Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Marcou Planes

Posts

Marcou Planes

#1

Marcou Planes

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Ellis, et al, :o)

I am trying to see if I can get some good information. Because I am just unsure as to how many people actually own one of Philip's planes I am also going to post this on several other boards where I am a member.

Okay, with that out of the way here is what I am looking for. A very good friend of mine on another board just ordered a S20A from Philip. I am also extremely interested in a Marcou plane and in particular the S55A. My question is does anyone on this board own a Marcou and would they be so kind as to post what you have and perhaps how it performs in relationship to a Lie-Nielsen, Veritas, etc.

To give you a bit of a background I have slowly over the last few years moved to the hand tool side of woodworking and absolutely enjoying it. The lack of sawdust, noise, the feel of the wood, etc. all of the things that you all know so well. At this point I have approx. 25 LN planes and seven Veritas. I have really become a LN junkie and because of that it is so hard for me to believe that the Marcou can perform all that much better. I do understand the beauty and the one off production of each plane and that alone is almost enough for me to pull the trigger.

I want to thank whomever may be able to help. Just as an aside I kind of liken many of the planes made today like the Groz, Anant and the non sweetheart Stanley's of the last few years as a Ford. I se the LN, Clifton's & Veritas as Mercedes, BMWs and Lexus in no particular order. I then see the Marcou, Sauer and Steiner and Holtey as well as the other super high end planes as Lamborghini's Ferrari's and Bugatti's. Does this type of rating if you will make sense?

Thank you again,

Fred

Re: Marcou Planes

#2

I don't own yet, but have used a Marcou.

Chuck Nickerson

>I think in terms of performance, the BMW-to-Bugatti jump may be misleading. My several hours of experience left me feeling the performance improvements are at the extremes (e.g. wild grain); in the corners, if you will. In buying the Marcou or similar, you're really supporting a rare level of craftsmanship. I look forward to doing that some day.

Re: Marcou Planes

#3

Re: Marcou Planes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Your rating system only works if your primary purpose is to have your buddy's eyes pop when you tell him which planes you have. And that assumes your buddy has the same system.

Why do you need so many planes? Please tell me half of them are molding, beading, and H&R's.

Pam

Re: Marcou Planes

#4

makes sense to me

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I have never fondled a Marcou, or Holtey, et al, but I have drooled over, fondled, spindled, not mutilated and briefly used a Wayne Anderson plane. It is so MUCH better than anything else in my arsenal, it's hard to describe. If nothing else, just the way it felt was superb.

Bruce

Re: Marcou Planes

#5

Re: Marcou Planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Fred,

Follow your gut. Get the Marcou plane. You'll never know if you don't. You'll always wonder.

Personal thought.... Things I want near me are things I have warm feelings for. The warm feeling may be a personal bond, admiration for the maker, the fact somebody made it, its heft or balance, or some deep-down quality I can't put my finger on. A favorite chisel is an old Japanese 36mm paring chisel by Kiyotada, one of the old Tokyo smiths. It was abused and the hollow almost ground away to restore it to use. It's an odd shape--square sided. Little too hard, but it does get incredibly sharp as a result. It's a dead matte black with zero ornament. Has clearance--the shank and handle just clear the work. Weld and side-wrap are tidy and perfect. I can see that old smith making this chisel the way he knew how to make them, his mind empty of everything else.

Just go for it.

Wiley

Re: Marcou Planes

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Marcou Planes

Moses Yoder

>I am not really familiar with Marcou but have seen some of Saur & Steiner's work up close. In reality I think a Bedrock plane could be made to function just as well as a hand made infill plane, since the function of a plane is simply based on blade angle, sharpness of the iron, width of mouth, and a secure bedding for the iron. So if you buy a Marcou plane thinking it will out perform your L-N's you might be disappointed, since the greatest percentage of a plane's function depends on how well you are able to sharpen the iron. If you buy one for it's looks and the fact it was hand made with loving care by an artiste you will definitely be happy.

The Lamborghini I think can go much faster safely than a VW Rabbit can, so in that sense I think it will outperform it physically and also mechanically so far as the quality of the parts used. There is a huge difference in performance between different makes of cars, but not so much in hand planes because the plane is such a simple tool while the car is much more complex.

Re: Marcou Planes

#7

Re: Marcou Planes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The Lamborghini I think can go much faster safely than a VW Rabbit can

Depends just as much on the driver as does hand plane performance.

Pam

Re: Marcou Planes

#8

Re: I don't own yet, but have used a Marcou.

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Chuck,

Thank you very much. I really appreciate the feedback as I have not been able to get my hands on one so to some extent I am going to have to rely on feedback like yours as well as the really good review that Derek Cohen wrote on them about three years ago.

Fred

Re: Marcou Planes

#9

Re: makes sense to me

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Bruce,

I too was able to briefly do everything you said about the Wayne Anderson plane. However, I feel as if Philip somehow got a hold of some of my DNA and implanted it into his planes. :o) Pam, I own so many planes first because I love them and secondly because I use them. And I use every one of them. Several are set up for a single use and I like having it that way.

