We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I tend more to the power-tool side of woodworking, but a couple recent experiences have convinced me I should still be fairly proficient in the use of tools such as planes. I have a small "Groz" block plane (made in India, I believe) which seems to at least be reasonably serviceable, albeit after a good amount of tuning/truing/sharpening/sanding of the sole, etc. I know Veritas planes are considered to be top-notch, but needless to say, I'd prefer not to spend ~$300 if I can at all avoid it. I understand some vintage Stanleys etc. are also of high quality & can be good values, if you find the right one. So I'm wondering, in addition to the block plane I have now, what are some representative examples (make & model) of the 1st larger-size plane I should add to my tool kit?
>This will probably start a lot of controversy and an endless argument, but I'm not afraid to say a good Stanley #5C (that's with the corrugated bottom) jack plane can't be wrong. Not a new one. One that is in reasonably good shape from the 1930's or so. You might consider putting in an aftermarket blade at some point.
A jack plane is just what is says,a jack of all trades. I went a long time with no other plane. You can set it coarsely and hog off a lot of material for rough squaring and truing. You can set it more finely and do smoothing. You can joint edges on smaller pieces. It'll take you a long way. If I could only take one plane along with me, it would be a #5C.
Best of all, they are common as dirt and you can take your pick for cheap off E-Bay.
Good question, and we've all been there--what's my first bench plane? In my own case, it was a beat-to-crap Stanley 605 (corrugated) bedrock. Which is simply a No. 5 size plane, as Roy recommended. Mine was an old one, Type 6 or so. I'm speaking in past tense, because I eventually gave it away to someone who needed it more than I did.
That plane couldn't even have been 'parted out' for Ebay, because it didn't have any good parts, except for the frog and frog screws.
However, the plane fettled up to be an excellent performer. And as my sharpening improved, the plane improved commensurately. It's all about sharpening. By the way, I'd like to commend you on getting that Groz to work--that speaks to having a good bit of talent and know-how.
I don't suggest you get a beater. But I mention my beater, because it shows that these old Stanley planes were tough customers and good value. I suggest you get one with good wood. The wood doesn't usually lie. If the thing is beat in ways that count--like if the adjuster doesn't work right, frog screws munged up, replacement screws holding the wood down that aren't right, bent shoe from being dropped--the wood will about always show it. You don't want a rewelded shoe either, but that's easy to see, unless the vendor is purposely hiding it with a sticker, or showing you the good side (only). Mostly though, if the thing looks right, meaning looks original with ordinary patina for its age, and is not shined up high, it probably is right.
I agree with Roy that a No. 5 is a good choice. Although I think that the advantage of a corrugated sole is that there's less metal to remove, if it needs flattening. I wouldn't pass over a really nice straight No. 5 to get to a lesser example that was corrugated. But reasonable people can differ on these things, so don't want to sound dogmatic about it.
What's good about a No. 5 for openers, is that it does a lot of things, and yet it's not so much plane that it becomes a challenge to fettle or maintain. A 2" blade is easier to sharpen, flatten, and push through hard wood (think sugar maple), than a 2-3/8" blade. The sole on a 14" No. 5 is easier to check for flat, and get flat if need be, than an 18" No. 6 or a 22" No. 7.
A No. 4 would also be a great choice, or even a No. 3 if you do small work. But as Roy said, a No. 5 is very good for edge truing boards off your power jointer, prior to edge gluing into panels.
Are you comfortable with Ebay, or do you need vendor recommendations?--there are some very fine ones we could recommend.
Sharpening is the gateway to all surface prep--do you feel comfortable in that area?
>If it fits into the budget, I vote for a Veritas low-angle jack, with at least one extra blade. Here's my reasoning:
1) The low-angle jack with a low angle blade is great for use with a shooting board.
2) Put a higher-angle blade on it (I prefer the 25-degree blade with a higher-angle microbevel) and it's an excellent all-purpose tool. Large smoother, small jointer, etc.
3) An even higher angle blade will allow you to work nasty grain, should you wish to do so.
4) A new high-quality plane will show you what the tool is capable of, and give you a target for tuning up subsequent used purchases.
>I agree that the low angle Veritas is an incredible bargain for it's flexibility. The bevel up system makes switching blades turn the plane into a completely different plane. In fact, this is my choice nowadays. The only problem is the cost. For a person just starting out with hand tools, that's a lot of commitment to a hobby that may run a short life.
>A #5 is a good choice, it is a versatile size for a bench plane. But a good block plane might be more useful for someone who is primarily a power tool user. Kept in your apron or in a holster on your belt. You'll find a multitude of ways to use one in the course of a project.
