Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Posts

Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#1

Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Alan DuBoff

>I had a similar D.R. Barton broad axe that I gave to the log craftsman that taught me how to build recently. I gave it to him as a token of appreciation for his help in teaching me how to craft my dream of building a log home.

I found another and was able to pick this beauty up for $38...about half of what I had to pay for the first one I gave away. This one is not in as nice of condition, but very close, IMO.

This will hang on the wall of my log home after it is built.

This is one amazing hunk of steel, it's heavy, and the blade is laminated. I'm very impressed with the D.R. Barton axes, they are very high quality, IMO.

I guesstimate this was made around 1850, as it has the old style stamp without the 1832 date inside. The D.R. Barton company was created in 1832, which happened around 1873. Not bad shape for a tool that is more than 150 years, and possibly close to 175 years old!





Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#2

Chronology???

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"The D.R. Barton company was created in 1832, which happened around 1873."

I take it from the context that you mean that the company changed its logo around 1873 to incorporate the 1832 date.

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#3

Re: Chronology???

Alan DuBoff

>Bill,

Yeah, I fat fingered that one. In 1873, the company changed ownership. Actually, in 1865, the factory was flooded and Barton borrowed $200k to rebuild and the company was partnered because of such, finally in 1873 Barton bought it back.

Interesting trivia, Charles & John Buck both worked as grinders in the D.R. Barton factory, grinding edge tools. Kinda fascinating as Charles Buck was born around 1829, just a few years before D.R. Barton opened his doors in 1832. Charles Buck would go on after he worked at D.R. Barton (circa 1850), to be one of the most successful edge tool makers in his day.

The logo changed in 1873 to include the 1832 stamp inside of it.

This axe was made before 1873, the only thing I know for certain.

D.R. Barton was considered one of the best edge tool makers of his time also. Both of the broad axes I've bought display such quality. The backs are extremely flat, and the blades are laminated. Nice tools.

I may use this on some of the porch timber.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#4

Thanks, interesting history

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I own a D.R. Barton mortise chisel; nice to have some of the history behind it.

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#5

I've seen a couple D.R. Barton chisels...

Alan DuBoff

>Bill,

I have seen a couple D.R. Barton chisels, but mostly the ones I see are timberframing chisels.

I was looking for some large timberframing chisels recently and bought this set for $51.

Charles Buck 1 1/4" gouge, Essex 2" timberframe chisel (17.5" long), Underhill 2" timberframe chisel (17" long), 2" Underhill timberframe chisel w/horked handle (15" long), and a 1" (can't read maker) timberframe chisel, 15" long.

The Buck gouge needs a new handle (the back had a big chunk gone) but the edge looks like it has never been sharpened, and they need to be cleaned up, but the cost was less than a single timberframe chisel. Most go used for about $30-$40 each.


Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#6

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi Alan,

That is a wonderful find! Laminated bit! D. R. Barton is a great name. You've got me headed for ebay to look up axes. Really a grand addition to the adventure.

What is the tanged blade right behind the ax? Any identifiers on it?

Wiley

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#7

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley asked:

"What is the tanged blade right behind the ax? Any identifiers on it?"

Those are tudlettes I forged at the California Blacksmith Association's Spring Conference back in April.

The one just above the axe is a knife, forged out of 5160 spring steel. It's pretty rough.

Just above that is a hardy cut-off forged out of S7, that is the toughest steel I've ever forged, it work hardens as you forge it...:-/ Could also be a small hatchet/axe if I put a handle on it.

Just to the left of that is a small drawknife that I forged out of a piece of coil spring at the conference, it was a piece I had in my bag...but the other knife was forged out of some 1 1/4" round rod that I bought from a guy, so it was different. The drawknife is most likely 5160 also, because that is the most common for car coil and leaf springs. None of them are really finished, although the S7 doesn't need to be tempered, it's ready to go...

There's also a scroll leaf project peeking out from the small leather working mallet. Thinking to give that to my Mother-In-Law, she currently uses another leaf I forged to hold her brushes she uses for Japanese water color painting, and traditional Japanese writing, they use a brush for that also.

Oh, to answer your question about a maker stamp, nope, not yet...but it will by my bass clef touchmark! *wink*

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#8

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Fred Peake

>Wiley, be sure to search ebay for civil war medical instruments. Ebay sellers would surely list this as an extremely rare amputation axe signed by the famous confederate surgeon Dr. Barton.

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#9

Clara's cousin, no doubt

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#10

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Dave Thompson

>That's a beauty. Nice patina. Interesting that you found a lefty, though I can see that's not the original handle.

I would imagine people in the day used a ~3 foot wheel to sharpen these. I was curious if you worked out your method, or perhaps the bevel and edge is in good shape as is? The one I picked up had a bit of pitting on the back, and not such a nice patina, which I worked at with a belt sander.

I still need to get a new handle for mine. I was holding a Gransfors Bruk broad axe with a short curved handle today and thought it had a wonderful curve, size and feel. Unless I find a source for those handles, I might have to make my own like it.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#11

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

bill mccarthy

>Nice axe, I noticed that the handle while it appears period does not have any offset. I was under the impression that hewing broad axes need an offset in the handle. I would like to know other peoples thoughts on that subject

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#12

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Alan DuBoff

>Bill,

It is my understanding that the older axes didn't have offset handles, that the offset is a modern twist that was added to them.

That said, I'm not sure if this handle is original or not, but it looks old.

The offset allows for 2 things.

1) offset when hewing so that the blade is offset to the dominant side one is hewing on.

