Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

Posts

philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#1

philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Today I was assembling boards to make leaves for a dining table. Some of the joints straight from the jointer were not perfect so I mounted the offending boards in the vise and planed the edge with a Stanley #5 until they were perfect. The response from many of you will, and should be, so?

Planing an edge was a skill that eluded me for many years. Recently motivated, and aided by encouragement and suggestions from WC participants, I gave it another try. With a bit of practice, using a proven technique otherwise know as "perfect practice", I became successful in fixing an edge off the jointer (that's power jointer). So now it is a "so?" event for me too.

To what ever degree this experience is typical, it suggests the value of classes/demonstrations that replicate to some extent apprenticing. I have no doubt that if I had been challenged, and instructed, 20 years ago to fix the edge of a board so as to achieve a perfect joint I would have done it. Yet I was unable to acquire this skill unaided. I should add that a properly tuned plane and the ability to make a sharp iron were also key ingredients to success.

So, many thanks to those on WC that offered useful advice and encouragement that led to acquiring this useful skill. And for those struggling, take a class. It may not be your lack of skill but rather a lack of confidence and instruction that is needed for success.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#2

Ellis Walentine

Agree

Ellis Walentine

>The hardest part of magazine editing for me was conveying the process -- whatever process -- in two dimensional images and text on a page. You're stuck with snapshots and captions -- no kinetics or feedback loops. Video images are much better because you witness the process in real time as you're listening to the voiceover. The ultimate learning situation, though, IMHO, will always be the one-on-one relationship with the instructor. You are there in the presence of the instructor, the tools and the techniques, and you can ask questions that go directly to the point. I can't imagine a more direct or efficient way to transfer that experience short of some kind of Vulcan mind meld.

Ellis

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Man problem

Jim in Burlington On

>For some reason men have a problem paying for "lesssons" or taking training. Whenever I suggest additional training for men there is a good deal of resistance. Women are much more open to training for some reason. Personally I cut to the chase and started out by taking several of Rob Cosmans seminars. Lack of knowledge slows down work IMO.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#4

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

James Watriss

>I think part of the virtue of the class is not just the time and instruction, it's the regular, scheduled practice that forces you to practice your techniques and develop your skills, regularly, and over a sustained period of time. For some reason, i we're doing it on "our time," it's always easy to put it of, or only do it on weekends, and take a break for a day or two when we get frustrated.

On the other hand, if you're in a class, you really have to apply yourself.

Pick a reason... you're right, there are a lot of virtues to getting some hands on instruction, just about anywhere.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#5

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I love woodworking classes, even the machine oriented ones at the local community college. And especially the Japanese tool classes that in 4 days each (Odate on Japanese tool use and Inomoto-san's plane making seminar and Yataiki's blacksmithing) taught me an amazing amount of technique and skill, truly unbelievable how much better I was after those classes).

Pam

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#6

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I agree completely. I find that I am still having problems putting together panels for a tool chest I'm making. When I took some classes that (a top put together from multiple pieces) was provided to me because of lack of time.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#7

I must be.....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>....the exception to the rule. I am mostly a self taught woodworker. I did not take shop in school and I have never taken a class....ever. Don't get me wrong here...I agree with the above statements about the value of classroom education. It's just that I tend to do better taking in and processing information outside of classrooms. (My wife would would interrupt here and tell you that I am brain damaged). I learn things and retain the information better when I either figure out the processes or glean it from sources like books...or even here on WC. Maybe it's just me but classroom education for skill subjects (I have taken classes in other things) have not served me as well. I think it's just the way my brain processes I guess. But I'm sure that for the vast majority, yes, classes are the way to go.

Tom

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#8

Re: I must be.....

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I was so surprised that I was allowed to take woodworking classes that I probably went a tad overboard. :)

Pam

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#9

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

Hank Knight

>I think it's easy for self-taught woodworkers to get into a rut and miss some of the techniques that are important for producing really fine work. I was self taught and considered myself a pretty good woodworker for many years, but I strugggled with some of the basics. I developed my own ways of doing things ther were not very efficient or effective, but I "got by." Four years ago I took a class from an excellent instructor and it was an eye-opener for me. I've taken a second class since then, and I can tell you, they have improved my work immensely. I learned some really valuable skills and I was reassured about my own skills. But probably the most important thing the instruciton did for me was ot give me the confidence to try things I never would have attempted before. I agree with Bill, I think the experience of hands-on instruction from somebody who really knows what they are doing can't be replicated by reading books and magazines.

Hank

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#10

Different strokes

Dave Anderson NH

>You're not that unusual Tommy....at least not in that respect. ;-))

I remember taking a course on teaching skills, in this case it was kayaking. Our mentor was a professional educator gave us a talk about the learning tringle. Basically, almost everyone learns primarily one of three ways. They watch a demo, they read or listen to a book, or they figure it out experimentally. Every person through either unconscious choice or necessity leans heavily and dominantly toward one of these 3 stles of learning. Having said that however, each of these same people still learn using elements of the other two styles. Over the years I have found that depending on the available resources my methods of learning woodworking skills has often changed as opportunities arose and disappeared. If it was my choice however, I would learn primarily from a mixture of watching and doing. The bottom line though is that everyone learns differently.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#11

Re: Less Philosophy more work

ThomD

>I think a lot of it is psychological, the unwillingness to jump in and try. I think the few classes I have taken were a ton of fun, but after all is said and done one is still in the shop looking at a piece of wood and trying to find the confidence to get on with it. Whereas, once one throws oneself into some practice one can progress rather rapidly.

