Fret Work Lay-Out Question
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>How does one lay out fret work and get the repetitive line spacing perfect such as in this tray? There must have been some tricks in days of old for this task.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Fret Work Lay-Out Question
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>How does one lay out fret work and get the repetitive line spacing perfect such as in this tray? There must have been some tricks in days of old for this task.
Dividers?
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>Can you measure the total length, select a reference line in the pattern, divide length by an appropriate number to fit the pattern size, step it off with dividers, and adjust as needed until the dividers are set right; then use them to step off the pattern?
You referred to "this tray" as if there were going to be a picture or link, and, in the absence of one, I may have misunderstood your question and said something really dumb - since I say or do something really dumb at least once daily, no big thing for me...
Duh! forgot the picture
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>
Re: Fret Work Lay-Out Question *LINK*
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I'd cut all the pieces first, then glue together, some with half-laps. You might want to take a look at kumiko shown in the John Reed Fox Woodwright's Shop episode for making the angled pieces, towards the end, IIRC.
accuracy
paul womack
>The various old (1930's) books I have from the Golden Age of hobby fret cutting in the UK all agree that regular, straight (or geometric) work is very difficulty with a fret saw - because people (and their eyes) know exactly what the cut SHOULD be, and can therefore spot any slight deviation easily.
So there's more to it than the (non trivial) layout.
Just a warning from the past.
BugBear
do you think.....
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I realize the problem. Do you think these cut-outs may have been made with a chisel instead? I have figured out how to lay out the pattern with high precision. If one could then chisel to these scribe lines then the result would be precise.
Re: do you think.....
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
>Bill,
Your results might differ from mine, but if I tried to chisel that open work out of a solid sheet, I would crack that cross right in the middle of the pattern, sure as little green apples. I think the only way I could avoid that would be to glue the workpiece blank onto backing, do the chiselling, then saw the finished openwork free from the backing. I've done that before with long, thin, twining, breakable pieces of inlay. But sawing the openwork free from the backing (without breaking it) is not a trivial task, as I found out.
Intuitively, I lean toward what i think Pam is suggesting: Cut many Y's with precision, then glue them together at half-lap joints to make the crossing pattern.
But the breakthrough in this thread may be Paul's books: How was this kind of work done in the 1930's? That's what you need to know. Can Paul advise?
Wiley
Re: do you think.....
Warren in Lancaster, PA
>I have done quite a bit of fretwork. Usually we make a hole with a drill near a corner and use a fretsaw to cut it out. Then use a file like a Swiss 1 or 2 with a safe edge to clean up. I have occasionally cut the front side perhaps 1/16 deep or a little more with a chisel before sawing. This gives a really clean look, but I think it is not worth the extra work. I think if you practice a few inches on scrap you will get good results.
I don't think you will get good results gluing together small pieces. Much easier to get precision with saw and file. And it is not so dependent on glue to hold it together.
You could ask this poster *LINK*
Bruce, a MN Galoot
>on WoodNet.
I apologize if cross-posting violates a whole bunch of rules.
Jameel Abraham's work
Holly smokes. That's some fret work.
Victor Parisian
>
Re: You could ask this poster see link
Victor Parisian
>Oh, that guy is such a piker. Try this one.
My brother responded with this after I sent him the link to Jameel's work.
http://khalafoud.com/images/personal/altarscreen.jpg
Wow
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>that's beyond beautiful work.
trellis
paul womack
>But the breakthrough in this thread may be Paul's books: How was this kind of work done in the 1930's? That's what you need to know. Can Paul advise?
I can now. I read through my "Practical Woodworker", by Bernard Jones - the original, 4 volume monster, not the 500 page, cut down reprint.
They have a few projects with the kind of feature asked about, and they're all described as "frets", and the instructions speak of cutting them. The thicknesses varied from 1/4" to 3/4".

So there's "the answer"; they were fret cut out of solid.
BugBear
thanks and I on to it
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>That is how I intend to attempt the fret work. I have successfully laid up the inlay pattern in test wood, and assembled the top piece to be "fretted" (upon and about, not doubt). I have borrowed a fretting saw, powered by electrons. And I have figured out a template that will make lay-out straight forward. So as soon as I stop procrastinating on the computer it is off to practice this art.