Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

Posts

Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#1

Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

Alex Yeilding

>Derek just posted a great article on shooting boards, which repeats an often-made claim that I don't buy (or maybe just don't understand, as is often the case):

The slight skew imparted by the ramped board is too low to be compared with the skewed blade of a #51 shooting board plane, but it was enough to enable the blade to enter the wood with a slight slicing action, and that this was significant.

I think the difference felt is not a slicing action at all, but rather that the blade is entering a corner of the workpiece, not an entire face. So there is a few thousandths inch "slow start" effect cushioning the impact. After that, you are cutting a very slightly thicker piece (as seen by the blade) for a very slightly shorter distance.

As a thought experiment, consider trimming the end of a 1" round dowel with an unskewed blade. Will the blade care whether the dowel is rested on a ramped or unramped board? I think clearly not. How about two 1/2" dowels side-by-side? Now think of the model of wood as a bundle of soda straws. The blade meets each straw at 90 degrees from the blade edge, whether the workpiece is sitting on a ramped board or not, just as it cuts the 1" dowel the same whichever board it is on.

Another way to look at this is to take the workpiece off the shooting board and put it in a vise. To duplicate the motion of a plane on an unramped board, you would run the plane straight down the end surface of the board, with the plane aligned with the board. To duplicate the action of a ramped board, you would slew the plane but still push the plane perpendicular to the blade edge.

If you wanted to lower the effective angle of attack, after slewing the plane, you would not push it perpendicular to the blade edge, but rather parallel to the edges of the workpiece, presenting the blade at an angle less than 90 degrees from its direction of travel, effectively skewing the blade.

To duplicate this skewing action with the shooting board, you would need not to angle the work, but rather to change the angle of the blade relative to its direction of travel, which could be done with a ramped plane carrier. If there were a wedge with provision for registering the plane to the wedge and the wedge to the shooting board, this would accomplish a skewed or slicing cut, at considerably more effort than using a plane with a skewed blade.

The argument above, if correct, in no way negates other benefits of a ramped board: entering the work at a corner, and using more of the width of the blade thus extending time between sharpening.

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#2

Ramp, skew, slice, and gravity

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alex and all,

It's an interesting problem. In looking at the effects of geometry, I'm inclined (pun intended) to think that the 5 degree ramp angle may be more significant than the 20 degree skew--and due to gravity. Just based on a few figures given below....

No question, the ramp is providing easy-start. The skewed blade is also providing easy-start, and also what might be called a slicing action.

Suggested definition: Slicing occurs when a bit of grain is severed by a width of blade which is greater than its own diameter. Example: On the ramped shooting board, a bundle of straws of end grain with diameter 1mm is severed by 1mm width of blade. But if the plane blade is skewed, that same 1mm of end grain will be severed by a width of blade greater than 1mm. But getting down to cases, a 20 degree skew will slice the 1mm of end grain with a blade width of 1.06mm--so how much slicing is really happening if the skew only brings 6% more blade into play on a given bundle of end grain? At 30% skew, 15% more blade is brought into play--still not very remarkable.

Slicing Equation: The width of blade cutting a unit amount of end grain is given by the secant of the skew angle. Secant = 1/cosine.

Another effect of skew is the lowering of the attack angle, which as Derek said is significant when cutting end grain. But again, a 20 degree skew doesn't do much lowering of the effective angle. For example, consider a plane bedded at 45 degrees. With no skew, it is cutting at 45 degrees. With a 20 degree skew, it is cutting at a little over 43 degrees--not very dramatic. If the skew were increased to 45 degrees, you'd have an effective cutting angle of 35 degrees, which is beginning to get somewhere, but 20 degree skew doesn't have much of a lowering effect.

Equation: Tan (effective angle) = cos (skew angle) x tan (bedding angle). As a special case, 45 degree bedded planes have tan(bedding angle) = 1, so that factor drops out and simplifies things.

Summary: 20 degrees of skew increases slicing by 6% and lowers the effective cutting angle by about 2 degrees. I'm inclined to think that the 5 degrees of ramp is at least as significant in the perceived cutting efficiency--and mainly due to gravity.

Wiley

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#3

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et a

wilbur

>I was once involved in a discussion about whether a ramped shooting board duplicates the effect of a skewed plane blade in the sense of lowering the effective cutting angle, and my conclusion was also that it did not. I've attached a diagram that will hopefully explain why.

