Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Metate for Japanese saws

Posts

Metate for Japanese saws

#1

Metate for Japanese saws

Gordon Thomas

>Just wanted to follow up on my post a couple of months agao regarding Mark Grable's work on my Mitsukawa katabas . I am happy to report that Mark did an excellent job on the 3 rip katabas. It is a relief to have someone in NA who is capable of "tuning" up a saw that was riddled from childbirth. Mark has proved to be an excellent source of information about the subejct and has been always willing to spend the time on the telephone discussing the nuances of these animals.

best wishes,

Gordon

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#2

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Gordon,

Thanks for sharing this! This is most helpful. I am aware of the poor shape of those saws as received from the maker, and it speaks extremely well of Mark that he was able to correct them, especially on a couple of very fine-toothed saws.

Did he have to re-tooth them, or was he able to work with them as was? What did he find was the problem?

Since Mark has no advertising other than word of mouth, yours is a most helpful post to all! My experience with Mark is that he is a real saw doctor.

Wiley

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#3

Second thought regarding Mark Grable

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Gordon,

Do you suppose that it would be possible to get Mark to make a post about those saws, and describe how he determined what their issues were, and what would be needed, and what he actually did? That would be a tremendous contribution, if he were willing to do it, and if it was OK with you. He wouldn't need to mention the sawmaker's name.

There are very, very few people able to discuss metate from first-hand experience--even in Japan, let alone the west--so any insight Mark might share would be of great value. Perhaps he could talk about his sawmaking plans as well, and progress on his forge.

Wiley

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#4

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

Gordon Thomas

>Hi Wiley:

The saws are made of quality steel and the forging was good. It was the next step that they were deficient.Firstly, the dozuki was thicker at the front and back of the blade by 3 thousands. This led to the spine disengaging from the blade. It also affected the feel as it moved through the kerf.

As for the katabas,the 210 rip had four teeth jointed to a different height than the rest. When Mark adjusted the four teeth he discovered that other teeth were also jointed inconsistently. One kataba was bent. Another had more set one one side than the other. Needless to say the saw did not cut straight.

I am happy to report that Mark was able to tune 2 katabas and they now perform flawlessly. The third kataba is better but not perfect which leads me to believe there may be something fundamentally flawed with it. The dozuki issue was mitigated by pinching the spine so that the blade does not flex the way it did previously.

Through all of this Mark kept me informed of the process and was always willing to spend as much time explaining the issues and the steps he took to overcome them.

Finally, the best means to contact Mark is via telephone. By his own admission he is not a "computer guy" and does not check his emails regularly.

best wishes,

Gordon

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#5

Re: Second thought regarding Mark Grable

Rogu

>Gordon and Wiley,

I was fortunate enough to attend a Japanese saw-sharpening course with Mark Grable in Maine last year. We had to make our own Japanese saw-sharpening vice and then learned how to cut new teeth for a cross-cut and rip saw. We then had a session of "geurilla" straightening. A lot of saws can be sharpened two or three times before they need hon metate--a process of removing the distortions and re-setting the teeth.

We also had lengthy talks on how he looks at saws and analyzes them.

Mark trained with Yataiki, otherwise known as Endo Tomoya, whose reputation is legendary in Japan. His saws are sold for thousands of dollars. Unfortunately, this great man is living his last days and will not be with us much longer. This will be the end of an era and he may never be replaced.

When he started his training with Yataiki, Mark was told to look at a saw under a certain lighting condition and see if he could find the distortions in the saw. It took him three weeks before he could see these. Some never gain this skill.

He speaks of Yataiki preaching patience and how he could scrape a saw to a consistent 11/1000" by hand. Mark is a gentle man who may spontaneously burst into song or recite a poem.

Mark's prices are very reasonable. If you want to to talk to him his business information is on the Daiku Dojo site:

http://www.daikudojo.org/Links/mark_grable_saw_sharpening_service.html

If you want to read about Yataiki:

http://www.daikudojo.org/Archive/gallery_yataiki/

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#6

Re: Second thought regarding Mark Grable

Mark Grable

>Well, yes, I find this computer (which I borrow) to be less tractable than saws. Why did they mix-up the letters on the keyboard anyway? Could'nt they make at least the keys out of wood? As for Gordon's saws, I really enjoyed working on them, the blacksmithing work very sweet. I hope I can do as well when I get to that phase. Dozuki are very different from other types of saws. The back is mild steel, and formed in such a way that it springs tight around the blade. Not like folded paper, creased to lay flat - more like a string bean which has some open space in the middle. The very top of the blade nestles in bottom of this channel, if the teeth are pointing up, and the sides of the blade are held at the top of channel. This narrow elipse cross section back is stiffer than a back with parralell flat sides. The back and blade become a unit. If the saw rattles when tapped on the side, it will rattle when cutting (or pulling, as is said half-way-round-the-world). Not good.

