Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

Posts

Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#1

Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Hi gang,

I finished making (2) sets of handles/knobs for the bowsaw (along with the toggles) I'm making for my buddy and wanted to get some feedback on them from y'all.

Bowsaw Handles

Bowsaw Handles

I turned one set from Cherry and the other from Walnut. I know my buddy likes both. However, just be be different I went and Ebonized the walnut using a mix of steel wool and vinegar. The finish on all items is multiple layers of garnet shellac and a coat of wax.

I think the ebonized walnut will look awesome because of the contrast. But I know that once the cherry ages it will also provide a nice contrast. I can't really ask my friend without spoiling the surprise. So some input would be appreciated.

I'm supposed to bring this bowsaw with me when I go over to his house on Saturday. Decisions, decisions, decisions!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#2

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

wilbur

>Before I can answer the question, I need to know how much attention you paid to grain orientation when you made the side pieces. :@)

I would vote for the cherry. Actually, my first vote would have been for the walnut, if it had not been ebonized. I'm not a big fan of ebonized walnut, but that's just me.

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#3

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

Dominic Greco in Bucks County Pa------WebKitFormBo

>Wilbur,

I really ebonized the walnut to HIDE the grain orientation!!!

Thanks for the input

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#4

Dude, tough choice...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I say keep the walnut because of effect. But, Cherry would be more "kosher" I ain't no Paris Hilton, but I say keep the walnut.

Not an easy choice IMHO.

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#5

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I'll vote for the walnut, Dominic. I think the walnut handles are a little more shapely, I like the color better, and walnut is generally a harder material.

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Cherry.......

Jesper, Denmark

>The ebonized may look stunning now, but in a while, they will appear contrived, whereas the cherry will remain classy.

IMHO of course.........

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#7

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont, Canada

>Stunning work Dom,

I love them both, a lucky man indeed!!

Take care,

Jim

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#8

Thanks! Made my choice------WebKitFormBoundary8+W7

Dominic Greco in Bucks County Pa------WebKitFormBo

>Thanks for all the input everyone. I appreciate the responses.

While a tally of the "votes" (here and on another ww'ing forum) clearly indicates a preference toward the walnut I've decided to use the cherry knobs.

During a discusion today I learned that my friend favors cherry. So I guessed that gives me an idea what he'd like.

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#10

Completed Mark III Bowsaw!

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Here's a photo of the completed Mark III Bowsaw with the cherry handles installed. While doing the final assembly I broke one of the brass pins. I used some 1/2" dia brass bar stock to make a new one.

bowsaw Mark III

New pin installed in knob

That's pretty much it. I give this saw to my friend tomorrow.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#11

Re: Completed Mark III Bowsaw!

Alan DuBoff

>It's always nice to give a tool away once in a while that you make. It has been said that this will prevent someone's dogma from running over your karma. :-)

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#12

The right choice

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dominic,

The cherry ones have the right look. My two cents: The art is in the form of the saw, the way it looks as a whole. The cherry knobs blend in to be part of the whole.

Where did the saw blade come from? Is that from Joel's kit, or from elsewhere on his site?

Wiley

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#13

Re: The right choice

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Thanks Wiley!

The entire kit came from TFWW. It includes (2) brass pins and (3) bowsaw blades.

Gramercy Tools Turning Saw Parts

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#14

Re: Completed Mark III Bowsaw!

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>I hear ya Alan!

My buddy was suitably impressed when he got his saw. He couldn't stop saying how cool it was. :>)

I just hope I can generate some good karma and get my lawn tractor running again (that's what my friend and I were working on today and the reason I made him a bowsaw)

Re: Handle/knob selection for bowsaw

#15

Re: Completed Mark III Bowsaw!

Alan DuBoff

>Hope you get that lawn tractor running, I loathe the idea of doing lawn like I did as a kid, with a push mower...and no motor, nowadays I see push mowers being called to mowers that have a motor on them...

Speaking of tractors, I got to play with his tractor loader for a bit yesterday, and it was fun while it lasted...;-) It has 2 joy sticks, one operates the tractors, the other operates the bucket...I had slight envy as I got back in to play with my forklift...*lol*

This has a turbo diesel in it! ;-)


img