Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

Posts

Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

#1

Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

Dave Thompson

>I haven't been around in a while. Nice to come back and see so many familiar names still on this board...

I was just visiting the Lie-Nielsen tool room today, and saw their new #48 tongue/groove plane. That's a beauty. I've never used the Stanley #48, so can't compare. I like how the fence swings 180 degrees, snaps into place and instantly becomes the match tongue or groove. Just curious if anyone has picked up one of these and has some first hand experience. Of course, I just missed my opportunity to form my own opinion, being preoccupied at the time with something else I was buying. While mulling it over after leaving, I kept thinking that would sure be slick for the next panel glue up.

Anyone use a #48 (Stanley or LN) and care to comment? Did you throw out your Lamello biscuit cutter the next day? ;-)

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

#2

Re: Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

Kevin Adams

>Hi Dave--

I was up at their shop in late June and did give one of their 48's a pretty good work-out. It is extremely well built and works great. Like others have said, it's a fun plane to use, too, and you just keep planing and planing! I picked one up (I had a GC burning a hole in my pocket!) and will use it on my current project.

To be honest, I don't think I would use it as much to join boards like you are talking unless I was looking for the decorative touch (where it would look "old fashioned", as in a table top, etc.). I think just nice clean, straight glue joints are plenty strong and easy enough to do.

BTW, if you didn't know, L-N has a video of Deneb using it on their You tube site.

Kevin

Re: Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

#3

Re: Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

Dave Thompson

>Thanks Kevin. I hadn't seen Deneb's video on it.

One noticible improvement I see over the Stanley is in the blade. Having a forked blade rather than two separate blades like on the Stanley, seems like one less thing to accidentally screw up. Of course, that tote is a nice improvement too.

I noticed Deneb didn't use the knob once while planing with it, focusing on the fence alignment of the stock's reference side.

I agree with you with regards to strength... i.e. not necessary. I like to rely on something more than just cauls for alignment of larger panel glue ups, though T&G might be overkill for that.

Re: Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

#4

Hi Dave, long time no see...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>The only drawback to the Stanley is having to adjust 2 blades. That's why I use a 146-148 planes. They have a forked blade as well. I wonder if the LN blade would fit in a Stanley. I'll have to look into that.

Cheers!

Re: Lie-Nielsen/Stanley 48?

#5

Re: Hi Dave, long time no see...

Dave Thompson

>Hey Scott, If I remember correctly the way you collect tools, you probably have 6 146's, 8 147's and 5 148's all hanging on a special rack.

;-)

Dave