2) allow your hand to hold the handle and not have your knuckles scraped when using the axe to hew in front, like to cut out a dovetail.

The D.R. Barton company is old enough that they would have had axes without the offset on them.

Maybe someone else has some other info on this subject.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#13

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>'It is my understanding that the older axes didn't have offset handles, that the offset is a modern twist that was added to them.'

Henry Mercer's Ancient Carpenters' Tools shows 'The Chisel-Edged Broad Axe with Bent Handle' in Figure 79, page 82, 5 examples.

Stephen

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#14

How old is the book?

Alan DuBoff

>Stephen,

How old is that book?

My understanding is that prior to the 19th century, the broad axes didn't have offset handles. In fact some of the text I've read online suggests that America could have possibly been responsible for it.

But this book you mention must be from Europe/France...

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#15

Coupla data points

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Alan and all,

A little data......

1. From Smith's Key (to the Manufactories of Sheffield, with Engravings of each Article), EAIA reprint of the 1816 edition, published by J. Smith, Sheffield. This would reflect English practice, of course.

Smith's Key provides pricing for 26 different ax patterns, plus variations. 24 of these axes are shown in engraving. No provision for handling is indicated in the pricing, and the engravings show only the ax head. Indeed, ax pricing is by the pound of weight, and the prices are close enough that I get the impression Sheffield shipped ax heads in bulk. By comparison, if we look at the hatchet entries, both the price entries and the engravings show handles, and horn handles are available at extra cost. The hatchets are priced by the dozen.

I would conclude from Smith's Key, that the Sheffield practice was to ship axes unhandled. Of course, this tells us nothing about who handled the ax: Did retailers add handles prior to sale, or did the user shop separately for the handle, or did most users handle the ax themselves.

2. Sandusky Tool Co., 1877 catalog. Sandusky, Ohio.

Sandusky in 1877 advertised 4 patterns of axes, and two quality levels. They shipped the axes by the dozen. They shipped both with and without handles. The handles they advertise are simply "No. 1 handles", with no further description. Surely these were not offset, but then the ax heads are either double bitted or single bit/double bevel--none single bevel.

Are there other catalog examples to be quoted? Based on these two examples, separated as they are in time and location, it is not clear who made the ax handles. Were tool handles a separate industry supplying retailers, or did many users provide their own handles to fit their need?

Wiley

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#16

Re: Coupla data points

Alan DuBoff

>Wiley,

My understanding of Sheffield is that the toolmakers were independent craftsmen, who operated on a per piece basis, or would barter their skill amongst the other toolmakers so that they could get the needed work done.

In that sense, it wouldn't surprise me that a craftsman specialized in axe handles, or saw handles, or chisel handles, etc...

The single bevel chisel edge, known as the broad axe, was specific for hewing. These bearded/goosewing/broad axes seem to be more derived from German or Norwegian heritage possibly.

Stephen,

I found that Ancient Carpenters' Tools book on Google, Ancient Carpenters' Tools by Henry C. Mercer at this link>

.

Here's a google book on American Axes. I was searching for goosewing at the time...

American Axes by Henry J. Kauffman

Does Smith list any hewing axes specific, of any type?

The English obviously had square timbers, their timberframe structures go way back...and good examples of structures from the 1600s is not uncommon. They must have had hewing axes back then.

Ah, and Sloan's book has some good info...on Google at this link.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#17

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Todd Hughes

>I would think that the axe head is later, post Civil War, 1870s since it has those hollow sections which was for breaking out chips I think.

Handle not original but could be old, you see lots of replacement handles that are put into these things so it turns the axe into a left handled axe. I think it more likely many of the people that rehandled them didn't think about it then needed a left handled hewing axe. Axe shown looks like it has seen some rough usage over the years probably from being used as a regular axe and splitting maul

A hewing axe like this would not need a bent handle because the handle is long enough so your hand is no where near the work. It would be used as you stand over your work so why the bent handle..think about it..OK?

You see the bent handle on Hewing Hatchets, could have large heads but the handles are short so they have to be bent so your hand clears. Early ones had eyes that were bent at an angle so even with a straight handle it would clear.

Probably most of the older Axe were sold minus handles, easier to ship and most guys would probaly want to make thier own handles. I sort of collect axe handle patterns. These are the pattern a guy would make of the style of handle he liked and then used to replicate it.....Todd

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#18

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

Alan DuBoff

>Todd,

Good info. You mentioned the hollow sections, are you taking about each side of the ridge down the center, referring to the sides as the hollows?

Does appear it was used for chopping, but in pretty darn good shape considering how old it is. Not as nice as the previous one I bought, but still, not bad shape, IMO.

It's a big piece of steel, and it's sharp! Don't want to be dropping it on one's foot...*lol*

There was a guy looking for you that posted a thread with your name, if you haven't seen that.

Cheers,

Alan

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#19

Mercer *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Henry Mercer was in Pennsylvania; his museum still is, and is a mind-boggling day trip for anyone passing near Doylestown, PA. It may need two days - your brain will fill up if you try to do it all in one day.


click on "museum guide" link

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#20

That's some museum. Wow.

Victor Parisian

>

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#21

It's even more awe-inspiring in the flesh

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>LOML couldn't get me out of there, although I then couldn't get her out of the tile-making area...

Re: Nice 'ol D.R. Barton Broad Axe

#22

Re: It's even more awe-inspiring in the flesh

Alan DuBoff

>Sounds like a cool place Bill, if I ever get back there, I'll make it a stop.