Because the mild steel back has more stiffness than spring, the blade has to be of uniform thickness along the back where its held. Gordon's dozuki's back came right off, and while we didn't use feeler gages or micrometers in Miki Shi to put backs on new saws, I use them to re-set loose backs, unless the back was formed completely flat (hopeless). The mike showed the front 0.013 in. for about an in. long, then 0.009 in. for an in. and a half, then 0.012 for the rest up to the taper at the neck. So I used a file to reduce the thickness at the front to 0.009, relaxed and straightened the blade, and did what I could with the back, though it had been flattened to a degree. If I had an unlimited supply of new backs, I would have put a new one on, but I may not be able to get anymore, and have to figure out how to make them. It can't be that hard, Yataiki bought his - somewhere. The other problems were the commonplace not-quite-flat/straight, one side set more than the other, and some teeth not quite completely filed down to the jointed level: flat on top. Getting the cutting edges (points) to all be the same hight is very difficult, and machines are better at it than I am, but perfection is not required. A bit low is much better than leaving a jointed flat top, but when I put the saw back in the vice after pulling it through a piece of wood to get the loose burrs and fileings off, I useually find some teeth to finish off. It takes more time to sneak up on 'em like this, but I have only once had ten saws a day to do on two consecutive days. (20) Then there were none for a week, then a couple. To be really skilled you need to do more than ten a day. Specialising in one or two brands also helps, and avoiding pitted saws. Maybe someday.

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#7

Re: Second thought regarding Mark Grable

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Just so you know, the keys on keyboards can be made of anything you can shape; so wood is definitely a possibility. Of course, it would take forever to make one that way, so it unless made of cast wood pulp, it would cost a small fortune.

Thanks for the description. Perhaps you could contact Tomohito Iida for the back maker source?

Pam

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#8

Re: Second thought regarding Mark Grable

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Mark,

Thank you very much for making such a detailed response, and on a borrowed computer with crazy a-s-d-f lettering!

It is a miracle that someone of your skill is here amongst us. After all, the saws you reworked for Gordon were not cheap saws. They are expensive saws, meaning there was reasonable skill used in their original making--and yet now they are much better than as-delivered. I had a similar experience when you reworked a 270mm rip dozuki (Mitsukawa) for me some years ago--that saw was far better than original when you returned it.

Can you tell us a little more about your saw-making plans? Are you going to make a standard set of saws, or take custom orders? Do you expect to use 1095, or try to obtain Hitachi steel? Do you have an idea when you might be ready for initial orders? Here's my crazy idea: I always wanted a real leaf saw. Why not make a run of leaf saws, keep one, and auction or sell the others.

I hope you will make or find dozuki backs that are blued, like Yataiki's.

Highest regards,

Wiley

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#9

Re: Second thought regarding Mark Grable

mark grable

>blueing is no problem. There is a matter of (touch wood) luck in finding backs, and files, I suppose. I have about 100 pieces of steel in various stages of forging from Yataiki, which I plan to save for when I feel confident about everything. Forge foundation will go in this summer/fall, and work on the frame this winter. Also website, and some classes this winter. Next year I plan to make cheap experimental saws of larger sizes, and work with broken and cracked blades. Also yarigana, hammers, setting hammers and anvils, sen, small knives. The box bellows needs work this winter, and the surface grinder. There's a 3"x20"D grinding wheel to set up. Right now I'm focusing on the hot water bath - for bathing. Just updated the computer - a T-42 Thinkpad (refurbished) and running Umbuntu OS - no more Windows forever! also invested in an Olympus 18x 560uz digital camera, so soon will be clean, and posting jpgs.

Re: Metate for Japanese saws

#10

Re: Second thought regarding Mark Grable

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Please keep me informed about classes you'll be offering, would love to have an excuse to visit New England. Of course, winter may be a bit problematic since I swore off snow when we moved here... Maybe global warming will obviate those concerns. :)

Also, you may receive an email from Tomohito Iida about saws and Yataiki.

Pam