Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

A good product *LINK*

Posts

A good product *LINK*

#1

A good product *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Am in the midst of putting together a small bench for a small location, and want to thank all those offering suggestions.

For a base, I ended up with Lee Valley's Cast Iron Table Legs, linked below. These turn out to be stout and satisfying. I can highly recommend them if they meet your functional need. Wilbur's suggestion--thanks Wilbur!

The only thing you have to do to get up and running is make the stretcher that connects the two leg assemblies, and then screw on a top. I face-glued two 2x6's to make the stretcher, and it is very stout--zero movement. The stretcher has to have a center channel (~13/16" square) to take the tensioning rod and connector nut. I used a soft wood (redwood) which is easy to hand plough for the channel--would not have been much fun with hardwood, but that old 19th century plough was lots of fun with the soft wood. McMaster Carr delivered the top, 2-1/4" maple, and it turned out well. Very flat, and while it's finger-jointed butcher block, the outside strips on the long sides are continuous (not jointed). I can recommend this top if you have a similar need. John Boos & Co. is original supplier. Will be adding an LV twin-screw vise on the end. Making the wrap-around apron now.

Observation and mini-rant: Lee Valley ships these cast iron legs with the basic hardware for attaching a top. The heavy screws for the top are #3 Robertson (square drive). Folks, I can't for the life of me understand why square drive Robertson's did not become the universal standard. They are so much better than Phillips, it's ridiculous. They do not cam out. Drive these larger ones with a brace.

Wiley


LV cast iron table/bench legs

Re: A good product *LINK*

#2

Square Drive

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I believe is illustrated in Smith's Key, 1816.

Stephen

Re: A good product *LINK*

#3

You're right!!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Stephen,

Super observation! There was a Sheffield square drive screw in 1816. Mr. Robertson got his patent in 1909. Perhaps it's Canadian, because USPTO's first filing by Robertson Mfg. Co. was in 1969.

Wonder when 'prior art' is considered to have begun?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: A good product *LINK*

#4

There is a difference!!

Brent Smith in Montreal

>Robertson screws have a tapered recess to hold the screw to the bit better. Square drive screws don't have this.

Re: A good product *LINK*

#5

Re: There is a difference!!

MikeW

>Actually, having used both, I would say Robertson's tapered improvement had to do with speed of the bit entering with little compromise to driving integrity.

Mike

Re: A good product *LINK*

#6

Yabbut!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Why didn't they catch on? They're great. IMO.

Wiley

Re: A good product *LINK*

#7

Re: Yabbut!

Dean J in MN

>Could it be because the reason the phillips is still the winner is due to its initial design criteria -- to cam out?

On an assembly line they want the driver to cam out. We don't like it at home, but that isn't what they were designed for.

Re: A good product *LINK*

#8

Re: Yabbut!

wilbur

>I've always heard that Robertson was too restrictive and wanted too much in royalties with his licensing, which is why his design never really caught on -- no one wanted to try to make and sell a more expensive screw, even if it did work better.

I agree that they are just great.

Re: A good product *LINK*

#9

Re: Yabbut!

Brent Smith in Montreal

>I seem to remember something about Henry Ford and Robertson. IIRC, they couldn't come to an agreement over who would retain the rights to the screw and Ford buried Robertson by turning to Phillips head screws instead.

Re: A good product *LINK*

#10

Re: A good product

Marv

>The reason the tapered recess doesn't cam out is because the taper maintains a tight fit with the driver and the harder you push, the tighter it gets. Great idea.

Marv

Re: A good product *LINK*

#11

camming

paul womack

>The reason the tapered recess doesn't cam out is because the taper maintains a tight fit with the driver and the harder you push, the tighter it gets. Great idea.

If you push hard enough, a Phillips won't cam out either - although it'll try!

BugBear

Re: A good product *LINK*

#12

square drive

Howard Pollack

>I've been using square drive wood screws for years and much prefer them to Phillips headed. Using a brace with the proper bit in it makes them easy drive and you can get great torque. -Howard

Re: A good product *LINK*

#13

Re: camming

Marv

>I couldn't tell you how many times I have stripped the head of a phillips screw when trying to remove one. Some of them are just badly made. Even a new phillips screwdriver won't fit them properly. Use a phillips screwdriver that is a bit dull, forget it no matter how much pressure is applied.

Having said that, they are a lot better than any slotted screw head. But a phillips is no comparison to a tapered squared recessed head. A tapered square recessed screw head can be any size. Even on bolt heads.

The phillips screw head was designed primarily for production assembly work with the use of power screw drivers. Screw it in and to hell with anyone having to unscrew it.

There's a type of phillips screw that is called a Posi-drive head. It is designed to cinch onto the end of a special phillips type screw driver and not fall off. This type of screw is usually made of stainless steel. A regular phillips screw driver will not fit this type screw. The fit between the screw and the special screw driver is a precise fit and is less apt to cam or slip out.

Marv

Re: A good product *LINK*

#14

Yep!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Howard, that's what I do too, if I don't have match the screws already there or make it look historically correct. That's also why I like the Yankee 2100 and 2101 braces--the ratchet action is so light that you can start the screw in tight quarters and the ratchet won't back it out--only need a 1/4-turn.

Wiley

Re: A good product *LINK*

#15

I like slotted head screws & old screwdrivers.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: A good product *LINK*

#16

Me too!

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: A good product *LINK*

#17

Straight slot screws--old and new--questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Pam and Stephen and all,

Straight slots do have that iconic look and are historically correct for so many things....

