Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

Posts

Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#1

Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Does someone have contact information on the fellow who makes large wooden bench screw/nut assemblies, that can be used for making wooden twin-screw vises?

Also, can anyone who has used this man's wares comment on their quality, durability?

Thank you,

Wiley

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#2

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

Eric Hartunian

>bigwoodvise.com

He makes his screws and nuts out of ash, and does a great job. I think he has 2 different head styles. I have the shaker version, as that is what went with my bench. Highly recommend.

Eric

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#3

BigWoodVise *LINK*

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

Possibly your looking for BigWoodVise.


BigWoodVise.com

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#4

Re: BigWoodVise--followup question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Eric and Alan,

Yes, thank you, that is what I had in mind. Might or might not be the same guy that Chris Schwarz mentioned a year or two ago, but this looks good!

Eric, did you fix the nut tightly on your bench, or allow it some play?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#5

It is the Chris source. *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>See his blog on building a bench.


Chris' blog

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#6

Thank you very much Dan!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#7

Yes, CS did use the BigWoodVise screws

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

As Dan pointed out, yes Chris Schwarz did use the BigWoodVise screws on the benches he built. Not only his own, but the benches that were made at Kelly Mehr's shop that Chris gave a workshop on building a bench.

I have a Veritas twin-screw, and they have one bad trait, being that the grease can get on the wood when working in the vise. For that reason, I have been contemplating replacing mine with wood screws from BigWoodVise, but that has been hard to justify. I really like the convenience of having the chain link them together. To date I use my Emmert clone more, but I think that is only because of the type of work I have been doing.

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#8

Re: Yes, CS did use the BigWoodVise screws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alan,

Thanks for the info. I have LV twin screw vises on my regular size bench, and like them a lot. Mainly, I'm looking for something more compact for this smaller bench I'm making now.

On your twin screw vise, do you have the steel studs mounted just above and outboard of the main screws. With those in place, the work shouldn't touch the main screws. If you don't have the studs, get in touch with LV--they're easy to install, though at this point you'd have to take off the moving jaw (front jaw) to do the drilling, but that's easy to do. It's not a precision drilling thing.

Wiley

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#9

Re: Yes, CS did use the BigWoodVise screws

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

Yeah I have those little stud things, they do help, but it's not a cure all for the problem. Depending on the work, it's hard to get it to sit on the little studs.

It's not that big of a deal, just that I have had a couple occasions where I've gotten some black marks on the wood I'm working.

Depending on the size you want for the small bench, you might be able to get one of the wood die/tap that let you cut the threads, could be an option. The ones from BigWoodVise look like good quality, which comes at a price. They are nice though.

Regards,

Alan

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#10

I would like to try...

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

A couple things I would like to try...

1) Double leg vise setup, one sliding, using wooden screws. Pic below uploaded from benchcrafted website uri.

2) double wooden twin-screw, just to be able to compare against the metal screws.

3) Benchcrafted hardware, although it is a metal screw, it looks excellent. But more so would like to see a glide leg vise with a wooden screw, like Jameel has on his own bench. Metal might be a good solution/tradeoff after all.:-)

I'm not unhappy with the twin-screw, just thinking that on a 10-12 foot bench, the double leg vise would have a tremendous travel, that would be very useful.

As I mentioned, the one attribute about the metal screw that is annoying for me is the grease. Not just on the work. I tend to get it on my hands in moving things around. But I like the functionality of the screws operating together. However, the loss of the chain is one question for my work style, I like that attribute of the Veritas.

I currently have a Holtzappfel which incorporates an Emmert clone as the end vise. I like this setup on this bench.

My next bench, which will go in the basement of the new house, and will be longer as it will need to function for much more, so will hopefully be longer, as I will have more shop space there.

Regards,

Alan


img

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#11

A possible problem with the wooden vise screw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alan,

I'm still weighing the wooden screw against the LV twin screw. Slight preference for the wooden screw for this application because it is a little more compact--less projection from the skirt of the bench. And it's a simpler installation too. And I like that BigWoodVise provides the 2" diameter screw--that diameter is tough to find.

However, I have one worry. This bench will have a 2-1/4" thick top. The nut for the wood screw is 3-1/2" high, which means it will stand 1-3/4" above the centerline of the screw. So if the nut is dead flush against the underside of the benchtop, then the screw centerline is 2-1/4" + 1-3/4" = 4" down the apron. And the top of the screw would be 3" minimum down the side of the apron. So that means that I will have 3" height of jaw above the screw.

