Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

Posts

New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>



Hi folks,

Whether you're a long-time Japanese tool aficionado or an apprehensive wannabee, Jay van Arsdale's new DVD set will demystify and illustrate the care and tuning of these sensitive hand tools. Check out Wiley Horne's in-depth review in our Video Reviews department for a detailed description of this authoritative video.

Cheers,

Ellis




Video Reviews: Japanese Hand Planes

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#2

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes

amelon

>Very nice review, Wiley. I've seen the video and I think your review covers it quite thoroughly.

Regarding ura dashi (the process to "move out" the hard steel on the back side), it's little understood here in the West. Oftentimes the user will aggressively flatten the back until the hollow is virtually gone. Aesthetic aside, this can result in a looser fitting blade which can impact the plane's performance. Jay's DVD may be the only video out there on this topic and it's only second to seeing the actual demonstration in person.

Perhaps my comment above that ura dashi being little understood here in the West is not true. Many of the vintage J-tools I've seen on eBay which are coming from Japan also seem to have rather poorly preserved backs - most have very little of the hollow left.

- Bob

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#3

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>My god, never thought of it as a fitting issue, how ingenious.

Thanks, Bob (and to Wiley for a great review)

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#4

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks Bob and Pam,

One of the things that struck me watching this video a few times, was Jay himself as a person. I've never met Jay. But he is so totally comfortable in his own skin. If I were making a video, I would be all antsy and nervous and posed for the occasion. But Jay is the picture of calm as the camera runs, with his pencil stuck in his hair, which must be where he always has it. He makes sure progress without getting in a hurry; and he is a natural teacher who takes time to show the small intricacies. As he got into the demo, I felt like I was there in his shop.

Bob, if you don't mind, could you offer some personal impressions, having learned from Jay as a student?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#5

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'll butt in here for a note. Jay was involved in setting up and running the Yataiki blacksmith workshop I attended in SF a few years ago. I was very impressed with everything he said and did, as with his (ex)students and associates who also helped: Dave Burnard and John Burt. Of course Mark Grable was there, talk about impressive, but I don't know if he ever studied with Jay.

The only thing I wasn't impressed with was the shack & forge Jay & students built to house the forge; but it was meant to be temporary in the back yard of the Arques School, so all is forgiven. :)

Pam

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#6

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes------WebKi

dburnard------WebKitFormBoundaryviieuGfbdP+NEiwS--

>I'll jump in too. I started taking classes from Jay back in 1990 I think. I had a few powertools and a set of crappy craftsman chisel-shaped-objects. I happened to walk by Hida Tool and found they has some classes on sharpening etc. That first class with Jay hooked me on hand sharpening and japanese tools even though I was terrible at it at first. Jay is a terrific teacher and his enthusuasm for the tools and their use is infectious.

Over the years I spent a few hours in Jay's classes, a few in the back room at Hida and then many later in Jay's shop. Always a great group of people learning from Jay and each other. You can read lots of books, but you'll learn so much more watching someone who knows what they are doing at work. Even better if they can then watch you work and help you correct your issues.

The key value of this video is that you get to watch Jay tune up and use a plane fresh from the toolstore in real time. Exactly what a novice japanese plane user needs to see before they head down the wrong path. And exactly what a more experienced user needs to see to start picking up on subtleties they may not yet have figured out. Like proper "ear" maintenance, tapping out, sharpening tips etc.

If you are going to pay $150+ for your first plane and another $100+ for stones and then more for a few chisels, a scraper plane etc - you'd be cheating yourself not to get this video.

You'll watch the plane setup steps many times over many years before you pick up all the subtleties.

Enjoy!

Dave

------WebKitFormBoundaryviieuGfbdP+NEiwS

------WebKitFormBoundarySeU+am24cI9NTaEM

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#7

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes------WebKi

dburnard------WebKitFormBoundaryviieuGfbdP+NEiwS--

>I'll chime in as well... An excellent video review by Wiley - there's a lot of info just in the review.

I started taking classes from Jay on 1990 or so, back then I knew nothing about hand sharpening or japanese tools. So much of what I've learned over the years came from Jay in his classes. Not just the facts, but an appreciation for the tools and their makers, and a completely different way of approaching woodworking than I had experienced previously.