As Alex said, it's not the ramp that affects the effective cutting angle, but whether the plane blade is traveling perpendicular to the edge of the blade. With a ramped shooting board, the plane enters at a corner of the board, but still travels perpendicular to the edge of the blade. Take away the ramp and expand the sides of the board, and you'll get a situation that is identical to pushing a plane straight along a board.


img

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#4

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et a

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

I thought the ramp was raised in the rear, but the material was flat.

I need to dig around and find the pic for Derek's board, I might be visualizing something that it is not.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#5

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et a

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

This would have the same effect, AFAICT, that I was thinking.

In this case where the work is raised in the front, it does apply the force to keep the work in the bottom/front stop. This would catch the upper rear edge of the work and apply force into the front stop

Surely that must have some effect on the cut as the fibers are being cut at a skew, no?

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#6

ok, one thing I don't understand about your image

Alan DuBoff

>Wilbur,

In your image it says that the ramped board is the same as a non-skewed cut...but there is clearly some visible skew in the image.

How do you figure? It is cutting at a skew, AFAICT, no????

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#7

Re: Ramp, skew, slice, and gravity

Alex Yeilding

>Wiley, thanks for this contribution to this inquiry. A couple of comments and questions:

Suggested definition: Slicing occurs when a bit of grain is severed by a width of blade which is greater than its own diameter.

I think that definition makes sense, and is equivalent to the statement that the blade is traveling in a direction not perpendicular to the edge. "skewing" and "slicing" are just two qualitative ways of describing the same action. I tend to think of "slicing" in this context as the component of the blade's motion parallel to the edge, creating a kind of "sawing" effect at the VERY small scale of edge irregularities.

Another effect of skew is the lowering of the attack angle, which as Derek said is significant when cutting end grain. But again, a 20 degree skew doesn't do much lowering of the effective angle. For example, consider a plane bedded at 45 degrees. With no skew, it is cutting at 45 degrees. With a 20 degree skew, it is cutting at a little over 43 degrees--not very dramatic.

Thanks for doing this. This is what I always assumed the big effect of skewing to be, but had never put pencil to paper on it. I was shocked at how small a difference you were getting. So much so that I thought you must have made an error. But I did the calculations independently and absolutely agree (forgive my skepticism). When I plane and slew the plane, in a difficult area, I turn it more like 45 degrees or more, which does have a significant effect. Now I see why I tend to slew it so much. This has made me rethink what advantage a skewed blade can give.

I'm inclined to think that the 5 degrees of ramp is at least as significant in the perceived cutting efficiency--and mainly due to gravity.

Okay, now you've stumped me. What the heck effect can gravity have on the difference between a ramped and unramped board?

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#8

Worth a thousand words!

Alex Yeilding

>Thanks. That is exactly the mental picture I had in trying to describe taking the workpiece off of the shooting board and putting it in a vise, then duplicating the action.

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#9

Re: Ramp, skew, slice, and gravity

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Alex,

In regard to 'gravity', it reflects that i don't understand what the ramped shooting board is doing. I just looked at photos provided by Alan Duboff, which shows that the effect of the ramp is to tilt the work up, but the plane is still travelling on the flat. I was somehow under the impression that it was the other way around, and that the plane was travelling downhill and the work was 'flat'--which strikes me as the way it should be done, though it would be tricky to arrange fencing for the plane!

So my bad.

Wiley....wondering if Derek tilted the whole contraption up a bit so it's all aimed downhill, whether it would work even better (<:)

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#10

Re: Ramp, skew, slice, and gravity

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Maybe the problem we're having is that such close cutting action is driven by quantum mechanics whereas we're speaking classical physics. Try it in string theory?

Pam

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#11

Re: ok, one thing I don't understand about your im

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi Alan,

The plane is "skewed" with respect to the board (at an angle, not parallel), but the planing angle remains perpendicular to the plane itself. You could rotate the plane as much as you want (i.e. increase the ramp angle), but the planing angle will always change with the rotation and remain 90 degrees to the cutting edge. If you continue to rotate the plane, you will end up planing the board from side to side, but the cut will still not be skewed. For a true skewed cut, the plane would have to continue cutting parallel to the board (with the plane body rotated).

