/2" long). This is simply because they can ride the hills and dales more effectively, taking off less wood in the process. This is the reason I smooth with the Veritas BUS rather than the LAJ. The LAJ can do a fantastic job as a panel plane, but the ultimate performance goes to the BUS. The little Muji can be set to take a really fine shaving. I often marvel at the delicate cuts it is capable of, and it is these fine shavings that often defeat the threatening tearout.
I am wondering if you managed to take the same fine shaving with the LAJ? The longer body length (even on a machined surface) might temp you to take a slightly thicker cut to overcome any irregularities in the wood (even though it was machined flat).
The other possibility - although a long shot - is that that LAJ ductile iron has moved. Nah!
>Sometimes we just come upon strange wood, such as my bocote experience. Nothing in my shop would plane that board except an ancient coffin smoother with a gaping mouth you wouldn't believe. I hadn't even had a chance to sharpen it.
When you look at the rosewood they used (notably hua li), more often than not you see knots in various panels. "Eyes" one of the attendants in the Honolulu Museum of Art called it. Placement of the "eyes" is considered a style element.
>I fall between Pam's weird happens, and Derek's idea that there may not be a comparable shaving thickness here. Bevel up smoothers do have less meat behind the blade, in the blade, so your 50 is a 38, which is pretty stout, but your 50 with a BD can be a 45.
It would be interesting to see how a toothing plane would do for prep, and then just touch it up with a finishing plane.
>Trouble was between the driver seat and the steering wheel...
Went back to that board tonight. With one change...
For years I've tried to wean myself from honing jigs. With success I have to say, except when the angle is high. 38 degree blade I sharpen freehand with nice bare spots on my forearms (I know that if I did a bad job the "shaving" is painful).
But for 50 degree blades I had mitigated success in the past. And so was the case here (the arm shaving trick doesn't work at that high a bevel angle).
To make sure that I wasn't the problem here, I dug out my Veritas honing jig from the drawer, where it sat unused for at least four years, to remove the possibility of my honing being the reason for the tearout I experienced.
I was humbled once again...
Sharpened with the jig, that blade sailed smoothly through the wood, without any of the tearout I had experienced before. In fact the finish was better than with my woodies...
Lesson learned, I'm not gonna stop trying to wean myself from the honing jig, but if I get tearout again with a 50 degree blade I will look closely at myself in the mirror...
DC
BTW, for those who mentioned the relief angle, I use the ruler trick on all my blades, still leaves a 11 degree clearance, more than appropriate AFAIK. Still it was a good observation...
>Ah yes. Denis, that is why I still use a honing guide with BU planes, while my preference is freehanding on a hollow grind for BD blades. It is simply not possible to hone an accurate and repeatable high angle microbevel without a guide.
Now the Ruler Trick is an excellent adjunct to sharpening - unless you are into stropping between honings. Then it is a short cut to nowhere.
I did mean 'can't'. Consider the opposite proposition: That we can find the limit. But as soon as one says 'I found the limit', then it is possible for someone to exceed that limit (if Mr. Headley is right).
>There is a theoretical limit. If and when someone figures out how to make the molecules in the steel line up in regular ranks across the edge, with no deviation other than the usual molecular squirming, we'll have reached the limit.
That's a ways away, though, and I think Wiley may have been thinking of it in terms of "you can always be a better musician."
Caveat: I need to say that Mr. Headley was doing some plain talk about a situation where he had sharpened a commercial coping saw blade or somesuch, to get it up to his standards. This philosophical baggage I have added on is my own and not his.
Let's take your analogy, which is a good one...... What I'm getting at is that, as we sharpen, we are not approaching some ideal limit. There is a chasm that separates real sharpening results from the model in our heads. We are not approaching the ideal edge of single molecules in a line. Even that visual model is a step away from reality, in that room-temperature steel molecules exist in a crystal lattice, and the lattice has dislocations in it. That perfect edge we're after is not hidden down in the steel blade--it is in our heads. As Yogi Berra is said to have said, "In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice, there is."
So in reality, we don't know how sharp we can make something. If I hold up a blade and say, 'this is it, this is as sharp as steel can get', rest assured that Pam, or Adam, or Larry Williams, or David Barnett, or you, or someone else on this forum--could take that blade and get it a little sharper, and then someone else, a little sharper yet.
