Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

Posts

Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#1

Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>There's a Tutankhamen exhibit at the DeYoung in San Francisco (and, somehow, a simultaneous one at the Children's Museum of Indianapolis; also, one of the exhibits moves on to the Art Gallery of Ontario in Toronto in November). LOML and I went today.

She found all kinds of interesting pottery-related things; you'd think she'd been a potter for over 20 years or something...

Me, I was struck by how many of the statues and other objects are of wood. Generally, the quality of the work is phenomenal (especially considering that they were using copper tools), and the condition of the pieces just as amazing (they ARE 3500 years old after all). Some of the low relief carvings were maybe 1/8" high, or even less, and the ground of the carvings was very very smooth. On one statue, maybe 18" high, you could see the toenails and those little wrinkles toes have at the knuckles. Most wood pieces were coated with gesso, which would tend to smooth over tearout; but even with that, a modern carver would be proud to do work like that. A lot of gold leaf that was so smooth, you could imagine seeing undistorted reflections in it.

On the other hand, I saw some issues that I struggle with: one funerary boat model, which was a solid carving, had some dead vertical end grain where the foredeck and quarterdeck (using Age of Sail terminology here - not sure what the Egyptians would have called it) stepped down to the main deck, and there was lots of tearout, where the wood fibers collapsed from the chisel. Insufficient sharpening, coupled with wood with fibers that wouldn't stand up to the side pressure.

Various woods - some pieces, with some rot or other damage, were clearly a softwood of some kind that resembled second growth redwood. Someone suggested cedar, and, when I researched it on the 'Net, there was discussion of Lebanese cedar. Other pieces looked to be some kind of very fine grain hardwood.

Lots of mortise and tenon joinery, often with amazingly tiny sections of wood, down to 5/8" by 3/4" or so; frequently pinned with, if I understood what was going on correctly, metal pins. One chest had tiny, beautifully done (from the bit I could see) metal hinges. Frame and panel or, more often, what I guess you'd call frame and slat - like assembling a panel from several pieces of wood and forgetting to glue them together.

Even though this was work for royalty, the workers weren't always choosy - while a lot of the wood was dead clear, it was just as common to find pieces with burl or knotty areas with which the worker just struggled through. My favorite was a chair (in the classic shape that screams "Egyptian chair" to the modern eye) on which the back was frame and slat (sides were too). As best I could tell - the chair was in a glass box, so I couldn't get closer than about 24" - the bottom member of the frame was made of a piece of wood that was dramatically narrower on one end - maybe 1-1/2" at one end, 2-1/2" at the other. The slats were adjusted in length to compensate, and angled on the end to fit. There was no visible aesthetic need for this; the paintings and inlays on the chair were all very rectilinear. I suspect the chairmaker had a piece of stock that was great in every way except its width, so used what was there.

Of course, all this was from the perspective of a not very knowledgeable 20th-century guy in the middle of a crowd in not always well-lit rooms (I believe for reasons of preserving the pieces).

I wouldn't drive across country to see it, but if it's near you, it's well worth going.

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#2

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Maybe Tut' body has been split up so multiple museums can claim "Tut's Mummy" displays concurrently? :)

How do you know they were using copper tools? They could have also been using flint and/or obsidian and/or various antlers.

Pam

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#3

the chair

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>did they have the chair with the cane bottom in it? We had a caner do a club program and he described how caning is done. It was exactly the same on the chair in the exhibit. I too was amazed at how they shaped wood without steel edged tools.

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#4

True

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I got the copper tools idea from some literature I'd seen on paper and on the Internet.

And I understand they used high-silica rush to smooth - naturally occurring sandpaper. If they used it wet (which would certainly work, the rushes having been growing by the water), they could presumably get things pretty smooth.

Still. The carved work was smooth right up to the relief. Impressive even with modern tools.

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#5

A side note

Dan Donaldson

>A few years ago, there was an exhibit on the Dead Sea Scrolls that came through here. The scrolls themselves were replicas, but much of the pottery and other artifacts were from the correct period and location. They had some problems where a pot got knocked over by a spectator. Luckily it didn't break, but they needed to get it on a different kind of stand to help protect it, but still have it visible. I knew one of the people that were helping to manage the exhibit and I ended up building the stand in my shop. They bought the materials (it ended up being made of oak) and delivered them to the shop and I duplicated one of the other stands that they had. It was kind of neat to see something that I built in the exhibit. (It was fairly simple and I built it overnight so that it could be used the next day.)

