Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

In case anyone should need a WW mag article

Posts

In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#1

In case anyone should need a WW mag article

Dan Mitchell

>I happen to have electronic copies of thousands of woodworking magazines, FWW, PW, WJ, Shopnotes, Wood, you name it. If anyone happens to need an article, email me directly & I'll see if I can send you a PDF.

Everyone has been so helpful with my plane question, I feel it's the least I can do (and never let it be said I didn't do THE LEAST I COULD DO!!!)

Dan

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Two words, Dan:

Copyright infringement!

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#3

Not if he is giving them away!

David Miller from Iowa

>

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#4

Re: Not if he is giving them away!

Tim Caley

>I would like to see a list of what you have available. Do you have them in a spreadsheet?

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#5

Re: Not if he is giving them away!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Even for "free," it's a copyright infringement; because the entity holding the copyright is NOT receiving money for the reader.

Pam

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#6

Re: Not if he is giving them away! *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>The observation that "Even for "free," it's a copyright infringement; because the entity holding the copyright is NOT receiving money for the reader." is incorrect. If this were true, there would be no libraries, and especially none with copy machines. There is a legal doctrine in copyright law known as "Fair use" that covers certain exceptions, a brief overview of which can be found at the Electronic Frontier Foundation web site at the link below. A somewhat longer description can be found by searching the term "Fair use" on Wikipedia.

I made this offer as a way of saying thanks for the help I have gotten in this forum, both here and on the main discussion. I'm just an individual who has collected some resources that serve our common interest, which I thought I would share. I have neither the time nor the inclination to have the situation "legally vetted" from every imaginable perspective. If anyone is uncomfortable with receiving my help with an article, the answer is simple: don't request one.

Sorry Tim, I really don't have a complete list of what I have. If you have a specific article you need, email me & I'll see if I have it in my collection.

Dan


http://w2.eff.org/IP/eff_fair_use_faq.php

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#7

Re: Not if he is giving them away!

Joel

>Fair use does not include scanning articles and giving them to anyone who asks. THis is why Google had to reach a deal with publishers and magazines.

Copying an article from your own magazine so that you can mark up a copy in the workshop is fair use. giving a copy to anyone who asks for it isn't.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#8

Re: Not if he is giving them away!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I am quite aware of fair use, and giving copies to potential buyers is NOT fair use. Fair use encompasses things like writing reviews and distributing in class.

Your offer is generous to most of us on this forum, most of whom don't write articles for any of the rags mentioned; but it's very unfair to those who do. I appreciate your intention, which is why I replied as I did.

Pam, who became acquainted with copyright laws by publishing software and a magazine

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#9

About libraries

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Libraries have special agreements with publishers, often paying many multiples of what we'd pay for a given item from a book store. They typically buy from one or two library-only sellers.

Pam

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#10

Re: Not if he is giving them away!

Norb Schmidt - Cumming, GA

>I agree with Pam - and she's softpeddling it too. And nobody is throwing stones here (me either).

The internet is a really cheap distribution method - for most of us its free. As newspapers go the way of the dinosaur, I wonder who will be writing these great articles and adding insight (the bloggers??). Sometimes we need to do what we "ought to" rather than what is "legal" or what nobody will chase us for.

Shoot, most of us have copied articles for other people - typically just one or two copies. The internet lets us do that hundreds of times - and at $2 to $5 per article - we start talking some real money lost for publishers. As we all know - nobody is getting rich publishing woodworking articles.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#11

A different understanding....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Dan's kind offer rang a bell with me, as there is an old article from Woodwork I would give an eyetooth to obtain. It can't be had from the original publisher or the new owner (I checked).

So I wrote Dan offline on the off-chance he might have it. He wrote back promptly. No, he didn't have it. But he had gone out of his way to do some Googling to try to find it, and gave me very specific suggestions about an interlibrary loan.

I appreciate his effort very much, and won't forget.

It is clear to me that Dan, having gotten some useful help (for example, Wilbur's link), simply wanted to offer a small service as repayment to the group. He is a gentleman who walked into our midst--is this not clear?

Wiley

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#12

Re: A different understanding....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I don't think anyone's questioning motivation - but copyright has, rightly, become a big issue with the internet and, before that, cheap copy machines. In my old job, faculty wanting to use articles or chapters from books had to demonstrate that they'd complied with the university's best understanding of the law before the copy center would make the copies.

If the university hadn't done so, it would have become liable for any violation of copyright, not just the faculty member (and guess whose pockets are deeper in the courts' eyes). It's possible that the same would apply to Wood Central, if it were used as a vehicle for distribution at a level that was found to violate copyright law.