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#12

Just having a little trouble

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>with uphill and downhill, is all. That other stuff is no problem.

Wiley..... lessee, which way is up, now?

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#13

Re: ok, one thing I don't understand about your im

Alan DuBoff

>You are still cutting the fiber at a skew, i.e., the edge is not perpendicular to the work. You don't think that will have some effect on the results?

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#14

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et a

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>As Alex said, it's not the ramp that affects the effective cutting angle, but whether the plane blade is traveling perpendicular to the edge of the blade. With a ramped shooting board, the plane enters at a corner of the board, but still travels perpendicular to the edge of the blade. Take away the ramp and expand the sides of the board, and you'll get a situation that is identical to pushing a plane straight along a board


Hi Wilbur

Here is my version ...


Let's zoom in on the cutting area ...


The image is poor (drawn in Paint), but you can see the blade entering the wood progressively. That is all I am referring to as the advantage of the ramped shooting board - this progressive cut at the start effects a smoother entry.

"Progressive cut" is probably the correct terminonology here. When I compare this progessive cut to a flat cut, there is clearly an advantage to the former. Add to the progressive cut a skew blade (ala #51), then you have the ideal set up for a shooting board. Is it necessary? No. It is simply the ideal.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#15

Re: ok, one thing I don't understand about your im

wilbur

>Hi Alan,

Sorry for not being more clear. I think that the problem is that the word "skew" is used to mean two different things: planing diagonally across a board, and pushing the plane so that the direction of travel is not perpendicular to the edge of the blade.

With the board on the ramp, the plane blade does hit the corner of the board first. So it is skewed in that sense. It can certainly make planing the board easier, since you're staring at a corner.

If you skew a plane so that it is not traveling perpendicular to the edge of the blade, as in the top diagram, that would also make planing a bit easier, because you lower the effective cutting angle of the plane.

What I was trying to show is that putting a board on a ramped shooting board does not change the effective cutting angle of the plane blade. I see that my diagram has the ramp going the opposite way as Derek's board (oops), but the point remains the same.

To show this, start with the third diagram, with the board on the ramp. In the fourth diagram, I imagine that the shooting board is taken away, and that the board is stretched so that the sides are now square with the plane. Now you have a situation that is identical to the second diagram.

So if the ramped shooting board lowered the effective cutting angle of the plane, then the effective cutting angle would remain low in the fourth diagram, since you haven't moved the plane at all. But the fourth diagram is identical to the second diagram, and no one would ever say that the plane in the second diagram has a cutting angle other than what the plane blade is bedded at. So the conclusion must be that the ramped shooting board maintains the same effective cutting angle of the plane blade.

If the ramp did change the effective cutting angle of the plane, then that means that the effective cutting angle changes with the geometric configuration of the sides of the board, which is silly, of course.

Hope that was more clear!

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#16

Re: Ramp, skew, slice, and gravity

wilbur

>What if the board being planed has a wormhole in it?

*rimshot*

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#17

Re: Ramp, skew, slice, and gravity

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I routinely see tiny black holes clustered around wormholes, swirling and twirling; but these are big physics stuff.

Pam

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#18

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et a

Gary Roberts

>But, and there always is a but... take a look at the angle of the blade relative to the top or bottom face of the workpiece. The blade is now at a slightly skewed angle. In some old book, the recommendation for a ramped shooting board had more to do with using the whole width of the iron than with skewing the blade. This made for even wear on that valuable hunk of metal.

Gary

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#19

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et a

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

> .. the recommendation for a ramped shooting board had more to do with using the whole width of the iron than with skewing the blade. This made for even wear on that valuable hunk of metal.

Hi Gary

You are reading too many books! :)

I really don't buy this as a reason for a ramped board. The ramp angle is too slight, and the blade wears in a narrow range.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#20

And just think (OT)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>if it weren't for Star Trek and other good science fiction shows, that bad pun might never have occurred to you.

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et al

#21

Re: Ramped shooting board vs skew ? for Derek et a

Gary Roberts

>Derek

True, I read too many books. If it wasn't for the existance of books, I wouldn't have to read so much.

I find it fascinating to track down the reality or relevance of myths. Perhaps that's the librarian in me. It's when myths become 'fact' that I question their validity.

Gary