Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Input needed *LINK*

Posts

Input needed *LINK*

#1

Input needed *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

I need a small but sturdy bench that I can plane and do everything on, at small scale. Like project parts 2-3 feet long, rather than 6 feet long. Important that this thing not skid and be rigid.

For various reasons, I would prefer to buy as much of this bench as possible, rather than make it from scratch. I am looking at these cast iron legs from LV as a base. They would be bolted down onto a ply base, and I would add a 2" thick maple top to it. Was thinking about 20" x 36" for the top.

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=40577&cat=1,41637

Question: Has anyone here used this LV bench base? Does it wiggle under chiselling or planing or sawing?

thanks,

Wiley


LV cast iron bench legs

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#2

Might consider the Blum Tool Portable Workbench

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

Just thought I would mention the Blum Tool Portable Workbench.

Mike Wenzloff had one at the LN Hand Tool Event in Oakland last Feb., and said he loves it, it's light, can be taken around easily, folds up in 5 minutes, and is sturdy enough to plane on. It's a torsion box design. You can use pipe clamps along the bench through the holes.

I don't see the advantage of the cast iron legs myself, you would have a really solid bench by using 4x4 on that size bench your talking about, m&t them into the top. Those wouldn't need to be laminated, but the top is more time consuming as it's laminated.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#3

Workmate

David Miller from Iowa

>When I fell on hard times about 15 years ago, all I had for a bench and vise was a Black and Decker Workmate - worked perfectly fine for holding smaller stuff, and it is very handy to have around for just about everything. I own 4 of them now. Get one of the larger ones. If you put an ad on Craigslist you may be able to find one of the old cast aluminum ones - I love the way they look.

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#4

Planing on a workmate

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I have found I need to put one foot on the step when planing, or the bench tends to travel - have you found a better solution, David?

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#5

Re: Input needed *LINK*

wilbur

>Hi Wiley,

This is a roundabout way of answering your question. I found with my old temporary poplar beam on sawhorses workbench that you can completely immobilize even a light workbench by figuring out ways to brace it against a solid object, like a wall. (See the link below.)

What I'm trying to say is that there are other ways besides sheer mass to keep a workbench in place.

By the way, my own little moment of workbench fame came when Chris Schwarz told me when I met him that he often refers to that post when people ask him the "How do I build a workbench without a workbench?" question.

As far as the LV cast iron legs you're looking at, the only issue I can think of is that the anchoring point of the benchtop to the legs is going to be relatively central, which might lead to more issues of racking the top if you have your plane stop towards the end of the benchtop, or are pounding on the end of the bench top. With a 36" long top, there's only going to be a 10" overhang along the length of your bench with these legs, however, so it might not be an issue.

Lee Valley also sells the cast iron legs from their regular workbench -- try this link:

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=40575&cat=1,41637

Those legs seem more suitable for what you want than the carver's bench legs.

The only other way to get a small bench quickly that I can think of off the top of my head is to make your 20" x 36" top, with an assembly to clamp it in a Workmate-type bench, which might give you the same issue with the central mount point, depending on how big the Workmate model is.


A scrap piece of 1x4 is as good as a 400 lb bench!

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#6

Re: Input needed

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thanks to all,

Mike W. confirms that he does indeed like the Blum portable bench a lot. The schlep is not so bad, what with carrying, setting up, and breaking down afterward.

In my case, this little bench is going to stay in one place, but I need a smallish footprint.

Actually I do like having a Workmate around, and only wish I could get one of the earlier ones.

For this present purpose, I think Wilbur is right about the bench and table legs from Lee Valley. That cast iron gives me a warm, fuzzy feeling inside. Will need a top. Note to Lee Valley: Please--go back to selling bench slabs.

Thanks to all for the most useful suggestions!

Wiley

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#7

LV bench slabs *LINK*

wilbur

>You get more than just the slabs, and this won't work for your application, but LV does sell the slabs for their workbench. You get two 10-3/4" x 72-3/4" x 2" maple slabs, along with the hardware to install it on their workbench legs.


LV bench kit

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#8

Re: Input needed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Surely some local home center sells maple slabs - the one that does near us sells 1-3/4" slabs, but I suspect they could provide thicker ones on special order, at, of course, special prices.

It would seem like shipping from Lee Valley of a chunk of wood could get kinda pricey (unless, of course, your plan was to wait for one of their free-shipping periods).

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#9

An elegent (and expensive) alternative *LINK*

Hank Knight

>Wiley,

Jameel Abraham of Bench Crafted builds outstanding bench hardware. He has recently posted a write-up with photos of his new bench over on Wood Net (link below). Apparently Jameel plans to sell his new bench at the next WIA show. It is larger than you want, but Jameel has previously built a smaller knock-down bench to demonstrate his wares at various woodworking shows. I'll bet he would build one to your specs and you'd have a fabulous custom bench with world class hardware. It would doubtless cost an arm and a leg; his vise hardware for both his leg vise and his wagon vise is just North of $700, but it's really nice stuff.

Just a thought. Actually, I'm lusting after one of Jameel's benches myself, but I have a perfectly satisfactory one already.

Hank


Jameel's bench

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#10

Correction

Hank Knight

>The cost of Jameel's vise hardware (total cost for his leg vise and his wagon vise together) is $675.00, not $700+ as I first quoted. The leg vise is $325 and the Wagon vise is $350. That does not include shipping.

I'm not affiliated with Jameel or Bench Crafted. I'm just an admirer.

Hank

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#11

Re: Correction

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Thank you, Hank,

That is a fabulous piece of engineering by Jameel. I'm gonna go wih a less expensive solution, but I believe Jameel will do very well with this bench and whatever else he decides to make (I have seen reference to him doing infills also).

Wiley

Re: Input needed *LINK*

#12

Resolution, and thanks Robin Lee

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Wilbur, Bill, and all,

Wilbur's suggestion of LV's cast iron table or bench legs is what I'm going to do.

Bill, you're right about the top--how tough of a problem is that? Not. Simplest thing in the world to just go buy one.....except that I need to have it delivered, due to some commitments around the house.

Enter Robin Lee. Talk about a great guy, this man is it! I have to tell this tale out of school, just to do him justice. He wrote offline (a propos of my note above suggesting LV sell slabs) to say that LV will sell those slabs on request. I then pestered him with two or three followup emails asking about details--which he, as CEO, took it upon himself to answer!! Kinda embarrassing, because I can't afford to pay for this man's time--he can only give it away. He wasn't even trying to make a sale: in the course of our emails, he linked me to two other vendors selling maple bench tops. Of all things, it turns out that Rob's link to McMaster-Carr is the way for me to go. But I won't forget this good deed he has done, and at least I will be buying LV's cast iron leg set and another pair of Veritas Hold Downs. A person of integrity and principle is rarest thing on God's earth, and Robin Lee is it.

The end.

Wiley