I'm not an attorney, and know very little about copyright law (although, having spent the final decade of my career in academic human resources, where intellectual property is a big deal, I can talk a little about plagiarism - but less from a legal than from an ethical perspective).

Mr. Mitchell's offer is a testament to his generous spirit. But there have been enough concerns expressed that I think some consideration of legal issues is worthwhile.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#13

Re: A different understanding....

Thomas S Stockton

>Wiley

E-mail me I have some older issues it might be in there. We can figure out some kind of mind meld to get it to you.

Tom

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#14

Will do! Thank you! Fingers crossed.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#15

Not a different understanding....

Alex Yeilding

>It is clear to me that Dan, having gotten some useful help (for example, Wilbur's link), simply wanted to offer a small service as repayment to the group. He is a gentleman who walked into our midst--is this not clear?

Wiley, I think it is clear, and that most everyone posting to this thread has expressed the same sentiment to one degree or another.

That said, if I were the publisher of Popular Woodworking e.g., and were offering electronic copies of back issues (the rights to which I owned) at what is clearly more than processing cost, I would not be happy with someone requesting or offering those same copies, denying me that revenue. While I doubt that is a basis for a legal position, it does inform my opinion.

On the other hand, your request of a copy of an out-of-print, not-being-sold-by-the-copyright-owner issue or article is a "whole 'nother kettle of fish" as far as I am concerned. Who's harmed? No one as far as I can tell. (But whether it is different legally is something for lawyers and courts to decide.)

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#16

Re: Not if he is giving them away!

Gary Roberts

>Coming out from under the log I lurk in... Pam is correct. Fair Use is a fuzzy area but one aspect is clear. You can distribute a PRINT title or excerpt for educational purposes provided you can prove that you do not receive any monetary gain from the process and that the original copyright holder is not being hurt monetarily by said distribution. Such distribution has to be limited in scope and numbers.

But... digital intellectual property rights are a bit different. The articles sold or distributed by a particular publisher may be restricted in terms of distribution by electronic means other than those approved by the publisher. FWW may distribute free plans from it's website as a means to attract attention to the cash earning aspects of the site. You'ld have to check the digital distribution restrictions, if any, before offering copies even free of charge.

Generally, the person who downloads or purchases a digital document does not own the document: which may be a separate issue from the contents of the document. The entity that created the document owns the container (PDF, DOC, etc.) but may not own the content. Confusing, but there it is.

So, you can link to an active electronic document housed at the publisher's web site, or on a disc distributed by the publisher, but to distribute it without first asking for consent from the publisher is a breach of copyright. Fair Use has nothing to do with this instance.

And that is why Fair Use, Copyright and Digital Copyright gives us libarians and publishers a glorious headache.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#17

Libraries Lend - They Don't Copy

David Cockey

>Libraries lend books and magazines they own. They don't make copies for patrons, and usually copiers in libraries have signs limiting copying to "fair use". Very well established legal doctrine allows owners to lend (and resell) phyical empbodiments of intellectual work such as books, magazines, CD's, etc.

This doctrine becomes more complicated with software and other information in digital form, where "lending" frequently is really copying.

I'm not aware that libraries pay more for special licenses/agreements so they can lend books. I wouldn't be surprised if it's true for software though.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#18

Re: Not a different understanding....

Peter Evans

>The legal and ethical issues overlap, as do the practical.

A practical example : I took a very cheap sale opportunity from the publishers to pick up all the PW back issues available on CD. The README file authorises printing and includes:-

"Legal Issues - These files are all copyrighted by F+W Publications Inc., Cincinnati, Ohio. Reproducing these files for distribution or for sale is strictly prohibited."

If I give one of those articles that I have printed to a friend, is that distribution? or similar to giving someone a copy of the print magazine; I can certainly give/lend the CD to my friend, who can obviously print an article for his/her own use.

However if I scan an article from a print copy, and give scan to said friend - that is a breach of copyright, and is probably not fair use. If I lend the magazine to my friend who then scans an article for personal use, is that a breach - no? If I scan an article from a magazine I borrow from the library for my personal use is that fair use? I can certainly use the library copier legally and ethically.

However to broadcast your willingness to copy articles - even with the best intent - is unfortunately going too far. I do not see an ethical problem with asking if someone has an out-of-print article they could copy for them. I have been on both ends of this non-economic arrangement.