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#6

Josef Greber's book

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Bill and Pam,

Greber made a historical study of the evolution of the plane (Ref. below). He states that Egyptian cutting tools--specifically, adzes and axes--were originally copper and later bronze. He shows a photo of a copper adz head from the OId Kingdom (3400-2100BC), along with 5 bronze ones from the Middle and New Kingdoms.

With respect to stones, Greber goes on to say that stones figured in the polishing of wood, with pumice and sandstone used in initial polishing, and a harder stone (doesn't say what) was used in final polishing. He says these stones are seen in illustrations from every epoch, with some still surviving.

[Reference: 'History of the Woodworking Plane', Josef M. Greber, 1956. Reprinted 1987 in Germany and in 1991 by Early American Industries Association (but without plates).]

Wiley

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#7

Re: Josef Greber's book

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I guess I just don't see how copper tools could even begin to cut wood. Maybe I should try it. Bronze, probably.

Pam

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#8

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

Hank Knight

>Some years ago, before it was broken up into smaller exhibits, I was fortunate enough to see the Tutankhamen Exhibit at the Pyramid in Memphis (the Tennessee one). Like Bill, I was blown away by the beauty and the quality of the work, given the tools they had to work with. But they were, after all, working for the Pharaoh, so I guess time and tribulation meant little to the artisans. I particularly remember the chair with the wonky rail and thinking, "Why did they do that?" Bill's explanation is better than anything I thought of.

During the same time frame, give or take a year or so, there was an exhibit of ancient Egyptian artifacts in Charlotte. But they were from other Pharoanic periods, not the Tut Era. The artifacts were mostly pottery or stone, not much wood. They were certainly beautiful and amazing, but they didn't come close to the quality and variety of the Tutankhamen Exhibit. I completely agree with Bill: the Tut Exhibit is worth seeing. If you get a chance to see it, go. You will be impressed and amazed.

Hank

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#9

Re: Josef Greber's book

Dan Donaldson

>Does copper work harden? I know that you can get tubing in differing degrees of hardness. Maybe the harder ones would be at least marginally acceptable for cutting tools.

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#10

Yes, copper work hardens *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The best copper would surely be some distance in edge retention from A2, though.

Bronze and, later, iron and, still later, steel must have been greeted with loud, glad cries by the woodworkers of that era.


some discussion

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#11

Re: Yes, copper work hardens

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, if I could plane with a tube copper wouldn't be a bad choice. :)

It certainly does work harden, but an edge butting up against desert ironwood or cedars of lebanon or whatever couldn't last long. Probably sharpen it with a hammer instead of stones.

Maybe something like a yarikanna could be finessed through wood.

Pam

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#12

Some of the early saws were copper also

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

Some of the early saws which the Egyptians made were also made out of copper.

Copper is the main ingredient in both brass and bronze, the primary difference between the two being that brass has zinc in it, and bronze has tin. Bronze is much more durable because of such. However, copper is certainly harder than wood. I'm sure it didn't hold a very good edge compared to high carbon steels, but certainly enough to cut wood.

The Egyptians cut stone with the saws as well. When bronze became available it was used for tools, and the softer alloys like brass were used for casting, but copper was used for tools before that point.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#13

Cutting stone - wandering further OT

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>One of the non-wood pieces that I spent several minutes admiring was a calcite vase, about 16 inches high, with a narrow neck (hole in neck maybe 1-1/2", at most) and moderately broad "belly." It was, like alabaster, almost translucent, and appeared to be well hollowed in the belly. It was dead smooth on the outside. I spent several minutes imagining hollowing the belly out through that neck opening and finally gave up.

Calcite is rated at 3 on the Mohs scale, fairly soft (Gypsum was the example mineral at 2, although it's not a linear scale, but an ordinal one, so the difference may not be a trivial one) - the one online reference I found puts copper at the same rating, but that may be in a natural, non-hardened state.

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#14

Re: Cutting stone - wandering further OT

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't know, but suspect I'd look high and low for a chemical solution to "cut" such a vase of calcite.

Pam

Re: Somewhat OT - Tutankhamen exhibit

#16

Re: You actualy got in!?!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We bought the tickets back in June or early July; no trouble, on Ticketmaster (hint: Lucky's apparently has had a promotion, 30% off if you use their code, something we didn't know when we bought ours).

You're given a designated time to get in, although we got in about 15 minutes earlier than that time. After that, you're free to roam, although we found that an hour and a half of crowds in relatively small rooms was all we could stand.