In this video you get to see blade sharpening, plane setup and sole maintenance, and even tapping out the blade to maintain the hollow. Jay demonstrates it all in real time. In other words you get to watch him at work, just as he would in class, or if he was setting up a plane on his own. From the simple to the complex and subtle - it's all there for you to see and process.

For a beginner who just dropped $150+ on a decent plane, $100+ on stones, and another couple of hundred on a few chisels and a scraping plane - you'd be crazy to start tuning up that plane without this video. You can read about the processes in a book or magazine article, and that is helpful, but to really ground your thinking you need to see it done by someone who knows what they are doing.

For an experienced japanese plane user, the video is full of subtleties and techniques you should see to broaden your understanding of the setup and maintenance process. How many times have I watched a video of a toolmaker for the nth time and had an aha! moment. Doesn't matter how much or little you know, if you watch someone else at work, you'll learn something new.

Let's hope this is the first of a series of videos from Jay. Other topics worthy of study: more sharpening, japanese saws, layout with sumisashi and inkpot, cutting basic joinery. Wow the VanArsdale boxed set!

Dave

------WebKitFormBoundaryiEFGH+tjmcBPAQQL

------WebKitFormBoundaryhWsnp2SP+yIQ1FDA

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#8

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes

wilbur

>I think that Wiley's review is right on the mark, especially with his observation about Jay being comfortable in his own skin. I haven't met Jay personally, but I talked to him on the phone when the DVD first came out, and exchanged thoughts on my impression of the DVD. I mentioned to Jay that it seemed like the DVD was shot in the "set up two cameras and let's do this in one take" school of filmmaking. He told me that's pretty much what they did. :@)

If I had any criticism of Jay's DVD, it would be that there are times that close up pictures are used to illustrate a point, and I think that Jay's DVD could have used more of these. On the Daiku Dojo website photos I've seen the way that Jay uses diagrams in his classes, and it's clear that he uses these diagrams quite effectively when teaching his classes. Even so, this is a must have DVD for anyone wanting to give Japanese planes a try.

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#9

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes

wilbur

>Having bought a bunch of used Japanese planes from eBay, it also seems to me that many woodworkers in Japan don't maintain the back of the plane blade as carefully as they could.

On the other hand, in Toshio Odate's book, there's a picture of him illustrating how to maintain the back of a Japanese plane blade, and the sides of the hollow of his plane blade come in quite a bit from the edge. It's not as much as the worst case scenario Japanese plane blades that I've seen on eBay, but it's more than the plane blade that I have been using the most.

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#10

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes

amelon

>Hi Wiley,

I would describe Jay as a "straight shooter." A while back, someone described Jay to me using these words. I had to look it up in the dictionary and had also concluded, "Yes, it's a perfect description of 'Da Man'."

It must be very difficult to make a living without relying much on machines. Jay uses his share of machines although it is quite limited compared to other professional woodworkers. In his shop, there's just a small 12" planer, 6" jointer, and table saw primarily for dimensioning lumber. Then there are a few hand-operated power tools like the Makita groover and drill. Everything else, like mortise and tenon for example, he does by hands. Much of the shop space is taken up by the large workbench which you see in the video.

I was reading James Krenov's foreword in "The Impractical Woodworker" where he talked about the urge to share knowledge (as if it were an obligation). I see the same desire in Jay. There is no secret, even in Japanese hand tools and techniques where there seems to be a shroud of mystery and secrets. He demystifies it, like you mentioned. In our class, questions are usually met with answers, else "I don't know, but let's find out..." or, "Let me know what you find out..."

I've known Jay for almost 5 years and I'm humbled to call him a teacher and a friend.

- Bob

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#11

Watching

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>So true, what you said about needing to watch someone who knows what they're doing, to get your own thinking grounded. Learning through our senses, rather than by intellect alone.

Like you, I hope Jay keeps it up. I would really love to see one on saws and sawing particularly.

Different subject--how about showing us some of your smithing stuff.

Wiley

Re: New Video Review -- Japanese Planes *LINK*

#12

Re: Watching

dburnard

>Forge has been quiet for a while, other than a high school student or two learning some basics this spring. Hope to be back at it this winter.