Here is one practical application. There are people who can plane a whole board of figured hardwood to a perfect no-tearout gloss with a 42-degree plane. Not a pass or two down a board--a whole board. That isn't supposed to happen. But then, we don't know where the limits are. I suspect that Denis' 38 degree blade will plane that ash board he was talking about to a fine finish, and am prepared to make a sizable bet on it.
I've built a few things out of Ash, and while it can be weird sometimes, I haven't had too many problems with using a normal 45 degree stanley smoother. But weird grain things do happen...
I gave up on the shaving trick after a while. It's cool and all, but I trained myself to rub a thumb up the blade and off the edge. After a while, I learned to feel if there's even the slightest resistance... indicating a burr.
Sharp is a hard thing to learn to gauge, because so many of the indicators are indirect for me. Slight levels of resistance, spots of reflected light, wood feels a little rougher... there are so many ways to increase the accuracy of the guess, but the proof is still in the pudding.
I will say that I've had a much easier time with steels other than A2. Not that I can't sharpen it, but other steels just seem to give a more refined edge. Don't know what you have in the LAJ, but if I recall correctly, the muji has A2, or something equivalent... and that stuff, while harder to sharpen than HC, does sharpen up VERY nicely, and very cleanly.
But after a while, I did get to the point where I decided I just had too many planes, and too many blades... because there was always SO much sharpening to do. I remember going through a binge last winter where I wanted to get EVERYTHING tuned back up... and I was sharpening for weeks. Then I realized I really wanted to be planing, and not sharpening. :-p
Lesson learned... I'm back to sharpening when I need to. I strop with MDF and diamond paste periodically, but I go with whatever plane cuts the best, and I've just about trained myself to let go of the expectations I normally associate with certain planes, or certain manufacturers... because in the end, they're all just fancy jigs to hold a wide, flat blade. And the sharp or dull has very little to do with the manufacturer, and a lot more to do with me.
Re: weaning from jigs, I don't know if you're flat-beveling, or hollow grinding, and then freehand sharpening, but the LAJ blades should give you a nice wide bevel on a hollow grind that should be excellent to practice with. Don't know what you're grinding with, if you are, but an 8" or 6" wheel should give a deep enough grind that the hollow will still be present when you're done sharpening, as it should be. Problem with freehanding a flat bevel is that sometimes it can hydroplane through the water and the oil, and throw off your sense of proper angle. Hollow gives a place for the water or oil to go, and it's easier to feel the blade on the stone.
Be bold with your grinding, too. Grind as much of the flat as you feel comfortable with, and then a little more. Worst thing that can happen is that you fry a corner, which you're just going to radius away anyway. And a small section of lost temper in a blade, that's been properly sharpened, will still cut better than a blade that you can't quite get sharp enough, because it's skating over your cutting fluid of choice. Sure, you'll have to sharpen it again when it dulls... but you'd have to do that anyway.
Last thought before I end this ramble... worry about how the final piece looks when you're done. Not how your tools look. It's too easy to get caught up in the shape of your tools at the expense of the shape of your work.
For my purposes, I have a piece of hard maple that I keep around, and I take a swipe or two when sharpness is critical to me. The grain is dense and regular enough that a cleanly sharpened blade will leave a clean and burnished looking surface, that will reflect light at a low enough angle. Then I can hold the board up to the light, and see if a poorly or incompletely sharpened blade is leaving streaks.
It's not really an empirical measurement, but I think its a good enough story stick to measure what I'm trying to measure. And like all of my other endeavors in this field, my ability to gauge the results is slowly and gradually getting better, all the time. Every time I think I've reached a limit, there's a spot on the board somewhere that just looks a little bit smoother, or reflects a little more brightly, than another spot... which gives me new data.
The Mujingfang blade is some kind of HSS, but the type is not specified AFAIK. It is harder than A2, takes more time to sharpen (but it's still not too hard). I don't use much HCS other than with my Japanese chisels, and they last so long between sharpenings that I can't develop a habit :-)
I do flat bevel with a belt sander, My take is that hollow grinding, while convenient, makes a blade act thinner than its thickness. No data, just theory here...
I hone using the Krenov method (but with waterstones), taught to me at Rosewood Studio by the then owner, a CR alumni. Takes a bit of practice to get used to the method, but it works fine after a while. But the method doesn't work that well with steep bevels, which caused my original problem.
As for the furniture pieces themselves, while I want them to show good craftsmanship, they're still thrown together pieces (to help my sons store their mountains of books), so don't expect too much... But I'll post pictures when the bookshelves are completed...