There are about as many block plane models out there as there are bench plane ones. Blade adjuster/no blade adjuster. Adjustable throat/fixed throat. Straight blade/skewed blade. 20 degree angled blade/12 degree angled blade (also called "low angled block plane"). Variations on lever caps, different sized blades... you get the picture. See the below link for a tour of the full line of Stanley planes.
I use my bronze Lie Nielsen skew block plane (like a Stanley #140) about as much as I use my antique Millers Falls #5 (like a Stanley #102). (That is roughly the high end/low end of block planes.) My point is that nearly any block plane is a good place to start. Good users are plentiful on the market, pick one that seems to be in good condition and go for it.
>Is for a #5 with a replacement L-N blade. Learn to use the plane, learn to sharpen the blade. The blade not only stays sharper longer and is just generally "better", but is also thicker and will close that mouth up a bit and allow you to plane thinner. Money well spent, and you'll be hard pressed to tell the difference between this combo and the more expensive options.
>For many years I built exclusively with power tools, never having had a positive experience with a hand tool. My epiphany was a visit to College of Redwoods where I watched the students deftly removing a few thousandths of an inch of material at a time with hand tools, in a highly controlled fashion, to achieve perfect fits of this and that. That is useful, I concluded. Been learning how ever since, and this is an excellent Forum to learn how. The world's experts in hand tools hang out here.
Step 1 is to learn what sharp is and how to achieve this state on your edged tools.
Step 2 depends on your patience and budget. I relate the story of me getting into the sheep raising business. I had intended to buy some lambs but the wise sheep farmer advised that since I didn't know what I was doing that I should buy some old ewes that did. It was sound advice. If you will be using a plane to supplement your power tools a $40 Stanley #4 or #5 in good working order will do all you need to do(well, a shoulder plane is mighty handy for fitting tenons). The problem I found, not knowing anything about planes, was how to know one was in good working order. I got screwed on ebay buying planes so that is not a sure way to achieve success. Maybe pay $75 for one of these planes and buy it from someone that has put it, or ensures that it is, in good working order.
Or, using the sheep analogy, buy a new Lee Valley or Lee Nielson, that is good from the box.
You are at the bottom of a long learning curve. Some hands on lessons will be of great value. Take a class or find a mentor.
>Well, I started with a Lie Nielsen low angle block. What a wonderful little tool. It is definitley one of my favorites. My wife gave it to me for my birthday over ten years ago. Next up was a Stanley #4 that I bought from a guy on this forum (he sells a lot on Ebay). Another great tool. I suggest you include good sharpening stones and a guide if you don't already have them. That's very important to being happy using a plane.
I took a class with Phil Lowe. It's amazing what he does with his #4. He uses it for everything.
The replacement irons that are available can make a big difference too. I replaced my Stanley original with a Hock and I have noticed a difference.
If you really want something new, I would look at the Veritas line at Lee Valley. Those are great tools for very good prices.
Good luck with whatever you choose. Once you get used to it/them, you'll wonder how you ever got along without it/them.
>I bought the old Stanley on e-bay. Then I bought another. And then another. And then..... . And some good blades. And some good chip breakers. And some spare parts. The 35 or so Stanleys and Sargents look real good on display in my workshop. And sometimes I use one of them, especially the 4 1/2 with Veritas blade and Hock chipbreaker. However, after fiddling with the old Stanleys I bought the low angle smoother and the low angle jack from Lee Valley for any serious work.
I would have saved a lot of money by buying a Lee Valley or Lie Nielsen plane right at the get-go. Of course then I wouldn't have all those pretty Stanleys to look at!
>It may not be as bad as it appears. Given the generally high selling price for Veritas and Lie-Nielsen on ebay and woodworking forums, if someone decides they don't really like woodworking they'll probably recoup 70-80% of the cost of the plane.
Heck, I've seen Lie-Nielsen stuff go on ebay for 100% of new, because of tax implications in other countries.
>a 5 1/4 but, when you added the "C", I remited. I've always had a "C-Jones". "C"s are for the collector who collects what no one else wants in their collection.
>First, did you notice there were lots of different opinions? Are you confused? This is normal. The truth is, there are lots of different ways to do anything - some really wrong, lots of variations of right.
Used vs. new - lots of us got into it with used tools. You spend more time (and money, sometimes) learning, but you spend fewer dollars (pounds, marks, whatever your local currency is). A compromise is to go to one of the dealers - you'll pay more than at a garage sale, but the good ones won't sell you garbage. I've never used one, so can't offer any testimony.
I concur that a No. 5 is a good first bench plane. If you read through all the old "introduction to working wood" texts, they pretty universally make the same recommendation. Not too big, not too small; Goldilocks approves.