But the hub of the screw--which provides the shoulder that drives the jaw forward--is advertised as 3" to 3.5" in diameter. Well, that seems decent sized. But if it is a 3" hub, then there is 1/2" of shoulder above the screw top, and so I would be counting on that 1/2" height of shoulder above the screw to drive 3" height of vise jaw.

If the work is 3+" high, sitting right on the screws, no problem. But if the work is a thinner stick, sitting above the hub shoulder, up toward the top of the jaw, then it appears that the jaw would deflect and open at the top, and not get a good bite on the thinner stick.

Now I know from experience that the LV twin screw will handle that situation. What I don't know is whether this particular wooden vise screw will do it. Now maybe if I taper the jaw, so it's thicker at the top (which is what you do with the LV jaw), then maybe that taper would absorb the deflection of the jaw and solve the problem of clamping thin sticks.

Maybe Eric could shed some light on this, since he has the vise installed and working, and is happy with it. Can anyone else comment?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#12

I tapered my jaw for the LV and would for BWV

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

I would taper the jaw, definitely. I tapered the jaw on my chop with the LV and would also with the BigWoodVise screws.

Can't you mortise the wooden nut partially into the top, so that the top of the screw moved up? That way you could still have 2 1/4" if you didn't use an apron.

I'm am not clear on your construction, I don't have aprons on my bench, but even if you have an apron the screw will still ideally be sitting just below the table, so that you don't need to add spacers under the screws to keep them from sagging. Come to think of it, could have been your bench site that shows that and how you got it level and solid. The wooden screws require that too, for the most part, AFAIK, and Schwarz incorporated a taper into his chop for the wood screws.

If I was building a smaller bench, I would be tempted to put a twin screw that stretched across the entire bench front.

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#13

Re: BigWoodVise--followup question

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>The nut should be captured by the bench/apron/leg but should be loose with some play.

Stephen

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#14

Re: BigWoodVise--followup question

Eric Hartunian------WebKitFormBoundary+BvuD5+qdjoS

>I posted last night, but the post didn't show up for some reason, so let me try again. I bolted the nut on the back side of my bench leg where the leg vise is located. I was going to mortise it into the leg, but decided it wasn't worth the extra work, and this way, I can easily replace the nut for whatever reason. I can't believe what an improvement this vise is over one with an iron screw.

Eric

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#15

Re: BigWoodVise--followup question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Eric,

Thank you for reposting. What happened is what happens to all of us Mac users (tipoff is all that WebFormKitBoundary jazz). When you posted last night, you thought it took, but actually a screen came up and said 'your message will appear after moderator approval'. That happens to me too--I back up a screen and repost. Usually there is success by the second try, but I have had to repost 3 times before it took. While doing this I also 'erase' all the stray marks about WebFormKitBoundary, etc etc. Bill Houghton solved the same problem by using Firefox as his browser.

The vise really looks to be excellent. I have one issue (up above) that I'm trying to resolve. My installation would be twin-screw.

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#16

Re: I tapered my jaw for the LV and would for BWV

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alan,

Yes, mortising the nut would save almost 3/4", which would mean that the !/2" hub shoulder above the screw would be driving 2-1/4" of jaw above the screw. Which is beginning to get into the ballpark. Also, I might be able to talk with the proprietor and get a little taller hub shoulder, depending on what blanks he has available. And indeed, one could even mortise for the screw itself and move things up some more.

However, it gets to be a lot of mortising into hard maple, especially in the twin-screw setup. And that begins to make the LV approach look more attractive. And yes, I posted several years ago about shimming above the LV vise screws to eliminate jaw sag. A good many people have done it since, and I haven't heard of problems arising. Mine is still OK.

We may have a terminology disconnect in regard to 'apron'. I am talking about that vertical slab that your LV twin screw is attached to. In my case, it will wrap around the front and one end, and be lag screwed into the top.

I completely agree with you about having the twin-screw extend the full length of the front on this small bench (38" long).

Thank you,

Wiley

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#17

What about a channel in the bottom of the top?

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

You can still get the screw up higher, but you would have to channel out the bottom of the top, for the amount you want to raise it, so if you wanted to raise an extra 1" for instance, I don't think that would weaken a 2 1/4" top. What if you were 1 1/4" from the top?

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#18

Mac problem?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've used Macs for quite a while, say 25 years, and have never seen the problem you're describing on this board, or any other for that matter.

Maybe you're using Safari?

Pam

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#19

Re: Mac problem?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>You're right Pam. It's not the Mac, it's Safari.

Wiley

Re: Wooden bench screws--who is maker?

#20

Re: A possible problem with the wooden vise screw

John Aniano - in NJ...

>Wiley,

Install a leg vise instead on your new bench and the distance between the screw and bench top surface can be much greater!

John