Two articles (both in Woodworking as it happens) had a big impact on me. One was by a guy who never quite got dovetails so he volunteered to teach a course on them and in the period leading up to the course he put in the time to master the joint. I did the same thing. I had been doing DTs for 20 years, but never to the standard one saw on tapes, etc... I leave stuff to the last moment so it wasn't until a day or two before the course that I actually settled down and did some joints. It is really astonishing how quickly the stuff comes together when you have to do it. I could do the Klauzs demo for the class after a few hours of practive. That was probably 2000ish. I had the Klauzs tape since '85 (?) when it came out!! Klauzs said he really perfected his technique when faced with one project with a huge number of drawers. One just has to do some work, not even that much.

I've been trying to teach myself TIG welding, which makes dovetails seem like cake. I've been at it about 5 years. Still not there. The other day I read some guy's blog, his welding was great. He mentioned he had made 200 practice joints to learn how. Probably about 195 more than I have done. One does a little job here or there, and every time one has something to do, and it is a struggle. I guess I just haven't put in the time yet. I doubt it will take me 200 joints, maybe 10, and I will be where I need to be. Practice vs. projects.

The other article was about Scott Neihring. He was quoted as saying he develope master craftsman chops by just doing simple practice like sawing 2x4s with Japanese saws. It's more of the same less time on the course more time on the practice tee stuff. What course prove is that relatively small amounts of correct practice will make a difference. It's the practice that makes the difference, but people want to make something.

One problem with cabinetmaking is there are a lot of skills, some of them take huge time and don't teach woodwork, like finishing, so practice can be broken up a lot. Something like woodturning which proceeds very quickly and where there is a lot more speed and flow, is learned really fast. The downturn with WT is the time spent getting out the wood, sharpening, and cleaning up. But for 1K you can automate all that stuff so you can keep moving right along and get lots of practice.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#12

Or, to put it another way

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"There are three kinds of men: The one that learns by reading, the few who learn by observation and the rest of them have to pee on the electric fence for themselves." Will Rogers

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#13

Re: Or, to put it another way

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I fear I am the later....egads!! ;-) Tom

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#14

Re: Or, to put it another way

Victor Parisian

>That's the fast way. damhikt

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#15

Re: Different strokes

Hank Knight

>Dave, I think you're right; everyone learns differently and most rely heavily on one of the three learning processes you described. What I found, though, is that, while I do most of my learning from reading and struggling through by myself, once in a while a little nudge or a comment from somenone more skilled than I will produce that "Ah Ha!" moment when the pieces fall into place. Those moments are few and far between when you're a solo practitioner. Woodworking classes have given me opportunities to learn from some really fine woodworkers and experience those moments.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#16

Welding

R.J.Whelan - Sierras, California

>When I wanted to learn how to weld I turned to a good friend who was a true "master".

He said he would teach me the same way he was taught:

First gas - I probably welded 1000 feet of plates and shaped of various thickness and angle of connection before he pronounced me ready to move on to ....

Stick arc - same routine

Heliarc - Mig - Tig

By the time I was done (probably 18 months) he said I might be barely hireable as a trainee; I could make really pretty welds that were strong, but it took me 2-3 times longer to do it than a journeyman would require.

The learning process was almost an end to itself: even if I'd never applied the skills to actual work I really enjoyed learning from an expert (he passed on several years ago and the hours we spent in my garage are among my best memories of him).

RJ

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#17

Apprentice approach

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Learning through what I will label apprenticing or mentoring does not handily fit the triangle or maybe it is a synthesis of its elements into an approach. The key element here is demo-practice-feedback-practice, repeat as necessary.

While any leg of the triangle will get a motivated and capable person to an end, the apprentice/mentor approach, the focus of a good class, will get someone to an end quickest.

It seems the impediment to success in learning a technique, assuming the person is capable, could be confidence(can I do it), knowledge(how to do it), practice, and maybe equipment. A class is a quick way to overcome these impediments if the capability is there. Of course the impedimet to the class may be time and/or money.

More often than not my impediment is confidence. Once I get convinced I can do something I usually find a way to do it and get on with it.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#18

another consideration- standards

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Learning from an experienced mentor also imparts reasonable standards to the work, possibly +/- from what a novice might presume. My fits ahve gotten steadily better over the years as I see what others do, while my sanding has gotten less as I optimize what is necessary.

Re: philosophical discussion on classes, etc.

#19

Yes interesting

roninkokomo

>This one task is, of itself, justification for acquiring some hand tool skills. On more than one occasion in the past few years I have had to show some of my "power tools only" crowd that they can do their best with a power jointer to produce a good edge joint, and then give it to me and I can improve it with two or three passes with my 508c. It is simply the way the tools are designed... they finally see what I am talking about. It is not just being odd. There are many times when the hand tool does a better job.