The general consensus is to look for a plane made before World War II. After the war, the power tool makers made a big push of portable tools with the returning GIs buying and fixing up homes, and the hand tool makers either faded or, in the case of Stanley, engineered down (I suspect there were factors that contributed to the success of the post-war power tools - technological improvements during the war perhaps, excess production capacity in the factories, etc. - but that's all speculation on my part). Down below I've got some notes on what I look for when garage saling.
I wouldn't go too far out of my way to find a corrugated sole - it adds little to the usefulness of the tool if you keep the sole waxed (use furniture paste wax, $5-10 at your local hardware or home improvement store).
As others have said, sharpening is critical. A tool that's otherwise not perfect acts like it is if the cutting edge is sharp; a tool that's otherwise 100% with a dull iron will send you back to your power tools.
My first clue that a bench plane is worth picking up when at a garage sale is that the tote (rear handle) is fully oval - if the tote's got flat sides, the plane's more recent. Then I look to see if there's a screw at the rear base of the frog (part where the cutting iron rests). If there's one pushing on a little bracket from the frog, good; if there are three (one with the bracket, one on each side of it), even better.
You should check your local library to see if it has a copy of "The Handplane Book" by Garrett Hack. This is a good introduction to getting and using them. Come on back here with questions; the unspoken motto here seems to be No Question Is Too Simple to Get a Thread Going.
You'll also need to consider how you hold your work while planing. Block planes let you hold it with one hand while planing with the other; larger planes require two hands. You need vises, stops, and so on. Again, troll your library (thank you, Ben Franklin!) for books on workbenches. "The Workbench Book," older now, is one of the better ones; Chris Schwarz has a book, "Workbenches from Design & Theory to Construction & Use," which is perhaps the best discussion of workholding alternatives and their tradeoffs (shameless advertising note: if you go to the Marketplace here and follow the link to Lee Valley, you can find it there at less than retail, plus, through the 19th, Lee Valley is offering free shipping. Purchases through the link here generate income for Wood Central). You can do a lot with a screw or two driven into the top of your workbench, but this gets old.
Don't disregard chisels. Planes are right helpful, but the more experienced I get (not much), the more I realize that a chisel, used well, is tremendously versatile.
Someone mentioned your being at the bottom of a learning curve. Yes. If you find yourself going out to the shop and putting a piece of pine in the vise just to plane it and admire the shavings, then you're also at the top of a slippery slope with no known end. It's possible to have too many planes; a lot of the members of this forum are testing what that limit is.
>Assuming that you're a relative beginner to plane use, I think that what would be even better than figuring out what to get for your next plane would be to get some hands on teaching on how to tune up a plane and how to sharpen a plane blade (and chisels, by extension). There are a number of ways to do this. You can go take a class locally. You can go to a local woodworking store, and talk to the staff there. You can join your local woodworking club and talk to the hand tool geek. (Every woodworking club has one, and believe it or not, in our club it's not me.) :@)
The reason for this is that WoodCentral and the internet is an invaluable source of woodworking information, but there are some things that you'll just pick up much more quickly in person. I can speak from experience, as two of the first things that happened to me when I started to learn how to do woodworking was that my back door neighbor showed me what a really well tuned plane can do, and I took a woodworking course through the local votech school where I learned how to get a tool really sharp. These are tangible experiences that are very difficult to convey over the internet.
Also, there's no better way to learn how a plane really works, which will make buying used planes on eBay a much less scary proposition.
Then get a used #5 Stanley, and stick a Hock blade and chipbreaker in it. :@)
Well, I certainly have a lot to consider now. On the one hand, getting a nice pre-war Stanley & tuning it up sounds like it could be a fun challenge, or at least fulfilling. I generally like things with a "history". On the other hand, I can see getting a badly described nightmare of a tool, pouring a ton of time into it and 40 bucks for a new blade, and as has been suggested, not being sure if the bad results it produces are the tool, my prepping of the tool, my inexperience in using the tool, or a combination of all 3.
I actually do have another plane, a late 50's-early 60's vintage Dunlap which belonged to my father. If it has a model number, I can't find it. A picture is below. I've been told these are not worth fooling with, is that true?
I see there are 2 Stanley 5C's on Ebay at the moment, one with a "buy it now" price of $115 w/shipping, and one sitting at $9.99, with no bids so far. I'm watching both. The $115 one looks to be in good shape & is suggested to be 1910's vintage. The link to that one is below.
Several people have suggested replacing the blade, which seems like a good idea, but would raise the price of the $115 Stanley to about $150, making a new Veritas #5-1/4W Bench Plane at $239.00 seem more attractive.
