A possible problem with the wooden vise screw
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Alan,
I'm still weighing the wooden screw against the LV twin screw. Slight preference for the wooden screw for this application because it is a little more compact--less projection from the skirt of the bench. And it's a simpler installation too. And I like that BigWoodVise provides the 2" diameter screw--that diameter is tough to find.
However, I have one worry. This bench will have a 2-1/4" thick top. The nut for the wood screw is 3-1/2" high, which means it will stand 1-3/4" above the centerline of the screw. So if the nut is dead flush against the underside of the benchtop, then the screw centerline is 2-1/4" + 1-3/4" = 4" down the apron. And the top of the screw would be 3" minimum down the side of the apron. So that means that I will have 3" height of jaw above the screw.
But the hub of the screw--which provides the shoulder that drives the jaw forward--is advertised as 3" to 3.5" in diameter. Well, that seems decent sized. But if it is a 3" hub, then there is 1/2" of shoulder above the screw top, and so I would be counting on that 1/2" height of shoulder above the screw to drive 3" height of vise jaw.
If the work is 3+" high, sitting right on the screws, no problem. But if the work is a thinner stick, sitting above the hub shoulder, up toward the top of the jaw, then it appears that the jaw would deflect and open at the top, and not get a good bite on the thinner stick.
Now I know from experience that the LV twin screw will handle that situation. What I don't know is whether this particular wooden vise screw will do it. Now maybe if I taper the jaw, so it's thicker at the top (which is what you do with the LV jaw), then maybe that taper would absorb the deflection of the jaw and solve the problem of clamping thin sticks.
Maybe Eric could shed some light on this, since he has the vise installed and working, and is happy with it. Can anyone else comment?
Thanks,
Wiley