Re: Not a different understanding....
Peter Evans
>The legal and ethical issues overlap, as do the practical.
A practical example : I took a very cheap sale opportunity from the publishers to pick up all the PW back issues available on CD. The README file authorises printing and includes:-
"Legal Issues - These files are all copyrighted by F+W Publications Inc., Cincinnati, Ohio. Reproducing these files for distribution or for sale is strictly prohibited."
If I give one of those articles that I have printed to a friend, is that distribution? or similar to giving someone a copy of the print magazine; I can certainly give/lend the CD to my friend, who can obviously print an article for his/her own use.
However if I scan an article from a print copy, and give scan to said friend - that is a breach of copyright, and is probably not fair use. If I lend the magazine to my friend who then scans an article for personal use, is that a breach - no? If I scan an article from a magazine I borrow from the library for my personal use is that fair use? I can certainly use the library copier legally and ethically.
However to broadcast your willingness to copy articles - even with the best intent - is unfortunately going too far. I do not see an ethical problem with asking if someone has an out-of-print article they could copy for them. I have been on both ends of this non-economic arrangement.
An interesting development of digital versions of magazines is the collapse of the value of print copies in the second hand market. For FWW you can digitally get all back copies for $150, and this sort of puts a ceiling on the price of old print copies.