Decisions, decisions...
Thanks all again for the great replies, I appreciate the time required to make them. If anyone knows of particularly good sources for a used Stanley, or has an opinion on the one in the Ebay link, or knows whether or not my dad's old Dunlap is good for much other than a boot scraper, I'd appreciate hearing about it.
>Look at the auctions for 5's that have ended (advanced search option). You'll soon see that $115 is WAY too high and $9.00 will be on the low side. You should be able to pick up a nice one for about $30.00-$50.00
>After a year of putzing around with old Stanleys and sort-of-Japanese planes, I finally bought the LN low angle jack. It worked right out of the box, and happens to be a very flexible tool, it does it all; and as you refine your use you can replace it with particular planes for particular functions at your leisure. Others have said the same about the LV low angle jack. So pick one, get it, and get to work.
True, the price approaches $300, but think of this as being the cost of about 4 planes in one.
>You may have just saved yourself a search for a #5 for now! Your plane certainly looks like it would work, and is the same size as a Stanley #5.
I'd take the plane apart, and check out the frog. If the frog is a chunk of cast iron, as opposed to stamped and folded steel, clean up the rust, sharpen the blade and try to get it tuned up.
If that doesn't work, contact Hock Tools and see if their blades and chipbreakers will fit. I'll be surprised if it doesn't. If you get a Hock blade, and it doesn't fit, or if it does and your plane still doesn't seem to work well, you can save the Hock blade for the Stanley #5 you'll be looking for at that point.
>The 1960's Stanley plane I have does just about as well as the better made Stanleys especially with a Hock blade in it. It doesn't look as good or feel as good as a pre-war plane but I could not fault it as a beginner plane. There is merit in starting cheap and seeing if your interest continues. For a while you won't be limited by the plane but rather your skill at sharpening. If you find a plane useful in your work then buy a new, better one.
The cheapest way to get into sharpening is with abrasive sheets. Check the Articles section for a detailed article on this technique. You must solve the sharpening step before you will be limited by a plane's quality. To that end the initial expense needs to be sharpening equipment, including a blade holding jig. Later you will wean yourself from the jig, but it is useful "training wheels" for a beginner.
>"I've been told these are not worth fooling with..."
Dunlap planes were a second line (as in second string) for Sears. Sears did not make its own planes; it contracted with other makers. Back when yours was made, it might have been Stanley, Sargent, or Millers Falls, all respectable companies.
The mechanical parts are often fine. Sometimes the quality of the cutting iron was below the top of the line planes; other times, maybe very competitive, with some of the top of the line features left off. Yours looks like it's got a cast iron frog, from the pictures. From the shape of the lateral adjuster lever, it looks like the manufacturer might have been Millers Falls, a company that is either just behind or just in front of Stanley, depending on who's speaking (this is a Ford/Chevy, Homelite/McCullough, Apple/Windows debate, in my opinion).
As Wilbur Pan suggests, sharpen it up and try it out. I would also clean it up, if you haven't already - take the frog off, clean it and the body (mineral spirits/paint thinner would be good), reassemble, align the frog carefully, LIGHTLY oil the operating mechanisms, maybe wax the face of the frog, definitely wax the sole of the plane.
All this will take you maybe half an hour, a little longer if you're still learning sharpening. At the end, you'll have either a good starter plane with, even better, a link to family history; or useful practice in plane maintenance and a better understanding of how they work.
>People make flat statements about certain lines of tools not being worthwhile based on their own experiences. The hardware store and mail order lines of woodworking tools often changed manufacturers over time, and what was once a good line may have become garbage (or vice versa, I suppose, although quality rarely seems to have gone upwards in this particular area). I gave away my early 1970's Craftsman plane because it was such a dog, but I own an early 20th century Craftsman No. 6 (larger than the No. 5 we've all been recommending) that's a very good tool.
There's often also a certain amount of perfection mystique operating. There are so many planes around that people focus on what are seen as the best, and disparage anything else. If used cars all tended toward similar prices, people would tell you that nothing less than a Mercedes or Jaguar was worth messing with, ignoring how serviceable a Ford might be (there's a great line in one of Josephine Tey's books, set in England and Scotland, in which a character says very condescending things about English Fords, even while admitting the darned things are very good cars). But if you've got a plane in your hand, it's always worth trying it out; you may be pleasantly surprised.
>I'm with you all the way ! I started collecting "C"s because, it seemed, there wasn't as much interest in them as, say, Bedrocks. They are kinda unusual though not rare. They appealed to my "excentric" side. Add to that the mystery and reason for the corugation.