Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

Posts

hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#1

hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

DaleLenz

>Purchased a Morso chopper machine this past Friday. Knives are dull, going to have them face-sharpen at a local sharpening service, $12/pair. Morso site says: knives need to be hollow-grind,w/8-10 wheel, of course they will do this for 54 dollars. I can not see a reason to have the knives hollow grind.

Am I missing something?

Below is a Morso-like machine that shows the knives.

TIA


Morso like machine

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#3

Re: The only reason...

DaleLenz

>I'm aware of to hollow grind is you don't have as much metal to remove next time you sharpen a plane iron. In the Morso case, it does not hold any water to my way of thinking.

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#4

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I suppose the effective angle at the edge for any given nominal angle would be more acute.

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#5

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind

DaleLenz

>Thanks for the post Bill. I thought of the acute angle, only thing my simple mind comes up with is maybe the knives edge would turn up quicker due to lack of mass behind the cutting edge(?).

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#6

All speculation on my part, understand

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I was told the Lion trimmer folks (are they still in business?) used to point out that trimmers are designed for just that - removing thin shavings from a piece of stock, like a giant mechanized paring chisel. If that's the case, then a low angle might last quite a while.

But, as my post title said, I'm speculating, something I can often do for hours on subjects about which I know very little. I should have gotten my PhD and become a college professor; I've got one of the core skills down.

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Could it be........

Jesper, Denmark

>That they mean the knives should be ground on a whell with AT LEAST 8-10 inch diameter?

Like others, I can see no logic behind the need for hollow grind.

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#8

Re: As I understand...

DaleLenz

>they suggest to hollow grind with a 8-10 wheel, ie 4-5" radius hollow grind.

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#9

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Dale

The difference between hollow grinding and face grinding is the cutting angle achieved.

If you create a low angle hollow grind and finish this with by honing coplanar to the bevel face, you achieve a microbevel that would be at the lowest cutting angle possible. Compare this with a secondary bevel on a face, which (by definition) must be created at a higher cutting angle.

In other words, using a hollow grind allows one to achieve the lowest possible cutting angle. Using a large grinding wheel to create the hollow removes the least amount of steel.

I have no idea whether this is the reason that underlies the sharping of these knives.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#10

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind

ThomD

>It all has to do with cutting power. The lower the bevel angle, within reason, the higher the cutting power. It really shouldn't make a lot of difference how that angle is achieved. With a hollow grind the low angle is accompanied with a higher angled shoulder, which could get in the way in some applications. But the overall bevel takes up less space and has more meat behind it.

As Bill correctly points out the hollow grind has more cutting power for the angle between the two faces, because at the edge the cutting angle is less. There is some flat grind with equivalent cutting power and it would have advantages also, compared to that lower overall angle ground hollow. Which is why the arguments can go around in circles for a while.

As we all know, the amount of cutting power required to get a good surface on wood is not fixed, a lower angle may, or not, be required. If you want to restore the machine to factory specs, follow their proceedures. Otherwise the adventure is yours for the taking

"If you create a low angle hollow grind and finish this with by honing coplanar to the bevel face"

Not sure what you are saying, are you saying a micro bevel that is at the same angle as the cutting edge? That would in most cases be quite a trick, and is rarely done.

", you achieve a microbevel that would be at the lowest cutting angle possible."

Except that there is always a flat grind that will have the same angle.

"Compare this with a secondary bevel on a face, which (by definition) must be created at a higher cutting angle."

Except that there is always a face angle that would yield the same secondary bevel angle. It would have less meat near the edge, but as a general principle, flat grinds probably win the meat behind the edge argument in most cases, and appear on most fancy swords, knives and chisels that are sold on cutting ability. Hollow grinds mostly exist because power grinders of lower sophistication create hollow grinds, while hand work was required to get flat grinds. While there are sophisticated options these days, most power options are still hollow ground, and hollow grinds are fine in many application.

What the heck is a "face" grind. Did I miss another trendy article or DVD?

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#11

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind

DaleLenz

>Thom and others,

Thanks for every one's help, still confused which is best. Think, I'll try the 12 dollar flat grind and See.

What the heck is a "face" grind. Did I miss another trendy article or DVD?

When typing the original post, my mind came up with non-hollow-ground or face. My mind did not pick up on flat grind, my apologizes.

Thanks again,

Dale

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#12

Face grind, I got it...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Then again I could understand the misconception. Please let us know how it goes.

Good luck!

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#13

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Thom

In response ...

(I wrote) "If you create a low angle hollow grind and finish this with by honing coplanar to the bevel face"

(You wrote) Not sure what you are saying, are you saying a micro bevel that is at the same angle as the cutting edge? That would in most cases be quite a trick, and is rarely done.

This is easier to explain with an illustration. Nothing new here ...


(I wrote) ", you achieve a microbevel that would be at the lowest cutting angle possible."

