Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al
Alex Yeilding
>Derek just posted a great article on shooting boards, which repeats an often-made claim that I don't buy (or maybe just don't understand, as is often the case):
The slight skew imparted by the ramped board is too low to be compared with the skewed blade of a #51 shooting board plane, but it was enough to enable the blade to enter the wood with a slight slicing action, and that this was significant.
I think the difference felt is not a slicing action at all, but rather that the blade is entering a corner of the workpiece, not an entire face. So there is a few thousandths inch "slow start" effect cushioning the impact. After that, you are cutting a very slightly thicker piece (as seen by the blade) for a very slightly shorter distance.
As a thought experiment, consider trimming the end of a 1" round dowel with an unskewed blade. Will the blade care whether the dowel is rested on a ramped or unramped board? I think clearly not. How about two 1/2" dowels side-by-side? Now think of the model of wood as a bundle of soda straws. The blade meets each straw at 90 degrees from the blade edge, whether the workpiece is sitting on a ramped board or not, just as it cuts the 1" dowel the same whichever board it is on.
Another way to look at this is to take the workpiece off the shooting board and put it in a vise. To duplicate the motion of a plane on an unramped board, you would run the plane straight down the end surface of the board, with the plane aligned with the board. To duplicate the action of a ramped board, you would slew the plane but still push the plane perpendicular to the blade edge.
If you wanted to lower the effective angle of attack, after slewing the plane, you would not push it perpendicular to the blade edge, but rather parallel to the edges of the workpiece, presenting the blade at an angle less than 90 degrees from its direction of travel, effectively skewing the blade.
To duplicate this skewing action with the shooting board, you would need not to angle the work, but rather to change the angle of the blade relative to its direction of travel, which could be done with a ramped plane carrier. If there were a wedge with provision for registering the plane to the wedge and the wedge to the shooting board, this would accomplish a skewed or slicing cut, at considerably more effort than using a plane with a skewed blade.
The argument above, if correct, in no way negates other benefits of a ramped board: entering the work at a corner, and using more of the width of the blade thus extending time between sharpening.






