Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Posts

Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#1

Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Hi All,

Doing some research here and thought I'd fire a few questions to the group.As we know companies making infill plane kits have not survived.

I'd like to know why ,and more importantly what as a consumenr/end user would you like to see in kit form?

1.Types of planes,smoothers,miter,jack,panel,shoulder,chariot,etc.?

2.Materials used-O-1 steel,mild steel,stainless steel,brass,bronze?

3.How complete of a kit,blade,levercap,wood??Just the sides and baseplate and you provide the rest via third party sources such as Hock blades,Ron Brese levercap??

4.How much would you be willing to pay for a kit that was just the sides and baseplate,knowing a levercap & blade would add $150(approx)to the cost of the plane as well as wood for stuffing the infill?

It isn't much of a secret that I have access to a waterjet and have toyed with the idea of providing a service such as this.i have a general idea of what the costs would be to use the waterjet and depending on the size of a plane what material would run and I would like to know if I could persue this as sideline project that would be profitable.

Thanks in Advance,

Andy

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#2

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

George Moore

>Andy,

The blade does not matter to me whether it is with a kit or not. The lever cap and screw is one of the hardest items to locate presently. Or it has been for me.

I think I would most like to have a smoother and a shoulder plane in kit form.

Have a Blessed day.

George

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#3

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Andy

I think that most potential buyers would want to have to access as few extra parts as possible - and those that may not can always request a custom kit. So all metal to be included, with as little metal finishing as possible. In other words, join the dovetails, peen the joints, file flush, add the infill and lever cap, and pop in the blade.

Ron (Brese's) small smoother kit only requires the infill (and a little imagination), but I think even this can be quite daunting for many. I have a tutorial on my website (in the Review section), and this illustrates that there are relatively few steps - nevertheless they need to be completed accurately if you want the end product to be worthy. I suspect that many are overwhelmed by the expectation that it is beyond their skill level. So, along with the materials I think that you need to include an illustrated step-by-step "manual". Those that do not need it do not read instructions anyway!

What kits?

Smoother (everyone wants one), shoulder plane (many will want one), block plane (a good place to get one's feet wet).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#4

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

ThomD

>The other possibility is that the real problem about getting people into these planes isn't that they aren't cheap enough, or easy enough yet. It was interesting to see a recent thread where it seemed fully realized, at last, that there was little actual advantage to the type, and some disadvantages. Seemed to be a realization that cast bodies were actually better. So Saint James has been cranking out parts in fully machined form in nice bronze at stanley prices for decades. In lots of styles. There isn't really a supply problem. Now someone wanting something else is either willing to pay up for a finished plane, or possibly would buy a kit except they want a steeper angle on the dovetails or a different metal... So is the real problem that the kit folks are just waiting for the single perfect offering, or are all over the map.

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#5

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I'm sitting here with an unfinished kit, probably because Ben sent it to me the week before I headed out to Inomoto-san's class on dai making. The rest is history, got so excited about the quality of the easy-to-make Japanese planes that I had little interest left for the infills. That said, I'd be very tempted by a $100 infill mitre plane, with or without the blade and wood.

Pam

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#6

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Joel

>there is a shepherd kit on the bay right now for 200 opening and nobody wants it yet. A kit of rough parts is too hard for more people to make - and is cheaper usually to just buy metal and cut it out. A mostly finished kit is too expensive for most people's idea of a kit.

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Moses Yoder

>I have toyed around with the idea of making my own infill but when it comes down to it I don't need one. It is simply a luxury item to wow your friends with. A 604-1/2 smoother with a Hock iron in it will do anything you ask of it. For really rough grain you will want a scraper anyway. It might be nice and fun to build a smoother that looks really sharp, but I would not want to do a lot of searching for parts for the kit. If I bought a kit it would be for a wide and short smoother with brass sides and steel sole so the dovetails really stand out, and I would want the wood and lever cap and everything else I might need included in the kit. If I could get sides and sole inexpensively along with a simple list of sources for the other materials and instructions on how to put it together that might be tempting as well. But you have to keep in mind that kits are for the middle class and a very small percentage of them; the upper class will buy a really nice plane already built by any one of a number of people now in that market.

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#8

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Alan DuBoff

>Derek wrote:

"I have a tutorial on my website (in the Review section), and this illustrates that there are relatively few steps - nevertheless they need to be completed accurately if you want the end product to be worthy."

Derek,

Not for nothing but this is only true if you want your tool to look like a piece of jewelery.

I know that you have one of Krenov's planes. His crude looking planes work well, and the one that Ron Hock owns is one of the cruder ones I've seen, yet it will take a whisper thin shaving that you can read through.

I like high end jewelery type tools myself, some classify my saws in that category, but I just wanted to point out that it is not needed and planes like Krenov's drive that point home.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#9

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Alan

I do believe that infills and Krenov-type woodies are a world apart. Both do the job and both have their individual charms. However I would not speak of Krenov woodies in the same breath as an infill. The Krenovs are crude aesthetically as they are all about function, and only about form where it affects function (such as in handling). Infills are equally about form. Yes I think that they are the jewellery of the handtool world, but that does not diminish the fact that they are tools. They do require greater attention to detail in construction, which was the point of my earlier post.

I don't think we are disagreeing here. I am simply amplifying these points.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#10

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Alan DuBoff

>Derek,

I agree that to produce the high quality that most infills are, does in fact require a great deal of skill and patience.

I was thinking more in the sense that isn't it possible to build an infill that doesn't require that level of expertise? That is essentially what Ron Brese did by providing a solid body that doesn't require assembly, no?

Just seems that a lot more folks could build tools at that level, even if they didn't put the same amount of work in it, they could still have a nice tool. Maybe I'm disappointed to hear that it is more difficult, even given the fact that the body is essentially done for the most part. I'd like it to be easier so that more people would venture to make their own.

And I like jewelery tools also, and do appreciate some of the high quality planes being made...I fear if I ever do venture into making an infill, I'll fall over the edge...:-/

And of course I would have to use bronze for mine...just because...:-)

I really like this plane, Konrad really makes nice stuff...(and in bronze;-)


Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#12

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

Alan DuBoff

>Derek,

No, no, not mine...but if I make an infill, it will be like that.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#13

Not necessarily Moses...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Sometimes a higher bedding angle is in order for really crazy woods.

Glad to see your 604.5 does that well for you.

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#14

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits *LINK*

Paul M.

>"I agree that to produce the high quality that most infills are, does in fact require a great deal of skill and patience. "

Hi Alan,

My pathetic attempts are living proof of that statement....


warning... Infill abuse

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#16

Re: OUCH!

Paul M.

>That plane is toast. I never went back to it.

I did make another Shepherd kit of a large 1.5" shoulder plane. That came out OK, but not awesome. It needs more fiddling with to tune up the bed absolutely flat. But I really despise metalwork so my heart wasn't into that. Besides, what would I do with a 5 lb shoulder plane anyways? That is the last tool that needs extra beefiness to help guide it along. I have other shoulder planes that I use, and the infill one just sits there looking pretty.

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#17

But how do they work?

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

Do they work ok though?

Aside from looks, do they function as they should?

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Survey on Infill Planes and/or Kits

#18

Well...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>"Besides, what would I do with a 5 lb shoulder plane anyways?"

Uhhh, The mother of all shoulders? The grand tenons?

Ahhh Who knows.