I have a question, though. The old slotted screws I come across (on plough plane skates, for example, or other old tools) seem to be harder than any wood screw I come across nowadays at the hardware store. So the big problem I have with slotted screws is that I have a screwdriver (I note that Pam specified 'old' screw driver) which doesn't exactly fit, driving what appears to be an unhardened screw.

Questions: Are the old screws harder than modern wood screws, or am I imagining this? Where can you find a straight slot screwdriver that exactly fits the slotted screw you're trying to drive?

Wiley

Re: A good product *LINK*

#18

Re: Straight slot screws--old and new--questions

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>You have to fix your screwdrivers (sometimes the old ones come fixed) so they sit tightly in the slot. So I kind of hollow grind a bit in back of the edge. Screwdrivers these days are sold set up the exactly wrong way, with the edge tapered thinner.

As far as screws in old tools, I've never had any particular problem. Of course, I spend no time resurrecting old metal planes.

Pam

Re: A good product *LINK*

#19

Re: Straight slot screws--old and new--questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I read somewhere once that wood screws and machine screws have different specifications for the slots, and that most screwdrivers other than the cool British turnscrews are built for machine screws.

Like Pam, I've found it necessary to regrind screwdrivers to fit wood screws at times, though I confess I don't use slotted wood screws much. I agree that they're aesthetically more pleasing, and would probably track them down if/when I ever get to making furniture to which I might apply the adjective "fine;" but in the meantime, Phillips screws are simpler, and Robertson or square screws OK too. My son's slowly getting me started using some of the Torx-bit screws, which, if anything, are even more startlingly odd when visible than square; but they sure drive easily.

Re: A good product *LINK*

#20

Re: Straight slot screws--old and new--questions

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Wiley,

You may be imagining things or modern mild steel screws are softer than the old wrought iron screws? The slots vary on old screws as they are all hand cut. I have seen deep and wide slots as well as narrow and shallow and all variations in between.

As for a proper fitting screwdriver or turnscrew, I would suggest a set from Joel of cabinet screw drivers, the English style with oval handles and a flat place for a wrench on the upper shank near the ferrule. I use a wrench regularly when removing old screws.

It is critical that the screwdriver 'exactly' fits the slot in width and thickness, so you need several in order not to bugger up the slot. A number of years ago I did a treatise on screw removal, I should dust it off and get it into print.

Stephen

Re: A good product *LINK*

#21

Re: Straight slot screws--old and new--questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Stephen,

Thanks for the lead on Joel's screwdrivers.

I'm pretty sure the old screws I'm talking about aren't wrought iron, but then they aren't that old. Post Civil War, say 1870 and on.

Wiley

Re: A good product *LINK*

#22

Re: Straight slot screws--old and new--questions

Dan Donaldson

>I am not too fond of the torx, at least in the larger sizes. My bike uses a lot of them and they really feel squirrelly when you try to get out a tight one with loctite on it.

Re: A good product *LINK*

#23

slot fit

paul womack

>Where can you find a straight slot screwdriver that exactly fits the slotted screw you're trying to drive?

Whilst old wood screws seem to be fairly standard, there seem to be a lot of non-standard screws out there.

In particular, some large headed screws (esp saw screws) have disproportionately narrow slots.

My solution is a large number of ground-by-me screwdrivers, which fit perfectly.

Fortunately screwdrivers-for-grinding are cheap and numerous in the s/h market.

There seems to be active debate wether a screwdriver should be a taper fit or a parallel fit in the slot.

The argument hinges on the practical impossibility of getting a perfect parallel fit. This mean that (in practise) the scrwedriver only touches the screw at either "end" of the tip. Whereas a tapered tip that doesn't go all the way to the bottom of the slot is fully engaged all the way across the slot.

BugBear

Re: A good product *LINK*

#24

Just the start of the question. It seems to me...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>That the correct hole matters most of all. If it's a tapered screw, use a tapered bit. DUH!

Seems to me people are not remembering the facts.

Re: A good product *LINK*

#25

Re: Yabbut! *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Wiley

Unfortunately just because one product is the better one, it may not win over the marketplace. There are often political and business influences at work to force the market place hands. The story of this lowly square drive screw, Robertson screw, being its proper correct name, is a good example.

As the story goes, PL Robertson came up with the idea after slipping and cutting his hand while demonstrating a slot screwdriver/screw.

His little invention revolutionized the fastener industry. He could mass produced both drivers and screws using die, faster, more efficiently (less operations)and his screws could held at the end of the driver (try that with a slot or phillips)by itself, and practically eliminated camout. HINT if you do experienced cam out using a square drive screw, try using a good quality screw, and the proper Robertson driver...That small taper is there for a reason.

Perhaps because PL recognized a good thing when he saw one, he tenaciously refuse to share his rights and wanted to keep control of his screws. Henry Ford recognized the potential, and wanted to get exclusive rights over his invention. PL refused, and Henry went on to use the Phillips instead.

Notwitstanding numerous efforts to wipe him out, today PL Robertson screws are a commun staple in Canada, and his company still exist.

and the Roberston screw hold 85% of the Fastener market in Canada, but only 10% in the States.

Everyone here is familiar with the standard Robertson color code: No 1 Green (small) No 2 Red(Medium)and No 3 Black (Large).

Less known, and seen, are the No 0 (yellow) and No 00 (Orange)

For years it was easy to tell if a product was made here: If it used Robertson screws, it was Made in Canada.

Coast to coast (accross 4 and a half time zones), if you walk into any hardware stores, you will find Robertson screws on the shelves.

See also http://tinyurl.com/myz8ag


Greatest Canadian invention??