(You wrote) Except that there is always a flat grind that will have the same angle.

The preference for the hollow grind is because the flat grind has a greater area to hone. A flat grind will require more effort and accuracy to achieve the same result as the hollow grind.

(I wrote)"Compare this with a secondary bevel on a face, which (by definition) must be created at a higher cutting angle."

(You wrote) Except that there is always a face angle that would yield the same secondary bevel angle.

Again, secondary bevels are used to avoid having to hone the entire bevel face (for reasons above).


(You wrote) (A secondary bevel) would have less meat near the edge, but as a general principle, flat grinds probably win the meat behind the edge argument in most cases, and appear on most fancy swords, knives and chisels that are sold on cutting ability. Hollow grinds mostly exist because power grinders of lower sophistication create hollow grinds, while hand work was required to get flat grinds. While there are sophisticated options these days, most power options are still hollow ground, and hollow grinds are fine in many application.

No argument from me here ... except to note that honing a hollow or a flat is a choice. The original issue was to question why the Sharpener would wish to hollow grind the guillotine blades. Certainly they could be done flat, but I assume that the reason s/he chose to hollow was that it was more efficient.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#14

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind

Peter Evans

>The hollow grind may be on the BACK of the blade, not the bevel. Mitre machines typically have a (slightly) concave back.

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#15

Re: What I found out

DaleLenz

>Scott and other that wish to know,

Got my knives from you Morso hollow ground, used 6" wheel, from a local sharpen for $5.50 for the set, gave the sharpen $5 extra, he worked for more than an hour. Probably should of gave him more! Brought the knives home and hone them using my stones and compound, about an hour of work, cut through newspaper with easy. Mounted the knives in the Morso and cuts Much better. My plane shooting jigs may be collecting dust, : ' >. Thanks again for everyone's help. Dale

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#17

Re: IF... I understand your statement,

DaleLenz

>use planes quite a bit in my work: Gives me near perfection to you don't screw up as quick, : ' >. During my last project run, had something like 132 miters to shoot. Two-thirds of those miters are about 3.25" square, 22.5 degrees miters. My Romancing the... Hand Plane got pretty thin, : ' >.

Enjoy the week,

Dale

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#18

Re: IF... I understand your statement,

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dale,

All those large miters sounds pretty fascinating. Do you mind sharing what kind of project that was/is? Are you doing architectural scale work, or furniture?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#19

Actually, neither *LINK*

DaleLenz

>>Are you doing architectural scale work, or furniture<

Used to build customer furniture, until my father died and my mother ask me to build a flag case, 1992. Flag Cases R Me slowly evolved, with the Internet has done wonders at least for me. My flag case building is an after 5 and weekend thing.

I'm always trying to improve my flag cases in some shape or fashion, keeps me from getting bored from doing the same thing over and over. Couple years ago started attempting to shoot miters. My aim was to get a miter joint so tight that the joint was invisable, if you will, only thing that showed what the grain change. Truthfully, maybe 1 in 5 of my flag cases turn out with "perfect joints" While shooting miters, I might lose some of my base angle on the bottom flag case joint, what I shoot first. Then I compensate on my "45" at the top of the flag case. Needless to say, ever flag case is somewhat different shaped, minor. But still very time consuming. I would like some repeatablity, which is why I purchased the Morso. Will need to build a 22.5 degree jig for the Morso.

Built a donkey ear or is that a mules ear, : ' >, not going to work with 3.25" miters, need a plane with 3.25+ iron. Came up with a simple 3 sided ramp looking device with one end cut off with 22.5 degree angle and the other end with a 45. Shoot the miters across the end grain, Trying to be careful not to blow the opposite side of the joint out! Anyway, found out the low angled L/N BU jack plane to be a good miter shooter. Had pictures of my jigs but lost my hard-drive a few weeks ago and they are gone from my picture file, might have on a disk. Anyway, I'll post my website below and that may help visualize my babble.

Thanks for asking, hope you and other are not disappointed as theres a lot of talented folks on this site.


Flag Cases

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#20

WOW!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Your site has grown up since I've last looked at it. Very nice indeed.

Care to share any of your secrets on the piano type finish?

Re: hollow grind vs. face grind *LINK*

#21

Very impressive!!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dale,

Those cases are very impressive, indeed!! It really looks to be a tough project to get just right, because all the joint lines are exposed. Which means all the fits have to be perfect; there's no fudge factor. And that three-way miter right on the case top (front) is super tough.

The miter machine really is a good idea, if not a must-have. The only other thing I could suggest (cause I'm thinking how would I create some fudge factor!), would be to scrape the mating pieces ever so slightly hollow, not even an eyelash worth, just enough to ensure that the edges meet first and there's no high spot in the interior of the mating surfaces.

Thanks for sharing, and we'd love to see the Morso in action.

Wiley