Re: hollow grind vs. face grind
ThomD
>It all has to do with cutting power. The lower the bevel angle, within reason, the higher the cutting power. It really shouldn't make a lot of difference how that angle is achieved. With a hollow grind the low angle is accompanied with a higher angled shoulder, which could get in the way in some applications. But the overall bevel takes up less space and has more meat behind it.
As Bill correctly points out the hollow grind has more cutting power for the angle between the two faces, because at the edge the cutting angle is less. There is some flat grind with equivalent cutting power and it would have advantages also, compared to that lower overall angle ground hollow. Which is why the arguments can go around in circles for a while.
As we all know, the amount of cutting power required to get a good surface on wood is not fixed, a lower angle may, or not, be required. If you want to restore the machine to factory specs, follow their proceedures. Otherwise the adventure is yours for the taking
"If you create a low angle hollow grind and finish this with by honing coplanar to the bevel face"
Not sure what you are saying, are you saying a micro bevel that is at the same angle as the cutting edge? That would in most cases be quite a trick, and is rarely done.
", you achieve a microbevel that would be at the lowest cutting angle possible."
Except that there is always a flat grind that will have the same angle.
"Compare this with a secondary bevel on a face, which (by definition) must be created at a higher cutting angle."
Except that there is always a face angle that would yield the same secondary bevel angle. It would have less meat near the edge, but as a general principle, flat grinds probably win the meat behind the edge argument in most cases, and appear on most fancy swords, knives and chisels that are sold on cutting ability. Hollow grinds mostly exist because power grinders of lower sophistication create hollow grinds, while hand work was required to get flat grinds. While there are sophisticated options these days, most power options are still hollow ground, and hollow grinds are fine in many application.
What the heck is a "face" grind. Did I miss another trendy article or DVD?