Fred

Re: Marcou Planes

#10

Re: Marcou Planes

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Wiley,

Thank you and I have to say that the odds right now are very high that I will go for it. Just as you were saying I am absolutely drawn to these planes and I have to say that over the last few months I have been emailing with Philip and he could not be nicer or more generous with his time and help. I think so far I have probably just given him agita with all of my questions and dilly dallying. However, I think I am just reaching the point where I can no longer put this decision off. Pretty sad/wonderful when you dream about a hand plane. :o)

Fred

Re: Marcou Planes

#11

Re: Marcou Planes  *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

> My question is does anyone on this board own a Marcou and would they be so kind as to post what you have and perhaps how it performs in relationship to a Lie-Nielsen, Veritas, etc.

Hi Fred

You have to keep in mind the law of diminishing returns. As the cost of a plane (such as this) goes up, the performance does not follow in the same way. Further, there are a number of factors involved in obtaining performance, one of which is simply to sharpen the blade!

I am assuming that cost is not an issue, and that the looks of Philip's planes attract you. These are personal factors.

OK, the bottom line for performance is that you can only measure this on wood that exacts the type of performance you seek. There will be no difference on the wood surface with a Marcou and a Stanley Handyman if the wood used was straight grained clear pine. You will see the difference on woods with interlinked, reversing grain, such as found on many exotics. The ability of a plane to cope with reversing grain is going to separate the men from the boys.

So let's say that you have the exotic wood and you have a Marcou (such as the one I own - link below,) set with a high cutting angle, as well as a LN # 4 1/2 (with a high angle frog) and a Veritas BUS, also set with a high cutting angle ... which would perform best?

There is no doubt in my mind that the Marcou would make the task the easiest. That is the simple answer. It is not a complete answer since you may not, nevertheless, enjoy using it. We choose planes for many reasons, one of which is feel and comfort. The Marcou is a Heavy Beast. It is quite different in feel from a light plane - the BUS is quite a lightweight by comparison. This may not detract since the Marcou has the ability to gain momentum and glide along, and with little apparent effort leave a glossy, perfect finish in its wake. This is a plane that I use as my reference. I have not come across another plane that reaches its performance (keeping in mind that there are many premium planes that I have not used).


Link to review below. Apologies for the poorer quality of the images - this is due to the artyicle being copied from one website to another. I will replace them.

Regards from Perth

Derek


The Marcou S15/BU Smoother

Re: Marcou Planes

#12

Re: Marcou Planes

ThomD

>And that review starts out

"Philip Marcou is a recent arrival in the planemaking arena with but a few production planes to his name to date"

So what can one say about that? Not the description I would expect to compare to a Lambo.

Performance is a pretty wide field. Lets say you were after a super plane, should it:

- Produce a finish finer than any other plane that you have, but is still in need of sanding for evenness and finishing for the requirements of the object;

- Take a finer shaving than any other plane you have;

- Take a thicker shaving than any similar plane you own with no real world decline in the utility of the surface produced

- Be most forgiving of beginer mistakes;

- Work for the longest period without requiring sharpening or other adjustments;

- Be capable of the widest range of working cuts;

etc...

Re: Marcou Planes

#13

Re: Marcou Planes

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Moses,

I certainly understand what you are saying but I think that in this case based upon the review I read by Derek Cohen, the people that I have spoken with or have written to me that there may actually be more of a difference than I expected to hear about and it is good. Please realize and Pam, you can wrap me across the head but at this point my heart is as involved if not more so than the logic that is going along as well.

Fred

Re: Marcou Planes

#14

Re: Marcou Planes

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Derek,

Thank you again. One of my favorite planes is my LN #8 which is a 10 pound beast. I love the way it too glides through the toughest grain. It amazes me that Philip's S15A is over eight pounds. Should you happen to be coming to the Philadelphia area anytime soon please feel free to bring your Marcou. :o)

Fred

Re: Marcou Planes

#15

Re: Marcou Planes

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I understand, having experienced my own tool lusts; but comparing tools to expensive cars is not useful and ultimately disappointing. It's much more useful to ask what a tool will allow you to do that you couldn't otherwise, as Derek and some others have so aptly pointed out.

Pam, who hasn't a clue how many planes she has :)

Re: Marcou Planes

#16

Plane counts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"Pam, who hasn't a clue how many planes she has :)"

I finally stopped counting mine - I realized that, if I knew, I'd have to answer if LOML ever asked, "So how many of those things do you HAVE anyway?" Now, I can just say, "Oh, some."

Re: Marcou Planes

#17

Re: Plane counts

Victor Parisian

>I haven't a clue either, I keep mine spread around my shop from one end to the other. Rationalizations: 1) accountant wife can't count them; 2) in event of break in, burglars only find a few; 3) there is usually one within reach where ever I am in the shop.

David Letterman where are you? I need help on the next 7 to make this a top ten list.

Victor

Re: Marcou Planes

#18

Re: Plane counts

Fred West in West Chester, PA

>Victor,

4)planes can be used as a paperweight for your cut list, 5)planes can be used late at night so as to not wake up accountant wife, 6) planes can be used to make something for accountant wife who then okays payment for new plane.:o)

Fred

Re: Marcou Planes

#19

Ellis Walentine

Stop over when you get it, Fred

Ellis Walentine

>I'd love to see you and play with that new toy. :-)

Ellis