An interesting development of digital versions of magazines is the collapse of the value of print copies in the second hand market. For FWW you can digitally get all back copies for $150, and this sort of puts a ceiling on the price of old print copies.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#19

Re: Not a different understanding....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The price of the CD doesn't necessarily devalue the printed editions since the reading experience is very different. For a test I ordered a digital version of "Woodwork." What a pain was the pdf format on screen; plus, since I don't have a monster screen, I couldn't get a good overview. Of course, I could have printed the article; but I figure "Woodwork" is more efficient at that task.

Pam

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#20

Re: Not a different understanding....

Peter Evans

>Pam, I agree that print is best, and I am not getting rid of my print copies. However I notice that FWW near complete sets seem to be bringing more like $150, rather than the $300+ of a few years ago. And I found it impossible to shift my duplicates recently at anything close to the prices of a few years ago.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#21

Re: Not a different understanding....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, but there are all kinds of other potential reasons for such a price decrease, the Great Recession for example.

Pam

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#22

Re: Not a different understanding....

Chris Friesen

>"If I give one of those articles that I have printed to a friend, is that distribution?"

Yes, it is.

"I can certainly give/lend the CD to my friend, who can obviously print an article for his/her own use.....If I lend the magazine to my friend who then scans an article for personal use, is that a breach - no? "

If I understand it correctly, a person is allowed to make a copy for "private study, scholarship, or research". Libraries and archives are allowed to make copies on behalf of your friend for that purpose, so I wouldn't consider it too much of an ethical stretch to do so yourself.

"If I scan an article from a magazine I borrow from the library for my personal use is that fair use? I can certainly use the library copier legally and ethically."

Scanning/photocopying a physical object is basically the same from a copyright point of view. In both cases you're making a reproduction.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#23

Re: Not a different understanding....

Gary Roberts

>This is a typical problem with the application of Fair Use. To sum it up, Fair Use boils down to three factors: intent, scope and distribution.

Intent: Why you are making copie(s)

Scope: To what extent you are copying a given work, such as the percentage of pages you copy from a book.

Distribution: How narrow is your intended range of distribution of the item copied.

That said, there are few hard and fast rules. Consider any item under copyright to be subject to some level of restriction. Read the item's copyright statement. If lacking such a statement, be cautious and request permission from the publisher or author first.

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#24

An attorney's opinion

CJ

>Dan:

Your intentions are sterling. However they can and will get you into trouble. You should not provide copies of articles to people that do not already own the article in question.

Some simple things to remember:

1. Making a copy of an article and distributing it (to even a single person) is an infringement of the copyright. Get written permission or don't do it.

2. Statutory damages can and will swamp you regardless of how much damage your infringement may have actually incurred.

3. Fair use is a defense, not an avoidance. This means that the only time you get to argue fair use is when a judge is involved. You will already have spent more than you wanted to at that stage.

4. Because fair use can be complicated, to be safe you should never presume that your copying is covered by fair use. About the only thing that I can tell you about fair use is that what you proposed likely won't be covered.

Be safe. We don't want you to end up like the poor woman in my home town of Minneapolis that just got sued into the stone age by RIAA for letting her kids or some one copy around a dozen songs. Damages for that case were about $1.9 million.

Best of luck.

CJ

Re: In case anyone should need a WW mag article

#25

Re: Super size me

ThomD

>"we start talking some real money lost for publishers"

Yes and no. I would never pay to have those articles. This is the missing piece. People download stuff that they never use, and would certainly never pay for. That is why they waited until it was "free" to do it. Still, it's like the money raked in on extra size meals, it all goes to the bottom line and the publisher is happy to have whatever little/large extra it may represent.

The one constant on the internet, is the number of internet lawyers who will descend on any suggestion of copyright infringement. The US is very unfriendly soil for this kind of discussion. So thoriginal works get posted on sites in Russia etc... Where downloading is up to your conscience and the rules affecting other jurisdictions, not all of which are hostile to this kind of thing. Not only does the US get nailed because the world steals it's intellectual property, but it gets nailed because individuals in other countries have free access without fear of prosecution, relatively. For instance some countries have departments that translate and disseminate "every" technical article published in the US. That's a government program and it is unlikely fees are making it back to the originators in the US. Other countries have creative schemes where there are taxes levied on stuff like blank media, and various more visible institutions, and these moneys are distributed to "creators". So the downloading is legal because... Someone creating Artic polka songs got paid a fee while everyone is actually downloading MJ's greatest hits.

Of course that is the essential tension in copyright/IP the payment of fees to creators is balanced against the needs of society to freely exchange ideas.. The US has tilted a lot towards paying creators lately, thereby giving the rest of the world a comparative advantage.